What Is Capital Neutral Rate?
The capital neutral rate, often referred to as the natural rate of interest or r-star ((r^*)), is a theoretical real interest rate at which an economy operates at its full potential, achieving both stable inflation and full employment. It represents a state where monetary policy is neither expansionary nor contractionary. This concept is a cornerstone of macroeconomics and monetary policy, guiding central banks in setting their benchmark interest rates to foster sustainable economic growth without generating inflationary or deflationary pressures.
History and Origin
The concept of a "natural rate of interest" originated with the Swedish economist Knut Wicksell in the late 19th century, notably in his 1898 work Geldzins und Güterpreise (Interest and Prices). Wicksell defined this rate as one that is "neutral in respect to commodity prices, and tends neither to raise nor to lower them." 21He distinguished it from the market rate of interest, proposing that deviations between the two could lead to cumulative processes of price increases or decreases. If the market rate fell below the natural rate, investment would outpace saving, leading to inflation. Conversely, if the market rate exceeded the natural rate, saving would outpace investment, leading to deflation. His work laid foundational ideas for understanding the relationship between interest rates, money, and price stability. The concept was later taken up by John Maynard Keynes and, more prominently, by monetarists like Milton Friedman in the post-war era, who saw it as the real interest rate determined by underlying economic fundamentals in a general equilibrium system.20
Key Takeaways
- The capital neutral rate is the theoretical real interest rate where the economy is at full employment with stable inflation, meaning monetary policy is neither stimulating nor restraining.
- It is a hypothetical concept that cannot be directly observed and must be estimated using various economic models.
- Central banks use estimates of the capital neutral rate as a guide to assess the appropriate stance of their monetary policy.
- Factors such as productivity growth, demographics, and global saving and investment patterns can influence the capital neutral rate over time.
- Its elusive nature and difficulty in precise measurement present significant challenges for policymakers.
Formula and Calculation
The capital neutral rate itself does not have a single, universally accepted explicit formula because it is an unobservable, theoretical concept. Instead, economists and central banks rely on various complex statistical models to estimate it. One widely cited approach, developed by Thomas Laubach and John Williams (Laubach-Williams model), and later extended (Holston-Laubach-Williams or HLW model), uses data on real gross domestic product (GDP), inflation, and the federal funds rate to extract trends and estimate the natural rate.
19
While there isn't a direct formula, the underlying principle often relates the neutral real interest rate ((r^*)) to the sum of the trend rate of economic growth ((g)) and a risk premium or time preference factor ((\rho)):
Where:
- (r^*): The capital neutral rate (or natural/neutral real interest rate).
- (g): The economy's long-run trend rate of productivity growth and labor force growth, which drives potential output.
- (\rho): A composite term representing factors like time preference, risk aversion, and the demand-supply balance of savings and investment.
The estimation methods, such as those using Kalman filters and state-space models, attempt to infer this unobservable rate by analyzing observed economic variables. 18These models aim to determine the real interest rate consistent with output equaling potential GDP and stable inflation, accounting for shifts in underlying preferences and technology.
Interpreting the Capital Neutral Rate
Interpreting the capital neutral rate involves understanding its role as a benchmark for monetary policy. If the current real interest rate set by a central bank (e.g., the policy rate adjusted for inflation) is above the estimated capital neutral rate, it suggests that monetary policy is restrictive, aiming to slow economic activity and curb inflation. Conversely, if the actual real interest rate is below the capital neutral rate, monetary policy is considered accommodative, designed to stimulate aggregate demand and economic growth.
The value of the capital neutral rate is not static; it can change over time due to fundamental economic factors. For instance, a decline in productivity growth, an aging population leading to increased savings, or a global scarcity of safe assets can all contribute to a lower capital neutral rate.,17 16A lower capital neutral rate implies that the central bank needs to maintain lower nominal interest rates to achieve a neutral stance, which can limit its ability to cut rates during a recession if the neutral rate approaches zero (the "zero lower bound").
15
Hypothetical Example
Consider a hypothetical economy, "Prosperity Land," that has been experiencing moderate economic growth and stable inflation for several years. The central bank of Prosperity Land, the Federal Reserve of Prosperity (FRP), estimates that its capital neutral rate is 2.5%. This means that a real interest rate of 2.5% should allow Prosperity Land to maintain full employment and its target inflation rate of 2%.
Suppose the FRP observes that inflation is steadily rising to 4% and unemployment is falling below its estimated natural rate, indicating an overheating economy. The current real interest rate set by the FRP is 1.5%. Since the current real interest rate (1.5%) is below the estimated capital neutral rate (2.5%), the FRP understands that its monetary policy is currently expansionary, contributing to the inflationary pressures.
To bring inflation back to target and guide the economy towards a neutral stance, the FRP decides to raise its policy interest rates. If they raise the nominal rate by 1 percentage point, assuming inflation remains at 4% for a short period, the real rate would increase to 2.5%. This move would align the policy stance with the capital neutral rate, signaling a shift towards a less stimulative environment, which should help cool down the economy and bring inflation under control without unduly stifling economic growth.
