Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to A Definitions

Adjusted estimated spread

What Is Adjusted Estimated Spread?

The Adjusted Estimated Spread is a refined measure used in fixed income analysis to quantify the additional yield an investor receives above a benchmark rate, after accounting for specific features or risks inherent in a security. While the term "Adjusted Estimated Spread" can be broadly applied to various financial instruments, in the context of bond valuation, it most commonly refers to the Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS). The Option-Adjusted Spread aims to provide a more accurate assessment of a bond's relative value by isolating the spread attributable to credit and liquidity risk, by removing the impact of embedded options. It is a critical metric for investors seeking to understand the true compensation for risk in complex securities, going beyond simpler spread calculations that do not factor in such nuances.

History and Origin

The concept of comparing bond yields to a risk-free rate, forming what is known as a credit spread, has existed for centuries, dating back to the emergence of corporate bonds in the 1600s and their widespread use for industrial expansion in the late 1800s5. However, the need for a more sophisticated "adjusted estimated spread" became apparent with the proliferation of bonds featuring embedded options, such as callable bonds and mortgage-backed securities (MBS).

Traditional yield measures or simple spreads failed to adequately capture the value of these options. As financial markets evolved in the late 20th century, particularly with the growth of the MBS market, the complexity of valuing securities with uncertain cash flows necessitated dynamic pricing models. This led to the development and widespread adoption of the Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS) in the 1980s. OAS models allowed market participants to quantify the yield premium required over a benchmark yield curve after accounting for the impact of these embedded options and their associated volatilities. This marked a significant advancement in fixed income analytics, providing a more robust measure of a bond's inherent value and risk.

Key Takeaways

  • The Adjusted Estimated Spread, often synonymous with Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS) in bond markets, measures the yield compensation for a bond's credit and liquidity risk, net of any embedded options.
  • It provides a more accurate assessment of a bond's true value compared to simpler yield spreads, especially for securities with features like call or put options.
  • The calculation of an Adjusted Estimated Spread involves complex modeling, such as Monte Carlo simulations, to account for various future interest rate scenarios and their impact on embedded options.
  • A higher Adjusted Estimated Spread generally indicates greater compensation for a given level of credit and liquidity risk.
  • It is a crucial tool for professional bond traders and portfolio managers for relative value analysis and risk management.

Formula and Calculation

The Adjusted Estimated Spread, particularly in its form as the Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS), does not have a single, simple algebraic formula. Instead, its calculation relies on complex quantitative models, typically involving a multi-step process:

  1. Build an Interest Rate Tree/Model: A probabilistic model is constructed to simulate hundreds or thousands of potential future interest rate paths. This accounts for [interest rate] volatility.
  2. Project Cash Flows: For each simulated interest rate path, the bond's cash flows are projected. For bonds with embedded options (like callable or putable bonds), the model determines if and when the option would be exercised, altering the projected cash flows. For instance, a callable bond might be called if interest rates fall significantly, shortening its expected life and cash flow stream. This step also accounts for prepayment risk in securities like mortgage-backed securities.
  3. Discount Cash Flows: The projected cash flows for each path are discounted back to the present using the benchmark yield curve plus an iterative spread (the OAS).
  4. Solve for the Spread: The OAS is the constant spread that, when added to the benchmark yield curve, makes the present value of the bond's expected cash flows across all simulated paths equal to its current market price.

Mathematically, the goal is to find the OAS (let's denote it as (S)) that satisfies:

Market Price=Expected Value[∑t=1TCFt(rt)(1+rt+S)t]\text{Market Price} = \text{Expected Value} \left[ \sum_{t=1}^{T} \frac{\text{CF}_t (r_t)}{\left(1 + r_t + S\right)^t} \right]

Where:

  • (\text{Market Price}) = Current market price of the bond.
  • (\text{Expected Value}) = The average present value across all simulated interest rate paths.
  • (\text{CF}_t (r_t)) = The bond's cash flow at time (t), which may vary depending on the interest rate (r_t) at that time due to embedded options.
  • (r_t) = The risk-free or benchmark interest rate at time (t) for a given path.
  • (S) = The Adjusted Estimated Spread (OAS) being solved for, expressed in basis points.
  • (T) = Maturity or expected life of the bond.

Due to the iterative and probabilistic nature, this calculation typically requires specialized software.

Interpreting the Adjusted Estimated Spread

Interpreting the Adjusted Estimated Spread, particularly the Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS), involves understanding what the resulting numeric value signifies in relation to a bond's risk and potential return. The OAS represents the compensation an investor receives for bearing the bond's non-option risks, such as default risk, liquidity risk, and sector-specific risks, after stripping out the impact of any embedded options.

