Skip to main content
← Back to A Definitions

Adjusted average roe

What Is Adjusted Average ROE?

Adjusted Average ROE, or Adjusted Average Return on Equity, is a profitability ratio that modifies the standard Return on Equity (ROE) calculation to provide a more accurate and representative measure of a company's sustainable earnings power. Within financial analysis, this adjustment typically involves removing the impact of non-recurring items or other unusual events from a company's net income over a period, often multiple periods, to smooth out temporary fluctuations. By considering the average of these adjusted figures over several years, Adjusted Average ROE aims to present a clearer picture of how effectively a company's management utilizes shareholders' equity to generate profits from its core operations.

History and Origin

The concept of adjusting financial metrics like Return on Equity has evolved alongside the increasing complexity of corporate financial reporting. While the basic Return on Equity (ROE) ratio has been a cornerstone of financial analysis for decades, analysts and investors recognized that reported net income could be skewed by one-time gains or losses. These non-recurring items, such as proceeds from asset sales, restructuring charges, or litigation settlements, do not reflect a company's ongoing operational performance.

Both Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) in the United States, overseen by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), and International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), provide frameworks for how companies present their financial statements. IAS 1, for instance, sets out general requirements for presentation and emphasizes consistency.12 However, these standards still allow for the reporting of various income and expense items that might not be core to regular business operations. Consequently, the practice of making "non-GAAP" adjustments to reported earnings and other metrics became prevalent to offer what management often considers a more insightful view of core business performance. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has provided guidance regarding the use and disclosure of these "key performance indicators and other metrics," emphasizing the need for clear definitions, explanations of usefulness, and how management uses them.11

Key Takeaways

  • Adjusted Average ROE provides a normalized view of a company's profitability by stripping out non-recurring or unusual items from net income.
  • It offers insights into a company's sustainable earnings power from its core operations, rather than being distorted by one-off events.
  • Calculating Adjusted Average ROE typically involves averaging adjusted net income over several fiscal periods against average shareholders' equity.
  • This metric is particularly useful for long-term investors and analysts seeking to understand fundamental business performance and make reliable forecasts.
  • While offering a clearer picture, the subjective nature of what constitutes an "adjustment" can lead to inconsistencies and potential for manipulation if not transparently applied.

Formula and Calculation

The calculation of Adjusted Average ROE begins with adjusting the net income for each period considered. This adjusted net income is then used to calculate an adjusted ROE for each period, and subsequently averaged.

1. Adjusted Net Income:
Adjusted Net Income=Reported Net Income±Impact of Non-Recurring Items (tax-affected)\text{Adjusted Net Income} = \text{Reported Net Income} \pm \text{Impact of Non-Recurring Items (tax-affected)}

Non-recurring items can include various gains or losses that are considered unusual or infrequent, such as litigation settlements, asset write-downs, restructuring costs, or gains/losses from the sale of a business segment. It's crucial that any adjustment is "tax-affected," meaning the tax impact of adding back or subtracting the item is also considered.

2. Adjusted ROE for a Period:
Adjusted ROE=Adjusted Net IncomeAverage Shareholders’ Equity\text{Adjusted ROE} = \frac{\text{Adjusted Net Income}}{\text{Average Shareholders' Equity}}
where:

  • Average Shareholders' Equity = (\frac{\text{Beginning Shareholders' Equity} + \text{Ending Shareholders' Equity}}{2})

3. Adjusted Average ROE:
Adjusted Average ROE=i=1nAdjusted ROEin\text{Adjusted Average ROE} = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n} \text{Adjusted ROE}_i}{n}
Where (n) represents the number of periods (e.g., 3 or 5 years) over which the average is calculated.

By using average shareholders' equity in the denominator, the formula accounts for changes in equity throughout the period, providing a more robust measure of the return generated on the capital available to the company's owners.

Interpreting the Adjusted Average ROE

Interpreting Adjusted Average ROE requires a nuanced understanding of its components and context. A higher Adjusted Average ROE generally indicates that a company is more efficient at generating profits from the equity invested by its shareholders, after removing the noise of unusual events. This suggests strong core operational performance and effective management.10

However, the interpretation should always be relative:

  • Industry Comparison: Adjusted Average ROE should be compared to the average of peer companies within the same industry. Different industries have varying capital structures and profitability profiles. For instance, a utility company might have a lower "normal" ROE than a technology company due to differing asset bases and debt levels.
  • Trend Analysis: Observing the trend of a company's Adjusted Average ROE over several years can reveal whether its core profitability is improving, deteriorating, or remaining stable. A consistent Adjusted Average ROE suggests predictable performance.
  • Quality of Adjustments: The value of Adjusted Average ROE heavily depends on the quality and transparency of the adjustments made. Analysts must scrutinize the reasons for adjustments and ensure they genuinely represent non-recurring items rather than efforts to obscure recurring expenses or inflate profitability.9 Companies are generally encouraged to provide clear definitions and rationale for such adjustments.8

This metric helps investors focus on the underlying business, assessing its ability to generate sustainable returns, which is crucial for long-term valuation metrics.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "Alpha Corp," a manufacturing company, and its financial performance over three years.

