Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to C Definitions

Commercial mortgage backed security

Commercial Mortgage-Backed Security

A commercial mortgage-backed security (CMBS) is a type of mortgage-backed security representing investments in commercial real estate loans. These are a component of the broader category of fixed income securities and are structured through a process called securitization. In a CMBS transaction, various commercial mortgage loans are pooled together and then divided into different classes, known as tranches, each with varying levels of risk and return. Investors purchase these securities, receiving payments of principal and interest generated by the underlying commercial properties, such as office buildings, retail spaces, hotels, and industrial facilities.58, 59, 60

History and Origin

The commercial mortgage-backed security market gained prominence in the U.S. following the savings and loan crisis of the late 1980s and early 1990s. At that time, the Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC) played a significant role by securitizing distressed assets, including commercial mortgages, to provide much-needed liquidity to the illiquid debt markets.55, 56, 57 This innovative approach, which transformed traditional balance sheet lending by introducing an alternative funding source tied to publicly traded securities, fundamentally changed the landscape for commercial mortgages.53, 54

The growth of CMBS issuance continued into the 2000s, reaching a peak in 2007 before experiencing a sharp decline during the 2008 financial crisis. Issuance fell from $229 billion in 2007 to just $3 billion in 2009, effectively halting the market.52 This disruption led to a reevaluation of the CMBS structure, particularly concerning issues like loan underwriting standards and potential incentive conflicts among market participants.50, 51 While the market has seen periods of recovery, new regulations and a collective memory of past market disruptions continue to shape its evolution.48, 49

Key Takeaways

  • CMBS are debt securities backed by a pool of mortgages on commercial properties.46, 47
  • They are structured into various tranches, each carrying a different level of credit risk and offering a corresponding yield.44, 45
  • CMBS provide investors an indirect way to gain exposure to the commercial real estate market.43
  • Payments to CMBS investors are derived from the income generated by the underlying commercial properties.42
  • Compared to direct real estate investments, CMBS can offer more liquidity as they are traded on secondary markets.41

Interpreting the Commercial Mortgage-Backed Security

Interpreting a commercial mortgage-backed security involves understanding the composition of the underlying loan pool, the structural characteristics of the security, and the prevailing market conditions for commercial real estate. Investors often analyze factors such as the property types (e.g., office, retail, multifamily, industrial), geographic diversification, tenant quality, and the loan-to-value (LTV) ratios of the underlying mortgages.39, 40

The credit quality of a CMBS is primarily assessed by its credit rating. Senior tranches typically receive higher ratings (e.g., AAA) because they are first in line for payments and are better protected from losses in the event of borrower default.38 Conversely, junior or subordinate tranches carry lower ratings and greater risk but offer higher potential yields to compensate for this increased exposure to losses.35, 36, 37 Understanding the servicer structure—including master servicers and special servicers who handle distressed loans—is also crucial for investors to assess how potential issues in the underlying loan pool will be managed.

##34 Hypothetical Example

Imagine a lender has originated five commercial mortgages:

  1. A $20 million loan on an office building.
  2. A $15 million loan on a retail shopping center.
  3. A $10 million loan on an industrial warehouse.
  4. A $5 million loan on a hotel.
  5. A $25 million loan on a multi-family apartment complex.

Instead of holding these loans on its balance sheet, the lender decides to pool them together, creating a $75 million pool of commercial mortgages. This pool is then transferred to a special purpose entity (SPE), which issues a commercial mortgage-backed security.

The SPE then divides this CMBS into three tranches:

  • Senior Tranche (Class A): $50 million with a high credit rating and lower yield.
  • Mezzanine Tranche (Class B): $15 million with a moderate credit rating and higher yield.
  • Junior Tranche (Class C): $10 million with a lower credit rating and the highest yield, absorbing first losses.

Investors purchase bonds from these tranches. The payments they receive originate from the monthly mortgage payments made by the borrowers on the underlying properties. If, for instance, the hotel loan defaults, the losses would first impact the junior tranche investors, then the mezzanine, and finally the senior tranche, until their investment is fully impaired.

Practical Applications

Commercial mortgage-backed securities are widely used in financial markets, primarily serving as investment vehicles and tools for capital management. For originators of commercial mortgages, CMBS provide a means to sell loans off their balance sheets, freeing up capital to issue new loans and increase lending capacity. Thi33s process enhances liquidity in the commercial real estate lending market.

