What Is Charitable Bequests?
Charitable bequests are gifts of assets made to a nonprofit organization through a last will and testament or trust, becoming effective upon the donor's death. This practice falls under the broader financial category of estate planning, enabling individuals to support causes important to them while also potentially achieving specific financial and tax objectives. These testamentary gifts are a cornerstone of many philanthropic strategies, allowing individuals to leave a lasting legacy. A charitable bequest outlines specific instructions for distributing property, cash, or other valuable assets to designated charitable organizations.
History and Origin
The practice of leaving assets to charitable causes through a will has a long and rich history. In the American colonies, early immigrants continued traditions of charitable giving through bequests, with records indicating such gifts as early as the 1620s in Jamestown, Virginia. For instance, four Mayflower Pilgrims made gifts to their churches through written wills in the 1600s, and Harvard College, founded in 1636, notably received significant financial support from bequests in its early years, including a substantial gift from John Harvard himself in 1638. From 1636 to 1712, Harvard received three times as much money from bequests as from gifts made by living individuals.12,11
For centuries, charitable gift planning was not primarily driven by tax considerations. However, the landscape began to shift significantly with the introduction of federal income tax in 1913 and the estate tax in 1916. A tax deduction for gifts to qualified charities was subsequently introduced in 1917, fundamentally altering the financial incentives for making charitable bequests.10,9 This marked a turning point, integrating charitable giving more formally into the framework of personal finance and taxation.
Key Takeaways
- Charitable bequests are gifts made to charitable organizations through a will or trust, taking effect after the donor's death.
- They are a significant component of estate planning, allowing for a lasting philanthropic impact.
- Such bequests can offer considerable estate tax benefits, as the value of the bequeathed assets can often be deducted from the taxable estate.
- Donors maintain full control over their assets during their lifetime when planning a charitable bequest.
- Proper planning and legal drafting are crucial to ensure the charitable bequest is executed according to the donor's wishes and qualifies for applicable deductions.
Interpreting the Charitable Bequests
Interpreting a charitable bequest involves understanding the donor's intent, the specific assets designated, and the legal framework governing the transfer. When a charitable bequest is made, it typically specifies the recipient organization and the nature of the gift—whether it's a specific amount of money, a percentage of the estate, or particular appreciated assets like real estate or securities. The terms of the donor's will or trust dictate how the charitable bequest is to be distributed.
The executor of the estate is responsible for ensuring the charitable bequest is fulfilled as outlined. For a charitable organization, receiving a bequest often means understanding any restrictions placed on the use of the funds. While many bequests are unrestricted, allowing the charity to use the funds where most needed, others may be designated for specific programs, endowments, or capital projects. This careful interpretation ensures the donor's wishes are honored and the charity can properly manage and utilize the gift.
Hypothetical Example
Consider Maria, a retiree with a substantial estate, including a diverse portfolio of investments and real estate. She wants to support her alma mater and a local animal shelter after her passing. In her will, Maria includes several charitable bequests.
- Specific Bequest: She designates a specific bequest of $100,000 to "University of ABC for the establishment of a scholarship fund in the Department of History."
- Residuary Bequest: Maria also states that "20% of the residuary of my estate, after all specific bequests, debts, and taxes have been paid, shall be distributed to the Local Animal Shelter."
Upon Maria's death, her executor initiates the probate process. After settling all debts and distributing specific non-charitable gifts, the remaining estate is calculated. If the residuary estate totals $2,000,000, the Local Animal Shelter would receive $400,000 ($2,000,000 * 0.20). Both the $100,000 to University of ABC and the $400,000 to the Local Animal Shelter would generally qualify for an unlimited estate tax tax deduction against Maria's gross estate, reducing the overall taxable value of her estate.
Practical Applications
Charitable bequests are a widely utilized tool in philanthropy and estate planning, offering various practical applications for donors and recipient organizations alike. For donors, a key advantage is the ability to retain full control and use of their assets throughout their lifetime, with the gift taking effect only upon death. This flexibility allows individuals to ensure their financial security while still planning significant charitable contributions.
