Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to A Definitions

Aggregate roll yield

What Is Aggregate Roll Yield?

Aggregate roll yield refers to the combined return or cost generated from the periodic "rolling" of multiple individual futures contracts within a larger portfolio or index. This concept is particularly relevant in the context of futures trading and commodity markets, forming a crucial component of an investor's total return from such assets. It falls under the broader umbrella of investment strategy, offering insights into the structural characteristics of futures curves.

When investors hold futures contracts, they typically do not intend to take physical delivery of the underlying asset. Instead, as a contract approaches its expiration date, investors close out their position in the near-term contract and open a new position in a longer-dated contract to maintain their market exposure. This process is known as "rolling" the contract. The aggregate roll yield captures the sum of the gains or losses incurred from these individual rolls across all components of a portfolio or index. A positive aggregate roll yield occurs when the longer-dated contracts are cheaper than the expiring near-term contracts (a market condition known as backwardation), allowing investors to sell high and buy low. Conversely, a negative aggregate roll yield arises when longer-dated contracts are more expensive (a condition called contango), forcing investors to sell low and buy high.

History and Origin

The concept of roll yield, and by extension, aggregate roll yield, is intrinsically linked to the evolution of futures markets, particularly in commodities. Futures contracts have existed for centuries, initially to manage agricultural price risks. However, their role expanded significantly with the development of organized exchanges like the Chicago Board of Trade in the mid-19th century. As financial participants began using futures not just for hedging physical exposure but also for speculation and investment, the need to understand all sources of return became critical.

The phenomenon of contango and backwardation, which directly drives roll yield, has been observed in commodity markets for a long time. Early theories, such as Keynes's normal backwardation hypothesis, attempted to explain why futures prices might trade at a discount to expected future spot prices, implying a positive roll yield as a risk premium for producers hedging their output. The widespread adoption of commodity index investing in the late 20th and early 21st centuries, exemplified by benchmarks like the Bloomberg Commodity Index (BCOM), brought the concept of aggregate roll yield to the forefront. These indices, designed to provide broad exposure to commodities without physical delivery, inherently involve continuous rolling of contracts. The Bloomberg Commodity Index methodology, for instance, details how its "rolling" process impacts its performance, explicitly mentioning that the difference between the prices of the two contracts when they are rolled is sometimes referred to as a "roll yield".14

Key Takeaways

  • Definition: Aggregate roll yield represents the collective profit or loss generated by rolling multiple futures contracts from a nearer-term expiration to a more distant one within an investment portfolio or index.
  • Market Structure Impact: It is heavily influenced by the shape of the futures curve. A market in backwardation (near-term prices higher than long-term) leads to a positive aggregate roll yield, while a market in contango (near-term prices lower than long-term) results in a negative aggregate roll yield.
  • Component of Total Return: For futures-based investments, particularly commodity indices, aggregate roll yield is a distinct and often significant component of total return, alongside changes in the spot price of the underlying commodity and the collateral yield.
  • Indicator of Supply/Demand: The presence of backwardation or contango, and thus the potential for positive or negative roll yield, can reflect underlying supply and demand dynamics in a commodity market. Backwardation may signal tight supply, while contango might indicate ample supply.
  • Crucial for Performance Analysis: Understanding the aggregate roll yield is essential for accurately analyzing the performance of commodity-linked investments and for making informed decisions regarding diversification and asset allocation within financial markets.

Formula and Calculation

The aggregate roll yield for a portfolio or index of futures contracts is derived from the roll yield of its individual components, weighted by their respective proportions in the portfolio. For a single futures contract roll, the roll yield can be conceptually calculated as the difference between the price of the expiring contract and the price of the new, longer-dated contract, relative to the expiring contract's price.

For a single futures contract:

Roll Yield=Pexpiring−PnewPexpiring\text{Roll Yield} = \frac{\text{P}_{\text{expiring}} - \text{P}_{\text{new}}}{\text{P}_{\text{expiring}}}

Where:

  • (\text{P}_{\text{expiring}}) = Price of the futures contract nearing expiration date.
  • (\text{P}_{\text{new}}) = Price of the longer-dated futures contract being purchased.

For an aggregate portfolio or index containing multiple futures contracts, the aggregate roll yield would be the sum of the weighted individual roll yields:

Aggregate Roll Yield=∑i=1N(wi×Roll Yieldi)\text{Aggregate Roll Yield} = \sum_{i=1}^{N} (\text{w}_i \times \text{Roll Yield}_i)

Where:

  • (N) = Total number of futures contracts or commodities in the portfolio/index.
  • (\text{w}_i) = Weighting of commodity (i) in the portfolio/index.
  • (\text{Roll Yield}_i) = Roll yield of individual futures contract (i).

