Claims management: Meaning, Criticisms & Real-World Uses

What Is Claims Management?

Claims management is the comprehensive process by which insurance companies receive, investigate, evaluate, negotiate, and ultimately settle or deny claims filed by policyholders. It is a critical component of insurance operations within the broader financial services industry, directly impacting an insurer's financial health, reputation, and relationship with its customers. Effective claims management balances the need to honor legitimate claims according to the terms of an insurance policy with the responsibility to detect and prevent fraud. The process typically begins when a policyholder reports an incident that may be covered by their policy and concludes with a settlement or formal denial of the claim.

History and Origin

The practice of managing insurance claims has evolved significantly since the earliest forms of insurance. In the nascent days of marine and fire insurance, claims handling was often an informal, often subjective process, relying heavily on direct negotiation between the insured and the insurer. As the insurance industry matured and policies became more complex, particularly in the 19th and early 20th centuries, a more structured approach became necessary to ensure fairness, efficiency, and consistency.

A pivotal development in the standardization of claims management in the United States was the creation of the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act (UCSPA). This model legislation was developed by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), a U.S. standard-setting and regulatory support organization for state insurance regulators. The NAIC separated issues regarding unfair claims settlement practices into a standalone act in June 1990, distinct from its broader Unfair Trade Practices Act. The purpose of this Act is to establish standards for the investigation and disposition of claims, defining specific practices considered unfair, such as misrepresenting facts or unreasonably delaying investigations and payments. Most states have adopted some form of unfair claims practice legislation modeled after the NAIC's UCSPA, which mandates that claims be handled fairly and that there be clear communication between the insurer and the insured.¹⁰, ¹¹, ¹², ¹³ These regulations were crucial in establishing a framework for equitable claims handling, shifting the emphasis from purely adversarial negotiations to a more regulated, consumer-protective process.

Key Takeaways

Claims management is the entire process of handling an insurance claim, from initial report to final resolution.
It involves investigation, evaluation, negotiation, and payment or denial of claims.
Effective claims management is vital for an insurer's financial stability, customer satisfaction, and reputation.
Regulations like the NAIC's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act aim to ensure fair and prompt claims handling.
Technology, particularly data analytics and artificial intelligence, is increasingly transforming claims management processes.

Interpreting the Claims Management Process

Interpreting the effectiveness of claims management often involves analyzing various metrics and regulatory adherence. For an insurer, efficient claims management is measured by factors such as the average time to close a claim, the accuracy of underwriting decisions (i.e., whether claims are consistent with initial risk assessments), and the ratio of justified claims to overall claims received. A high volume of justified complaints against an insurer, as tracked by state regulatory bodies like the California Department of Insurance, can indicate systemic issues in claims handling.⁷, ⁸, ⁹

From a policyholder's perspective, successful claims management means a timely, transparent, and fair resolution of their claim, consistent with the terms of their policy and the premium paid. Understanding the steps involved in claims management helps policyholders navigate the process and ensures their rights are protected.

Hypothetical Example

Consider Sarah, who has a homeowner's insurance policy. A severe hailstorm damages her roof, and she decides to file a claim.

Notification: Sarah calls her insurance company to report the damage. This initiates the claims management process.
Investigation: The insurer assigns a claims adjuster. The adjuster inspects the roof, assesses the damage, and gathers evidence, such as photos and repair estimates. The adjuster confirms the damage is covered under Sarah's policy, noting that the deductible applies.
Evaluation: The adjuster reviews the evidence, policy terms, and repair costs. They determine the extent of the insurer's liability, taking into account the property's depreciation and Sarah's deductible.
Negotiation/Settlement: The adjuster presents a proposed settlement amount to Sarah. After reviewing it, Sarah agrees, and the insurer processes the payment, allowing her to have her roof repaired.
Closure: Once the payment is made, the claim is officially closed. The entire process, from reporting to closure, falls under claims management.

Practical Applications

Claims management is fundamental to the insurance industry, touching upon numerous aspects of its operations and external interactions.

