Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to A Definitions

Adjusted free reserves

What Is Adjusted Free Reserves?

Adjusted Free Reserves refer to the level of bank reserves held by commercial banks in excess of their reserve requirements, minus any borrowings from the Federal Reserve's discount window. This metric is a key indicator within central banking and monetary policy, providing insights into the overall liquidity available within the financial system. A positive value for Adjusted Free Reserves indicates that banks, collectively, have more funds than required and are not relying on central bank lending. Conversely, a negative value (often called "net borrowed reserves") suggests that banks, as a whole, are borrowing from the central bank to meet their reserve needs. This concept is vital for understanding the banking sector's capacity for lending and investment, thereby influencing interest rates and the broader money supply.

History and Origin

The concept of bank reserves and their management by a central bank has been fundamental to monetary policy since the establishment of such institutions. In the United States, the Federal Reserve System, created in 1913, was tasked with stabilizing the financial system and influencing credit conditions. Historically, the Federal Reserve imposed reserve requirements on depository institutions, mandating a certain percentage of deposits to be held as reserves. These requirements, along with the Fed's role as a lender of last resort through the discount window, naturally gave rise to the tracking of concepts like free reserves and adjusted free reserves.

Before 2020, reserve requirements were a primary tool of monetary policy. The Federal Reserve could adjust the required reserve ratio to influence the amount of funds banks had available for lending. For example, a 1999 article from the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco noted that the decline in required reserve balances was due in part to regulatory action, such as the elimination of reserve requirements on large time deposits in 1990 and the lowering of requirements on transaction accounts in 1992, as well as the growth of "sweep accounts."4 This evolution in bank practices necessitated a nuanced understanding of actual available reserves, hence the development of metrics like Adjusted Free Reserves to assess the banking system's true liquidity position. However, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Federal Reserve reduced reserve requirement ratios to zero percent effective March 26, 2020, essentially eliminating them for all depository institutions. While this changed the operational significance of required reserves, the concept of a bank's total reserves and its borrowings from the central bank remains relevant for understanding bank liquidity.

Key Takeaways

  • Adjusted Free Reserves measure bank liquidity beyond statutory requirements, accounting for central bank borrowings.
  • A positive value indicates excess liquidity in the banking system; a negative value (net borrowed reserves) indicates reliance on central bank funding.
  • This metric provides insight into banks' capacity for lending and investment, impacting economic activity.
  • It is a significant indicator for central banks in assessing the effectiveness of monetary policy and overall financial stability.
  • The elimination of reserve requirements in 2020 has changed how this metric is interpreted, though the underlying components of reserves and borrowings remain important.

Formula and Calculation

The calculation of Adjusted Free Reserves involves two primary steps: first, determining "Free Reserves," and then adjusting for central bank borrowings.

1. Free Reserves:
Free Reserves are the amount of total reserves held by commercial banks that exceeds their reserve requirements.

Free Reserves=Total Reserves−Required Reserves\text{Free Reserves} = \text{Total Reserves} - \text{Required Reserves}

2. Adjusted Free Reserves:
Adjusted Free Reserves then subtract any direct borrowings by commercial banks from the central bank (specifically, the discount window in the U.S. context) from the Free Reserves.

Adjusted Free Reserves=Free Reserves−Borrowings from Central Bank\text{Adjusted Free Reserves} = \text{Free Reserves} - \text{Borrowings from Central Bank}

Alternatively, the formula can be expressed as:

Adjusted Free Reserves=Total Reserves−Required Reserves−Borrowings from Central Bank\text{Adjusted Free Reserves} = \text{Total Reserves} - \text{Required Reserves} - \text{Borrowings from Central Bank}

Where:

  • Total Reserves: Funds held by commercial banks, either as vault cash or as balances at the Federal Reserve.
  • Required Reserves: The minimum amount of reserves that commercial banks were historically required to hold against their deposits. (Note: As of March 2020, reserve requirements are set to zero in the U.S.3).
  • Borrowings from Central Bank: Funds that commercial banks have borrowed directly from the central bank, typically through its discount window.

