Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to A Definitions

Adjusted economic return

What Is Adjusted Economic Return?

Adjusted Economic Return is a financial metric that measures a business's true profitability by considering both explicit and implicit costs, thereby offering a more comprehensive view of performance than traditional accounting measures. It falls under the broader financial category of performance measurement. While standard accounting metrics primarily focus on historical costs and revenues, Adjusted Economic Return incorporates the concept of opportunity cost—the value of the next best alternative forgone when a particular decision is made. This makes Adjusted Economic Return a critical tool for assessing the economic viability and efficiency of investments and business operations, moving beyond mere compliance-based reporting to reflect actual value creation. It provides a more nuanced understanding of how effectively capital is being utilized.

History and Origin

The concept behind Adjusted Economic Return originates from the field of economics, contrasting sharply with traditional accounting practices. While accountants focus on accounting profit, which subtracts explicit costs from revenue, economists have long emphasized the importance of including implicit costs in profit calculations. This distinction became particularly relevant in the mid-20th century as financial theory evolved to incorporate more sophisticated measures of value. The divergence in perspectives stems from the fundamental difference in how economists and accountants view costs; economists consider all resources, including those not directly paid for, as having a cost. For example, if a business owner uses their own building, the forgone rent is an implicit cost that an accountant might not record but an economist would. The emphasis on economic return gained further traction as companies and investors sought to better understand the true value generated, especially when traditional financial statements, based on Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), were criticized for not fully capturing a firm's economic reality. Regulators, such as the SEC, have also provided extensive guidance on non-GAAP financial measures, highlighting the need for transparent reconciliation to comparable GAAP measures when these adjusted metrics are presented publicly.

5## Key Takeaways

  • Adjusted Economic Return considers both explicit and implicit costs, including opportunity costs, to provide a more holistic view of profitability.
  • It is a non-GAAP measure, meaning it is not standardized by generally accepted accounting principles.
  • This metric is crucial for strategic decision-making, such as capital budgeting and evaluating alternative investments.
  • Unlike net income, which focuses on historical accounting data, Adjusted Economic Return offers insights into future potential and resource allocation efficiency.
  • It helps in assessing the true return on investment by accounting for all resources consumed.

Formula and Calculation

The core idea behind Adjusted Economic Return is to subtract both explicit and implicit costs from total revenue. While there isn't one universal "Adjusted Economic Return" formula, it generally extends the concept of economic profit.

A simplified formula can be expressed as:

Adjusted Economic Return=Total Revenue−Explicit Costs−Implicit Costs\text{Adjusted Economic Return} = \text{Total Revenue} - \text{Explicit Costs} - \text{Implicit Costs}

Where:

  • Total Revenue: The total sales or income generated by the business or project.
  • Explicit Costs: Direct, out-of-pocket expenses, such as wages, rent, raw materials, and utility payments. These are typically recorded in a company's financial statements.
  • Implicit Costs: The opportunity costs of resources owned by the firm and used in production. These do not involve a direct monetary payment but represent the income foregone by not using the resources in their best alternative use. Examples include the salary an entrepreneur could earn working elsewhere or the rent that could be received by leasing a company-owned building.

Interpreting the Adjusted Economic Return

Interpreting the Adjusted Economic Return involves understanding that a positive value indicates that a business or project is not only covering its direct expenses but also generating enough profit to exceed the returns available from its next best alternative use of capital. A zero Adjusted Economic Return suggests that the business is covering all its costs, both explicit and implicit, but is not generating any surplus beyond what could be earned from an alternative investment of similar risk. A negative Adjusted Economic Return implies that the business is not even covering its full economic costs, meaning the resources could be better utilized elsewhere to generate greater value.

This metric is particularly useful in strategic planning and valuation, as it provides a realistic assessment of true profitability and efficiency. Companies can use it to evaluate whether a project is truly adding shareholder value or if resources are being misallocated.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "GreenGrow," a small organic farm owned and operated by Alex. In a given year, GreenGrow generates $150,000 in revenue from selling produce.

Its explicit costs are:

  • Seeds and supplies: $20,000
  • Hired labor: $30,000
  • Equipment maintenance: $10,000
  • Utilities: $5,000
  • Total Explicit Costs = $20,000 + $30,000 + $10,000 + $5,000 = $65,000

Alex, the owner, works full-time on the farm. If Alex were to work as an agricultural consultant, they could earn $70,000 annually. This $70,000 is an implicit cost (specifically, an opportunity cost) of Alex's labor.

Additionally, Alex owns the land the farm is on. If the land were leased to another farmer, it could generate $15,000 in annual rental income. This is another implicit cost.

