What Are Cumulative Dividends?
Cumulative dividends refer to a feature of certain types of shares, most commonly preferred stock, that guarantees payment of all missed dividends from prior periods before any dividends can be distributed to other classes of shareholders, such as common stock holders. This concept falls under the broader discipline of corporate finance, specifically dealing with the rights and obligations associated with a company's capital structure. If a company's board of directors opts not to declare or pay a dividend in a given period, the cumulative dividend obligation accrues and becomes a liability that must be settled in the future. These unpaid dividends are often referred to as dividend arrears.17 The cumulative feature provides an added layer of security for investors, ensuring that their entitled income stream is eventually received, even if temporarily delayed.16
History and Origin
The concept of preferred stock, which often carries the cumulative dividend feature, emerged in the mid-19th century in the United States.15 Early examples include shares issued by the Pennsylvania Railroad Company, designed to offer investors a more predictable income stream and a preferential claim on company assets compared to common shares.14 Over time, as corporations evolved and their financial structures became more complex, the legal doctrines surrounding shareholder rights, including the accumulation of unpaid dividends, were debated and refined. Academic and legal discussions, such as those found in scholarly works on corporate law, highlight the critical role of the "corporate charter" in defining the preferred stock contract and the treatment of accrued dividends.13 The cumulative feature became a standard way to attract investors seeking a more secure income, especially from utility and transportation companies which were significant issuers in the early 20th century.12
Key Takeaways
- Cumulative dividends are a feature of some preferred stock that ensures all missed past dividend payments must be paid.
- These accumulated unpaid dividends, known as dividend arrears, must be settled before any dividends can be paid to common stockholders.
- The cumulative feature provides a greater level of income security for preferred shareholders compared to non-cumulative preferred shares.
- Most preferred stock issued by companies today includes a cumulative feature due to its appeal to investors and its potential to lower a company's cost of capital.11
- While offering income stability, cumulative preferred stock generally has limited potential for capital appreciation and is sensitive to changes in interest rates.
Formula and Calculation
The calculation of cumulative dividends involves tracking the fixed dividend payment amount per share and multiplying it by the number of periods for which dividends have been skipped.
The formula for total cumulative dividends due per share can be expressed as:
Where:
- Annual Dividend Per Share is the fixed annual dividend amount that the preferred stock is contractually obligated to pay. This is often calculated as a percentage of the stock's par value.
- Number of Periods in Arrears represents the total number of dividend periods (e.g., quarters, years) for which the company has failed to pay the stipulated dividend to its cumulative preferred shareholders.
For example, if a company has a cumulative preferred stock with a $5 annual dividend per share and has missed payments for two years, the cumulative dividends in arrears would be:
$5/share/year × 2 years = $10/share in arrears.
This amount must be fully paid to cumulative preferred shareholders before any dividends can be distributed to common stock holders.
10
Interpreting Cumulative Dividends
The presence of cumulative dividends in a company's financial statements signals an important aspect of its equity financing structure. For investors, the cumulative feature provides a measure of safety, indicating that even if a company faces financial difficulties and suspends dividend payments, the accumulated amount remains an obligation. This differs significantly from common stock, where dividends are discretionary and forfeited if not declared.
From a company's perspective, accumulated cumulative dividends, or dividend arrears, represent a significant financial obligation that must eventually be satisfied before the company can resume paying dividends to its common shareholders. This can impact decisions related to retained earnings and future distributions, potentially influencing the company's stock price and overall shareholder value. The total amount of unpaid cumulative dividends is often disclosed in the notes accompanying a company's balance sheet.
Hypothetical Example
Consider XYZ Corp. which has issued 100,000 shares of cumulative preferred stock with a par value of $100 and an annual dividend rate of 5%. This means each share is entitled to an annual dividend of $5 ($100 par value × 0.05).
In Year 1, due to unexpected economic downturns, XYZ Corp. decides not to pay any dividends. The $5 per share dividend for the cumulative preferred stock goes into arrears.
- Cumulative dividends in arrears at the end of Year 1: $5 per share.
In Year 2, the economic situation remains challenging, and XYZ Corp. again skips dividend payments.
- Cumulative dividends in arrears at the end of Year 2: $5 (Year 1) + $5 (Year 2) = $10 per share.
In Year 3, the economy improves, and XYZ Corp. generates substantial profits. The board of directors decides to resume dividend payments. Before any dividends can be paid to common stockholders, XYZ Corp. must first pay the accumulated dividends to its cumulative preferred shareholders.
- Payment to cumulative preferred shareholders: $10 (arrears) + $5 (current year's dividend) = $15 per share.