This calculation reflects the return component generated purely from the relative pricing between different contract maturities, independent of the overall change in the spot price of the underlying commodity.

Interpreting the Aggregate Roll Yield

Interpreting the aggregate roll yield involves understanding the implications of its sign and magnitude for a futures-based investment. A positive aggregate roll yield indicates that, on average, the futures contracts in the portfolio are rolling from higher-priced near-term contracts to lower-priced longer-term contracts. This scenario, characteristic of a backwardated market, can contribute positively to overall investment returns. It suggests a potential premium earned by maintaining exposure to the underlying commodities over time. For example, the Bloomberg Enhanced Roll Yield Index (BERY) is designed to mitigate the negative effects of contango by identifying commodities with the most backwardation or least contango to invest in.13

Conversely, a negative aggregate roll yield implies that, on average, the futures contracts are rolling from lower-priced near-term contracts to higher-priced longer-term contracts, which is typical of a contango market. This can detract from total returns, as the cost of rolling positions erodes potential gains from changes in the futures prices themselves. Investors need to be aware that in contango, continuously rolling positions can lead to a drag on performance, meaning that the returns from a futures position may fall short of the changes in the underlying spot price.12 Therefore, the aggregate roll yield provides a critical signal about the structural profitability (or cost) of holding a futures-based commodity exposure.

Hypothetical Example

Consider a hypothetical commodity index composed equally of two commodities: Crude Oil and Natural Gas.

Scenario:

  • Crude Oil Futures:
    • Expiring contract price: $80.00
    • Next month contract price: $78.00
    • Weight in index: 50%
  • Natural Gas Futures:
    • Expiring contract price: $3.00
    • Next month contract price: $3.10
    • Weight in index: 50%

Step-by-step Calculation:

  1. Calculate Roll Yield for Crude Oil:

    • Crude Oil is in backwardation (expiring > new).
    • Roll Yield (Crude Oil) = ($80.00 - $78.00) / $80.00 = $2.00 / $80.00 = 0.025 or 2.5%

  2. Calculate Roll Yield for Natural Gas:

    • Natural Gas is in contango (expiring < new).
    • Roll Yield (Natural Gas) = ($3.00 - $3.10) / $3.00 = -$0.10 / $3.00 = -0.0333 or -3.33%

  3. Calculate Aggregate Roll Yield for the Index:

    • Aggregate Roll Yield = (0.50 * 2.5%) + (0.50 * -3.33%)
    • Aggregate Roll Yield = 1.25% + (-1.665%)
    • Aggregate Roll Yield = -0.415%

In this example, despite Crude Oil providing a positive roll yield due to backwardation, the significant negative roll yield from Natural Gas (due to contango) leads to a negative aggregate roll yield for the overall index. This illustrates how the combined effect of different commodity futures curves impacts the total return of a multi-commodity investment portfolio.

Practical Applications

Aggregate roll yield is a vital consideration for investors, fund managers, and analysts involved in commodity-linked investments, exchange-traded products (ETPs), and risk management strategies.

  1. Commodity Index Performance: Many broad-based commodity indices, such as the Bloomberg Commodity Index (BCOM), are "rolling indices" that continuously manage positions across different futures maturities.11 The aggregate roll yield significantly impacts the total return of these indices and, consequently, the performance of ETPs that track them. Investors use this insight to understand why a commodity ETP's performance might deviate from the spot price performance of the underlying commodities. Understanding these components allows for more informed decision-making.10
  2. Investment Strategy and Allocation: Fund managers use aggregate roll yield analysis to inform their asset allocation decisions within commodities. They might tilt portfolios towards commodities consistently in backwardation to capture positive roll yields, or implement strategies designed to mitigate the negative impact of contango. This focus on "carry risk premium" is a sophisticated element of modern investment strategy.9
  3. Inflation Hedging: Commodities are often viewed as a hedge against inflation.8 However, the effectiveness of this hedge when investing via futures can be significantly impacted by negative aggregate roll yield during periods of contango. Understanding the aggregate roll yield helps investors assess the true cost of maintaining commodity exposure for diversification or inflation-hedging purposes.
  4. Arbitrage and Trading: While direct arbitrage opportunities from roll yield are typically short-lived in efficient markets, sophisticated traders and quantitative funds analyze the aggregate roll yield for potential tactical trading opportunities, focusing on the spread between different futures prices.

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its importance, aggregate roll yield has certain limitations and has faced criticism, particularly concerning its interpretation as a direct cash flow and its predictive power.