Now, let's calculate GreenGrow's Adjusted Economic Return:

Adjusted Economic Return=Total Revenue−Explicit Costs−Implicit Costs\text{Adjusted Economic Return} = \text{Total Revenue} - \text{Explicit Costs} - \text{Implicit Costs} Adjusted Economic Return=$150,000−$65,000−($70,000+$15,000)\text{Adjusted Economic Return} = \$150,000 - \$65,000 - (\$70,000 + \$15,000) Adjusted Economic Return=$150,000−$65,000−$85,000\text{Adjusted Economic Return} = \$150,000 - \$65,000 - \$85,000 Adjusted Economic Return=$150,000−$150,000\text{Adjusted Economic Return} = \$150,000 - \$150,000 Adjusted Economic Return=$0\text{Adjusted Economic Return} = \$0

In this hypothetical example, GreenGrow's Adjusted Economic Return is $0. This indicates that while the farm is covering all its explicit costs and providing Alex with an income equivalent to their next best alternative, it is not generating any "extra" economic value beyond that. From an economic perspective, Alex is breaking even, as the farm's return equals the opportunity cost of all resources used.

Practical Applications

Adjusted Economic Return finds practical application across various financial and business contexts, serving as a powerful analytical tool. In portfolio theory, it can help investors assess the true economic performance of different asset classes or investment strategies, considering not just explicit transaction costs but also the opportunity costs of capital tied up. Corporations leverage this metric in making informed capital budgeting decisions, comparing potential projects based on their ability to generate returns above the cost of capital and alternative uses of funds.

Furthermore, Adjusted Economic Return is valuable in evaluating corporate divisions or individual projects, allowing management to allocate resources more efficiently by identifying areas that truly create economic value versus those merely generating accounting profits. It can also inform executive compensation schemes, aligning incentives with long-term value creation rather than short-term accounting gains. The metric's emphasis on true economic performance is particularly relevant in periods of economic change, such as those influenced by inflation, which can distort traditional accounting figures. The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco has noted how persistent inflation can impose burdens that reduce economic welfare by interfering with the efficiency of the price system and making it harder for firms to make correct decisions. T4his highlights the importance of adjusting performance metrics to reflect real economic conditions. Companies are increasingly re-evaluating their performance metrics in today's complex business environment to drive long-term value creation.

3## Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its theoretical advantages, Adjusted Economic Return has several limitations. A primary criticism is the subjectivity involved in quantifying implicit costs and opportunity costs. Unlike explicit costs, which are recorded transactions, implicit costs require estimation and assumptions about foregone alternatives, which can vary significantly depending on the estimator's perspective. This subjectivity can lead to different interpretations of the same business performance and makes comparisons between companies challenging.

Another limitation is its non-standardized nature. Unlike GAAP-compliant accounting profit, there is no universally agreed-upon methodology for calculating Adjusted Economic Return, which can reduce its comparability and verifiability for external stakeholders. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has issued guidance regarding the use of non-GAAP financial measures, emphasizing that they should not be misleading and must be reconciled to the most directly comparable GAAP measure. T2his regulatory scrutiny underscores the potential for misuse or misinterpretation when such non-standardized metrics are presented without proper context and transparency. Companies must also ensure their non-GAAP measures do not exclude normal, recurring, cash operating expenses necessary for business operations. C1ritics also point out that while valuable for internal decision-making and risk management, its reliance on theoretical constructs rather than verifiable historical data can limit its utility for external reporting or investor relations, where verifiable financial statements are paramount.

Adjusted Economic Return vs. Accounting Profit

The fundamental difference between Adjusted Economic Return and accounting profit lies in how each accounts for costs. Accounting profit is the financial gain a company reports after subtracting only explicit costs (actual out-of-pocket expenses like wages, rent, and supplies) from total revenue. It is governed by standardized accounting principles and is the figure typically reported on a company's income statement for tax and investor purposes.

Conversely, Adjusted Economic Return takes a broader view by subtracting both explicit and implicit costs from total revenue. Implicit costs represent the opportunity cost of resources—the benefits forgone by not pursuing the next best alternative. For instance, if a business owner uses their own building, the implicit cost would be the rent they could have earned by leasing it out. Therefore, accounting profit can be positive while Adjusted Economic Return is zero or negative, indicating that while the business is making a reported profit, it's not generating a return higher than what its resources could earn elsewhere. Economists and accountants often have different perspectives on profit measurement, with economists including opportunity costs that accountants typically do not.

FAQs

What is the main purpose of calculating Adjusted Economic Return?

The main purpose is to provide a more accurate and comprehensive view of a business's true profitability and efficiency by factoring in all costs, including the opportunity cost of capital and other resources. It helps in making better strategic decisions.

Is Adjusted Economic Return used in financial reporting?

Adjusted Economic Return is typically an internal performance metric used for decision-making and analysis rather than for external financial reporting. Public companies are required to report their financial results based on Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), which do not include implicit costs in their profit calculations. If companies disclose non-GAAP measures, they must reconcile them to the most comparable GAAP measure and ensure they are not misleading.

How does inflation affect Adjusted Economic Return?

Inflation can erode the purchasing power of money, and if not accounted for, can distort traditional accounting profits. Adjusted Economic Return, by focusing on economic reality, implicitly or explicitly aims to reflect the real return on investment, which means considering the impact of changing price levels on the value of inputs and outputs. Adjustments for inflation can be incorporated to provide a more realistic picture of economic performance.