Skip to main content
← Back to A Definitions

Advance directives

What Are Advance Directives?

Advance directives are crucial legal documents that allow individuals to make their healthcare preferences known in advance, particularly concerning medical treatment should they become unable to communicate their wishes. These directives are a fundamental component of comprehensive healthcare planning, ensuring that an individual's autonomy over their medical decisions extends even into periods of incapacity. By formally documenting these choices, advance directives guide family members, physicians, and other healthcare providers in delivering care that aligns with the patient's values and desires.

History and Origin

The concept of individuals controlling their medical treatment gained significant traction in the mid-20th century, particularly as medical advancements made it possible to prolong life through artificial means. The very idea of an advance healthcare directive was first introduced in 1967 by human rights attorney Luis Kutner, who proposed the "living will" to empower patients to direct their end-of-life care.20, 21

Early legislative efforts to legalize these directives faced challenges, but the movement gained momentum following high-profile cases that highlighted the ethical dilemmas faced by families and healthcare providers when patients could no longer express their wishes. California made a landmark move in 1976 by passing the Natural Death Act, the first law in the United States to give legal force to a living will.17, 18, 19 This act permitted competent adults to refuse life-sustaining treatment in the event of a terminal condition.16 The passage of the Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA) by Congress in 1990 further solidified the importance of advance directives, requiring most healthcare facilities to inform adult patients of their rights to execute such a document.14, 15 This federal legislation underscored the right of individuals to control their own destiny in medical contexts.

Key Takeaways

  • Advance directives are legal documents that specify an individual's wishes regarding medical treatment, particularly for future situations where they cannot communicate.
  • They typically include instructions for life-sustaining treatment, pain management, and the appointment of a healthcare proxy or surrogate decision-makers.
  • These documents aim to uphold patient autonomy and alleviate the burden of difficult medical decisions on family members.
  • Common types of advance directives include living wills and durable power of attorney for healthcare.
  • Their effectiveness relies on clear communication, regular review, and accessibility to healthcare providers and designated agents.

Interpreting Advance Directives

Interpreting advance directives involves understanding the specific instructions outlined by the individual and applying them to the current medical situation. These documents typically detail preferences concerning various medical interventions, such as cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), mechanical ventilation, artificial nutrition, and pain management. The effectiveness of an advance directive hinges on its clarity and the degree to which it anticipates potential medical scenarios. For instance, a directive might specify that in the case of a terminal illness with no reasonable hope of recovery, the individual wishes to forgo all life-sustaining treatment.

Healthcare providers and designated agents must carefully interpret these written instructions in light of the patient's current condition and the underlying values expressed in the document. Open communication between the patient (while capable), their family, and healthcare teams is paramount to ensure that the spirit and intent of the advance directive are honored, rather than simply adhering to rigid interpretations of specific clauses.13

Hypothetical Example

Consider Maria, a 55-year-old single professional. She decides to complete an advance directive as part of her broader financial planning. In her advance directive, she specifies that if she were to enter a persistent vegetative state with no reasonable prospect of recovery, she would not want artificial hydration or nutrition. She also names her sister, Elena, as her healthcare proxy, empowering Elena to make medical decisions on her behalf if Maria is unable.

Years later, Maria is involved in a severe accident and sustains extensive brain damage, leading to a persistent vegetative state. Her doctors inform Elena that Maria's condition is irreversible. Because Maria had a clear advance directive in place, Elena has a defined legal framework for making difficult choices. She can confidently communicate Maria's pre-expressed wishes regarding life-sustaining measures to the medical team, honoring her sister's autonomy and relieving herself of the sole burden of this weighty decision.

Practical Applications

Advance directives are critical tools in various aspects of personal and legal planning, extending beyond immediate healthcare scenarios. They are commonly integrated into estate planning documents, working in conjunction with a will and other instruments to provide a holistic approach to an individual's future affairs. These directives enable individuals to maintain control over their healthcare, even when they cannot participate in decision-making.

For example, a durable power of attorney for healthcare, a common type of advance directive, designates a trusted person to make medical decisions. This is particularly valuable in unexpected emergencies or sudden incapacitation. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) highlights that advance directives, including living wills and Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) orders, are common among individuals receiving long-term care, indicating their practical use in managing ongoing health conditions and end-of-life considerations.12 The American Bar Association provides guidance on creating these legal documents, emphasizing their role in ensuring personal preferences are respected and family conflict is minimized.11

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their intended benefits, advance directives face several limitations and criticisms regarding their effectiveness and implementation. One primary concern is that individuals may not be able to foresee all possible future health scenarios, leading to directives that are too vague or do not accurately reflect their wishes in specific, unforeseen circumstances. A study published in PubMed Central suggests that the correspondence between responses to standard living will questions and actual preferences in specific end-of-life scenarios can be modest.10 This highlights that preferences can change over time, or with a decline in health status, potentially locking individuals into decisions they might no longer desire.8, 9

Furthermore, even when advance directives are completed, they may not be readily available to healthcare providers in an emergency, or their existence may not be communicated effectively to family members or the medical team.6, 7 Healthcare professionals may also encounter difficulties in interpreting ambiguous language in the directives or may face their own ethical dilemmas, leading to a reluctance to strictly follow the stated wishes.3, 4, 5 The focus on written directives can sometimes overshadow the more crucial process of ongoing dialogue and advance care planning discussions between patients, families, and clinicians, which are essential for ensuring a comprehensive understanding of a patient's values.

Advance Directives vs. Living Will

While often used interchangeably, "advance directives" is the broader term encompassing various legal instruments for future healthcare decisions, whereas a "living will" is a specific type of advance directive.

A living will is a written legal document that outlines a person's wishes regarding medical treatment and life-sustaining treatment in specific end-of-life scenarios, such as if they become terminally ill or permanently unconscious. It directly states what medical interventions the individual would or would not want.

Advance directives is the umbrella term that includes living wills, as well as other documents like a durable power of attorney for healthcare (also known as a healthcare proxy or medical power of attorney). A durable power of attorney for healthcare designates a trusted individual to make medical decisions on behalf of the patient if they are incapacitated, but it does not necessarily include specific treatment instructions unless combined with a living will. Therefore, while all living wills are advance directives, not all advance directives are living wills.

FAQs

Q: Who should have an advance directive?
A: Any adult of sound mind can benefit from having an advance directive, regardless of age or current health status. It is a proactive step in healthcare planning that ensures your wishes are known if you become unable to communicate.

Q: What happens if I don't have an advance directive?
A: Without an advance directive, medical decisions for you may fall to family members or, in some cases, be determined by state law or court-appointed guardians. This can lead to family disputes and decisions that may not align with your true wishes.2

Q: Can I change or revoke my advance directive?
A: Yes, as long as you are of sound mind, you can modify or revoke your advance directive at any time. It is crucial to review your advance directive periodically, especially after significant life events, and ensure that updated copies are shared with your healthcare proxy and physicians.

Q: Is an advance directive legally binding?
A: Yes, when properly executed according to state laws, an advance directive is a legally binding legal document that healthcare providers are generally obligated to follow. State laws vary, so it's important to ensure your document complies with the regulations in your jurisdiction.1