Adjusted z score: Meaning, Criticisms & Real-World Uses

What Is Adjusted Z-Score?

The Adjusted Z-Score is a financial modeling tool used in credit risk analysis to predict the likelihood of a company experiencing financial distress or bankruptcy. It is a refinement of the original Altman Z-Score, specifically tailored by its creator, Edward Altman, to assess the financial health of non-manufacturing or private companies where certain data, like market value of equity, might not be readily available or directly applicable. This score falls under the broader category of quantitative financial ratios and corporate finance, providing a numerical output that helps analysts and investors gauge a firm's solvency. The Adjusted Z-Score aims to offer a robust measure of corporate vulnerability.

History and Origin

The concept of using a multivariate model to predict corporate failure was pioneered by Edward I. Altman in 1968 with his original Z-Score model, which was initially developed for publicly traded manufacturing firms. This groundbreaking work utilized multiple discriminant analysis to combine several financial ratios into a single score. However, as the application of such predictive models expanded, it became clear that the original Z-Score had limitations, particularly for private companies or those outside the manufacturing sector, primarily due to the inclusion of a market-value-based variable.

Recognizing these limitations, Altman developed adjusted versions of his model. These adjustments led to formulations like the Z'-Score (for private firms and non-manufacturing public firms) and Z"-Score (for emerging markets, or non-manufacturing firms with international data considerations), collectively referred to as the Adjusted Z-Score. These iterations replaced market-based variables with book-value equivalents, making the model more versatile for firms without readily observable market capitalization. Edward Altman, a professor at NYU Stern School of Business, has continuously refined and discussed his models, providing a "50-year retrospective on his famed Z-score model" highlighting its applications in financial and managerial markets⁵. His ongoing research and publications, such as "Corporate Financial Distress, Restructuring, and Bankruptcy," further detail the evolution and application of these models⁴.

Key Takeaways

The Adjusted Z-Score is a modified version of the Altman Z-Score, primarily used for private companies or non-manufacturing firms.
It utilizes financial ratios derived solely from a company's financial statements, bypassing the need for market-based data.
A lower Adjusted Z-Score indicates a higher probability of financial distress or bankruptcy.
The model serves as a quantitative tool for assessing corporate solvency and early warning of potential financial issues.
It is widely applied in credit risk assessment, lending decisions, and distressed investing strategies.

Formula and Calculation

The Adjusted Z-Score has different formulations, but a common version suitable for private or non-manufacturing companies (often referred to as the Z'-Score or Z"-Score) replaces the market value of equity component with a book value equivalent. One widely cited formula for the Adjusted Z-Score (Z'-Score) is:

Z' = 6.56(\text{X}1) + 3.26(\text{X}2) + 6.72(\text{X}3) + 1.05(\text{X}4)

Where:

(\text{X}1 = \text{Working Capital} / \text{Total Assets})
- Working Capital measures liquidity, indicating if a company has enough short-term assets to cover short-term liabilities.
- Total Assets represents the total value of all assets owned by the company.
(\text{X}2 = \text{Retained Earnings} / \text{Total Assets})
- Retained Earnings are the cumulative net earnings of a company that have been retained and reinvested rather than distributed to shareholders as dividends. This ratio reflects a company's cumulative profitability and age.
(\text{X}3 = \text{Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT)} / \text{Total Assets})
- Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT) represents a company's operating profitability. This ratio indicates how efficiently a company is using its assets to generate earnings.
(\text{X}4 = \text{Book Value of Equity} / \text{Total Liabilities})
- Book Value of Equity is the total value of a company's assets minus its total liabilities, as recorded on its balance sheet. This ratio measures the company's financial leverage and indicates how much assets can decline before liabilities exceed them. Total Liabilities represent the company's total financial obligations.

Note that for publicly traded companies, the original Z-Score uses Market Value of Equity for X4 and also includes a fifth variable, Sales/Total Assets. The coefficients in the Adjusted Z-Score are also different from the original Z-Score, reflecting the re-estimation of the model for a broader set of companies or those without market value data.

