Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to A Definitions

Adjusted gross spread

What Is Adjusted Gross Spread?

Adjusted Gross Spread is a refined measure within Investment banking and Capital Markets Analysis that goes beyond the basic Gross Spread to account for additional costs, risks, and post-issuance activities incurred by underwriters in a securities offering. While gross spread represents the direct compensation an underwriting syndicate receives for facilitating the sale of securities, Adjusted Gross Spread seeks to provide a more comprehensive view of the underwriting firm's true profitability by factoring in expenses that are not always captured in the initial gross spread calculation. These additional elements might include ongoing marketing costs, costs of unsold inventory, or market stabilization efforts.

History and Origin

The concept of an "adjusted" spread or margin has parallels in various financial contexts, such as adjusted gross margin which includes inventory carrying costs to show a truer profitability. In investment banking, the primary fee structure for an offering, known as the gross spread, has been a long-standing practice. This spread compensates underwriters for their services, which typically include managing the issuance, conducting due diligence, and distributing the securities13.

Historically, underwriting fees, which form the core of the gross spread, have been a significant source of revenue for investment banks12. However, these fees have also faced scrutiny. For example, a 2017 report citing the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) highlighted concerns about high underwriting fees on initial public offerings (IPOs), suggesting they might be "akin to tacit collusion" and could hinder long-term productive investment11. Furthermore, a discussion referencing a former SEC Commissioner's observations noted that the standard underwriting fee for middle-market IPOs had remained static at around 7% for many years, leading to the term "IPO tax" among some observers10. These discussions implicitly underscore the need for a more granular understanding of the profitability derived from these fees, leading to the practical application of an "Adjusted Gross Spread" to reflect the full financial impact.

Key Takeaways

  • Adjusted Gross Spread provides a more comprehensive view of underwriting profitability by considering costs beyond the initial gross spread.
  • It is crucial for investment banks to accurately assess the true financial outcome of a deal.
  • Calculating Adjusted Gross Spread helps in evaluating the efficiency of underwriting operations and informs future pricing strategies.
  • The concept is particularly relevant for complex or higher-risk offerings where ancillary costs can significantly impact overall profitability.

Formula and Calculation

The Adjusted Gross Spread builds upon the fundamental Gross Spread. While there isn't one universally standardized formula for Adjusted Gross Spread due to its internal and deal-specific nature, it can generally be conceptualized as:

Adjusted Gross Spread=Gross Spread−Additional Underwriting Costs−Post-Issuance Expenses\text{Adjusted Gross Spread} = \text{Gross Spread} - \text{Additional Underwriting Costs} - \text{Post-Issuance Expenses}

Where:

  • Gross Spread: The difference between the price at which the underwriter buys the securities from the issuer and the price at which they sell them to the public9. It typically includes management fees, underwriting fees, and selling concessions8.
  • Additional Underwriting Costs: Expenses directly related to the underwriting process that are not explicitly covered by the primary components of the gross spread. This might include extended legal or accounting fees beyond initial estimates, or unforeseen marketing expenditures.
  • Post-Issuance Expenses: Costs incurred after the initial sale of the securities, such as market stabilization costs, the financial impact of unsold allocations held in inventory, or ongoing investor relations efforts tied to the offering.

For example, if the initial Gross Spread is $3.00 per share, but the underwriter incurs an additional $0.25 per share in unforeseen marketing costs and $0.10 per share in holding costs for unsold shares, the Adjusted Gross Spread would be:

$3.00−$0.25−$0.10=$2.65 per share\$3.00 - \$0.25 - \$0.10 = \$2.65 \text{ per share}

This adjusted figure offers a more realistic assessment of the firm's profitability for the deal.

Interpreting the Adjusted Gross Spread

Interpreting the Adjusted Gross Spread provides a more accurate picture of an underwriting firm's success and efficiency in a capital raising transaction. A higher Adjusted Gross Spread indicates greater net revenue for the underwriter after accounting for various direct and indirect costs associated with the offering. Conversely, a lower Adjusted Gross Spread, or even a negative one, suggests that the additional expenses and risks significantly eroded the initial gross compensation.

