Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to A Definitions

Adjusted deferred earnings

What Is Adjusted Deferred Earnings?

Adjusted Deferred Earnings is a financial accounting concept that refers to the modifications or reclassifications made to a company's deferred revenue balances to align with specific accounting standards, business events, or regulatory requirements. In essence, it represents the original unearned revenue that has undergone specific accounting adjustments before being recognized as earned income on the income statement. This concept is crucial for presenting an accurate picture of a company's financial health and future obligations within its financial statements.

Deferred revenue, also known as unearned revenue or a contract liability, arises when a company receives payment for goods or services before they have been delivered or performed. It is initially recorded as a liability on the balance sheet, reflecting the company's obligation to provide future goods or services. Adjustments to these deferred earnings can stem from various factors, such as changes in the fair value of acquired deferred revenue in mergers and acquisitions, or reallocations necessitated by complex contracts and evolving revenue recognition standards.

History and Origin

The concept of adjustments to deferred earnings, particularly concerning revenue recognition, gained significant prominence with the advent of new global accounting standards. Prior to these changes, accounting practices for revenue could vary widely across industries and jurisdictions, making financial comparisons challenging. To address these inconsistencies, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) collaborated to create a converged standard. This effort culminated in the issuance of Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2014-09, known as ASC Topic 606, "Revenue from Contracts with Customers," in May 2014.4

ASC 606, along with its international counterpart IFRS 15, established a five-step model for revenue recognition, moving from a rules-based to a principles-based approach. Under ASC 606, revenue is recognized when control of goods or services is transferred to the customer, rather than merely when payment is received. This fundamental shift often necessitated companies to reassess and adjust their existing deferred revenue balances, particularly for long-term contracts, subscriptions, or bundled offerings. For instance, in business combinations, acquired deferred revenue may need to be adjusted to its fair value, which often results in a lower recognized revenue post-acquisition. This historical evolution highlights how the push for greater transparency and comparability in financial reporting directly led to more refined treatments of deferred earnings.

Key Takeaways

  • Adjusted Deferred Earnings refers to changes made to unearned revenue balances, often due to new accounting standards or business acquisitions.
  • These adjustments ensure that revenue is recognized in accordance with principles like those outlined in ASC 606, aligning with the transfer of control of goods or services.
  • The adjustments primarily impact the timing and amount of revenue reported on the income statement, moving from a liability on the balance sheet.
  • Understanding Adjusted Deferred Earnings is vital for investors and analysts to accurately assess a company's true profitability and future revenue streams.
  • Fair value adjustments for acquired deferred revenue are a common reason for such modifications in mergers and acquisitions.

Formula and Calculation

Adjusted Deferred Earnings is not determined by a single universal formula but rather results from applying specific accounting principles and judgments to a company's unearned revenue. The calculation involves assessing the nature of the contracts with customers and making reclassifications or revaluations based on accounting standards.

For instance, under ASC 606, the revenue recognition process involves five steps:

  1. Identify the contract(s) with a customer.
  2. Identify the separate performance obligations in the contract.
  3. Determine the transaction price.
  4. Allocate the transaction price to the separate performance obligations.
  5. Recognize revenue when (or as) the entity satisfies a performance obligation.3

The "adjustment" element often comes into play during step 4, where the transaction price is allocated, particularly when multiple goods or services are bundled, or in specific scenarios like business combinations. In an acquisition, the acquirer must value the deferred revenue of the acquired company at its fair value, which is generally lower than the acquiree's historical carrying amount because the acquirer does not incur the selling effort and profit margin associated with the original sale. This fair value adjustment reduces the amount of deferred revenue (a contract liability) on the balance sheet at the acquisition date, which then impacts the amount of revenue recognized in future periods from those acquired contracts.

Another form of adjustment involves the reclassification of deferred revenue into contract assets or liabilities, depending on the nature of the performance obligations and payment terms. This is less a "calculation" and more a "re-presentation" to reflect the timing of revenue recognition.

Interpreting the Adjusted Deferred Earnings

Interpreting Adjusted Deferred Earnings requires an understanding of the underlying accounting changes or business transactions that led to the adjustments. When companies report Adjusted Deferred Earnings, it typically indicates a more refined or revalued portion of their unearned revenue. For instance, if a company acquires another business, the acquired deferred revenue will often be "adjusted" down to its fair value. This means that future revenue recognized from these pre-existing contracts will be lower than what the acquired company would have recognized had it continued as a standalone entity.