Practical Applications
The capital neutral rate serves as a crucial conceptual guide for central banks worldwide in formulating their monetary policy. Policymakers at institutions like the U.S. Federal Reserve, the European Central Bank (ECB), and the Bank of Canada regularly consider estimates of this rate when making decisions about setting benchmark interest rates, such as the federal funds rate. By comparing the actual real interest rate to the estimated capital neutral rate, central bankers can gauge whether their policy stance is restrictive, neutral, or accommodative relative to the economy's underlying potential.
14
For instance, if the actual real interest rate is persistently below the neutral rate, it signals that the central bank is stimulating the economy, potentially leading to inflationary pressures if left unchecked. Conversely, if the real rate is above the neutral rate, it indicates a restrictive stance, which could slow economic activity and inflation. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) emphasizes that effective monetary policy must consider various factors beyond just the domestic goods market, including financial conditions and capital flows, when assessing the appropriate neutral rate for short-term policy. 13Understanding the capital neutral rate also helps financial market participants forecast long-term interest rates and assess the likely future path of monetary policy, impacting everything from bond yields to equity valuations.
Limitations and Criticisms
Despite its theoretical importance, the capital neutral rate is not without limitations and criticisms. The primary challenge is that it is an unobservable variable, meaning it cannot be directly measured. Economists rely on complex models and various assumptions to estimate it, leading to a wide range of estimates that can vary significantly depending on the model used, the data inputs, and the time period considered. 12This inherent imprecision makes it difficult for policymakers to use it as a precise, real-time guide for setting interest rates. As former Federal Reserve Chair Jay Powell noted, "These assessments of the values of the stars are imprecise and subject to further revision."
11
Critics also argue that over-reliance on the capital neutral rate can lead to misguided policy. Some heterodox economists contend that the concept is too abstract and can be used to justify policies that suppress employment or wages by targeting an "equilibrium" that may not reflect true full employment potential. 10Additionally, the capital neutral rate is often considered a long-run concept, while economic conditions can change rapidly in the short term due to factors like fiscal policy or unforeseen shocks, making a fixed reliance on a long-term neutral rate problematic for immediate policy adjustments. There is ongoing debate about how accurately it reflects the actual state of the economy and whether it truly captures all the forces influencing equilibrium, particularly in dynamic global markets.
Capital Neutral Rate vs. Market Rate of Interest
The capital neutral rate and the market rate of interest are distinct but related concepts, often causing confusion.
| Feature | Capital Neutral Rate | Market Rate of Interest |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | A theoretical real interest rate consistent with full employment and stable inflation. 9 | The actual interest rate observed in financial markets. 8 |
| Observability | Unobservable; must be estimated. | Directly observable and fluctuates daily. |
| Determinants | Underlying economic fundamentals (e.g., productivity, demographics, saving/investment balance). 7 | Supply and demand for loanable funds, central bank policy, inflation expectations. 6 |
| Role | A guide for central bank monetary policy. 5 | The actual cost of borrowing and return on lending. |
| Impact on Economy | Indicates the economy's potential, helps assess policy stance. | Directly influences consumption, investment, and capital flows. |
The key difference lies in their nature: the capital neutral rate is a hypothetical benchmark, a long-run equilibrium real interest rate that would keep the economy balanced, while the market rate of interest is the actual nominal or real interest rate that prevails in financial markets at any given time. Central banks strive to move the market rate towards the capital neutral rate to achieve their macroeconomic objectives of price stability and full employment. Deviations between the two signal whether monetary policy is stimulative or restrictive.
FAQs
What is the primary purpose of the capital neutral rate?
The primary purpose of the capital neutral rate is to serve as a theoretical benchmark for central banks to gauge whether their monetary policy stance—through setting interest rates—is stimulating, restraining, or neutral for the economy. It aims to achieve price stability and full employment.
###4 Is the capital neutral rate constant?
No, the capital neutral rate is not constant. It is a dynamic concept that can change over time in response to shifts in fundamental economic factors such as productivity growth, demographic changes, global saving and investment patterns, and technological advancements.
###3 How do central banks use the capital neutral rate?
Central banks use estimates of the capital neutral rate as a conceptual guide. If the actual real interest rate is above the estimated neutral rate, they may consider easing policy; if it's below, they might consider tightening. This helps them manage inflation and support economic growth.
###2 Why is the capital neutral rate difficult to measure?
The capital neutral rate is difficult to measure because it is a theoretical construct rather than a directly observable market rate. Its estimation relies on complex economic models that make various assumptions, leading to uncertainty and a range of potential values.
###1 What is the relationship between the capital neutral rate and inflation?
The capital neutral rate is the real interest rate consistent with stable inflation. If the actual market rate is held below the neutral rate for too long, it can lead to inflationary pressures as the economy overheats. Conversely, if the market rate is significantly above the neutral rate, it can lead to disinflation or even deflation.