Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to B Definitions

Bilateral treaties

What Are Bilateral Treaties?

Bilateral treaties are formal agreements established between two sovereign states or international entities. These agreements, a fundamental component of international finance and international law, outline specific rights and obligations, aiming to facilitate cooperation, regulate interactions, and resolve issues of mutual concern. Unlike multilateral agreements involving three or more parties, bilateral treaties are highly focused, addressing specific issues or fostering relationships exclusively between the two signatories. Common areas covered by bilateral treaties include trade barriers, investment, environmental protection, defense, and taxation. The specificity of bilateral treaties allows for tailored solutions that might be difficult to achieve in broader, more complex multilateral frameworks.

History and Origin

The concept of agreements between two distinct political entities has roots dating back to antiquity. However, the modern form and widespread adoption of bilateral treaties, particularly in the economic sphere, gained significant traction in the post-World War II era. After the war, there was a fear that the economic conditions that led to the Great Depression and protectionism might re-emerge, leading countries to seek more direct, manageable agreements. While the immediate post-war period saw some initial attempts at broader multilateral frameworks, a resurgence of bilateralism occurred in the late 1940s as countries sought to stabilize their economies and promote exports, sometimes leading to the curtailment of imports to manage debts.9

Early examples include the Reciprocity of Duties Act in Great Britain in 1823, which allowed for the reciprocal removal of import duties under bilateral agreements. In the mid-1990s, following the dissolution of the Soviet Union, the European Union actively pursued bilateral trade agreements with Central and Eastern European nations, while the U.S. also engaged in its own bilateral trade negotiations, such as the agreement with Israel in 1985. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has played a crucial role in standardizing bilateral tax treaties since its first Model Tax Convention was published in 1963, providing a benchmark for countries to avoid double taxation and prevent tax evasion.8

Key Takeaways

  • Bilateral treaties are agreements between two sovereign states or international entities.
  • They provide tailored frameworks for cooperation across various sectors, including trade, investment, and taxation.
  • These agreements help reduce trade barriers such as tariffs and quotas.
  • Bilateral treaties often include provisions for dispute resolution and the protection of intellectual property rights.
  • They serve as a foundational element of international trade and diplomatic relations.

Interpreting Bilateral Treaties

Interpreting a bilateral treaty involves understanding the specific language, clauses, and intent agreed upon by the two signatory parties. These agreements typically cover a broad range of provisions governing the conditions of interaction between the parties, including rules on customs duties, fiscal regulations, and transit arrangements.7 For instance, in free trade agreements, bilateral treaties define how goods and services will flow between the two nations, specifying the reduction or elimination of tariffs and other non-tariff barriers.

In the context of cross-border investment and taxation, interpreting a bilateral treaty means understanding how it allocates taxing rights between the two countries to prevent double taxation and address fiscal evasion. The OECD Model Tax Convention, for example, provides detailed guidance on interpreting articles related to business profits, dividends, interest, and royalties, helping to standardize the application of these treaties globally.6

Hypothetical Example

Consider a hypothetical "Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT)" between Country A and Country B.

  1. Objective: Country A, a developed nation, wants to encourage its businesses to invest in Country B, a developing nation, to build factories and create jobs. Country B seeks foreign direct investment to boost its economy.
  2. Negotiation: Representatives from both countries negotiate the terms. Country A insists on robust protections for its investors, including fair and equitable treatment, protection against expropriation without compensation, and mechanisms for dispute resolution in case of disagreements. Country B agrees but also seeks provisions that ensure technology transfer and local employment.
  3. Agreement: The bilateral treaty is signed, stipulating that investments from Country A in Country B will receive national treatment (i.e., treated no less favorably than domestic investments) and most-favored-nation (MFN) treatment (i.e., treated no less favorably than investments from any third country). It also includes a clause for international arbitration if an investor from Country A believes their rights under the treaty have been violated by Country B's government.
  4. Outcome: With the security provided by the bilateral treaty, companies from Country A are more willing to deploy capital in Country B, leading to increased investment flows and economic integration between the two nations.

