Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to C Definitions

Coinsurance clause

What Is Coinsurance Clause?

A coinsurance clause is a provision commonly found in property insurance policies, which dictates that a policyholder must insure their property for a specific percentage of its total value to receive full compensation for a partial loss. This mechanism belongs to the broader category of insurance finance and is designed to promote adequate coverage and ensure a fair distribution of risk between the insured and the insurer. If the insured property is not covered up to the required percentage, typically 80% to 100% of its replacement cost, the policyholder may face a penalty, meaning they become a "co-insurer" for a portion of any covered loss.36, 37

History and Origin

The concept of coinsurance in property insurance emerged to address the issue of underinsurance, particularly in scenarios where policyholders might insure their property for only a fraction of its true value, hoping to cover only minor losses while paying lower premiums. Insurers introduced the coinsurance clause to ensure that policyholders carried sufficient coverage commensurate with the value of the assets being protected. This allowed for a more equitable assessment of risk and the collection of appropriate premiums. An early and widely recognized standard, the "New York Standard Coinsurance Clause," established the common 80% coinsurance provision for fire or water damage policies, requiring the insured to cover the remaining portion of risk if coverage fell short.35

Key Takeaways

  • A coinsurance clause requires property to be insured for a specified percentage of its value, usually 80% to 100%.34
  • It ensures that policyholders maintain adequate insurance coverage and share the risk with the insurer.33
  • Failure to meet the coinsurance requirement can result in a significant financial penalty, reducing the payout for a claim.31, 32
  • The clause is primarily found in property insurance policies, including homeowners insurance and commercial property insurance.29, 30
  • The calculation involves comparing the amount of insurance carried to the amount required by the clause at the time of loss.

Formula and Calculation

When a coinsurance clause is in effect and the property is underinsured, a specific formula is used to determine the payout for a loss. This formula effectively penalizes the policyholder for not meeting the required coverage percentage.

The formula for calculating the amount paid by the insurer is:

Amount Paid by Insurer=(Amount of Insurance CarriedAmount of Insurance Required)×Amount of Loss−Deductible\text{Amount Paid by Insurer} = \left( \frac{\text{Amount of Insurance Carried}}{\text{Amount of Insurance Required}} \right) \times \text{Amount of Loss} - \text{Deductible}

Where:

  • Amount of Insurance Carried: The actual amount of insurance the policyholder purchased.
  • Amount of Insurance Required: The replacement cost or actual cash value of the property multiplied by the coinsurance percentage (e.g., 80% of $1,000,000 if the coinsurance clause is 80% and the property value is $1,000,000). This figure is also referred to as the insured value.
  • Amount of Loss: The total cost of the damage or loss sustained.
  • Deductible: The deductible amount specified in the policy, which is the initial out-of-pocket amount the policyholder must pay.27, 28

Interpreting the Coinsurance Clause

Interpreting the coinsurance clause is crucial for any policyholder to understand their potential financial responsibility in the event of a loss. The clause essentially means that the insurer expects the property to be insured for a certain percentage of its total value. If this expectation is not met, the policyholder becomes a "co-insurer" for the difference. For instance, if a policy has an 80% coinsurance clause and the property's replacement cost is $500,000, the required coverage is $400,000. If the policyholder only has $300,000 in coverage, they are underinsured. When a loss occurs, the insurer will only pay a proportionate amount of the loss, based on the ratio of the actual coverage to the required coverage, after the deductible is applied. This mechanism encourages accurate property valuation and coverage.25, 26

Hypothetical Example

Consider a commercial building with a replacement cost of $1,000,000. The commercial property insurance policy includes an 80% coinsurance clause and a $5,000 deductible.

  1. Calculate Required Insurance:
    Required Insurance = Property Value × Coinsurance Percentage
    Required Insurance = $1,000,000 × 0.80 = $800,000

  2. Scenario A: Adequately Insured
    Assume the policyholder carries $800,000 in insurance. A fire causes $100,000 in damage.
    Amount Paid by Insurer = ($800,000 / $800,000) × $100,000 - $5,000 = $100,000 - $5,000 = $95,000.
    In this case, the policyholder receives full compensation for the loss, less the deductible.

  3. Scenario B: Underinsured
    Assume the policyholder carries only $600,000 in insurance. A fire causes $100,000 in damage.
    Amount Paid by Insurer = ($600,000 / $800,000) × $100,000 - $5,000
    Amount Paid by Insurer = (0.75) × $100,000 - $5,000
    Amount Paid by Insurer = $75,000 - $5,000 = $70,000.
    In this scenario, because the policyholder was underinsured, they only receive $70,000, even though the loss was $100,000. The policyholder bears the remaining $30,000 of the loss. This illustrates the financial penalty for not meeting the coinsurance requirement.

