What Is Convertible Bonds?
A convertible bond is a type of debt security that gives the holder the option to convert it into a predetermined number of common shares of the issuing company. This hybrid security blends features of both bonds and stocks, positioning it within the broader fixed-income and equity derivatives categories. Convertible bonds offer investors the safety of fixed-income payments while also providing the potential for capital appreciation if the underlying stock performs well. Companies issue convertible bonds to raise capital at a lower interest rate than traditional bonds, as the conversion feature offers a benefit to investors that compensates for the reduced yield.
History and Origin
The concept of convertible securities dates back to the mid-19th century, with one of the earliest recorded convertible bond issuances in the United States by the New York and Erie Railroad in 1852. These early instruments were often used to finance expanding industries, particularly railroads, providing a means to raise capital when direct equity issuance might have been difficult or costly. The hybrid nature offered a compromise to investors, allowing them to participate in potential growth while retaining the security of a debt instrument. While the specific terms and structures have evolved, the fundamental appeal of convertible bonds as a financing tool bridging debt and equity has persisted through various economic cycles. In recent times, convertible bond issuance saw a significant uptick in 2023, with global issuance reaching approximately $90 billion, effectively doubling the volume from 2022.5,4
Key Takeaways
- Convertible bonds are hybrid securities offering features of both debt and equity.
- They provide regular interest payments like traditional bonds but can be converted into common stock.
- The conversion option offers investors potential for capital appreciation if the underlying stock price increases.
- Issuers benefit from lower interest rates compared to straight bonds due to the embedded equity option.
- Convertible bonds provide investors with a degree of downside protection while retaining upside potential.
Formula and Calculation
The value of a convertible bond is influenced by its bond component (straight bond value) and its equity component (value of the embedded option). Key calculations include:
Conversion Ratio (CR): This is the number of common shares an investor receives upon converting one convertible bond.
Conversion Price (CP): The price per share at which the convertible bond can be converted into common stock.
Conversion Value (CV): The market value of the shares an investor would receive if they converted the bond immediately.
Bond Value (BV): The present value of the bond's future interest payments and principal repayment, assuming it is treated as a straight bond. This calculation involves discounting future cash flows using the prevailing market yield to maturity for similar non-convertible bonds.
The overall value of a convertible bond will typically trade at a premium to both its conversion value and its bond value, reflecting the value of the embedded option. This premium is often referred to as the convertible premium.
Interpreting the Convertible Bond
Interpreting a convertible bond involves assessing its dual nature. When the underlying stock price is low, the convertible bond tends to trade more like a straight bond, with its value primarily driven by its interest payments and credit quality. In this "bond floor" scenario, the equity conversion feature holds little immediate value.
However, as the underlying stock price rises, the equity component becomes more significant. The convertible bond's price will begin to track the stock price more closely, offering investors participation in the stock's upside. This is where the "equity kicker" comes into play. Investors weigh the current market price of the convertible against its conversion value and its bond floor to determine if it is trading at an attractive premium or discount. A high premium might indicate that the embedded option is expensive, while a low premium (or even a discount) could suggest undervaluation or a lack of market enthusiasm for the underlying equity.
Hypothetical Example
Consider XYZ Corp. issues a convertible bond with a face value of $1,000, an annual coupon rate of 5%, and a maturity of five years. The conversion ratio is 20 shares per bond.
Suppose the current market price of XYZ Corp. common stock is $40 per share.
-
Conversion Price:
This means the investor can convert the bond into shares at an effective price of $50 per share. -
Conversion Value:
If the investor converted the bond immediately, the shares received would be worth $800.
In this scenario, since the conversion value ($800) is less than the face value of the bond ($1,000), the bond is trading below its "conversion parity" and its value is largely derived from its fixed-income characteristics. The investor benefits from the 5% annual interest payments ($50 per year) until maturity or until the stock price rises above the conversion price, making conversion attractive. If the stock price were to rise above $50, say to $60, the conversion value would be $1,200 ($60 x 20 shares), making the conversion option "in the money" and potentially leading the bond's price to trade closer to or above its face value, offering capital appreciation in addition to interest income.
Practical Applications
Convertible bonds are widely used in corporate finance and investment strategies. Companies, particularly those in growth-oriented sectors or with uncertain future cash flows, issue convertible bonds to raise capital at a lower cost of debt compared to traditional bonds. This is because the embedded conversion option acts as a sweetener for investors, allowing the issuer to offer a lower interest rate.