Practical Applications

Bilateral treaties are widely applied in various aspects of international finance and global relations:

  • Trade Agreements: These are perhaps the most common forms of bilateral treaties, aiming to reduce or eliminate tariffs, quotas, and other trade barriers between two countries, thereby enhancing market access. An example is the United States-Korea Free Trade Agreement (KORUS FTA), which significantly reduced tariffs on goods and services between the two nations upon its entry into force in 2012.5,4 It aimed to boost bilateral trade by eliminating duties on nearly 95% of consumer and industrial products within three years.
  • Investment Treaties (BITs): These agreements protect and promote foreign direct investment between two countries, establishing standards for treatment of investors and providing mechanisms for dispute resolution.
  • Tax Treaties: Designed to prevent double taxation of income or capital for individuals and businesses operating across borders, these treaties often follow models like the OECD Model Tax Convention.3,2 They also aim to prevent fiscal evasion and promote cooperation between tax authorities.
  • Aviation and Shipping Agreements: These bilateral treaties regulate air and sea travel between two nations, covering issues such as landing rights, routes, and cargo transport.
  • Security and Defense Pacts: Countries enter into bilateral defense treaties to establish alliances, share intelligence, and coordinate military actions, reflecting common security interests.

Limitations and Criticisms

While bilateral treaties offer targeted solutions and can be negotiated more quickly than multilateral agreements, they come with certain limitations and criticisms. A significant concern is the creation of a "spaghetti bowl" effect, where numerous crisscrossing agreements with different rules of origin and varying tariffs make global trade complex and potentially inefficient.1 This complexity can disproportionately burden smaller businesses trying to navigate diverse sets of rules for different trading partners.

Another criticism is that bilateral treaties can undermine the principles of non-discrimination central to global trade bodies like the World Trade Organization (WTO). While the WTO permits regional trade agreements under certain conditions, a proliferation of purely bilateral deals can lead to trade diversion, where trade shifts from a more efficient non-partner country to a less efficient partner country simply due to preferential treatment. This may not always contribute to overall global economic integration or liberalization. Furthermore, the power dynamics between the two negotiating parties can sometimes lead to imbalanced agreements, especially when there is a significant disparity in economic size or political influence.

Bilateral Treaties vs. Multilateral Treaties

The primary distinction between bilateral treaties and multilateral treaties lies in the number of parties involved. A bilateral treaty, as discussed, is an agreement exclusively between two states or entities. It is characterized by its specificity, allowing for highly customized provisions that address the unique interests and concerns of the two signatories. This targeted approach can lead to quicker negotiations and deeper levels of cooperation on particular issues, such as specific free trade agreements or agreements to prevent double taxation.

In contrast, multilateral treaties involve three or more countries. These agreements are often broader in scope, aiming to establish universal norms, facilitate cooperation on global issues (like climate change or nuclear non-proliferation), or create international organizations. Examples include the conventions of the World Trade Organization (WTO) or the United Nations Charter. While multilateral treaties promote uniformity and a more level playing field across many nations, their negotiation process is typically far more complex and time-consuming due to the need to reconcile diverse interests among numerous parties. The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), which evolved into the WTO, sought to reduce trade barriers on a multilateral basis, contrasting with the more focused scope of bilateral arrangements.

FAQs

What is the main purpose of a bilateral treaty?

The main purpose of a bilateral treaty is to formalize an agreement between two parties, typically countries, to regulate specific areas of cooperation, such as trade, investment, or taxation, to their mutual benefit. These treaties aim to clarify expectations, establish rules, and often reduce barriers in specific sectors.

How do bilateral treaties impact international trade?

Bilateral treaties can significantly impact international trade by reducing or eliminating tariffs and quotas, harmonizing standards, and setting rules for cross-border transactions between the two signatory countries. This often leads to increased trade volumes and closer economic integration.

Are all free trade agreements bilateral?

No, not all free trade agreements are bilateral. While many are bilateral, involving only two countries, others are multilateral, involving three or more countries, or regional trade agreements that encompass a specific geographic area. The European Union, for example, functions as a customs union among its members, which is a type of multilateral arrangement.

Can a bilateral treaty be terminated?

Yes, like most international agreements, a bilateral treaty can generally be terminated. The conditions for termination are usually specified within the treaty itself, which might include mutual agreement, a specified duration, or a breach of the treaty's terms by one of the parties.