Analysts and investors should examine the disclosures accompanying these adjustments in the financial statements. They provide crucial insights into the quality and sustainability of a company's future revenue streams. A significant reduction in deferred earnings due to fair value adjustments, for example, can imply a lower baseline for future reported revenue from acquired contracts, even if the underlying cash flow remains the same. Conversely, reclassifications under new accounting standards might not alter the overall revenue recognized but change its presentation or timing, offering more clarity on performance obligations.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "Software Solutions Inc." (SSI), a hypothetical company that sells annual software subscriptions. In January 2024, a customer pays SSI $1,200 for a one-year subscription, valid from January 1, 2024, to December 31, 2024.

Original Entry (January 1, 2024):
When SSI receives the $1,200, it records it as unearned revenue (a liability).
Debit: Cash $1,200
Credit: Deferred Revenue $1,200

Monthly Recognition (Before Adjustment):
Each month, SSI would recognize $100 ($1,200 / 12 months) as revenue.
Debit: Deferred Revenue $100
Credit: Subscription Revenue $100

Now, suppose on July 1, 2024, "Tech Innovations Corp." (TIC) acquires SSI. At the acquisition date, SSI has $600 in deferred revenue remaining for this customer (6 months x $100). Under purchase accounting rules, TIC must revalue this acquired deferred revenue to its fair value. Let's assume TIC determines the fair value of the remaining obligation is $450, reflecting the present value of the cost to service the remaining contract without the original profit margin.

Adjustment Entry (July 1, 2024 - TIC's books):
TIC would record the acquired deferred revenue at $450 on its consolidated balance sheet. The difference of $150 ($600 - $450) is typically absorbed into the acquisition accounting, often reducing goodwill.
Debit: Deferred Revenue (from SSI's books) $600
Credit: Deferred Revenue (adjusted, on TIC's books) $450
Credit: Goodwill (or a similar acquisition adjustment account) $150

Post-Adjustment Monthly Recognition (July 1, 2024, onwards - TIC's books):
TIC will now recognize the remaining $450 of deferred revenue over the next 6 months.
Monthly Revenue Recognition: $450 / 6 months = $75 per month.
Debit: Deferred Revenue $75
Credit: Subscription Revenue $75

In this example, the "Adjusted Deferred Earnings" for this customer, from TIC's perspective, effectively lowered the future recognized revenue from $100/month to $75/month for the remaining contract term, even though the customer continues to pay the same amount to SSI (now part of TIC). This adjustment provides a clearer picture of the acquired entity's ongoing profitability from TIC's acquisition date.

Practical Applications

Adjusted Deferred Earnings plays a significant role in various financial contexts, primarily within financial accounting and corporate finance. Its practical applications include:

  • Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A): A crucial application is in business combinations. When one company acquires another, the acquirer must revalue the target company's assets and liabilities, including its deferred revenue, to fair value. This often results in a "haircut" or reduction of the deferred revenue amount on the acquirer's consolidated balance sheet, impacting the revenue that will be recognized in future periods. This practice is evident in public company filings, such as Thomson Reuters' quarterly reports, which explicitly adjust reported revenues by excluding "fair value adjustments related to acquired deferred revenue" to compute adjusted EBITDA margin.2
  • Compliance with Accounting Standards: Companies must frequently adjust their deferred earnings to comply with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) or International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). The adoption of ASC 606 and IFRS 15, for instance, required many companies to reassess their revenue recognition patterns for contracts with customers, leading to adjustments in how deferred revenue is classified and subsequently earned.
  • Financial Analysis and Valuation: Investors and analysts scrutinize Adjusted Deferred Earnings to understand the true underlying performance of a business. These adjustments can affect key metrics like revenue growth rates, gross margins, and profitability, making it essential to differentiate between reported (GAAP) revenue and "adjusted" revenue that may exclude these specific items for a more operational view.
  • Internal Financial Planning: Management teams use these adjusted figures to forecast future revenue streams more accurately, especially after significant corporate events like acquisitions. This helps in resource allocation, budgeting, and setting realistic performance targets.