Interpreting the Adjusted Z-Score

Interpreting the Adjusted Z-Score provides insights into a company's propensity for default risk. Generally, higher scores indicate lower risk, while lower scores suggest increasing financial vulnerability. The interpretation zones for the Adjusted Z-Score (Z'-Score) are typically defined as follows:

Z' > 2.60: This zone is considered "safe." Companies with scores above this threshold are generally deemed financially healthy and unlikely to face bankruptcy.
1.10 < Z' < 2.60: This is the "grey zone." Companies in this range have a moderate probability of financial distress. The situation is not immediately critical, but closer monitoring and deeper analysis of their liquidity and profitability are warranted.
Z' < 1.10: This is the "distress zone." Companies with scores below this threshold are considered to be at a high risk of financial distress or bankruptcy within a short period.

These thresholds are empirical and can vary slightly depending on the specific industry or economic conditions, requiring expert judgment for accurate application. The Adjusted Z-Score provides a quantitative measure that complements qualitative assessments of a firm’s financial health.

Hypothetical Example

Consider a private manufacturing company, "Widgets Inc.," at the end of its fiscal year. We want to calculate its Adjusted Z-Score to assess its financial stability.

From Widgets Inc.'s income statement and balance sheet, we gather the following information:

Working Capital: $500,000
Total Assets: $2,000,000
Retained Earnings: $300,000
EBIT: $250,000
Book Value of Equity: $800,000
Total Liabilities: $1,200,000

Now, we calculate each component of the Adjusted Z-Score formula:

(\text{X}1 = \text{Working Capital} / \text{Total Assets} = $500,000 / $2,000,000 = 0.25)
(\text{X}2 = \text{Retained Earnings} / \text{Total Assets} = $300,000 / $2,000,000 = 0.15)
(\text{X}3 = \text{EBIT} / \text{Total Assets} = $250,000 / $2,000,000 = 0.125)
(\text{X}4 = \text{Book Value of Equity} / \text{Total Liabilities} = $800,000 / $1,200,000 \approx 0.667)

Next, we plug these values into the Adjusted Z-Score formula:

Z' = 6.56(0.25) + 3.26(0.15) + 6.72(0.125) + 1.05(0.667)

Z' = 1.64 + 0.489 + 0.84 + 0.70035

Z' \approx 3.66935

Based on this calculation, Widgets Inc. has an Adjusted Z-Score of approximately 3.67. This score falls well above the typical "safe zone" threshold of 2.60, indicating that Widgets Inc. is currently in a strong financial position and has a low probability of financial distress.

Practical Applications

The Adjusted Z-Score is a crucial tool in various financial contexts, particularly where traditional market-based valuations are unavailable or unreliable.

Commercial Lending: Banks and other financial institutions use the Adjusted Z-Score to evaluate the creditworthiness of private businesses seeking loans. It helps them assess the risk of loan default and determine appropriate interest rates and collateral requirements.
Credit Risk Management: Corporations employ the Adjusted Z-Score internally for risk management, monitoring the financial health of their suppliers, customers, and business partners. This proactive monitoring helps identify potential disruptions in the supply chain or payment issues.
Distressed Investing: Investors specializing in distressed debt or turnaround situations use the Adjusted Z-Score to identify companies on the brink of financial distress. A low score can signal potential opportunities for acquiring undervalued assets or providing rescue financing.
Private Equity and Venture Capital: Private equity firms and venture capitalists assess the financial resilience of their portfolio companies, many of which are not publicly traded. The Adjusted Z-Score provides a standardized method to gauge the ongoing financial viability of these investments.
Bankruptcy Forecasting: Researchers and policymakers utilize the Adjusted Z-Score to understand macro-level trends in corporate insolvency. For example, during periods of economic uncertainty, models like the Z-Score can help identify sectors or firm types most at risk. The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco noted in October 2020 that during the COVID-19 pandemic, the insolvency risk for U.S. nonfinancial firms rose significantly, with the amount of outstanding liabilities among high-risk firms more than doubling compared to the global financial crisis of 2008. ³This highlights the relevance of such models in understanding systemic risk. The rise in corporate bankruptcies in recent years, influenced by factors like increasing interest rates and inflation, underscores the continued need for effective bankruptcy prediction tools.
²

Limitations and Criticisms

While a valuable tool, the Adjusted Z-Score, like any predictive model, has limitations and faces criticisms.