For instance, if a callable bond has an OAS of 150 basis points, it means investors are demanding an extra 1.50% yield above the benchmark yield curve to compensate for the bond's credit risk, liquidity risk, and other non-option factors. A higher OAS for a bond generally suggests that investors are requiring greater compensation for the risks it carries. Conversely, a lower OAS may indicate lower perceived risk or a less attractive risk-adjusted return relative to other securities.

The primary application of the Adjusted Estimated Spread is to enable "apples-to-apples" comparisons between bonds that have different structural characteristics, especially those with and without embedded options. Without this adjustment, comparing a callable bond's simple yield spread to a non-callable bond's simple yield spread would be misleading, as the call option's value significantly impacts the bond's true yield. By isolating the spread from the option's influence, investors can better gauge the true risk premium of a security. It also provides insights into how the market prices a bond's unique features, allowing analysts to identify potentially undervalued or overvalued securities.

Hypothetical Example

Consider two hypothetical corporate bonds, Bond A and Bond B, both with a par value of $1,000, a 5-year maturity, and issued by companies with similar credit ratings.

  • Bond A: A plain vanilla (non-callable) corporate bond, currently trading at $980.
  • Bond B: A callable corporate bond, meaning the issuer can buy it back at a predetermined price (e.g., par) before maturity, currently trading at $970.

Let's assume the current 5-year U.S. Treasury [yield] (the risk-free benchmark) is 3.00%.

Step 1: Calculate the Z-Spread for both bonds.
The Z-spread (zero-volatility spread) is a common [credit spread] measure that accounts for the entire [yield] curve but does not adjust for embedded options. Suppose, after calculating, we find:

  • Bond A's Z-spread = 200 [basis points] (2.00%)
  • Bond B's Z-spread = 220 [basis points] (2.20%)

Based purely on Z-spread, Bond B appears to offer a higher return for similar [credit risk]. However, this ignores Bond B's call feature.

Step 2: Calculate the Adjusted Estimated Spread (OAS) for Bond B.
Since Bond A is non-callable, its Adjusted Estimated Spread (OAS) would be approximately equal to its Z-spread, assuming no other embedded options that affect its cash flows dynamically. So, Bond A's OAS ≈ 200 [basis points].

For Bond B, the presence of the call option means the issuer might recall the bond if interest rates fall, forcing the investor to reinvest at lower rates. This call option reduces the bond's value to the investor. When we run Bond B through a complex Option-Adjusted Spread model, which simulates thousands of interest rate paths and the issuer's propensity to call, we might find:

  • Bond B's Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS) = 170 [basis points] (1.70%)

Interpretation:
Even though Bond B initially showed a higher Z-spread (220 bps vs. 200 bps for Bond A), its Adjusted Estimated Spread (OAS) of 170 [basis points] is lower than Bond A's OAS of 200 [basis points]. This difference of 50 [basis points] (220 bps - 170 bps) represents the cost of the embedded call option to the investor. The OAS reveals that, on a risk-adjusted basis after accounting for the option, Bond B actually offers less compensation for its non-option risks compared to Bond A. An investor interested in maximizing compensation for [default risk] and [liquidity] risk would likely prefer Bond A, as its OAS is higher.

Practical Applications

The Adjusted Estimated Spread, particularly in its form as the Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS), is widely used across various facets of financial markets:

  • Bond Pricing and Valuation: Portfolio managers and traders use OAS to determine if a bond is fairly priced relative to similar securities. If a bond's OAS is higher than comparable bonds, it might suggest it is undervalued, or offers attractive compensation for its unique risks. Conversely, a lower OAS could indicate overvaluation.
  • Relative Value Analysis: It allows for "apples-to-apples" comparison of bonds with differing structures, especially those with embedded options. For example, comparing the OAS of a callable bond to a non-callable one provides a truer picture of the compensation for [credit risk] and [liquidity].
  • Risk Management: OAS helps in assessing the risk profile of bond portfolios. Changes in OAS over time can signal shifts in market perception of credit quality or liquidity for specific issuers or sectors. For instance, a sudden widening of OAS across a segment of the [fixed income] market might indicate increased perceived risk or liquidity issues.
  • Portfolio Construction: Investment managers use OAS to optimize portfolios, seeking bonds with higher adjusted spreads for better risk-adjusted returns, or to achieve specific risk exposures.
  • Regulatory Scrutiny: Increased transparency in the bond markets, partly driven by initiatives like the SEC's TRACE (Trade Reporting and Compliance Engine) system, has made the use of sophisticated metrics like Adjusted Estimated Spread more critical. TRACE enhances post-trade transparency in the U.S. corporate bond market, making pricing and spread analysis more robust. 3, 4During periods of financial stress, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, policymakers, including the Federal Reserve, closely monitor bond spreads to gauge market conditions and implement measures to support market [liquidity].
    2

