Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to A Definitions

Acquired quality of earnings

What Is Acquired Quality of Earnings?

Acquired Quality of Earnings (QoE) is a specialized financial analysis that assesses the sustainability, accuracy, and true nature of a company's historical earnings, particularly in the context of a mergers and acquisitions (M&A) transaction. It falls under the broader category of financial analysis and due diligence. This in-depth examination goes beyond standard audits by scrutinizing the underlying factors contributing to a company's reported profits, aiming to identify non-recurring, discretionary, or aggressive accounting practices that might inflate reported earnings. The purpose of an Acquired Quality of Earnings report is to provide prospective buyers or investors with a clear, adjusted view of a target company’s ongoing profitability and cash flow, informing their valuation and deal structuring. Key areas of focus include revenue recognition, expense recognition, and the identification of any significant pro forma adjustments made by management.

History and Origin

The practice of assessing earnings quality gained prominence as financial markets evolved and the complexity of corporate financial reporting increased. While the concept of evaluating the reliability of reported profits has always been implicit in sound financial practice, the formalization of "Quality of Earnings" reviews, especially within the M&A landscape, began to solidify as investors and acquirers sought to mitigate risks associated with information asymmetry. Academic research has increasingly focused on the earnings quality of target firms in M&A settings, highlighting how it affects transaction processes and outcomes. 4The need for a dedicated Acquired Quality of Earnings analysis arose from instances where reported earnings, while compliant with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP)), did not accurately reflect the business's underlying operational performance or future prospects. This scrutiny became critical to avoid overpaying for an acquisition based on unsustainable profits.

Key Takeaways

  • Acquired Quality of Earnings analysis provides a comprehensive review of a target company's historical financial performance to determine the sustainability and accuracy of its reported earnings.
  • It is a crucial component of the due diligence process in M&A transactions, helping buyers assess the true operational profitability.
  • The analysis typically involves scrutinizing revenue, expenses, and non-recurring items to arrive at a normalized view of earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA)).
  • A QoE report aims to uncover potential red flags, such as aggressive accounting policies or unusual one-time events that might distort reported profits.
  • The findings directly influence the purchase price, deal terms, and post-acquisition integration strategies.

Interpreting the Acquired Quality of Earnings

Interpreting the Acquired Quality of Earnings involves a granular assessment of how various financial line items contribute to the overall picture of profitability. The core objective is to determine how "clean" and sustainable a company's earnings are. A high-quality earning stream is typically characterized by being derived from core operations, supported by strong cash flow from operations, and free from aggressive revenue recognition or expense recognition practices. Conversely, low-quality earnings might indicate reliance on one-time events, aggressive accounting choices, or a mismatch between reported profits and actual cash generation. Analysts look for specific adjustments to reported financial metrics, such as adding back non-recurring expenses or normalizing discretionary spending. This process helps buyers understand the true profitability that they can expect to "acquire" and whether there are any hidden liabilities or unsustainable practices that could impact future performance.

Hypothetical Example

Consider Tech Innovations Inc., a software company being acquired by Global Solutions Corp. Tech Innovations reports annual EBITDA of $10 million. During the Acquired Quality of Earnings review, the following adjustments are identified:

  1. One-time legal settlement: Tech Innovations received a $1 million payment from a settled lawsuit, which was included in their revenue. This is a non-recurring item.
  2. Owner's discretionary expenses: The owner expensed $500,000 in personal travel and entertainment that will not continue post-acquisition.
  3. Capital expenditure misclassification: $200,000 in routine maintenance, which should have been expensed, was capitalized, artificially boosting current period earnings.
  4. Customer concentration risk: A significant portion of revenue, say 40%, comes from a single customer, introducing considerable risk. While not a direct accounting adjustment, this impacts earnings quality and sustainability.

Calculation of Adjusted EBITDA:

Original EBITDA: $10,000,000
Less: One-time legal settlement: ($1,000,000)
Add: Owner's discretionary expenses: $500,000
Add: Capital expenditure misclassification (expense added back): $200,000

Adjusted EBITDA: $10,000,000 - $1,000,000 + $500,000 + $200,000 = $9,700,000

This adjusted EBITDA of $9.7 million provides Global Solutions Corp. with a more realistic picture of Tech Innovations' sustainable operating profitability, allowing for more accurate valuation and informing negotiation of the purchase price and working capital adjustments.

