Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to C Definitions

Community reinvestment act cra

What Is Community Reinvestment Act (CRA)?

The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) is a landmark U.S. federal law enacted in 1977 that encourages commercial banks and savings associations to help meet the credit needs of the communities in which they are chartered, including low- and moderate-income (LMI) neighborhoods. This act falls under the broader category of banking regulation, aiming to address historical patterns of disinvestment in certain areas. The CRA seeks to ensure that financial institutions fulfill their affirmative obligation to serve all segments of their communities, consistent with safe and sound banking operations.

History and Origin

The Community Reinvestment Act emerged from a period of growing concern over urban decay and a pervasive lack of investment in low- and moderate-income communities. Prior to the CRA, practices like "redlining," where lenders would deny or limit financial services to residents of specific geographic areas, often based on race or income, were prevalent. Although the Fair Housing Act of 1968 had outlawed racial discrimination in lending, many community groups and policymakers believed that redlining persisted, hindering economic development in these neighborhoods.26, 27

Reformers argued that since banks benefited from federal deposit insurance, they had a reciprocal obligation to serve the credit needs of their entire community. This principle harked back to the Banking Act of 1935, which considered "the convenience and needs of the community to be served by the bank" as a factor for deposit insurance.25 After extensive debate, President Jimmy Carter signed the CRA into law in October 1977. Its immediate impact was to pressure lenders to seriously assess the credit needs of LMI communities and work towards ending redlining.23, 24 Federal banking agencies, including the Federal Reserve, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), are responsible for implementing the CRA and reviewing banks' compliance.21, 22 Over the years, the regulations implementing the CRA have been updated to reflect changes in the financial sector, with significant revisions in 1995 to focus more on performance, and further adjustments in 2005.19, 20

Key Takeaways

  • The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) encourages banks to meet the credit needs of all communities they serve, especially low- and moderate-income areas.
  • It was enacted in 1977 to combat historical disinvestment and practices like redlining.
  • Federal banking regulators assess a bank's CRA performance through various tests, including lending, investment, and service.
  • A bank's CRA rating can influence regulatory approvals for mergers and other applications.
  • The CRA promotes community development through activities like affordable housing, small business financing, and community services.

Interpreting the CRA

Interpreting the Community Reinvestment Act involves understanding how regulatory bodies assess a financial institution's compliance and performance. Regulators evaluate a bank's record of helping to meet the credit needs of its entire community, with a particular focus on low- and moderate-income neighborhoods. This assessment is based on three performance categories:

  • Lending Test: Evaluates a bank's home mortgage, small business, small farm, and consumer lending within its assessment areas, including the geographic distribution of those loans and lending to borrowers of different income levels. This connects to mortgage lending and small business loans.
  • Investment Test: Assesses the bank's qualified investments that benefit the community, such as investments in affordable housing projects or economic development initiatives.
  • Service Test: Examines the availability and accessibility of a bank's retail banking services and the extent of its community development services.

Banks are assigned a CRA rating (Outstanding, Satisfactory, Needs to Improve, or Substantial Noncompliance). This rating is publicly disclosed and taken into account by regulators when considering applications for mergers, acquisitions, or branch expansions.17, 18 The focus is on performance rather than just process, encouraging banks to actively engage in community development efforts.16

Hypothetical Example

Imagine "Community First Bank," a medium-sized financial institution operating in a metropolitan area. To demonstrate its commitment under the Community Reinvestment Act, Community First Bank undertakes several initiatives:

  1. Affordable Housing Loans: The bank dedicates 20% of its annual residential mortgage originations to properties located in designated low- and moderate-income (LMI) census tracts within its assessment area. They also offer flexible underwriting standards for eligible borrowers in these areas to improve access to credit.
  2. Small Business Lending Program: Community First Bank launches a special loan program for small businesses located in distressed or underserved LMI neighborhoods. This includes offering microloans with favorable terms and providing financial literacy workshops to local entrepreneurs.
  3. Community Development Investment: The bank invests $5 million in a local non-profit organization that is developing a mixed-use affordable housing and retail complex in an LMI area. This investment counts as a qualified community development investment under CRA guidelines.
  4. Financial Education Services: Bank employees volunteer their time to conduct free financial education seminars at local community centers, covering topics like budgeting, credit repair, and homeownership preparation.

During its CRA examination, regulators would review the volume and distribution of Community First Bank's lending, the impact of its investments, and the accessibility and effectiveness of its services in meeting the credit needs of its entire community, particularly LMI segments.

Practical Applications

The Community Reinvestment Act has broad practical applications across the financial landscape, influencing how banks operate and interact with their communities. Its primary role is in shaping lending practices and investment decisions of regulated financial institutions.

