Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to C Definitions

Conservation easements

What Is Conservation Easements?

A conservation easement is a voluntary legal agreement that allows a landowner to restrict the type and amount of development on their property while retaining private ownership. It is a tool within Real estate finance and wealth management that enables property owners to protect significant natural, scenic, or historic resources. The core of a conservation easement involves permanently limiting certain property rights to achieve specific conservation goals, such as preserving farmland, forestland, wildlife habitat, or historical sites. Landowners typically donate conservation easements to a qualified land trust or government entity. This action can provide significant financial incentives, including federal income tax deductions, state tax credits, and estate tax benefits. The terms of a conservation easement are legally binding on all future owners of the property, ensuring its conservation values are protected in perpetuity.

History and Origin

The concept of preserving land through easements has roots in British law, but conservation easements as a modern land protection tool began to emerge in the United States in the mid-20th century. Early uses included the National Park Service acquiring scenic easements along highways in the 1930s and 1940s. The term "conservation easement" itself gained prominence in the 1950s. A significant turning point for conservation easements occurred when the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) began to allow donations of these easements to qualify for tax deductions. In 1980, Congress made this deduction a permanent part of the Internal Revenue Code, significantly incentivizing landowners to protect their property for conservation purposes.8

Key Takeaways

  • Conservation easements are voluntary legal agreements that restrict development on private land to protect its conservation values.
  • They are typically donated to land trusts or government agencies and are binding on all future owners, ensuring permanent protection.
  • Landowners may receive significant tax benefits, including income tax deductions and estate tax advantages, for donating a conservation easement.
  • The value of a conservation easement for tax purposes is generally determined by the difference in the property's fair market value before and after the easement is granted.
  • Despite their benefits, conservation easements have faced scrutiny due to instances of abusive transactions and inflated appraisals.

Interpreting the Conservation Easements

A conservation easement's interpretation centers on the specific restrictions outlined in the easement deed and their alignment with recognized conservation purposes. These purposes, defined by IRS regulations, include the preservation of land for public outdoor recreation or education, the protection of a relatively natural habitat, the preservation of open space (for scenic enjoyment or pursuant to governmental conservation policy), or the preservation of historically important land areas or certified historic structures.7 The effectiveness of a conservation easement is measured by its ability to permanently safeguard these identified values while allowing compatible uses of the property. For a conservation easement to qualify for federal tax benefits, it must be granted to a qualified organization (such as a publicly supported charity or governmental unit) and its conservation purpose must be protected in perpetuity.6

Hypothetical Example

Consider Sarah, a landowner who owns a 200-acre farm with significant wetlands and a rare bird habitat. She wants to ensure the land remains undeveloped and its ecological features are preserved, even after she passes it on to her heirs. Sarah decides to place a conservation easement on 150 acres of her property, allowing her to continue farming on the remaining 50 acres and retain ownership of the entire parcel.

She works with a qualified land trust, which helps her draft a conservation easement agreement. This agreement permanently prohibits commercial or residential development on the 150 acres but allows for traditional agricultural practices that do not harm the wetlands or habitat. Before the easement, her entire 200-acre property had a fair market value of $2,000,000. After a qualified appraisal, the value of the property with the easement in place is determined to be $1,200,000. The value of the conservation easement, for charitable contribution purposes, is calculated as the difference: $2,000,000 - $1,200,000 = $800,000. Sarah can then claim this $800,000 as a non-cash charitable contribution deduction on her federal income taxes, subject to certain limitations based on her Adjusted Gross Income (AGI).

Practical Applications

Conservation easements are primarily used by landowners to achieve land preservation goals while potentially benefiting from tax incentives. They are a flexible tool in estate planning for individuals who wish to see their land protected beyond their lifetime, serving as a lasting bequest of their conservation ethic.

