Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to C Definitions

Convertible securities

What Is Convertible Securities?

Convertible securities are a type of hybrid financial instrument, typically bonds or preferred stocks, that can be converted into a predetermined number of common equity shares of the issuing company. This unique feature blends characteristics of both debt and equity, offering investors potential capital appreciation alongside the income and relative safety of a fixed-income instrument. As a result, convertible securities occupy a distinctive space within fixed income investing, appealing to those seeking a balance between growth potential and downside protection. Companies issue convertible securities to access capital at potentially lower interest rates than traditional bonds, as investors are willing to accept a reduced yield in exchange for the conversion option.

History and Origin

The concept of convertible securities dates back to the 19th century, though their widespread adoption and complexity evolved significantly in the 20th century. Early forms were often used in railroad financing. Over time, as financial markets matured, so did the structures and applications of these hybrid instruments. A significant period of growth for convertible bonds occurred in the mid-20th century as companies sought flexible financing options. More recently, accounting standards have adapted to reflect the hybrid nature of these instruments. For instance, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) issued Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2020-06, aiming to simplify the accounting for convertible instruments by reducing the number of accounting models and eliminating complexities such as the beneficial conversion feature and cash conversion feature models.6

Key Takeaways

  • Convertible securities offer a blend of debt and equity characteristics.
  • They provide regular interest payments or dividends and the potential to participate in stock price appreciation.
  • Issuers often benefit from lower interest rates compared to straight debt.
  • Their value is influenced by interest rates, the issuer's credit quality, and the underlying stock price.
  • Convertible securities can offer downside protection while retaining equity upside potential.

Formula and Calculation

The valuation of convertible securities is complex, as it involves elements of both fixed income and equity options. While a single universal formula for their market price doesn't exist due to varying features, key components in their valuation involve:

  1. Bond Value (or Investment Value): This is the present value of the convertible security's future interest payments and principal repayment, assuming it will never be converted and is treated purely as a bond. It is calculated using the security's coupon rate and the prevailing market yield for non-convertible debt of similar risk.

    Bond Value=∑t=1NCoupon Paymentt(1+r)t+Face Value(1+r)N\text{Bond Value} = \sum_{t=1}^{N} \frac{\text{Coupon Payment}_t}{(1+r)^t} + \frac{\text{Face Value}}{(1+r)^N}

    Where:

    • (\text{Coupon Payment}_t) = Interest payment at time (t)
    • (r) = Market yield for comparable non-convertible debt
    • (N) = Number of periods to maturity
    • (\text{Face Value}) = Principal amount of the bond

  2. Conversion Value (or Equity Value): This represents the value of the convertible security if it were immediately converted into common stocks.

    Conversion Value=Conversion Ratio×Current Stock Price\text{Conversion Value} = \text{Conversion Ratio} \times \text{Current Stock Price}

    Where:

    • (\text{Conversion Ratio}) = The number of shares of common stock received upon conversion of one convertible security.
    • (\text{Current Stock Price}) = The market price of the underlying common stock.

The market price of a convertible security will typically trade at a premium above both its bond value and its conversion value. This premium reflects the value of the embedded call option that allows the holder to benefit from stock price appreciation.

Interpreting the Convertible Securities

Interpreting convertible securities involves understanding their dual nature. When the underlying stock price is significantly below the conversion price, the convertible security behaves more like a traditional debt instrument, with its value primarily driven by prevailing interest rates and the issuer's creditworthiness. In this scenario, it offers income and relative capital preservation. Conversely, when the underlying stock price rises significantly above the conversion price, the convertible security's value increasingly mirrors that of the underlying equity, with its bond characteristics becoming less dominant. Investors evaluate convertible securities based on metrics like the conversion premium (the percentage by which the convertible's market price exceeds its conversion value) and the payback period (how long it takes for the higher yield of the convertible over the common stock to offset the conversion premium). The goal is often to find securities with a reasonable premium and strong underlying company fundamentals.

Hypothetical Example

Consider XYZ Corp. issues a convertible bond with a face value of $1,000, a 2% annual coupon rate, and a maturity of five years. The bond is convertible into 20 shares of XYZ Corp.'s common stock. At the time of issuance, XYZ Corp.'s common stock trades at $40 per share.

  • Conversion Ratio: 20 shares
  • Conversion Price: $1,000 / 20 shares = $50 per share (This is the effective price at which the bond can be converted into stock).
  • Initial Conversion Value: 20 shares * $40/share = $800.

In this scenario, the conversion value ($800) is less than the bond's face value ($1,000). The bond is "out-of-the-money" for conversion, and its value will primarily be influenced by its fixed income characteristics.

Now, imagine after two years, XYZ Corp.'s stock price rises to $60 per share.