After paying the total $15 per share to all 100,000 cumulative preferred shares, XYZ Corp. can then consider declaring and paying dividends to its common stock holders. This example highlights how cumulative dividends ensure that preferred shareholders eventually receive all their promised payments.
Practical Applications
Cumulative dividends primarily appear in the realm of preferred stock, which represents a unique class of securities that blends characteristics of both debt and equity. C9ompanies, particularly those in the financial sector like banks, often issue cumulative preferred stock as a form of equity financing to raise capital without diluting the voting rights of common shareholders.
8These shares are attractive to income-oriented investors seeking a stable stream of payments because the cumulative feature ensures that any missed dividends accrue and must be paid in full before common shareholders receive any distributions. F7or example, a company's S-3/A filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) might explicitly detail the terms under which cumulative preferred dividends are payable, including scenarios like conversion or liquidation, reinforcing their contractual nature. T6his makes them a useful tool in portfolio construction for those prioritizing consistent income over significant capital appreciation.
Limitations and Criticisms
While cumulative dividends offer a layer of security for investors, they are not without limitations. One primary criticism is that preferred stock, even with cumulative features, typically has limited potential for capital appreciation compared to common stock. Their market price tends to be more influenced by prevailing interest rates than by the issuing company's growth prospects. If interest rates rise, the fixed dividend payments of preferred stock become less attractive, potentially leading to a decline in their market value.
5Another drawback is the absence of voting rights for most preferred shareholders, which means they have little to no influence over significant corporate governance decisions. Furthermore, while preferred shareholders have priority over common shareholders in receiving dividends and in liquidation, they are still subordinate to bondholders and other creditors. This positioning in the capital structure means that in severe financial distress, preferred shareholders may still face losses if assets are insufficient to cover all obligations.
Cumulative Dividends vs. Non-cumulative Dividends
The key distinction between cumulative dividends and non-cumulative dividends lies in the treatment of unpaid distributions.
| Feature | Cumulative Dividends | Non-cumulative Dividends |
|---|---|---|
| Dividend Arrears | If a dividend payment is missed, it accumulates and must be paid in the future. | 4 If a dividend payment is missed, it is permanently lost and does not accumulate. |
| Priority of Payment | All accrued and current dividends must be paid to cumulative preferred shareholders first before any dividends can be paid to common stock holders. | Only the current period's declared dividend (if any) is paid to non-cumulative preferred shareholders before common stockholders. Missed past payments are irrelevant. |
| Investor Security | Offers greater income security, as missed payments are eventually recovered. | 3 Offers less income security, as the right to a dividend is forfeited if not declared. |
| Typical Issuers | Most common form of preferred stock issued, due to higher investor appeal. | 2 Generally issued by financially strong companies or in specific regulatory contexts, like some bank capital. |
Confusion often arises because both types of preferred stock grant priority in dividend payments over common stock. However, the "cumulative" feature is the crucial differentiator, providing a claim to past missed payments, whereas "non-cumulative" preferred stock offers no such guarantee.
FAQs
Q1: Are cumulative dividends guaranteed?
No, cumulative dividends are not guaranteed in the same way that interest payments on a bond are. A company's board of directors must still declare the dividend. However, if they don't declare it for a cumulative preferred stock, the unpaid amount accumulates and becomes a liability that must be paid before any dividends can be distributed to common stock holders in the future.
Q2: What happens if a company goes bankrupt with cumulative preferred stock?
In the event of a company's liquidation, holders of cumulative preferred stock have a higher claim on the company's assets than common stockholders, but they are subordinate to all creditors and bondholders. Any accumulated unpaid dividends (arrears) would generally be paid out to preferred shareholders before common shareholders receive anything, assuming sufficient assets remain after satisfying all debt obligations.
Q3: Why would a company issue cumulative preferred stock?
Companies issue cumulative preferred stock to raise equity financing while offering investors a more attractive and secure income stream than common stock. It allows the company to obtain capital without diluting the voting power of existing common shareholders. The cumulative feature reduces investor risk, often enabling the company to issue shares at a lower dividend rate than if the stock were non-cumulative.
1### Q4: Do cumulative preferred stock dividends always pay out in cash?
While typically paid in cash, the terms of a specific cumulative preferred stock issue may allow for dividends to be paid in other forms, such as additional shares of stock or other marketable securities, especially if the company is facing cash flow constraints. The specific method of payment would be detailed in the offering documents for that particular stock.
Q5: How do cumulative dividends affect a company's financial statements?
If cumulative dividends are not paid, the accumulated amount is typically disclosed as dividend arrears in the notes to the company's financial statements, rather than as a direct liability on the balance sheet. While not a legal debt that triggers default, it represents a claim against future earnings that must be satisfied before common shareholders can receive dividends.