Year 1:

  • Reported Net Income: $10 million
  • One-time gain from sale of obsolete equipment: $2 million (tax-affected)
  • Beginning Shareholders' Equity: $80 million
  • Ending Shareholders' Equity: $85 million

Year 2:

  • Reported Net Income: $12 million
  • Restructuring charge: $1 million (tax-affected)
  • Beginning Shareholders' Equity: $85 million
  • Ending Shareholders' Equity: $90 million

Year 3:

  • Reported Net Income: $15 million
  • No significant non-recurring items
  • Beginning Shareholders' Equity: $90 million
  • Ending Shareholders' Equity: $95 million

Calculations:

Year 1:

  • Adjusted Net Income = $10 million - $2 million = $8 million
  • Average Shareholders' Equity = (\$80 million + $85 million) / 2 = $82.5 million
  • Adjusted ROE (Year 1) = ($8 million / $82.5 million) = 0.09697 or 9.70%

Year 2:

  • Adjusted Net Income = $12 million + $1 million = $13 million
  • Average Shareholders' Equity = (\$85 million + $90 million) / 2 = $87.5 million
  • Adjusted ROE (Year 2) = ($13 million / $87.5 million) = 0.14857 or 14.86%

Year 3:

  • Adjusted Net Income = $15 million
  • Average Shareholders' Equity = (\ Radiology 90 million + $95 million) / 2 = $92.5 million
  • Adjusted ROE (Year 3) = ($15 million / $92.5 million) = 0.16216 or 16.22%

Adjusted Average ROE (3 years):
Adjusted Average ROE=0.0970+0.1486+0.16223\text{Adjusted Average ROE} = \frac{0.0970 + 0.1486 + 0.1622}{3}
Adjusted Average ROE=0.40783=0.13593 or 13.59%\text{Adjusted Average ROE} = \frac{0.4078}{3} = 0.13593 \text{ or } 13.59\%

This Adjusted Average ROE of 13.59% provides a more consistent measure of Alpha Corp's core profitability over the three years, offering a better basis for forecasting future performance than simply averaging the unadjusted ROE figures. It allows for a clearer view of the company's ability to generate returns on its capital structure.

Practical Applications

Adjusted Average ROE finds several practical applications across investing, financial analysis, and corporate planning:

  • Investment Analysis: Investors utilize Adjusted Average ROE to gauge a company's true operational efficiency and long-term earnings sustainability. By removing volatile, non-recurring elements, it helps in identifying companies with consistent underlying profitability, making it a critical metric for fundamental analysis.7 It informs decisions on whether a company is effectively using shareholders' equity to generate returns.
  • Comparative Analysis: This metric is highly valuable when comparing companies within the same industry or across different industries, especially those that frequently report non-recurring items. It levels the playing field, allowing for more apples-to-apples comparisons of core business performance.
  • Forecasting and Valuation: For financial analysts, Adjusted Average ROE serves as a more reliable input for future earnings projections and valuation metrics. Stable, predictable profitability is a key driver of long-term value.
  • Management Performance Evaluation: While not the sole metric, Adjusted Average ROE can assist boards and investors in evaluating management's effectiveness in generating returns from ongoing operations, rather than from fortuitous one-off gains or significant non-operational charges.
  • Credit Analysis: Lenders and credit rating agencies may look at Adjusted Average ROE to assess a company's ability to generate consistent profits to service its debt and maintain financial health. Consistent profitability, even after adjustments, indicates lower risk.
  • Regulatory Scrutiny: The use of "non-GAAP" or "adjusted" financial measures, which include adjustments like those for Adjusted Average ROE, has been a focus of regulatory bodies like the SEC. The SEC has issued guidance requiring clear disclosure requirements for such metrics, emphasizing transparency and avoiding misleading presentations.6 This underscores the importance of proper application and reporting when using adjusted figures in public filings.