Interpreting the Adjusted Free Reserves

Interpreting Adjusted Free Reserves involves understanding what a positive, negative, or near-zero value signifies for the financial system. When Adjusted Free Reserves are significantly positive, it indicates that commercial banks have ample liquidity beyond their obligations and are not borrowing from the Federal Reserve. This suggests that banks have a strong capacity to extend new loans and invest, which can support economic growth and potentially lead to lower interest rates as banks compete to lend out their excess funds. This scenario is often associated with an accommodative monetary policy.

Conversely, a negative value for Adjusted Free Reserves, sometimes called "net borrowed reserves," implies that, on average, commercial banks are relying on the central bank's discount window to meet their reserve needs. This can signal tightness in the banking system's liquidity, potentially leading to higher short-term interest rates and a reduced willingness of banks to lend. A period of negative Adjusted Free Reserves might occur during times of financial stress or when the central bank is pursuing a tight monetary policy.

Even with the elimination of statutory reserve requirements in the U.S. in 2020, the underlying components of bank reserves and central bank borrowings remain critical for assessing the overall money supply and financial system health. The metric, though its historical context has shifted, still provides insight into the banking system's reliance on central bank funding.

Hypothetical Example

Consider a hypothetical banking system in a country where the central bank still imposes reserve requirements.

Assume Bank Alpha has:

  • Total Reserves = $500 million
  • Required Reserves = $400 million
  • Borrowings from the Central Bank = $50 million

First, calculate Bank Alpha's Free Reserves:

Free Reserves=Total Reserves−Required Reserves=$500 million−$400 million=$100 million\text{Free Reserves} = \text{Total Reserves} - \text{Required Reserves} = \$500 \text{ million} - \$400 \text{ million} = \$100 \text{ million}

Next, calculate Bank Alpha's Adjusted Free Reserves:

Adjusted Free Reserves=Free Reserves−Borrowings from Central Bank=$100 million−$50 million=$50 million\text{Adjusted Free Reserves} = \text{Free Reserves} - \text{Borrowings from Central Bank} = \$100 \text{ million} - \$50 \text{ million} = \$50 \text{ million}

In this scenario, Bank Alpha has $50 million in positive Adjusted Free Reserves. This means that after meeting its reserve requirements, and accounting for its borrowings from the central bank, it still has $50 million in available liquidity that it can use for lending or investment. This indicates a healthy and liquid position for the bank, contributing to the overall money supply within the economy.

Practical Applications

Adjusted Free Reserves serve as a crucial indicator for various stakeholders within the financial system. For the Federal Reserve, tracking Adjusted Free Reserves helps in assessing the effectiveness of its monetary policy tools, particularly open market operations and the discount rate. A persistent decline in Adjusted Free Reserves, for example, might signal that the market needs more liquidity, prompting the Fed to inject funds through bond purchases of Treasury securities. Conversely, a large surplus could suggest ample liquidity, allowing the Fed to consider withdrawing funds to temper potential inflation. The New York Federal Reserve, responsible for conducting open market operations, closely monitors market conditions to ensure the smooth functioning of the Treasury market and effective transmission of monetary policy.2

For commercial banks, understanding the aggregate level of Adjusted Free Reserves provides insight into the competitive landscape for lending and the overall availability of funds in the interbank market. When Adjusted Free Reserves are high, banks might face less pressure to borrow from the discount window and could be more inclined to lend to each other or to customers at lower interest rates. Conversely, low or negative Adjusted Free Reserves could indicate tighter credit conditions.1

Economists and financial analysts also use this metric to gauge the health and credit conditions within the banking sector. It provides a real-time snapshot of how much lending capacity banks have, beyond their immediate needs and borrowings, influencing projections for economic growth and investment trends.

Limitations and Criticisms

While Adjusted Free Reserves have historically been an important metric for understanding bank reserves and liquidity in the financial system, their relevance and interpretation have evolved, particularly since the Federal Reserve changed its approach to reserve requirements.

One major limitation stems from the Fed's decision in March 2020 to reduce reserve requirement ratios to zero. Prior to this, a non-zero reserve requirement meant that banks actively managed their reserves to meet this mandate, and free reserves represented funds above that requirement. With the requirement set to zero, the "required reserves" component of the Adjusted Free Reserves formula becomes negligible, meaning that Free Reserves are now effectively equal to total reserves. This shift fundamentally alters the interpretation, as banks no longer hold reserves primarily to meet a requirement but rather for other purposes, such as facilitating payments or managing their balance sheets.

