What Is Adjusted Margin Call?
An adjusted margin call refers to a demand from a broker-dealer for additional funds or securities to be deposited into a margin account when the account's equity falls below a certain threshold, calculated using a more sophisticated, risk-based methodology rather than traditional fixed percentages. Unlike a standard margin call, which typically applies uniform maintenance margin percentages across all positions, an adjusted margin call often arises in the context of portfolio margin accounts. These accounts, commonly used in complex brokerage operations and by professional traders, assess margin requirements based on the overall risk of the entire portfolio, taking into account offsetting hedged positions and potential market moves, rather than individual positions in isolation. This allows for potentially lower margin requirements but necessitates more dynamic and granular adjustments as market conditions or portfolio volatility shifts.
History and Origin
The concept of margin requirements in financial markets dates back centuries, but standardized regulation gained prominence following market crises. In the United States, significant efforts to regulate margin lending emerged after the stock market crash of 1929, which was partly attributed to excessive leverage facilitated by low margin requirements. At the time, investors could buy securities with as little as 10% cash down, borrowing the rest8. This led to amplified losses when markets declined, forcing widespread asset liquidation. In response, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 granted the Federal Reserve Board the authority to set initial margin requirements, leading to the establishment of Regulation T7.
While initial margin was standardized, the evolution toward adjusted margin calls, particularly through portfolio margining, is a more recent development. Traditional margin rules often failed to recognize the risk-reducing effects of diversified or hedged portfolios, leading to higher-than-necessary margin requirements for sophisticated strategies. To address this, risk-based margin methodologies, such as portfolio margin, began to be adopted by regulators like the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) in the early 2000s. FINRA Rule 4210 outlines various margin requirements, including provisions for risk-based margining that consider the overall risk exposure of a portfolio rather than individual securities6. This shift allowed for a more capital-efficient approach for traders managing complex strategies, but it also introduced the need for more frequent and potentially more significant "adjusted" margin calls as portfolio risk profiles change.
Key Takeaways
- Adjusted margin calls are demands for additional capital in a margin account, typically calculated using a risk-based approach for the entire portfolio.
- They are most common in portfolio margin accounts, which assess overall portfolio risk rather than applying fixed percentages to individual positions.
- This dynamic calculation can result in lower margin requirements for diversified or hedged portfolios but also means the required equity can change more frequently.
- Failure to meet an adjusted margin call can lead to the forced liquidation of positions by the broker-dealer to cover the deficiency.
- The system aims to align margin requirements more closely with the actual risk management of complex trading strategies.
Formula and Calculation
The calculation for an adjusted margin call in a portfolio margin account is not a simple linear formula but rather involves a "stress test" methodology. The goal is to determine the maximum potential loss of the entire portfolio across a range of hypothetical market scenarios. The Options Clearing Corporation's (OCC) Theoretical Intermarket Margin System (TIMS) is widely used for this purpose.
The margin requirement (MR) for a portfolio is generally determined as the largest theoretical loss across various defined market scenarios:
Where:
- Portfolio P&L: The profit and loss of the entire portfolio under specific market conditions.
- Stress Scenarios: These include hypothetical movements in the price of underlying assets (e.g., ±15% for individual equities, ±8% to +6% for broad-based indexes), as well as changes in volatility.
If the account's equity falls below this calculated MR, an adjusted margin call is issued. The methodology accounts for the offsetting risks of different derivatives and underlying securities within the portfolio, potentially reducing the overall margin required compared to traditional fixed-percentage rules.
5
Interpreting the Adjusted Margin Call
An adjusted margin call indicates that the overall risk profile of a portfolio has shifted, or market movements have eroded the account's equity such that it no longer meets the dynamically calculated margin requirement. For sophisticated investors utilizing portfolio margin accounts, understanding an adjusted margin call involves more than just a simple percentage drop. It requires analyzing which specific market movements or changes in volatility might have triggered the call. Because portfolio margin aims to reflect the net risk of all positions, an adjusted margin call could stem from adverse movements in an otherwise hedged strategy if the correlation between positions breaks down, or if an unhedged component incurs significant losses. It signals that the current market conditions pose a greater hypothetical risk to the portfolio than the existing maintenance margin can cover, necessitating a deposit of additional funds or the reduction of risk exposure through selling positions.
Hypothetical Example
Consider an investor, Alex, who uses a portfolio margin account. Alex holds a complex strategy involving long shares of Company A, combined with short call options and long put options on Company A, creating a synthetic long position with some hedging elements.
-
Initial Setup:
- Alex has $100,000 in account equity.
- The brokerage's risk-based model calculates the initial margin requirement for this diversified portfolio to be $30,000, significantly lower than traditional initial margin rules might demand for the underlying stock position alone.
- The maintenance margin (the point at which an adjusted margin call is triggered) is determined dynamically, for instance, based on a 15% adverse movement in the stock price. Let's say this translates to a $25,000 threshold for the portfolio's net liquidation value.
-
Market Scenario:
- Company A announces unexpected negative news, causing its stock price to drop sharply, say by 10%.
- While Alex's long put options gain value, the decline in the long stock position and losses on the short call options outweigh these gains, leading to a net portfolio loss.
- The portfolio's current equity value drops to $22,000.
-
Adjusted Margin Call:
- Since the portfolio's current equity of $22,000 falls below the dynamically calculated maintenance margin threshold of $25,000, Alex receives an adjusted margin call.