  1. Misconception as Cash Flow: A common misconception is that roll yield represents a direct cash flow received or paid when rolling futures contracts. However, as some researchers highlight, "No such cash flow occurs—at the time of roll trades or on any other date." I7nstead, it reflects the excess return or cost beyond spot price changes, or the benefit to the marginal holder of a spot position. It's a return component rather than a physical income or expense at the moment of the roll.
    26. Variability and Unpredictability: The aggregate roll yield can be highly volatile and unpredictable. Commodity markets are influenced by numerous factors, including geopolitical events, supply shocks, demand shifts, and inventory levels, all of which can rapidly alter the shape of the futures curve and, consequently, the roll yield. T5his volatility makes it challenging to consistently predict or rely on a positive aggregate roll yield.
  2. Does Not Always Predict Spot Price Changes: While a market in backwardation (positive roll yield) is often associated with tight supply and potentially rising spot prices, and contango (negative roll yield) with oversupply and falling spot prices, this relationship is not a consistent predictor of future spot price movements. F4actors beyond the roll yield, such as unexpected supply or demand changes, can significantly influence the spot price independent of the futures curve's shape. Research suggests that while roll yield can be useful over long time frames, it's not useful in the short term.
    43. Impact of Financialization: The increased "financialization" of commodity markets, with more investment from financial institutions rather than just commercial hedgers, has been criticized for potentially distorting traditional supply-demand dynamics and contributing to periods of persistent contango, which can negatively impact returns for passive index investors.

2## Aggregate Roll Yield vs. Roll Yield

While closely related, "aggregate roll yield" and "roll yield" refer to different scopes of measurement within futures investing.

Roll Yield typically refers to the return or cost generated from rolling a single futures contract. It is the percentage gain or loss realized when an investor sells an expiring near-term futures contract and simultaneously buys a longer-dated contract for the same underlying commodity. This gain or loss depends on the price difference between the two contracts at the time of the roll, reflecting whether that specific commodity's futures curve is in contango or backwardation.

Aggregate Roll Yield, on the other hand, is the total, weighted roll yield across an entire portfolio or index that holds multiple futures contracts on different commodities. It sums up the individual roll yields, weighted by each commodity's allocation, to provide a comprehensive view of the roll-related profitability or cost for the entire futures exposure. For instance, a commodity index might consist of various energy, agricultural, and metal futures. The aggregate roll yield would capture the blended effect of all the individual rolls within that index. It provides a macro-level perspective on how the term structure of futures prices is collectively impacting the performance of a diversified commodity allocation.

FAQs

What causes aggregate roll yield to be positive or negative?

Aggregate roll yield is positive when the collective effect of individual commodity futures markets in a portfolio are in backwardation, meaning near-term contracts are priced higher than longer-term ones. This allows investors to "sell high and buy low" when rolling. It is negative when most of the markets are in contango, where near-term contracts are lower priced than longer-term ones, leading to "selling low and buying high" during the roll.

How does aggregate roll yield affect my investment returns?

Aggregate roll yield directly impacts the total return of investments that hold futures contracts, such as commodity index funds or exchange-traded products. A positive aggregate roll yield contributes to higher returns, while a negative one can create a drag on performance, potentially causing the investment to underperform the spot price changes of the underlying commodities. Understanding this is key for evaluating commodity investment portfolio performance.

Is aggregate roll yield predictable?

While the concept is well understood, precisely predicting aggregate roll yield is challenging. It depends on future supply and demand dynamics, which can shift rapidly due to economic, geopolitical, or environmental factors. However, the prevailing market conditions (contango or backwardation) can give an indication of the expected short-term roll yield for individual commodities. Over very long time horizons, some historical patterns related to roll yield have been observed in certain commodity markets.

1### Can I avoid negative aggregate roll yield when investing in commodities?
Investors cannot entirely avoid negative aggregate roll yield if they wish to maintain continuous exposure to commodity futures contracts. However, some active strategies or enhanced indices attempt to mitigate its impact by selecting contracts with the most favorable roll yields (e.g., those in deep backwardation or minimal contango) or by adjusting their rolling schedules. These strategies often add complexity and may not always succeed.

What is the relationship between aggregate roll yield and liquidity?

The liquidity of futures contracts can influence the costs associated with rolling positions, which indirectly affects the aggregate roll yield. In highly liquid markets, the bid-ask spreads for rolling contracts are typically narrower, making the roll process more efficient. Conversely, less liquid contracts might incur higher transaction costs during the roll, further eroding potential gains or exacerbating losses from the roll yield.