23, 24Practical Applications

The coinsurance clause is a fundamental aspect of many property insurance policies, influencing how claims are settled for both individuals and businesses. It appears in various forms of property insurance, including homeowners, commercial property, and sometimes even inland marine policies. Its 22primary application is to encourage policyholders to adequately insure their assets, thereby spreading risk effectively across the insured pool. For businesses, properly managing the coinsurance clause is a key component of risk management. Failure to ensure sufficient coverage can lead to significant out-of-pocket expenses for businesses following a loss, potentially hindering their recovery. Regu20, 21lators and insurers emphasize the importance of understanding this clause to avoid unexpected financial burdens.

19Limitations and Criticisms

While intended to encourage adequate coverage and fair premium calculation, the coinsurance clause has its limitations and can be a source of frustration for policyholders. One common criticism is that it places the burden of accurate and up-to-date property valuation on the insured, which can be challenging due to fluctuating market conditions, construction costs, and inflation. If a18 property's value increases over time and the insured does not adjust their coverage accordingly, they could inadvertently become underinsured and face a coinsurance penalty, even if they believed they had sufficient coverage.

Ano17ther limitation is the potential for unexpected financial hardship. A policyholder who experiences a partial loss might be surprised to find their claim payout significantly reduced due to the coinsurance penalty, leading to a shortfall in funds needed for repairs or rebuilding. Some16 argue that the complexity of the clause can make it difficult for non-experts to fully grasp its implications until a loss occurs. For example, a court case involving "coinsurance" explained that such clauses are "designed to compel the insured...to carry insurance on the risk" and that recovery is "reduced in proportion to the value that was uninsured." To m15itigate these issues, some policies offer an "agreed value" endorsement, which can waive the coinsurance clause by having the insurer and insured agree on a specific property value, ensuring the clause does not apply to a loss.

13, 14Coinsurance Clause vs. Underinsurance

While closely related, a coinsurance clause and underinsurance are distinct concepts within the realm of insurance. Underinsurance refers to the situation where an insured property's coverage amount is less than its actual value or replacement cost. This can happen for various reasons, such as undervaluing assets, failing to update policies to reflect current market conditions, or intentionally seeking lower premiums.

A c11, 12oinsurance clause, on the other hand, is a provision within an insurance policy that addresses underinsurance. It is the contractual mechanism by which an insurer enforces a minimum coverage requirement. If underinsurance exists and a coinsurance clause is present in the policy, it triggers a penalty that reduces the amount the insurer will pay for a partial loss. Therefore, underinsurance is the condition of having inadequate coverage, while the coinsurance clause is the specific policy term that determines the financial consequence of that condition for partial losses.

10FAQs

What is the purpose of a coinsurance clause?

The primary purpose of a coinsurance clause in property insurance is to encourage policyholders to insure their property for a sufficient percentage of its true value. This ensures that the insurer collects adequate premiums for the risk undertaken and that the policyholder shares in the financial responsibility if they choose to underinsure.

###8, 9 How does a coinsurance clause affect my claim?

If your property is underinsured according to the coinsurance clause, your claim payout for a partial loss will be reduced proportionally. This means you will receive less than the full amount of your loss (minus your deductible), and you will be responsible for covering the difference out-of-pocket.

###7 Is a coinsurance clause the same as a deductible or copay?

No. A coinsurance clause in property insurance requires you to insure your property for a certain percentage of its value. If you don't, you share a portion of any partial loss. A deductible is a fixed amount you pay out-of-pocket before your insurance coverage begins. A copay (or copayment) is a fixed fee you pay for a specific service, commonly found in health insurance. While both coinsurance (in the health context) and copays are cost-sharing mechanisms, the property insurance coinsurance clause operates differently by affecting the overall claim payout based on coverage adequacy.

###6 What happens if I have a total loss with a coinsurance clause?

In the event of a total loss, the coinsurance clause typically does not apply in the same way it does for partial losses. If you have a total loss, the insurer will usually pay up to the policy limits you purchased, regardless of whether you met the coinsurance percentage. However, if your policy limits were less than the total value of the property, you would still be underinsured and would not receive the full amount needed to rebuild.

###5 Can a coinsurance clause be waived?

In some cases, a coinsurance clause can be waived through a policy endorsement, often referred to as an "agreed value" endorsement. This means the insurer and policyholder agree on the value of the property upfront, and as long as the property is insured for that agreed value, the coinsurance clause will not apply to losses. This can provide greater certainty for the policyholder regarding their claim settlement.

###3, 4 How can I avoid a coinsurance penalty?

To avoid a coinsurance penalty, ensure your insurance coverage is at or above the percentage required by your policy's coinsurance clause, based on your property's current replacement cost or actual cash value. Regularly review and update your policy limits to account for increases in property value, construction costs, and inflation. Consulting with an insurance broker can help ensure proper valuation and adequate coverage.

1, 2Additional Resources

  • The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) provides resources on insurance regulations and consumer protection. https://www.naic.org/
  • The Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) offers consumer-friendly information on various insurance topics, including property insurance. https://www.iii.org/
  • For a detailed look at how coinsurance impacts commercial property, you can explore guides from industry associations like NAIOP, the Commercial Real Estate Development Association. https://www.naiop.org/
  • The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) offers insights into various types of property insurance, including flood insurance, which may also contain coinsurance provisions. https://www.fema.gov/

LINK_POOL