From an investor's perspective, convertible bonds can be part of a diversified portfolio strategy, offering a blend of income and growth potential. They are often attractive to investors seeking downside protection (from the bond component) with exposure to equity upside. Hedge funds frequently employ complex strategies involving convertible bonds, such as convertible arbitrage, which seeks to profit from pricing discrepancies between the convertible bond and its underlying common stock. Convertible debt is often registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) under regulations like Regulation S-K, which dictates disclosure requirements for public companies.3,,2
Limitations and Criticisms
While convertible bonds offer distinct advantages, they also come with limitations and criticisms. For investors, the potential for equity upside is capped once the bond is converted, meaning they lose out on any further appreciation beyond the conversion value. Additionally, the yield on convertible bonds is typically lower than that of comparable straight bonds, as investors are effectively paying for the embedded option through a reduced interest payment. This lower yield can be a drawback for investors primarily seeking income.
For issuers, there's the risk of equity dilution if the bonds are converted. This means that existing shareholders will own a smaller percentage of the company, which can negatively impact earnings per share. Furthermore, the complex valuation of convertible bonds can make them difficult for some investors to understand and analyze. The market for convertibles can also be less liquid than the market for plain vanilla bonds or common stocks, potentially making it harder to buy or sell them at desired prices.1
Convertible Bonds vs. Preferred Stock
Convertible bonds and preferred stock are both hybrid securities that offer features of both debt and equity, often leading to confusion. However, their fundamental differences lie in their legal standing and how they function.
A convertible bond is primarily a debt instrument. It has a maturity date, and the issuer is legally obligated to make interest payments and repay the principal at maturity, similar to a traditional bond. If the company faces bankruptcy, convertible bondholders are creditors and have a higher claim on the company's assets than equity holders. The conversion feature allows them to switch from a debt position to an equity position.
Preferred stock, on the other hand, is an equity security. While it typically pays fixed dividends (similar to bond interest), these payments are not legally obligatory and can be suspended by the company's board of directors. Preferred stockholders generally do not have voting rights but have a higher claim on assets and dividends than common stockholders in the event of liquidation. If preferred stock is convertible, it can be exchanged for common shares, but it does not have a maturity date or principal repayment obligation.
The key distinction is the legal obligation and seniority in the capital structure: convertible bonds are debt first, with an option to become equity, whereas preferred stock is equity first, with some debt-like characteristics.
FAQs
What happens if a company's stock price never reaches the conversion price?
If the company's stock price never reaches a level where converting the bond into shares is profitable, the convertible bond will likely remain a debt instrument. Investors will continue to receive their interest payments until the bond matures, at which point the principal will be repaid. In this scenario, the convertible bond acts much like a straight corporate bond.
Are convertible bonds considered more risky than straight bonds?
Generally, convertible bonds carry more market risk than straight bonds due to their equity component. While they offer downside protection via the bond floor, their value is also influenced by the volatility of the underlying stock. A significant drop in the stock price can still cause the convertible bond's value to decline, even if it remains above its bond floor.
Can convertible bonds be "called" by the issuer?
Yes, many convertible bonds include a "call provision," which allows the issuing company to redeem the bonds before maturity, often when the stock price has risen significantly above the conversion price. This allows the company to force conversion or retire the debt. Investors might also have a "put option," allowing them to sell the bond back to the issuer under certain conditions. These provisions are important factors in evaluating a convertible bond's attractiveness and potential return.
How do interest rate changes affect convertible bonds?
Interest rate changes have a dual effect on convertible bonds. Like straight bonds, their value generally moves inversely to interest rates; when rates rise, the bond component's value tends to fall. However, rising interest rates can also sometimes signal economic growth, which might be beneficial for the underlying company's stock, potentially offsetting some of the negative impact on the bond component. The net effect depends on the relative sensitivity of the bond and equity components to interest rate fluctuations.
Are convertible bonds suitable for all investors?
Convertible bonds are often best suited for investors seeking a balance between income and growth potential, and who are comfortable with a moderate level of risk. They can be a good option for those who want some exposure to equity markets without taking on the full volatility of common stocks. However, their complexity means they may not be ideal for investors who prefer simpler, more direct investment vehicles.