Financial Stability: For insurers, efficient claims management directly impacts profitability. Accurately assessing and paying out claims minimizes unnecessary expenditures, while effectively mitigating fraudulent claims protects the company's financial reserves.
Customer Experience: The claims process is often the primary interaction a policyholder has with their insurer after purchasing a policy. A smooth, transparent, and fair claims experience is crucial for customer retention and overall satisfaction.
Risk Management: Insights gained from claims data inform an insurer's risk management strategies and actuarial science models. This data helps refine pricing, adjust underwriting guidelines, and develop new insurance products.
Compliance and Regulation: Claims management operations must adhere to a complex web of state and federal regulations designed to protect consumers. Regulatory bodies monitor insurers' claims practices to ensure fairness and compliance. The California Department of Insurance, for example, publishes consumer complaint data, allowing the public to see how insurance companies rank based on justified complaints per 100,000 policies.⁵, ⁶
Technological Advancement: The claims management landscape is increasingly being reshaped by technology. Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning are being integrated to automate routine tasks, analyze large datasets for fraud detection, and even assist in damage assessment through image recognition. Integrating edge hardware, companies could deploy models that analyze photos of damaged products to more accurately process insurance claims.⁴ In the second quarter of 2025, insurers in the UK paid out £1.6 billion in property claims, with adverse weather being a significant driver.
³

Limitations and Criticisms

While claims management aims for fair and efficient resolutions, the process is not without its limitations and faces various criticisms. A significant concern revolves around "unfair claims practices," where insurers may attempt to delay, avoid, or reduce payouts on legitimate claims. These practices, which are often illegal, can include misrepresenting policy provisions, failing to promptly investigate, or denying claims without reasonable investigation or explanation. ²Many states have enacted laws, often modeled after the NAIC's UCSPA, to protect insured parties from such behavior.
¹
Another limitation can be the inherent conflict of interest: insurers aim to minimize payouts while policyholders seek full indemnity. This can lead to disputes, lengthy negotiations, and, in some cases, litigation. The complexity of certain claims, particularly those involving intricate damage assessment or multiple parties, can also prolong the process and lead to dissatisfaction. Furthermore, the reliance on historical data for reinsurance and reserving can sometimes lead to premiums that do not fully reflect current market conditions or climate risks, potentially exacerbating claims pressure during widespread events.

Claims Management vs. Loss Adjusting

Claims management encompasses the entire administrative and operational framework an insurance company employs to handle a claim from start to finish. This includes receiving the initial notification, conducting investigations, evaluating policy coverage, negotiating a settlement, and processing payments. It involves various departments and functions within the insurance organization, from customer service to legal and compliance.

In contrast, loss adjusting is a specific, specialized function within the broader claims management process. A loss adjuster, or claims adjuster, is the professional responsible for investigating the claim on-site, assessing the damage or loss, determining the cause, and verifying the policy's applicability. They gather evidence, interview witnesses, and compile a report that informs the insurer's decision on the claim. While a loss adjuster plays a crucial role in gathering the necessary information, they typically do not make the final decision on the claim payout or manage the administrative aspects of the claim's lifecycle.

FAQs

What is the primary goal of claims management?

The primary goal of claims management is to process insurance claims efficiently and fairly, ensuring that legitimate claims are paid according to the terms of the insurance policy while mitigating fraud and managing costs for the insurer.

Who is involved in the claims management process?

Key parties involved typically include the policyholder (the claimant), the insurance company (represented by claims adjusters, examiners, and administrative staff), and sometimes third-party service providers like independent adjusters, restoration companies, or legal counsel.

How does technology impact claims management?

Technology, particularly data analytics and artificial intelligence, significantly impacts claims management by automating routine tasks, enhancing fraud detection, speeding up assessment processes, and improving overall efficiency and accuracy. This can lead to faster claim resolutions and a better customer experience.

What are common challenges in claims management?

Common challenges include preventing and detecting fraudulent claims, ensuring consistent and fair claim handling across a large volume of claims, managing customer expectations, adhering to complex regulatory requirements, and adapting to new types of claims (e.g., cyber incidents) or increased frequency of natural disaster claims.