  • Agricultural Land Preservation: Farmers and ranchers use conservation easements to protect their working lands from future development, helping to ensure the continuity of agricultural operations. The U.S. Department of Agriculture's Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) offers programs like the Agricultural Conservation Easement Program (ACEP) that provide financial and technical assistance to conserve agricultural lands and wetlands through easements.5
  • Wildlife Habitat Protection: Landowners can restrict activities that might harm sensitive ecosystems, endangered species habitats, or migratory corridors.
  • Open Space and Scenic Preservation: Easements can protect scenic vistas, preserve community character, and maintain undeveloped open spaces near urban or suburban areas.
  • Historic Preservation: Easements can also be applied to historic properties or structures to ensure their architectural and historical integrity is maintained.
  • Forestry and Timberland Conservation: For large tracts of forest, conservation easements can prevent subdivision and maintain sustainable forestry practices. This can also influence the property's asset valuation.

Limitations and Criticisms

While conservation easements serve a vital role in land preservation, they are not without limitations and have faced significant criticism, particularly concerning their use for abusive tax shelters.

One primary concern revolves around the valuation of the easement for tax deduction purposes. The value is typically the difference between the property's fair market value before and after the easement is placed. This valuation process can be complex and subjective, relying heavily on appraisals. Abuses have arisen where inflated appraisals lead to deductions far exceeding the actual conservation value or the donor's initial investment.4

The IRS has aggressively challenged what it identifies as "syndicated conservation easements," where promoters sell interests in a pass-through entity holding land, promising investors inflated charitable contribution deductions. These transactions have been labeled as abusive tax avoidance schemes, costing the U.S. Treasury billions in lost taxes.3 Congress and the IRS have implemented measures, including the Charitable Conservation Easement Program Integrity Act, to curb these abuses by disallowing deductions for certain transactions where the contribution exceeds 2.5 times the sum of each entity member's relevant basis.2

Other criticisms include the potential for easements to be too restrictive or, conversely, not restrictive enough to genuinely achieve conservation goals in the long term, especially if the easement holder lacks sufficient resources for monitoring and enforcement. Furthermore, the perpetual nature of conservation easements means that future generations may be bound by restrictions that no longer align with societal needs or ecological priorities, leading to debates about their adaptability over time.

Conservation Easements vs. Easement

The terms "conservation easement" and "easement" are related but refer to distinct legal concepts. An easement is a general legal term defining a non-possessory right to use or enter onto the real property of another without possessing it. Common examples include utility easements (allowing power lines or pipes across land), access easements (granting a right of way), or drainage easements. These typically benefit a specific party or a piece of adjacent land.

A conservation easement, on the other hand, is a specialized type of easement. Its defining characteristic is its explicit purpose: the permanent protection of land for conservation purposes, such as preserving natural, scenic, historical, or agricultural values. Unlike many general easements that might benefit private individuals or utility companies, conservation easements are typically granted to qualified land trusts or government entities to serve a public benefit. Furthermore, conservation easements often result in a charitable contribution and associated tax deductions, which is not typically the case for general easements. They permanently restrict future development, whereas a general easement may simply grant a specific right without altering development potential.

FAQs

What types of land qualify for a conservation easement?

Land that qualifies for a conservation easement typically possesses significant natural, scenic, historical, recreational, or agricultural value. This can include farmlands, forests, wetlands, wildlife habitats, historic sites, or even scenic open spaces within developed areas. The specific qualifying criteria are outlined by federal tax law and often supplemented by state regulations and the accepting land trust's mission.

How is the value of a conservation easement determined?

The value of a conservation easement for federal tax deduction purposes is generally the difference between the property's fair market value before the easement is granted and its fair market value after the easement is in place, reflecting the development rights that have been extinguished. This valuation must be determined by a qualified appraisal performed by a certified appraiser.

Can a conservation easement be changed or terminated?

Conservation easements are designed to be perpetual, meaning they are intended to last forever and bind all future owners of the property. Changes or termination are exceptionally rare and typically only occur under very specific and limited circumstances, usually requiring court approval and adherence to strict legal standards to ensure the original conservation purpose is upheld or transferred.

What are the tax benefits of donating a conservation easement?

Donating a qualifying conservation easement can provide significant tax benefits. For federal income tax purposes, landowners may claim a charitable contribution deduction for the value of the easement. This deduction can be up to 50% of their Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) in any given year, with a 15-year carryforward period for any unused portion. For qualified farmers and ranchers, this limit can be as high as 100% of AGI.1 Additionally, conservation easements can reduce estate planning taxes and potentially capital gains taxes if the property is later sold.