What Is Adjusted Growth Premium?
The Adjusted Growth Premium refers to the observed difference in returns or valuation multiples between growth-oriented investments and other investment styles, after accounting for specific market conditions, risk factors, or analytical methodologies within the broader field of asset pricing. While the term "Growth Premium" broadly describes the historically observed tendency for growth stocks to command higher valuations or, at times, deliver superior risk-adjusted returns, the "Adjusted Growth Premium" implies a more nuanced analysis. It seeks to isolate the pure effect of growth by stripping away confounding variables that might influence the raw premium. This concept is particularly relevant in quantitative finance and portfolio management, where understanding the precise drivers of returns is paramount. The Adjusted Growth Premium helps investors and analysts assess whether the premium paid for growth is justified given various market dynamics.
History and Origin
The concept of a "growth premium" is deeply intertwined with the long-standing debate in financial economics between value investing and growth investing. For decades, academic research, notably by Eugene Fama and Kenneth French, has explored whether value stocks consistently outperform growth stocks, leading to the identification of a "value premium" as a persistent anomaly. Their extensive data library provides key insights into these market factors.15 Conversely, periods where growth stocks outpace value stocks lead to discussions of a "growth premium."
The "adjusted" aspect of the growth premium stems from attempts to explain the various drivers behind observed market premiums. Researchers often employ factor models to decompose returns into different sources, such as market risk, size, value, profitability, and investment. By adjusting for these other factors, analysts aim to determine if a pure "growth factor" delivers a premium, or if the observed premium is merely a byproduct of other characteristics often correlated with growth stocks, such as higher momentum or lower quality. For example, a 2017 paper from MSCI explored whether a pure growth factor, net of country, industry, and other style factors, earned a premium.14
Key Takeaways
- The Adjusted Growth Premium analyzes the performance or valuation advantage of growth stocks after controlling for external factors.
- It is a concept rooted in asset pricing and seeks to refine the understanding of the traditional "Growth Premium."
- Analysts use this adjustment to determine if the premium associated with growth is attributable to inherent growth characteristics or other correlated market factors.
- Understanding the Adjusted Growth Premium helps investors make more informed decisions about allocating capital between growth and value strategies.
- The persistence and magnitude of any Adjusted Growth Premium are subjects of ongoing academic and practical debate.
Formula and Calculation
The Adjusted Growth Premium is not defined by a single, universal formula, as the "adjustment" component depends on the specific factors being controlled for and the analytical framework used. However, the underlying "Growth Premium" typically represents the difference in returns or valuation multiples between a portfolio of growth stocks and a benchmark or a portfolio of value stocks.
A basic representation of the raw Growth Premium (GP) in terms of returns could be:
Where:
- (R_{\text{Growth}}) = Return of a portfolio of growth stocks
- (R_{\text{Benchmark}}) = Return of a relevant market benchmark (e.g., total market index)
- (R_{\text{Value}}) = Return of a portfolio of value stocks
When considering the Adjusted Growth Premium, this fundamental difference in returns or valuations is then analyzed within a multifactor model framework. For example, using a regression approach, the return of a growth portfolio might be regressed against various factor models (like the Fama-French factors) to see if a significant, independent premium remains for growth after accounting for size, value, and other known factors.
For instance, if analyzing the premium in terms of valuation multiples, such as the price-to-earnings ratio (P/E) or book-to-market ratio (B/M):
The "adjustment" would then involve examining how this valuation premium changes when controlling for aspects like industry composition, profitability metrics, or reinvestment rates, which influence a company's cost of capital and future cash flows.
Interpreting the Adjusted Growth Premium
Interpreting the Adjusted Growth Premium requires a deep understanding of market dynamics and the specific adjustments made. A positive Adjusted Growth Premium suggests that growth-oriented investments have delivered superior returns or commanded higher valuations even after accounting for other known risk factors or market characteristics. Conversely, a negative Adjusted Growth Premium would indicate that growth has underperformed or been valued less favorably after such adjustments.
When evaluating this premium, analysts consider the economic environment and market sentiment. For example, during periods of low economic growth, investors might pay a higher Adjusted Growth Premium for companies that can still deliver robust earnings growth, regardless of the broader economy.13 Conversely, in strong economic expansions, the premium might compress as more companies achieve higher growth rates. Understanding this interplay helps investors determine if the market is appropriately pricing growth or if a particular investment style is over or undervalued.
Hypothetical Example
Consider an investment analyst studying the performance of growth stocks. They observe that a portfolio of growth stocks yielded a 15% return over the past year, while the overall market benchmark returned 10%. This 5% difference is the raw Growth Premium.
To calculate the Adjusted Growth Premium, the analyst suspects that part of this outperformance might be due to the specific industry composition of the growth portfolio, which heavily favors technology companies that experienced a general surge.
-
Raw Growth Premium Calculation:
- Growth Stock Portfolio Return: 15%
- Market Benchmark Return: 10%
- Raw Growth Premium = 15% - 10% = 5%
-
Adjustment for Industry Bias: The analyst builds a hypothetical portfolio with similar industry weights to the growth portfolio but using non-growth stocks in those industries, or they use a statistical model to remove the industry factor's contribution. Suppose this adjustment indicates that 2% of the raw 5% premium was attributable solely to the tech sector's overall strong performance, rather than the "growth" characteristic itself.