Limitations and Criticisms

While Adjusted Average ROE offers a refined view of profitability, it is not without limitations and criticisms:

  • Subjectivity of Adjustments: The primary criticism revolves around the subjective nature of what constitutes a "non-recurring" or "unusual" item. Management has discretion in deciding which items to exclude, potentially leading to an overly optimistic portrayal of financial health by consistently removing "bad" items while sometimes including "good" one-off gains in other adjusted metrics.5 This can obscure the true impact of certain events on long-term performance.
  • Lack of Standardization: Unlike measures strictly adhering to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) or International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), the methodology for calculating Adjusted Average ROE (and other "non-GAAP" metrics) is not standardized across companies. This lack of uniformity can make cross-company comparisons challenging, even within the same industry, unless the adjustments made by each company are thoroughly understood and normalized by the analyst.
  • Ignoring Real Costs: Some "non-recurring" items, while infrequent, can represent real economic costs or benefits. For example, restructuring charges might be necessary for a company's future viability, and consistently ignoring them could provide an incomplete picture of its operational challenges.4 Similarly, the financial impact of changes in accounting policies or error corrections can materially influence reported equity and ROE, indicating that such "prior period adjustments" should be carefully considered.3
  • Potential for Manipulation: The flexibility in making adjustments can be exploited to present a more favorable financial picture to investors, potentially misleading those who do not delve into the specifics of the adjustments.2 This emphasizes the need for investors to review the reconciliation of adjusted figures to their GAAP or IFRS equivalents, which companies are typically required to provide.
  • Contextual Relevance: An extremely high Adjusted Average ROE could signal financial leverage issues rather than just strong operational performance. If a company heavily relies on debt to finance its assets, its shareholders' equity might be very small, which can artificially inflate the ROE ratio. Therefore, it is essential to analyze Adjusted Average ROE in conjunction with other metrics, such as debt-to-equity ratios. Some studies have also indicated that excessive ROEs in certain regulated industries, like utilities, might incentivize capital expenditure over more cost-effective solutions, suggesting a potential misalignment of incentives.1

Adjusted Average ROE vs. Return on Equity (ROE)

While Adjusted Average ROE and Return on Equity (ROE) both measure a company's profitability relative to its shareholders' equity, their key differences lie in their calculation and the insights they provide.

FeatureAdjusted Average ROEReturn on Equity (ROE)
Calculation BasisUses net income adjusted for non-recurring or unusual items, averaged over multiple periods.Uses reported net income from a single period.
FocusSustainable, core operational profitability.Overall profitability as reported, including one-off events.
VolatilityLess susceptible to short-term fluctuations caused by extraordinary events.Can be significantly impacted by one-time gains or losses.
ComparabilityAims for better comparability between companies by normalizing earnings, but methodology can vary.Directly comparable based on reported figures, but actual underlying performance might differ due to non-recurring items.
Use CaseIdeal for long-term analysis, trend assessment, and forecasting future sustainable performance.Useful for immediate snapshot of current profitability, but may require analyst adjustments for deeper insight.

The confusion often arises because analysts frequently make adjustments to the standard ROE to arrive at a more "normalized" figure, effectively creating an adjusted ROE. Adjusted Average ROE formalizes this by explicitly incorporating these adjustments and averaging them over time, striving to filter out the noise and present a clearer, more consistent picture of a company's fundamental ability to generate returns for its owners from its ongoing business operations.

FAQs

Why is it important to adjust ROE?

Adjusting ROE is important because the standard Return on Equity (ROE) calculation uses reported net income, which can be heavily influenced by one-time or unusual events. By adjusting for these non-recurring items, analysts can gain a clearer understanding of a company's sustainable earnings power from its core operations, providing a more reliable basis for future performance assessment and investment decisions.

What kinds of items are typically adjusted out of net income for Adjusted Average ROE?

Items typically adjusted out of net income for Adjusted Average ROE include non-recurring gains or losses, such as profits or losses from the sale of assets, significant litigation settlements, large one-time restructuring charges, or impairments of goodwill or other assets. These are items that are not expected to recur regularly and are not part of the company's ordinary business activities.

How many years should be used when calculating Adjusted Average ROE?

The number of years used when calculating Adjusted Average ROE can vary, but typically a period of three to five years is common. Using multiple years helps smooth out any remaining short-term volatility and provides a more representative average of the company's long-term operational profitability and ability to generate returns on shareholders' equity.

Does Adjusted Average ROE account for debt?

Indirectly, Adjusted Average ROE does account for debt through its relationship with shareholders' equity. Equity is calculated as assets minus liabilities (including debt) on the balance sheet. Therefore, changes in a company's debt levels, which affect total assets and liabilities, will impact the amount of shareholders' equity. High levels of financial leverage can reduce shareholders' equity, potentially inflating ROE even without strong operational performance. Analysts using Adjusted Average ROE should also examine a company's debt levels and overall capital structure for a complete picture.