  • Mortgage and Small Business Lending: Banks actively seek to originate mortgages and small business loans in low- and moderate-income areas to fulfill their CRA obligations. This can lead to increased homeownership and economic activity in these neighborhoods.
  • Community Development Financing: The CRA encourages banks to make qualified investments in projects that benefit LMI communities, such as affordable housing, revitalization efforts, and facilities that provide essential community services like childcare or healthcare.
  • Financial Inclusion: The act promotes financial inclusion by encouraging banks to offer accessible banking services, including checking accounts, savings accounts, and financial literacy programs, to underserved populations.
  • Regulatory Scrutiny for Mergers: Banks considering mergers or acquisitions face heightened regulatory scrutiny regarding their past CRA performance. A poor CRA rating can significantly hinder or even prevent approval of such transactions, making CRA compliance a strategic imperative for financial institutions.14, 15
  • Targeted Programs: Many banks develop specific programs and initiatives tailored to address identified credit needs in their assessment areas, often in collaboration with local community organizations. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York provides resources and guidance on activities that qualify for CRA credit.13

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its intentions, the Community Reinvestment Act has faced various limitations and criticisms since its inception. One recurring critique centers on its effectiveness in truly addressing the systemic issues it was designed to tackle. Some argue that while the CRA has encouraged lending in low- and moderate-income areas, it hasn't always led to substantial long-term economic development or fully eliminated disparities in financial services.11, 12

Critics also point to the complexity of CRA regulations and the potential for banks to engage in "CRA-driven" activities that fulfill technical requirements without necessarily achieving maximum community impact. Measuring a bank's true commitment and the actual benefits to a community can be challenging. There have also been concerns about the geographic delineation of "assessment areas," which may not always capture the full scope of a bank's lending activities, particularly with the rise of online banking and a shift away from traditional brick-and-mortar branches.10

Furthermore, the enforcement and interpretation of the CRA have been subject to change and debate among the various regulatory agencies. Recent attempts to modernize the CRA regulations in 2023 faced litigation, leading to a proposal in 2025 to rescind those changes and revert to earlier frameworks, highlighting ongoing challenges in adapting the act to an evolving financial landscape.7, 8, 9 This regulatory flux can create uncertainty for bank management and community organizations alike.

CRA vs. Fair Housing Act

While both the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) and the Fair Housing Act aim to promote equitable access to housing and credit, they differ in their scope and approach.

The Fair Housing Act (FHA), enacted in 1968, is a civil rights law that prohibits discrimination in the sale, rental, and financing of housing based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin. Its focus is on preventing discriminatory practices.

In contrast, the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), enacted in 1977, is an affirmative obligation placed on regulated financial institutions. It requires banks to proactively demonstrate that they are meeting the credit needs of the entire communities they serve, including low- and moderate-income neighborhoods, consistent with safe and sound operations. Rather than simply prohibiting discrimination, the CRA encourages positive action and reinvestment. The FHA focuses on "what lenders should not do," while the CRA focuses on "what lenders should do."5, 6

FAQs

What types of institutions are subject to the Community Reinvestment Act?

The Community Reinvestment Act primarily applies to commercial banks and savings associations that are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC).4

How is a bank's CRA performance evaluated?

A bank's CRA performance is evaluated by federal banking regulators (Federal Reserve, OCC, FDIC) through comprehensive examinations that assess its lending, investment, and service activities within its designated assessment areas. They assign a public rating based on this evaluation.3

What happens if a bank fails its CRA examination?

If a bank receives a low CRA rating ("Needs to Improve" or "Substantial Noncompliance"), it can face significant consequences. This includes increased regulatory scrutiny, potential restrictions on growth, and most notably, difficulty in obtaining approval for applications like mergers, acquisitions, or branch expansions.2 A poor rating can severely impede a bank's strategic objectives and impact its regulatory compliance.

Does the CRA dictate specific loan quotas for banks?

No, the Community Reinvestment Act does not impose specific loan quotas on banks. Instead, it encourages banks to have a strong record of meeting the credit needs of their communities. The regulations are performance-based, allowing banks flexibility in how they achieve their obligations while adhering to safe and sound banking principles.

How does the CRA promote affordable housing?

The CRA promotes affordable housing by incentivizing banks to make loans and investments for affordable housing development, rehabilitation, and mortgage financing in low- and moderate-income communities. Many community development financial institutions (CDFIs) partner with banks to achieve these goals.

Can individuals or community groups provide input on a bank's CRA performance?

Yes, the CRA includes provisions for public input. Banks are required to maintain a public file of their CRA performance, and community members can submit comments to regulators regarding a bank's performance. These comments are considered during the CRA examination process.1 This encourages public accountability in banking.