Limitations and Criticisms

While Adjusted Deferred Earnings provide a more nuanced view of a company's financial position, the practice is not without limitations and criticisms. One significant concern arises from the subjective nature of "fair value" assessments, particularly in business combinations. Determining the fair value of acquired deferred revenue often involves complex assumptions about the costs to fulfill future obligations and appropriate profit margins, which can introduce subjectivity and potentially reduce comparability across different acquisitions or companies.

Furthermore, the impact of these adjustments on reported revenue can sometimes be misconstrued by stakeholders. When deferred revenue is written down to fair value upon acquisition, the acquiring company will recognize less revenue from those pre-existing contracts than the acquired company would have. This can create a temporary drag on reported revenue growth for the acquiring entity, even though the underlying cash flows from the contracts remain unchanged. Critics argue that such adjustments can obscure the true economic value of the acquired contracts, potentially leading to a less transparent picture of the combined entity's actual performance.

The complexity of ASC 606 itself has presented challenges in understanding and applying revenue recognition principles, as noted by academics.1 This complexity can lead to variations in how companies interpret and implement the standard, potentially affecting the consistency of deferred earnings adjustments. While the goal is to improve transparency, the intricacies of these adjustments can sometimes make financial statements harder for non-experts to fully comprehend, requiring careful review of accompanying disclosures.

Adjusted Deferred Earnings vs. Deferred Revenue

The terms "Adjusted Deferred Earnings" and "Deferred Revenue" are closely related but refer to distinct concepts in financial reporting.

Deferred Revenue (also known as unearned revenue) is a liability account on a company's balance sheet that represents payments received from customers for goods or services that have not yet been delivered or performed. It is essentially an obligation to the customer. For example, if a software company receives a $1,200 payment for an annual subscription upfront, that $1,200 is initially recorded as deferred revenue. As the service is provided over the year, a portion of that deferred revenue is moved to the income statement as earned revenue each month.

Adjusted Deferred Earnings, on the other hand, refers to the modifications or revaluations made to these deferred revenue balances. These adjustments typically occur in specific circumstances, such as:

  • Business Combinations: When one company acquires another, the deferred revenue of the acquired company is often adjusted to its fair value on the acquirer's books. This fair value is usually less than the historical carrying amount because it reflects only the cost to fulfill the obligation, not the profit margin of the original sale.
  • Application of New Accounting Standards: With the implementation of standards like ASC 606, companies were required to reassess their contracts and potentially reallocate transaction prices to different performance obligations, leading to adjustments in how deferred revenue is initially recorded and subsequently recognized.

In summary, deferred revenue is the initial unearned payment recorded as a liability. Adjusted Deferred Earnings is the result of applying specific accounting principles or fair value assessments to that deferred revenue balance, influencing how and when that unearned amount is eventually recognized as earned income. The adjustments aim to present a more accurate financial picture according to prevailing accounting standards, particularly in complex business scenarios.

FAQs

What causes deferred earnings to be adjusted?

Deferred earnings, often referred to as deferred revenue, are primarily adjusted due to two main reasons: business combinations (like mergers and acquisitions) where acquired deferred revenue is revalued to fair value, and the adoption of new accounting standards (such as ASC 606) that require a reassessment of how and when revenue is recognized.

How does Adjusted Deferred Earnings impact a company's financial statements?

Adjusted Deferred Earnings directly impacts both the balance sheet and the income statement. On the balance sheet, the deferred revenue liability account is changed to reflect the adjustment. Consequently, on the income statement, the amount of revenue recognized in future periods from those contracts will reflect these adjustments, potentially affecting reported revenue growth and profitability.

Is Adjusted Deferred Earnings typically higher or lower than original deferred revenue?

In the context of mergers and acquisitions, the Adjusted Deferred Earnings (fair value of acquired deferred revenue) is typically lower than the original deferred revenue recorded by the acquired company. This is because the fair value reflects the cost to fulfill the remaining service obligation, excluding the profit margin that was part of the original sale.

Why is it important for investors to understand Adjusted Deferred Earnings?

Understanding Adjusted Deferred Earnings is crucial for investors because it provides insight into the true economics of a company's operations, especially after acquisitions. It helps investors differentiate between accounting adjustments and actual operational performance, allowing for a more accurate assessment of future revenue potential and a company's financial health. It aids in assessing the quality of reported revenue recognition.