-
Adjusted Growth Premium:
- Adjusted Growth Premium = Raw Growth Premium - (Premium attributable to industry bias)
- Adjusted Growth Premium = 5% - 2% = 3%
In this hypothetical scenario, the Adjusted Growth Premium is 3%. This suggests that even after controlling for the strong performance of the underlying industries, growth stocks still provided an additional 3% return. This refined view provides a clearer picture of whether the "growth" characteristic itself is being rewarded in the market, rather than just other correlated factors. Such insights are crucial for fine-tuning an investment strategy.
Practical Applications
The Adjusted Growth Premium finds several practical applications in the financial world, particularly in the realm of investment strategy and quantitative analysis.
- Portfolio Construction: Understanding the Adjusted Growth Premium helps portfolio managers decide on their allocation to growth versus value stocks. If the adjusted premium is consistently low or negative, it might suggest that growth is overpriced relative to its fundamental drivers, prompting a shift towards value investing. Conversely, a robust Adjusted Growth Premium could justify a higher allocation to growth.
- Performance Attribution: Asset managers use the Adjusted Growth Premium in performance attribution analysis to discern whether a portfolio's outperformance (or underperformance) is genuinely due to its exposure to growth characteristics or merely to other underlying factors. This helps in refining investment processes and communicating results to clients.
- Valuation Models: In sophisticated discounted cash flow (DCF) models, analysts may incorporate insights from the Adjusted Growth Premium. Professor Aswath Damodaran of NYU Stern highlights that while higher earnings growth generally increases equity value, if that growth is accompanied by higher reinvestment or increased risk, it can potentially destroy value.12 Analyzing the Adjusted Growth Premium helps determine how much value is truly being created by growth, informing assumptions about future cash flows and terminal value.
- Academic Research: The concept is a key area of ongoing research, with institutions like Research Affiliates publishing extensive work on the historical performance and drivers of the value and growth premiums. Their research often decomposes returns into components such as revaluation and profitability to explain observed premiums.11
Limitations and Criticisms
Despite its analytical utility, the Adjusted Growth Premium is not without limitations and criticisms. A primary challenge lies in the subjective nature of what constitutes an "adjustment." Different researchers and practitioners may choose different factor models or control variables, leading to varied conclusions about the magnitude and persistence of the premium. The selection of adjustment factors can significantly influence the outcome, potentially introducing model risk.
Another criticism revolves around the dynamic nature of market conditions. What explains a premium in one economic cycle may not hold true in another. For instance, the prolonged outperformance of growth stocks post-2007 led many to question the traditional value premium, prompting a re-examination of underlying drivers.9, 10 Some argue that the growth premium, even when adjusted, can be a function of investor behavior and expectations, rather than purely fundamental drivers. Investors' perceptions of future earnings and growth can lead to higher price-to-earnings ratios, which may not always materialize, potentially leading to a "growth trap" if the anticipated growth does not occur.8
Furthermore, the data used for calculating and adjusting the premium, such as that provided by the Kenneth R. French Data Library, relies on historical observations. While history provides valuable insights, it does not guarantee future results, and market anomalies can emerge or disappear over time.
Adjusted Growth Premium vs. Growth Premium
The distinction between the Adjusted Growth Premium and the Growth Premium lies in the level of analytical sophistication and the intent of the analysis.
- Growth Premium: This is the more general and often raw observation of the difference in returns or valuation multiples between growth stocks and other investment styles, typically value stocks or the broader market. For example, if the Morningstar US Growth Index outperforms the Morningstar US Value Index, that outperformance could be referred to as the Growth Premium.7 It represents the direct, unrefined difference in performance or pricing.
- Adjusted Growth Premium: This term signifies that the observed Growth Premium has undergone a more rigorous analysis, where its magnitude is assessed after controlling for various confounding factors. These adjustments might include accounting for differences in risk (e.g., using risk-adjusted returns), profitability, reinvestment rates, industry concentrations, or other market anomalies. The goal is to isolate the "pure" effect of growth, providing a clearer understanding of whether growth itself, as opposed to other correlated characteristics, is driving the premium. In essence, the Adjusted Growth Premium seeks to provide a more accurate and attributable explanation for why growth stocks might perform differently.
FAQs
What does "premium" mean in finance?
In finance, "premium" generally refers to an amount by which a price or value exceeds a benchmark or an intrinsic amount. For example, a bond trading at a premium means its market price is above its face value, or an equity risk premium is the excess return expected from investing in stocks over a risk-free rate.6
How is the Growth Premium different from the Value Premium?
The Growth Premium refers to the higher returns or valuations achieved by growth investing strategies compared to others. Conversely, the Value Premium refers to the observed tendency for value investing strategies to outperform growth strategies over long periods. Academic research extensively debates the existence and drivers of both premiums.3, 4, 5
Why would a Growth Premium need to be "adjusted"?
A Growth Premium might need to be "adjusted" to separate the true effect of growth from other factors that may be correlated with growth stocks but are not inherently part of their growth characteristics. For example, a growth stock might also be a high-momentum stock, and its performance could be due to momentum rather than growth. Adjusting for these factors helps analysts understand the genuine drivers of returns.
Does the Adjusted Growth Premium always exist?
No, the existence and magnitude of an Adjusted Growth Premium are subject to market cycles and ongoing debate in asset pricing research. Historical data shows periods where growth has outperformed and periods where it has underperformed. The "adjusted" analysis helps to explain why these trends occur, but it does not guarantee a persistent premium.1, 2
How does profitability relate to the Adjusted Growth Premium?
Profitability is a key factor in determining a company's intrinsic value and its ability to generate sustainable growth. When analyzing the Adjusted Growth Premium, analysts might control for profitability to see if the premium is simply a reward for high-profit companies (which often includes growth companies) or if there is an additional premium specifically for the rate of growth itself, independent of current profitability.