- The call requires Alex to deposit an additional $3,000 ($25,000 - $22,000) or reduce the portfolio's risk exposure by liquidating some positions to bring the account back above the required threshold.
This example illustrates how an adjusted margin call considers the net effect of all positions within a portfolio, reflecting a more nuanced approach to risk management.
Practical Applications
Adjusted margin calls are primarily found in advanced trading environments, particularly in accounts that qualify for portfolio margin. These accounts are often utilized by professional traders, hedge funds, and sophisticated individual investors who engage in complex strategies involving derivatives and hedged positions. The application of adjusted margin calls allows for more efficient use of capital by recognizing the offsetting risks within a diversified portfolio, leading to lower overall margin requirements compared to traditional, strategy-based margin calculations.
4
A notable real-world instance highlighting the impact of margin calls, including those implicitly adjusted for risk, was the collapse of Archegos Capital Management in March 2021. Archegos, a family office, had amassed highly leveraged positions in certain stocks through total return swaps—a type of derivative—with various prime brokers. When the value of these underlying stocks sharply declined, the brokers issued margin calls demanding additional collateral. Archegos failed to meet these demands, leading the banks to forcefully liquidate massive blocks of stock, causing significant market disruption and billions in losses for the involved financial institutions. Whil3e the specifics of Archegos's arrangements involved highly customized over-the-counter derivatives, the event underscored the critical role of margin calls and the systemic risks associated with highly leveraged positions that, when triggered, necessitate rapid and substantial adjustments.
Limitations and Criticisms
While offering the benefit of increased capital efficiency for complex trading strategies, adjusted margin calls and the underlying portfolio margin systems are not without limitations and criticisms. One primary concern is their complexity. The dynamic, risk-based calculations can be difficult for investors to fully comprehend, potentially leading to a false sense of security or underestimation of actual risk exposure. Unlike a fixed maintenance margin percentage, the threshold for an adjusted margin call is constantly shifting with market volatility and changes in portfolio composition, which can make it challenging for investors to anticipate when a call might occur.
Furthermore, while portfolio margin often allows for higher leverage due to its risk-offsetting considerations, this increased leverage can also amplify losses rapidly if the assumed correlations or hedging strategies fail. In extreme market dislocations, seemingly hedged positions might move in an unexpected manner, leading to much larger losses and more severe adjusted margin calls than anticipated. The swiftness with which adjusted margin calls must be met, often within hours, also poses a significant challenge, especially during periods of high market stress when liquidity may be scarce. Failure to meet an adjusted margin call can result in forced liquidation of positions by the broker-dealer, potentially at unfavorable prices, leading to substantial losses for the investor and, in some cases, contributing to broader market instability. Regulators, such as FINRA, continue to refine rules surrounding portfolio margin accounts to balance capital efficiency with adequate risk management and investor protection, sometimes requiring additional capital charge for certain exposures.
2Adjusted Margin Call vs. Margin Call
The key distinction between an adjusted margin call and a standard margin call lies in the methodology used to determine the required equity. A standard margin call, typically associated with Regulation T and FINRA Rule 4210 for basic margin accounts, is triggered when the account's equity falls below a fixed percentage of the total market value of the securities held—often 25% or 30% for maintenance margin. This c1alculation is straightforward and applies uniformly to individual positions or an entire portfolio without considering complex interrelationships between assets.
In contrast, an adjusted margin call typically occurs in a portfolio margin account. Here, the margin requirement is calculated dynamically based on the overall risk of the entire portfolio, taking into account the offsetting effects of various securities and derivatives. This risk-based approach assesses the maximum potential loss across a range of hypothetical market scenarios. Consequently, an adjusted margin call is a notification that the portfolio's net risk exposure, as assessed by a sophisticated model, requires additional capital, rather than simply a breach of a static percentage. While a standard margin call focuses on maintaining a basic buffer for individual positions, an adjusted margin call aims to ensure sufficient capital for the combined risk of complex, often hedged positions.
FAQs
What triggers an Adjusted Margin Call?
An adjusted margin call is triggered when the total equity in a portfolio margin account falls below the dynamically calculated minimum margin requirement. This requirement is based on the overall risk of the entire portfolio, considering hypothetical changes in asset prices and volatility, rather than fixed percentages for individual positions.
Can I get an Adjusted Margin Call even with a diversified portfolio?
Yes, a diversified portfolio can still trigger an adjusted margin call. While portfolio margin accounts recognize the risk-reducing benefits of diversification and hedged positions, unexpected market movements or severe volatility can still lead to a net loss that erodes your equity below the required maintenance level. The models used to calculate adjusted margin are complex and can react sharply to unforeseen market events.
What happens if I don't meet an Adjusted Margin Call?
If you fail to meet an adjusted margin call within the specified timeframe (often a few days or even hours), your broker-dealer has the right to sell some or all of your securities in the margin account to cover the deficiency. This is known as liquidation and can occur without prior notice, potentially leading to substantial losses and loss of control over your investments.
Is an Adjusted Margin Call more common for certain types of investors?
Yes, adjusted margin calls are almost exclusively associated with sophisticated investors who qualify for and utilize portfolio margin accounts. These accounts typically require a high minimum initial margin (e.g., $100,000 or more) and are often used by professional traders or hedge funds employing complex strategies involving derivatives and significant leverage.