Another criticism is that Adjusted Free Reserves may not fully capture the entirety of liquidity available to banks. Banks can access funds from various sources beyond just their reserves, including interbank lending markets, wholesale funding, and other forms of short-term financing. Therefore, focusing solely on Adjusted Free Reserves might provide an incomplete picture of a bank's or the system's true financial flexibility and its capacity for financial innovation.

Furthermore, the measure of "borrowings from the central bank" through the discount window might not always reflect financial distress. While such borrowings can increase during periods of stress, they can also occur for routine balance sheet management or to take advantage of short-term interest rate differentials. Therefore, a negative Adjusted Free Reserves value (net borrowed reserves) does not automatically signal a crisis, but rather a greater reliance on the central bank for funds.

Adjusted Free Reserves vs. Excess Reserves

The terms Adjusted Free Reserves and Excess Reserves are closely related but describe distinct aspects of bank reserves within the financial system.

Excess Reserves are simply the total reserves held by commercial banks that exceed the amount mandated by reserve requirements. The formula is straightforward:

Excess Reserves=Total Reserves−Required Reserves\text{Excess Reserves} = \text{Total Reserves} - \text{Required Reserves}

In essence, Excess Reserves represent the "surplus" cash that banks hold beyond what they are legally obligated to maintain. These funds are available for lending, investment, or other purposes, contributing directly to the money supply.

Adjusted Free Reserves, as discussed, take Excess Reserves a step further by subtracting any borrowings that commercial banks have made from the central bank's discount window. The formula is:

Adjusted Free Reserves=Excess Reserves−Borrowings from Central Bank\text{Adjusted Free Reserves} = \text{Excess Reserves} - \text{Borrowings from Central Bank}

The key difference lies in the consideration of borrowings. Excess Reserves tell you how much a bank has above its requirements. Adjusted Free Reserves tell you how much a bank has above its requirements that it didn't have to borrow from the central bank to get. A bank could have high Excess Reserves, but if a significant portion of those funds were acquired through discount window borrowings, its Adjusted Free Reserves would be lower, potentially even negative, indicating a reliance on the central bank for its liquidity. Thus, Adjusted Free Reserves provide a more nuanced view of the liquidity that is truly "free" and unencumbered by central bank debt.

FAQs

What does it mean if Adjusted Free Reserves are negative?

If Adjusted Free Reserves are negative, it means that commercial banks, on average, are borrowing more from the central bank (through the discount window) than they hold in excess reserves. This situation, sometimes called "net borrowed reserves," indicates a tightening of liquidity in the banking system, suggesting that banks are relying on central bank lending to meet their funding needs. It can imply a less accommodative monetary policy stance or a period of financial stress.

How do central banks influence Adjusted Free Reserves?

Central banks influence Adjusted Free Reserves primarily through their monetary policy tools, especially open market operations and the discount rate. When the central bank conducts open market purchases (buying Treasury securities from banks), it injects liquidity into the financial system, increasing bank reserves and, consequently, Adjusted Free Reserves. Conversely, open market sales reduce reserves. Changes to the discount rate also affect bank behavior; a lower discount rate makes borrowing from the central bank cheaper, potentially increasing borrowings and thus reducing (or making more negative) Adjusted Free Reserves.

Why is Adjusted Free Reserves important for the economy?

Adjusted Free Reserves are important because they offer insight into the liquidity available to commercial banks, which directly impacts their capacity and willingness to lend to businesses and consumers. A high level of positive Adjusted Free Reserves suggests banks have ample funds for new loans, fostering economic growth and potentially lowering interest rates. Conversely, low or negative Adjusted Free Reserves can signal tighter credit conditions, which may hinder economic activity. It provides a real-time measure of the banking sector's underlying health and its role in influencing the broader money supply.

Did the elimination of reserve requirements make Adjusted Free Reserves irrelevant?

While the Federal Reserve's decision in March 2020 to set reserve requirements to zero significantly changed the operational dynamics of bank reserves, the concept of Adjusted Free Reserves remains relevant, albeit with a shifted interpretation. With no required reserves, "Free Reserves" essentially equate to "Total Reserves." However, the subtraction of "Borrowings from Central Bank" is still crucial. The metric now highlights how much of the banking system's total reserves are unencumbered by central bank debt, providing continued insight into financial system liquidity and banks' reliance on the Fed.