This metric helps evaluate how effectively the underwriting firm managed the entire offering lifecycle, from initial due diligence to post-issuance market support. It provides insights into areas where costs might be excessive or where risk assessment during the deal's negotiation phase could be improved. For instance, if an underwriting firm consistently sees a substantial reduction from Gross Spread to Adjusted Gross Spread on deals with particular characteristics (e.g., specific industries, issuer sizes, or market conditions), it might signal a need to re-evaluate its fee structure or operational efficiency for such transactions.

Hypothetical Example

Consider an investment bank, "Global Capital Partners," acting as the lead underwriter for an Initial Public Offering (IPO) for "TechInnovate Inc." TechInnovate plans to issue 10 million shares at an IPO price of $20 per share.

  1. Gross Spread Calculation: Global Capital Partners agrees to a gross spread of 6%, meaning they purchase the shares from TechInnovate at $18.80 per share ($20 - 6% of $20) and sell them to the public at $20.

    • Total Gross Spread Revenue = 10,000,000 shares * ($20.00 - $18.80) = 10,000,000 shares * $1.20/share = $12,000,000.

  2. Additional Costs and Post-Issuance Expenses:

    • Despite thorough initial marketing, Global Capital Partners incurs an additional $500,000 in advertising costs to ensure full subscription for the equity securities due to unforeseen market volatility.
    • Furthermore, they spend $100,000 on market stabilization efforts in the first few days post-IPO to prevent a significant price drop.
    • There were no unsold shares held in inventory.

  3. Adjusted Gross Spread Calculation:

    • Adjusted Gross Spread = Total Gross Spread Revenue - Additional Underwriting Costs - Post-Issuance Expenses
    • Adjusted Gross Spread = $12,000,000 - $500,000 - $100,000 = $11,400,000.

In this scenario, while the initial gross spread appeared to yield $12 million, the Adjusted Gross Spread of $11.4 million provides a more accurate reflection of Global Capital Partners' net earnings from the TechInnovate IPO after accounting for all relevant expenditures.

Practical Applications

Adjusted Gross Spread is primarily an internal metric used by investment banking firms and other financial institutions involved in underwriting to gauge the true profitability of their deals. It moves beyond the face value of the gross spread to incorporate a broader range of costs and risks that can affect the bottom line.

  • Performance Evaluation: Investment banks use Adjusted Gross Spread to evaluate the performance of their underwriting divisions and individual deal teams. It helps determine if a deal was genuinely profitable, considering all associated expenses. This insight can influence future compensation structures and strategic decisions regarding which types of deals to pursue.
  • Pricing Strategy Refinement: By understanding the full cost structure reflected in the Adjusted Gross Spread, firms can refine their pricing models for future offerings of debt securities or equity. This allows them to quote gross spreads that more accurately cover their comprehensive costs and desired profit margins.
  • Risk Management: Analyzing historical Adjusted Gross Spread data helps firms identify recurring unexpected costs or risks associated with certain types of offerings or underwriting syndicate structures. This informs better risk management practices and due diligence processes.
  • Regulatory Compliance and Disclosure Context: While the Adjusted Gross Spread itself is typically an internal metric, the components that influence it, particularly the initial gross spread, are often subject to regulatory scrutiny. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) requires detailed disclosure of fees related to registered securities offerings to ensure transparency for investors and issuers6, 7. For example, in recent years, the SEC has adopted amendments to modernize filing fee disclosures, requiring structured formats for fee calculation information5. This regulatory environment emphasizes the importance of understanding all fee components.

For instance, major investment banks like Goldman Sachs generate substantial revenue from investment banking fees, which include underwriting fees3, 4. The internal calculation of an Adjusted Gross Spread helps these institutions understand the true profitability of these revenue streams after accounting for all direct and indirect expenses involved in executing complex financial instrument transactions.