In32vestors, including institutional funds, insurance companies, and pension funds, use CMBS to diversify their portfolios and gain exposure to the commercial property sector without directly owning properties. The31 segmented nature of CMBS into various tranches allows investors to select securities that align with their specific risk and return preferences.

CM29, 30BS also feature prominently in structured finance and can be part of broader asset-backed securities (ABS) portfolios. Regulators, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), oversee the issuance and trading of CMBS to ensure transparency and investor protection. Add28itionally, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) monitors commercial real estate lending practices by national banks and federal savings associations, including those related to the origination of loans that may become part of CMBS pools. Thi26, 27s regulatory oversight helps maintain stability in the market for these complex instruments.

##25 Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their benefits, commercial mortgage-backed securities come with notable limitations and criticisms. One significant concern is their inherent complexity. The layered structure of CMBS, with multiple tranches and diverse underlying loan pools, can make them challenging for investors to analyze thoroughly. Thi24s complexity can obscure the true level of credit risk associated with lower-rated tranches.

An23other criticism revolves around potential conflicts of interest among the various parties involved in the securitization process, including loan originators, issuers, servicers, and credit rating agencies. His22torically, these misalignments of incentives have been cited as contributing factors to market instability, particularly during the 2008 financial crisis. Reg20, 21ulatory responses, such as the Dodd-Frank Act, introduced "risk retention" rules, requiring issuers to retain a portion of the credit risk to better align their interests with investors.

CM18, 19BS also carry prepayment risk, though often less than residential mortgage-backed securities due to common lockout provisions or penalties in commercial mortgages. How17ever, economic downturns or shifts in commercial real estate demand can lead to increased loan delinquencies and potential losses for CMBS investors, particularly those holding subordinate tranches. For15, 16 example, the struggles in the office sector in 2023 saw delinquency rates increase, highlighting the sensitivity of CMBS to specific property market trends.

##14 Commercial Mortgage-Backed Security vs. Residential Mortgage-Backed Security

Commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) and residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) are both types of mortgage-backed security that derive their value from pools of mortgage loans, but they differ fundamentally in the type of underlying collateral. CMBS are backed by mortgages on income-generating commercial properties like office buildings, shopping centers, industrial facilities, and hotels. In 13contrast, RMBS are collateralized by residential mortgages, such as those on single-family homes or apartment complexes primarily used for residential purposes.

Th11, 12e differing nature of their collateral leads to distinct risk profiles and repayment structures. Commercial mortgages often feature fixed terms and include prepayment penalties or lockout periods, which can reduce prepayment risk for CMBS investors compared to RMBS. Add10itionally, the analysis of CMBS typically involves assessing property-specific cash flows, tenant stability, and the overall health of the commercial real estate market. RMBS analysis, conversely, focuses more on borrower credit scores, housing market trends, and general consumer economic conditions. CMBS tend to be more complex and potentially more volatile than RMBS due to the unique characteristics and localized nature of commercial property assets.

FAQs

What types of properties back CMBS?

Commercial mortgage-backed securities are backed by mortgages on income-generating commercial real estate properties. This can include a wide range of asset types such as office buildings, retail spaces, industrial warehouses, hotels, and multi-family apartment buildings.

##8, 9# How do CMBS pay investors?
Investors in commercial mortgage-backed securities receive payments of principal and interest that are generated by the monthly mortgage payments from the borrowers of the underlying commercial loans. These cash flows are distributed to the various tranches of the CMBS according to their seniority.

##7# What is the primary risk of investing in CMBS?
The primary risk associated with commercial mortgage-backed securities is credit risk, which is the possibility that borrowers on the underlying commercial mortgages may default on their loan payments. This risk is mitigated through the layered structure of tranches and assessed by credit rating agencies. Inv6estors also face risks related to market volatility in the commercial real estate sector.

##5# Are CMBS regulated?
Yes, commercial mortgage-backed securities are regulated. In the U.S., the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) oversees their issuance and trading, requiring disclosures and transparency. Add4itionally, regulations like those stemming from the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act impose requirements such as risk retention rules on CMBS issuers.

##3# How do CMBS provide diversification?
CMBS offer diversification benefits by pooling multiple commercial mortgage loans, which can include a variety of property types and geographic locations. This pooling helps to reduce the impact of a single loan default on the overall security. For investors, CMBS provide a unique way to gain exposure to the commercial real estate market, which historically has shown relatively low correlation with other asset classes like traditional stocks and bonds.
1, 2