Skip to main content
← Back to A Definitions

Advanced neutral rate

What Is Advanced Neutral Rate?

The Advanced Neutral Rate, often referred to simply as the neutral rate or r-star, is the theoretical real interest rate that would prevail when an economy is operating at its full sustainable capacity with stable inflation. It represents a critical concept in monetary policy within the broader field of macroeconomic theory, serving as a benchmark for central banks to gauge the appropriate stance of interest rates. When the actual policy rate is above the Advanced Neutral Rate, monetary policy is considered restrictive, aiming to cool the economy. Conversely, if the policy rate is below the Advanced Neutral Rate, it is considered stimulative. Understanding the Advanced Neutral Rate is crucial for policymakers seeking to achieve both full employment and price stability.

History and Origin

The concept of a natural or neutral rate of interest has its roots in the late 19th century with the Swedish economist Knut Wicksell. Wicksell introduced the idea of a "natural rate of interest" as the rate that would balance saving and investment in a full-employment economy, consistent with a stable price level. Deviations of the market rate from this natural rate, in Wicksell's view, would lead to cumulative processes of inflation or deflation.11, 12, 13

Modern interpretations of the Advanced Neutral Rate build upon Wicksell's foundational work, incorporating insights from New Keynesian economic models. A significant advancement in the estimation of the neutral rate came with the development of the Laubach-Williams (LW) model in the early 2000s by Thomas Laubach and John C. Williams, economists at the Federal Reserve. This model provided a framework for estimating the unobservable natural rate by filtering observed data on output, inflation, and policy rates. Subsequent refinements, such as the Holston-Laubach-Williams (HLW) model, extended this analysis to other advanced economies, acknowledging that the neutral rate can vary over time due to factors like trend economic growth and demographics.8, 9, 10

Key Takeaways

  • The Advanced Neutral Rate is the real interest rate consistent with an economy operating at its full capacity and stable inflation.
  • It serves as a benchmark for central banks to determine whether their current policy stance is stimulative, neutral, or restrictive.
  • The concept originated with Knut Wicksell's "natural rate of interest" and has been refined through modern macroeconomic modeling.
  • Estimates of the Advanced Neutral Rate are unobservable and rely on sophisticated statistical models, such as the Laubach-Williams framework.
  • Factors like productivity growth, demographics, and global saving/investment patterns can cause the Advanced Neutral Rate to fluctuate over time.

Formula and Calculation

The Advanced Neutral Rate is not directly observable and thus cannot be calculated with a simple, fixed formula. Instead, it is estimated using complex econometric techniques, most notably the Laubach-Williams (LW) and Holston-Laubach-Williams (HLW) models. These models employ a state-space framework with a Kalman filter to extract an unobserved trend for the natural rate.

The core idea often involves a dynamic IS (Investment-Saving) curve and a Phillips curve that relate the output gap to the real interest rate and inflation. While the full model is intricate, a simplified representation of the unobserved Advanced Neutral Rate ((r^*_t)) in these models often includes components such as the trend growth rate of potential output ((g_t)) and other unobserved factors ((z_t)):

rt=gt+ztr^*_t = g_t + z_t

Where:

  • (r^*_t) = Advanced Neutral Rate at time (t)
  • (g_t) = Trend growth rate of potential output at time (t)
  • (z_t) = Other factors influencing the neutral rate (e.g., shifts in desired saving and investment due to demographics, technological change, or risk premia)

Both (g_t) and (z_t) are assumed to follow random walk processes, implying they can change over time. The models estimate these unobservable components simultaneously by observing their impact on inflation and output.6, 7

Interpreting the Advanced Neutral Rate

Interpreting the Advanced Neutral Rate is crucial for central bank officials. It provides a theoretical compass for gauging the overall stance of interest rates relative to the economy's underlying health. If the actual policy rate set by the central bank is significantly above the estimated Advanced Neutral Rate, it suggests that monetary policy is tight, potentially restraining aggregate demand and economic activity. Conversely, if the policy rate is below the Advanced Neutral Rate, policy is considered accommodative, aiming to stimulate the economy.

Policymakers monitor this estimated rate to guide decisions on raising, lowering, or holding steady their benchmark rates. A decline in the Advanced Neutral Rate over time, as observed in many advanced economies, implies that lower actual interest rates are needed to achieve a neutral stance. This has significant implications for how much room central banks have to cut rates during downturns. The estimated Advanced Neutral Rate serves as a guidepost, indicating the real interest rate that would neither stimulate nor restrain the economy, allowing it to grow at its sustainable pace without generating inflationary or deflationary pressures.5

Hypothetical Example

Consider a hypothetical economy where the estimated Advanced Neutral Rate is 0.5%. This suggests that a real policy interest rate of 0.5% would keep the economy in equilibrium, with full employment and stable inflation.

Suppose the central bank observes signs of accelerating inflation and an overheated economy, with unemployment falling below its natural rate. To temper these pressures, the central bank might decide to set its nominal policy rate such that the real policy rate rises to, say, 1.5%. Since 1.5% is above the 0.5% Advanced Neutral Rate, this action represents a restrictive monetary policy stance, designed to cool the economy and bring inflation back to target.

