Business models: Meaning, Criticisms & Real-World Uses

What Are Business Models?

A business model defines how an organization creates, delivers, and captures value. This framework, central to strategic management, articulates the fundamental logic by which a company operates, outlining its core activities, how it generates revenue, and its overall cost structure. Business models provide a holistic view, moving beyond just products or services to encompass the entire system that allows a business to function and generate profitability. Essentially, a business model answers critical questions about who the customer is, what value is offered, and how the enterprise makes money from that value proposition.

History and Origin

While businesses have always operated with underlying methods for generating revenue, the formal concept and widespread use of the term "business model" is relatively modern. Early discussions about the elements that constitute a business model can be traced back to academic articles in the mid-20th century. However, the term gained significant traction and became widely recognized in the late 1990s, largely propelled by the emergence of the internet and e-commerce⁵, ⁶, ⁷.

The rise of digital technologies facilitated entirely new ways of conducting business, leading to innovative approaches that challenged traditional structures. Companies needed frameworks to describe how these new, often asset-light, enterprises could create and capture value. This period saw the "business model" become almost synonymous with the 'new economy' and a focus on how organizations could successfully transition to profitable e-business models⁴. The concept provided a language to explain ventures, many of which were initially unprofitable but highly innovative, particularly in the tech sector where conventional valuation methods were often insufficient due to a lack of precedents³.

Key Takeaways

A business model describes how an organization creates, delivers, and captures value.
It encompasses a company's core activities, target customers, value proposition, and revenue generation methods.
The concept gained prominence with the rise of the internet and digital innovation in the late 1990s.
Effective business models are crucial for achieving competitive advantage and adapting to market changes.
Business model innovation is an ongoing process essential for long-term sustainability.

Interpreting Business Models

Interpreting a business model involves understanding the intricate interplay of its components and how they collectively contribute to value creation and capture. It’s not just about a single aspect, like a product, but the entire ecosystem. A robust business model clearly defines the customer segments being served, the unique value proposition offered, and the channels through which this value reaches the customer.

Furthermore, interpretation requires assessing the underlying key resources and key activities necessary to deliver the value proposition. Analyzing the partnership network, how revenue streams are generated, and the associated cost structure provides insight into the economic viability and scalability of the model. Companies with well-defined business models can more effectively communicate their strategic intent to stakeholders, align their organizational structure, and make informed decisions regarding growth and resource allocation.

Hypothetical Example

Consider a hypothetical startup, "EcoRide," which offers electric scooter rentals in urban areas.

Value Proposition: EcoRide provides convenient, eco-friendly, on-demand short-distance transportation.
Customer Segments: Urban commuters, tourists, and individuals seeking quick, flexible travel alternatives.
Channels: Mobile app for scooter location, unlocking, and payment; physical scooter hubs for charging and maintenance.
Customer Relationships: Automated customer service via app, community forums, occasional in-person support.
Revenue Streams: Per-minute rental fees, subscription passes for frequent users.
Key Resources: Fleet of electric scooters, mobile application, charging infrastructure, maintenance team.
Key Activities: Scooter deployment and retrieval, battery swapping/charging, app development and maintenance, marketing.
Key Partnerships: City governments for permits and parking, charging station providers.
Cost Structure: Scooter acquisition and maintenance, software development, electricity, labor for operations, marketing.

EcoRide's business model is a platform-based service that relies on the widespread adoption of smartphones and a shared economy approach. Its scalability depends on expanding its fleet and geographical coverage while optimizing operational efficiency.

Practical Applications

Business models are fundamental tools across various domains, from startup ideation to large corporate transformations. In venture capital, investors scrutinize a company's business model to assess its potential for growth, market entry, and long-term viability. For established corporations, business models are continuously reviewed and adapted in response to technological shifts, changing consumer preferences, and competitive pressures. The concept of digital transformation often involves a re-evaluation and overhaul of existing business models to leverage new digital capabilities.

For instance, the media industry has undergone a significant evolution of its business models, shifting from traditional advertising-supported or direct-sale models (e.g., newspapers, CDs) to subscription-based streaming services and freemium models. This shift, driven by internet distribution and changing consumer behavior, fundamentally altered how content is created, delivered, and monetized. Modern business models increasingly incorporate concepts like "multilateral platforms," where a business serves distinct customer groups that are interdependent (e.g., app stores connecting developers and users), and "free as a business model," where a basic service is offered for free to attract users, with revenue generated through premium features or advertising.
²

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their utility, business models are not without limitations or criticisms. One common critique, articulated by strategist Michael Porter, is that the definition of a business model can be "murky at best," often serving as a vague term for how a company generates revenue rather than a rigorous strategic framework. ¹Critics argue that an overemphasis on merely "having a business model" can lead to faulty thinking if it distracts from deeper strategic analysis, the development of unique capabilities, or understanding competitive forces.

Another limitation is that a business model describes a snapshot of how a company intends to operate, but it doesn't guarantee success or account for dynamic market changes. A well-designed business model can become obsolete if it fails to adapt to technological advancements, regulatory changes, or evolving customer needs. Companies that rigidly adhere to outdated business models, even if previously successful, risk disruption and decline. For example, traditional brick-and-mortar retail business models faced significant challenges with the rise of e-commerce, forcing many to adapt or cease operations.

Business Models vs. Strategy

While closely related and often used interchangeably, business models and strategy represent distinct concepts. A business model describes how a company creates, delivers, and captures value. It is the blueprint of the company's operational design and economic logic. It answers questions like: What do we offer? To whom? How do we make money? And what resources and activities are required?

In contrast, strategy defines why a company chooses a particular business model, where it will compete, and how it will gain a sustainable competitive advantage. Strategy involves making choices about industry positioning, target markets, and differentiating capabilities. A company's strategy guides the selection and design of its business model. For example, a company's strategy might be to dominate a niche market, and its business model would then detail the specific operations and revenue generation methods to achieve that strategic goal. An effective strategy leverages a well-designed business model to achieve its objectives, but the business model itself is a component of, or an outcome of, strategic decisions, rather than the strategy itself.

FAQs

What are the main components of a business model?

While frameworks vary, common components include a company's value proposition, customer segments, channels, customer relationships, revenue streams, key resources, key activities, key partnerships, and cost structure.

Can a company have multiple business models?

Yes, it is common for large or diversified companies to operate with multiple business models, often for different product lines, services, or market segments. For example, a technology company might have one business model for its hardware sales (direct sales) and another for its software subscriptions (recurring revenue).

How do business models evolve?

Business models evolve in response to technological advancements, changes in consumer behavior, new regulations, and competitive pressures. Evolution can involve adopting new revenue streams, altering distribution channels, or entirely reconfiguring how value is created and delivered.

What is business model innovation?

Business model innovation refers to creating new business models or significantly altering existing ones. This can involve finding new ways to deliver value, targeting underserved markets, or redefining the economic logic of an industry. It is a critical aspect of staying competitive and achieving growth.