Limitations and Criticisms

While the Adjusted Estimated Spread, particularly Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS), offers a more nuanced view of bond value, it is not without limitations:

  • Model Dependence: The primary criticism of OAS is its reliance on complex quantitative models, such as interest rate trees and Monte Carlo simulations. The accuracy of the Adjusted Estimated Spread is highly dependent on the assumptions built into these models, including interest rate volatility, prepayment speeds (for MBS), and option exercise behavior. If the model assumptions do not accurately reflect real-world market dynamics, the resulting OAS can be misleading.
  • Complexity and Opacity: The intricate calculations behind the Adjusted Estimated Spread can make it difficult for general investors to fully understand or replicate. This opacity can be a disadvantage compared to simpler [yield] measures.
  • Data Requirements: Accurate calculation of the Adjusted Estimated Spread requires extensive and high-quality market data, including current [bond] prices, yield curve data, and historical volatility. Data inconsistencies or lack of liquid trading for certain securities can impair the reliability of the calculation.
  • Behavioral Assumptions: For bonds with embedded options, the models often rely on assumptions about how issuers or borrowers will behave (e.g., when a callable bond will be called, or when mortgages will be refinanced). Actual behavior may deviate from these assumptions, leading to discrepancies between the calculated OAS and the true risk-adjusted return. Academic studies have highlighted challenges in accurately estimating [yield] spreads, especially during times of market crisis, emphasizing the ex-ante underestimation of spreads.
    1

Adjusted Estimated Spread vs. Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS)

The terms "Adjusted Estimated Spread" and "Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS)" are often used interchangeably in the context of bond analysis, particularly when discussing bonds with embedded options. However, it's useful to clarify their relationship:

  • Adjusted Estimated Spread is a broader, more general concept referring to any spread calculation that has been modified or refined to account for specific factors, risks, or structural complexities of a financial instrument. It suggests that a basic spread (like a nominal spread or Z-spread) has undergone further adjustment for greater accuracy.
  • Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS) is a specific type of Adjusted Estimated Spread that is specifically designed to isolate the credit and [liquidity] premium of a bond by removing the value of any embedded options. It achieves this by using complex dynamic pricing models that simulate various interest rate scenarios and the potential exercise of these options.

The key distinction lies in the mechanism of adjustment. While an "Adjusted Estimated Spread" could, in theory, refer to an adjustment for anything (e.g., a tax adjustment), the OAS refers exclusively to the adjustment for the impact of embedded options. Therefore, when discussing the valuation of securities like callable bonds, putable bonds, or mortgage-backed security (MBS), the Option-Adjusted Spread is the precise term for the adjusted estimated spread being calculated. In simpler terms, OAS is the most prominent and widely recognized instance of an "Adjusted Estimated Spread" in fixed income markets.

FAQs

What is the primary purpose of an Adjusted Estimated Spread?

The primary purpose of an Adjusted Estimated Spread, typically the Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS), is to provide a more accurate measure of the compensation an investor receives for holding a bond, by stripping out the influence of embedded options. This allows for better comparison of different [fixed income] securities on a risk-adjusted basis.

How is the Adjusted Estimated Spread different from a simple yield spread?

A simple [yield] spread (like the nominal spread or Z-spread) measures the difference between a bond's yield and a [benchmark] yield without accounting for any embedded options the bond might have. An Adjusted Estimated Spread, specifically OAS, refines this by using complex models to remove the impact of these options, giving a cleaner view of the compensation for [credit risk] and [liquidity].

What types of bonds typically require an Adjusted Estimated Spread calculation?

Bonds that typically require an Adjusted Estimated Spread calculation are those with embedded options. This includes callable bonds (where the issuer can redeem early), putable bonds (where the investor can sell back early), and mortgage-backed security (MBS) which have significant [prepayment risk] due to homeowner refinancing options.

Does a higher Adjusted Estimated Spread mean a better investment?

Generally, a higher Adjusted Estimated Spread (OAS) means that the [bond] offers more compensation per unit of non-option risk (like [default risk] and liquidity risk). While this might suggest a more attractive investment from a risk-adjusted return perspective, it's crucial to consider all underlying risks and your investment objectives before making a decision.