Conversely, if the economy were in a recession with high unemployment and falling prices, the central bank might lower its nominal policy rate to achieve a real policy rate of, for example, -0.5%. This rate, being below the 0.5% Advanced Neutral Rate, would be considered an accommodative stance, stimulating borrowing, investment, and aggregate supply to help the economy recover.

Practical Applications

The Advanced Neutral Rate is primarily a tool used by central banks and economic analysts for assessing and conducting monetary policy. Its practical applications include:

  • Policy Stance Assessment: Central bankers use the estimated Advanced Neutral Rate as a long-run guide to determine if their current interest rates are expansionary, contractionary, or truly neutral. For instance, if the policy rate is above the neutral rate, it implies a tightening of financial conditions.
  • Inflation Targeting: In economies with an inflation target, the neutral rate helps policymakers understand the real interest rate level consistent with achieving that target over the medium term without creating undue economic slack or overheating.
  • Forecasting and Projections: Economists incorporate the Advanced Neutral Rate into their macro-economic forecasts to project future paths of interest rates, inflation, and economic activity.
  • Understanding Economic Trends: Long-term declines in the estimated Advanced Neutral Rate, as observed globally over recent decades, help explain why interest rates have generally been lower than in past periods. This trend has significant implications for investment and saving patterns.
  • Communication: Central banks sometimes refer to the neutral rate concept in their communications to explain their policy rationale and outlook. For example, the Reserve Bank of India has indicated that its "neutral" policy stance means future rate decisions will be data-dependent, balancing inflation and economic growth.4

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its importance in monetary policy discussions, the Advanced Neutral Rate is subject to several limitations and criticisms:

  • Unobservability: The most significant challenge is that the Advanced Neutral Rate cannot be directly observed; it must be estimated using complex economic models. These estimates are model-dependent and come with significant uncertainty and measurement error. Different models and data inputs can yield varying estimates, leading to debate among economists.2, 3
  • Time-Varying Nature: The Advanced Neutral Rate is not static but changes over time due to shifts in fundamental economic factors like productivity growth, demographics, and global saving and investment behavior. Constantly updating and accurately estimating this moving target is a significant challenge for policymakers.
  • Real-time Estimation Challenges: Real-time estimates of the Advanced Neutral Rate can be particularly volatile and prone to revision as new data become available. This makes it difficult for central bank officials to rely solely on these estimates for immediate policy decisions.
  • Policy Relevance: Some argue that while the neutral rate is a useful theoretical concept, its practical utility as a precise guide for short-term interest rates may be limited, especially during periods of significant economic shocks or uncertainty. As one Federal Reserve official noted, it is a good benchmark as a general concept but less useful as a precise short-term estimate.1
  • Exclusion of Financial Factors: Traditional models for estimating the Advanced Neutral Rate, such as the initial Laubach-Williams model, may not fully account for the role of financial imbalances or the financial stability considerations that can influence real interest rates and economic outcomes.

Advanced Neutral Rate vs. Natural Rate of Interest

The terms "Advanced Neutral Rate" and "Natural Rate of Interest" are often used interchangeably in modern macroeconomic discourse. Both refer to the theoretical real interest rate that is consistent with an economy operating at its full productive capacity and achieving stable inflation (or price stability).

Historically, Knut Wicksell introduced the "natural rate of interest" as the rate that equates real saving and investment in the absence of monetary disturbances. The term "neutral rate" gained prominence with modern interpretations, particularly within New Keynesian frameworks, which emphasize the role of nominal rigidities. In these models, the "neutral rate" is the real interest rate that would prevail in an economy without these nominal frictions, making it a suitable target for policy when attempting to eliminate inefficiencies. While the "natural rate" might be seen as the slow-moving, long-run determinant, the "neutral rate" can also incorporate shorter-run factors stemming from temporary economic shocks, distinguishing it slightly in some contexts as a more immediate policy benchmark influenced by current conditions, alongside its underlying long-run component. However, for most practical purposes, particularly in central bank communications and academic papers using models like Laubach-Williams, the terms are effectively synonymous.

FAQs

Why is the Advanced Neutral Rate important for central banks?

The Advanced Neutral Rate is crucial for central banks because it acts as a guidepost for setting interest rates. By comparing the actual policy rate to the estimated Advanced Neutral Rate, central banks can determine if their monetary stance is stimulative, restrictive, or appropriately neutral to achieve their goals of full employment and price stability.

Can the Advanced Neutral Rate be measured directly?

No, the Advanced Neutral Rate cannot be measured directly. It is an unobservable theoretical concept that economists estimate using complex economic models and statistical techniques, such as the Laubach-Williams model. These estimates are subject to uncertainty and revisions as new data become available.

What factors cause the Advanced Neutral Rate to change?

The Advanced Neutral Rate is influenced by fundamental, real-side factors of the economy. These include changes in productivity growth, demographic shifts (like an aging population affecting saving and investment), technological advancements, and global supply and demand for capital. These factors can cause the rate to fluctuate over time, often slowly.

How does the Advanced Neutral Rate relate to the business cycle?

The Advanced Neutral Rate helps assess the stance of monetary policy relative to the business cycle. When the economy is weak (e.g., in a recession), the actual real interest rate needs to be below the neutral rate to stimulate aggregate demand and encourage recovery. During strong economic expansions, the actual rate may need to rise above the neutral rate to prevent overheating and control inflation.