One primary limitation is its reliance on historical accounting data, which may not always reflect a company's current or future financial state. Accounting data can be manipulated or may not capture intangible assets and off-balance-sheet items that impact true financial health. The model's effectiveness can also diminish over time if economic conditions or industry structures change significantly, requiring periodic recalibration of the coefficients.

Furthermore, the Adjusted Z-Score provides a probabilistic assessment, not a definitive prediction. A low score indicates a higher likelihood of distress, but it does not guarantee bankruptcy. Conversely, a high score does not guarantee immunity from financial problems, especially in the face of unforeseen external shocks or poor strategic decisions.

Critics also point out that the original thresholds for interpretation were developed based on specific historical data sets and may not be universally applicable across all industries or geographical regions without further customization. Different industries have varying capital structures and operating cycles, which can influence what constitutes a "healthy" or "distressed" financial ratio. For instance, companies with high leverage are inherently riskier, but the acceptable level of leverage can differ greatly between, say, a utility company and a technology startup. Edward Altman himself has noted that the cut-off scores from his original 1968 model are no longer strictly applicable in the same way today, with current distress thresholds often being lower due to evolving credit markets and corporate structures. ¹Therefore, the Adjusted Z-Score should be used as one indicator among many in a comprehensive financial analysis, rather than as a sole determinant of a company's financial future.

Adjusted Z-Score vs. Altman Z-Score

The terms "Adjusted Z-Score" and "Altman Z-Score" are often used interchangeably, but it is important to distinguish between the original model developed by Edward Altman and its subsequent adaptations. The key difference lies in their applicability and the variables used in their calculation.

The Altman Z-Score refers to the original five-variable model designed for publicly traded manufacturing companies. A crucial component of this original model is the inclusion of the market value of equity, reflecting the market's perception of the company's value. This makes the original Altman Z-Score unsuitable for private companies or those for which market capitalization data is not available.

The Adjusted Z-Score, often denoted as Z'-Score or Z"-Score, are modifications of the original model. These adjustments were specifically developed to address the limitations of the original Z-Score when applied to non-manufacturing firms, private companies, or companies in emerging markets. The primary modification involves replacing the market value of equity with the book value of equity, making the model solely reliant on accounting data. This allows for a more consistent assessment of financial distress across a broader range of company types, regardless of their public trading status. While the underlying purpose of predicting financial distress remains the same, the Adjusted Z-Score offers a broader utility by accommodating different data availability scenarios.

FAQs

What is the primary purpose of the Adjusted Z-Score?

The primary purpose of the Adjusted Z-Score is to predict the likelihood of a company, particularly a private or non-manufacturing firm, experiencing financial distress or bankruptcy. It serves as an early warning system based on a firm's financial health.

How does the Adjusted Z-Score differ from the original Altman Z-Score?

The key difference is that the Adjusted Z-Score uses the book value of equity instead of the market value of equity in its calculation. This modification makes it applicable to private companies or those without publicly traded stock.

Can the Adjusted Z-Score predict bankruptcy with 100% accuracy?

No, the Adjusted Z-Score provides a probabilistic assessment of financial distress, not a guaranteed prediction. It is a statistical model that indicates the likelihood of future financial problems based on historical financial data. It should be used as part of a broader financial analysis.

Is the Adjusted Z-Score only for U.S. companies?

While the original Z-Score was developed using U.S. data, adapted versions like the Z"-Score have been developed and tested for use in emerging markets and for international companies, recognizing differences in accounting standards and economic environments. However, direct application without considering local contexts may limit its predictive power.

What are the main components of the Adjusted Z-Score formula?

The main components of the Adjusted Z-Score formula are financial ratios that measure a company's liquidity (working capital to total assets), cumulative profitability (retained earnings to total assets), operational efficiency (EBIT to total assets), and leverage (book value of equity to total liabilities).