Limitations and Criticisms

While Adjusted Gross Spread offers a more nuanced view than the basic gross spread, it is not without limitations. Its primary criticism stems from the subjective nature of what constitutes "additional underwriting costs" and "post-issuance expenses." Unlike the defined components of gross spread (management fee, underwriting fee, selling concession), these additional costs can vary greatly depending on internal accounting practices, the complexity of the deal, and unforeseen market events. This variability can make direct comparisons of Adjusted Gross Spread between different firms, or even different deals within the same firm, challenging.

Another criticism is that while it accounts for the costs incurred, it still represents a retrospective view. It doesn't inherently predict future profitability or entirely mitigate the inherent risk assessment challenges in underwriting. Critics of the overall underwriting fee structure have argued that these fees can be disproportionately high, especially for smaller IPOs, potentially hindering companies' access to public markets2. While the Adjusted Gross Spread provides a more accurate internal picture of the bank's actual take, it doesn't address these broader market criticisms regarding the initial cost burden on issuers. The volatility of market conditions can also lead to significant fluctuations in the effective Adjusted Gross Spread, as unexpected challenges in distributing securities can quickly escalate post-issuance costs.

Adjusted Gross Spread vs. Gross Spread

The distinction between Adjusted Gross Spread and Gross Spread lies in their scope and the depth of their financial analysis.

Gross Spread is the fundamental compensation received by an underwriting firm for facilitating a securities offering. It is the difference between the price the underwriter pays to the issuer for the securities and the public offering price at which those securities are sold to investors1. This figure is typically broken down into three main components:

  • Management Fee: Compensates the lead underwriter for originating and managing the deal.
  • Underwriting Fee: Remunerates the underwriting syndicate for assuming the risk of purchasing the securities from the issuer.
  • Selling Concession: Rewards the syndicate members and selling group for distributing the securities to investors.

Adjusted Gross Spread, on the other hand, takes the Gross Spread as its starting point and then deducts any additional, often unforeseen, costs and post-issuance expenses incurred by the underwriting firm. These can include unexpected marketing outlays, the cost of holding unsold shares in inventory, or expenses related to market stabilization efforts after the offering. The Adjusted Gross Spread provides a truer measure of the underwriter's net profitability for a given deal, reflecting the total financial impact rather than just the initial revenue recognized.

The confusion between the two often arises because "gross spread" is the publicly quoted and widely understood fee structure. However, sophisticated financial analysis necessitates accounting for all costs, leading to the internal use of Adjusted Gross Spread for more precise performance evaluation and risk assessment.

FAQs

What is the primary purpose of calculating Adjusted Gross Spread?

The primary purpose of calculating Adjusted Gross Spread is to gain a more accurate understanding of the true profitability of a securities offering for the underwriting firm. It moves beyond the initial fee structure to include additional costs and risks incurred during and after the offering process.

How does Adjusted Gross Spread differ from the standard Gross Spread?

While Gross Spread is the upfront compensation (difference between purchase price from issuer and sale price to public), Adjusted Gross Spread subtracts further operational costs and post-issuance expenses that impact the underwriter's actual net earnings from the deal.

Why is Adjusted Gross Spread not always publicly disclosed?

Adjusted Gross Spread is typically an internal metric used by investment banks for their own profitability analysis and operational efficiency evaluations. Regulatory disclosures generally focus on the gross fees paid by the issuer, not the granular internal cost breakdowns of the underwriting firm.

Can Adjusted Gross Spread be negative?

Yes, Adjusted Gross Spread can be negative if the additional costs and post-issuance expenses incurred by the underwriter exceed the initial Gross Spread. This indicates that the deal, despite its initial gross revenue, resulted in a net loss for the firm, highlighting potential issues with pricing or unexpected complications during the offering.