From a tax perspective, charitable bequests can be highly advantageous. Under federal law, there is generally an unlimited tax deduction for qualified charitable bequests against the value of an estate. This means the value of assets transferred to a qualified charity through a will or trust can be deducted from the gross estate, potentially reducing or even eliminating federal estate tax liability. For example, the IRS provides guidance on deductible charitable contributions, which includes bequests made by estates and trusts. T8his tax efficiency makes charitable bequests a powerful tool for reducing the taxable estate, especially for large estates that might otherwise face significant estate taxes.,
7
6Furthermore, charitable bequests provide clear instructions to an executor regarding asset distribution, which can streamline the probate process. These bequests can take various forms, including outright gifts of specific dollar amounts or assets, percentages of the total estate, or even residuary gifts (what remains after all other expenses and bequests are fulfilled). Some donors may also choose to establish charitable vehicles like a donor-advised fund through a bequest, creating an ongoing means of charitable support.,
5
4## Limitations and Criticisms
While charitable bequests offer significant benefits, they also come with certain limitations and potential challenges. One primary limitation is that, unlike some other planned giving strategies, a charitable bequest provides no income tax deduction for the donor during their lifetime. The tax benefit is primarily realized as an estate tax deduction upon death.
Complexity in estate administration can also pose a limitation. If a will or trust is not drafted with sufficient clarity, disputes among beneficiaries or with the charitable organization can arise, potentially delaying or even jeopardizing the charitable bequest. For instance, a case highlighted by the Iowa State University Center for Agricultural Law and Taxation demonstrated how poor planning and unforeseen litigation could lead to an estate losing its intended charitable deduction because the funds were not "permanently set aside" as required by tax law due to ongoing disputes.
3Moreover, the irrevocable nature of a properly executed will or trust clause containing a charitable bequest means that once finalized, altering the provision typically requires formal amendments to the estate plan. While wills can be updated, changes may necessitate legal review, adding to the complexity and cost. For charitable organizations, there can be uncertainty regarding the timing and exact amount of a bequest until the estate is settled, which can impact their financial planning. Additionally, state laws, such as those related to the Uniform Probate Code, often require notice to the state's Attorney General when a charitable interest is involved, adding a layer of oversight and potential complexity to the administration of estates with charitable bequests.,
2
1## Charitable Bequests vs. Charitable Trusts
While both charitable bequests and charitable trusts are tools for philanthropic giving within estate planning, they differ significantly in their structure, timing, and control.
A charitable bequest is a direct gift made through a will or revocable trust that takes effect only after the donor's death. The donor retains full control over their assets during their lifetime and can modify the bequest at any time. The primary tax benefit is an estate tax deduction for the value of the gift.
In contrast, a charitable trust is a separate legal entity established during the donor's lifetime or upon their death. There are two main types:
- A charitable remainder trust (CRT) pays income to the donor or other non-charitable beneficiaries for a specified term or their lifetime, with the remaining assets going to charity afterward.
- A charitable lead trust (CLT) pays income to a charity for a specified period, after which the remaining assets revert to the donor or other non-charitable beneficiaries.
Charitable trusts often provide immediate income tax deductions for the donor (for CRTs, on the remainder interest; for CLTs, on the lead interest) and can offer strategies to avoid capital gains tax on appreciated assets transferred into the trust. However, most charitable trusts are irrevocable once established, meaning the donor relinquishes control over the assets. The choice between a charitable bequest and a charitable trust depends on the donor's financial goals, desired level of control, and timing of tax benefits.
FAQs
Q: Can I change my mind about a charitable bequest?
A: Yes, if your charitable bequest is made through a will or a revocable trust, you can typically modify or revoke it at any time during your lifetime, as long as you are of sound mind. It requires a formal amendment (codicil for a will) or restatement of the document.
Q: Do charitable bequests reduce estate taxes?
A: Yes, generally, the full value of a charitable bequest made to a qualified charitable organization can be deducted from your taxable estate, which can significantly reduce or even eliminate federal and state estate tax liabilities.
Q: What types of assets can I include in a charitable bequest?
A: You can bequeath a wide variety of assets, including cash, publicly traded securities, real estate, personal property, and even interests in retirement accounts or life insurance policies. The specific type of asset can sometimes have different tax implications for your estate.
Q: What happens if the charity I named no longer exists?
A: If the designated charity no longer exists at the time of your passing, the courts may apply a legal doctrine called "cy pres" (meaning "as near as possible"). This doctrine allows the court to direct the gift to another charity with a similar purpose to your original intent, ensuring your philanthropy is still realized.
Q: Do I need a lawyer to make a charitable bequest?
A: While simple charitable bequests can be straightforward, it is highly recommended to consult with an attorney specializing in estate planning. A legal professional can ensure your will or trust is properly drafted, complies with all relevant state laws, and maximizes potential tax benefits, while also accounting for any complex situations or potential disputes.