  • New Conversion Value: 20 shares * $60/share = $1,200.

At this point, the conversion value ($1,200) is greater than the bond's face value ($1,000). The bond is "in-the-money," and its market price would likely trade near or above $1,200, as investors would realize the benefit of converting into valuable stocks.

Practical Applications

Convertible securities are utilized across various aspects of finance. For companies, they serve as a flexible financing tool within their capital structure, often allowing them to raise capital at a lower interest rate than traditional non-convertible debt, especially for growth-oriented firms. For investors, they can offer a unique risk-return profile. They are often sought after by those looking for equity participation with some level of downside protection, making them appealing during periods of market uncertainty. The liquidity of convertible bonds can be comparable to investment grade bonds, despite a smaller overall market size compared to high-yield bonds.5

Convertible arbitrage strategies are employed by hedge funds, aiming to profit from mispricings between the convertible security and its underlying stock by simultaneously buying the convertible and shorting the common stock. A recent example of convertible bond issuance is JL MAG Rare-Earth Co., Ltd.'s completion of a $117.5 million guaranteed convertible bond issuance due in 2030, which is now listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange.4 These securities can also be used in tax and estate planning, as stock acquired through convertible debt may qualify for certain exclusions under Section 1202 of the U.S. tax code if held for a specified period and other conditions are met.3

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their advantages, convertible securities come with specific limitations and criticisms. For investors, the potential for dilution upon conversion is a key concern, as an increase in the number of outstanding shares can reduce the value of existing shares. The embedded conversion feature means that the yield on convertible bonds is typically lower than that of comparable non-convertible debt, meaning investors sacrifice some income for the equity upside potential. Additionally, the complex nature of convertible securities makes them harder to value than straight bonds or common stocks, requiring sophisticated analysis.

From an issuer's perspective, while they may secure lower initial interest costs, forced conversion when the stock price performs well can lead to significant dilution of existing shareholder equity. Furthermore, if the stock price does not perform as expected, the company remains obligated to pay interest and principal as with regular bonds, without the benefit of equity conversion. Academic research also explores how features of convertible bonds, particularly those with contingent capital (CoCo) provisions, can influence bank risk-taking behavior, noting a trade-off between equity dilution effects and the potential for increased risk shifting incentives.2

Convertible Securities vs. Warrants

While both convertible securities and warrants provide the holder with the option to acquire a company's common stock, they differ fundamentally. Convertible securities are typically bonds or preferred shares that themselves are investment instruments, paying interest or dividends. They represent a claim on the company's assets and income, possessing a fixed income component. In a worst-case scenario where the stock price does not appreciate, the investor still holds a bond or preferred stock that continues to pay income (unless the issuer defaults), offering a degree of downside protection. The default rate for convertible bonds has historically been lower than that of the high-yield bond market.1

In contrast, a warrant is solely an option to buy a company's stock at a specified price within a specified timeframe. Warrants are issued separately from any underlying bond or preferred stock, and they do not pay interest or dividends. Their value is purely derived from the underlying stock's price movement. If the stock price does not rise above the exercise price, warrants can expire worthless, leading to a complete loss of the initial investment. Therefore, warrants carry higher risk and offer no inherent downside protection from a fixed income component, unlike convertible securities which act as a hybrid providing some principal safety and risk-adjusted returns potential.

FAQs

What is the primary benefit of convertible securities for investors?

The main benefit for investors is the hybrid nature: they offer the income and relative stability of a bond (or preferred stock) along with the potential for capital appreciation if the underlying company's stocks perform well.

Why do companies issue convertible securities instead of regular bonds?

Companies often issue convertible securities to secure capital at a lower interest rate than they would with traditional bonds, as investors are willing to accept a reduced yield in exchange for the embedded equity conversion option. This can also be a way for growing companies to attract investors who want a blend of security and growth potential.

Can convertible securities be callable or puttable?

Yes, many convertible securities include provisions that allow either the issuer or the holder to take certain actions. Issuers may have a call option, allowing them to redeem the securities at a specified price, often forcing conversion if the stock price is sufficiently high. Conversely, holders may have a put option, allowing them to sell the security back to the issuer at a set price, providing some downside protection if the stock price or the issuer's credit quality deteriorates.

Are convertible securities suitable for all investors?

Convertible securities can be suitable for investors seeking a balance between income and growth, and who are comfortable with the complexities of these hybrid instruments. They may not be ideal for investors who prioritize maximum income (as their yields are lower than comparable straight bonds) or those solely focused on aggressive equity growth (as their upside is capped by the conversion terms and they carry bond-like characteristics). Understanding the trade-offs between yield, equity participation, and the specific terms of a convertible security is crucial for any investor.