Practical Applications

Acquired Quality of Earnings reviews are integral to numerous aspects of investing and corporate transactions:

  • Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A): The primary application, where buyers use QoE reports to validate historical financial performance, identify potential risks, and ensure that the purchase price reflects the target company's true earnings power. According to Opportune LLP, a quality of earnings report provides buyers an "extra level of certainty" during their due diligence process. 3It helps uncover hidden liabilities or undisclosed issues.
    2* Lending and Financing: Lenders often require a QoE analysis before providing acquisition financing or other substantial loans, as it helps them assess the borrower's repayment capacity based on sustainable earnings.
  • Divestitures and Sales: Sellers may commission a QoE report (often called "sell-side QoE") to proactively identify and address potential issues before a sale process, presenting a more credible and attractive financial picture to potential buyers.
  • Private Equity Investments: Private equity firms heavily rely on Acquired Quality of Earnings to assess the operational health and growth prospects of portfolio companies, ensuring that investment theses are grounded in accurate financial data.
  • Restructuring and Turnarounds: During financial distress, a QoE analysis can help identify the true sources of profitability or loss, guiding strategic decisions for operational improvements and financial restructuring.
  • Financial Modeling and Forecasting: The adjusted financial figures from a QoE report are used as a reliable baseline for building future financial models and forecasts, making projections more robust and accurate.

Limitations and Criticisms

While invaluable, Acquired Quality of Earnings analysis has limitations. It is backward-looking, focusing on historical financial statements and trends. While it provides a strong foundation, it cannot perfectly predict future performance, which is subject to market dynamics, competition, and economic shifts. The subjective nature of certain adjustments can also be a point of contention; different analysts might interpret the "quality" of an earning differently, leading to variations in adjusted figures. For example, the decision to normalize certain discretionary expenses or one-time events can involve judgment calls. Moreover, even with a thorough QoE review, there remains a risk of undetected fraud or misrepresentation. Regulatory bodies like the SEC frequently take action against companies for misleading statements related to financial performance, underscoring the ongoing challenge of ensuring complete accuracy and transparency in financial reporting. 1An Acquired Quality of Earnings report, while rigorous, is not a guarantee against all unforeseen issues, nor does it replace the need for ongoing due diligence and robust post-acquisition integration strategies.

Acquired Quality of Earnings vs. Due Diligence

Acquired Quality of Earnings is a specialized component within the broader scope of due diligence. Due diligence encompasses a comprehensive investigation into all material aspects of a target company, including legal, operational, environmental, commercial, tax, and human resources considerations, in addition to financial matters. Its purpose is to verify information, assess risks, and confirm the accuracy of representations made by the seller before a transaction is finalized. Acquired Quality of Earnings, specifically, dives deep into the financial aspects, focusing intently on the integrity and sustainability of a company's reported earnings. Therefore, while a QoE report provides critical financial insights, it is one of many reports and analyses that collectively form the complete due diligence process undertaken by a prospective buyer or investor. The confusion often arises because the financial findings from a QoE heavily influence the economic viability and pricing of the deal, making it a pivotal, though not exhaustive, part of due diligence.

FAQs

What is the main goal of an Acquired Quality of Earnings review?
The main goal is to understand the true, sustainable profitability of a company being acquired by adjusting its historical financial statements for non-recurring items, discretionary expenses, and aggressive accounting practices.

How does Acquired Quality of Earnings differ from a financial audit?
An audit primarily verifies that financial statements adhere to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP)) and present a fair view of the company's financial position. An Acquired Quality of Earnings review goes beyond compliance to assess the sustainability and predictability of earnings, often making adjustments that are not required under GAAP to provide a "normalized" view of profitability.

Who performs an Acquired Quality of Earnings analysis?
Typically, independent accounting firms, specialized financial advisory firms, or internal finance teams with expertise in M&A transactions conduct Acquired Quality of Earnings reviews.

Why is Acquired Quality of Earnings important for buyers?
It helps buyers avoid overpaying for an acquisition by providing an accurate picture of the target company's ongoing financial performance, uncovering potential financial risks, and informing the purchase price and deal structure. It is crucial for assessing the expected future cash flow and return on investment.

Can an Acquired Quality of Earnings report uncover fraud?
While an Acquired Quality of Earnings review is not designed as a forensic audit to detect fraud, its rigorous examination of financial records and underlying transactions may uncover inconsistencies or red flags that could indicate fraudulent activity. However, its primary purpose is to assess earnings sustainability rather than fraud detection.