Debt outstanding subject to limitation

A hidden table containing internal and external links has been created for use in the article.

What Is Debt Outstanding Subject to Limitation?

Debt outstanding subject to limitation, often referred to as the debt ceiling, is the maximum amount of money the U.S. federal government is legally authorized to borrow to meet its existing legal obligations. These obligations include funding for government operations, Social Security and Medicare benefits, military salaries, tax refunds, and interest payments on the national debt⁵¹. This concept falls under the broad financial category of public finance, as it directly concerns the government's ability to manage its financial commitments and maintain fiscal stability. The debt outstanding subject to limitation is a crucial figure that reflects the cumulative sum of all past federal borrowing that has not yet been repaid.

History and Origin

The concept of a statutory limit on federal debt emerged in the United States to streamline the borrowing process. Before 1917, Congress typically authorized each specific debt issuance individually. This ad hoc approach became cumbersome, particularly with the escalating financial needs of World War I. To address this, Congress passed the Second Liberty Bond Act of 1917, which established an aggregate limit on the total amount of bonds that could be issued⁵⁰. This act allowed the Treasury Department more flexibility in debt management by removing the need for congressional approval for each new bond sale, subject to an overall cap⁴⁹. The debt limit, in its modern form, was largely solidified by the Public Debt Acts of 1939 and 1941, which eliminated separate limits on different types of debt and consolidated nearly all federal borrowing under a single, comprehensive ceiling. Since then, the debt ceiling has been raised or suspended numerous times—at least 90 times in the 20th century, and 14 times from 2001 to 2016 alone.
⁴⁷, ⁴⁸

Key Takeaways

• Debt outstanding subject to limitation represents the maximum amount of money the U.S. government can borrow to fulfill its existing legal obligations.
• It does not authorize new spending but rather allows the government to finance spending commitments already approved by Congress and the President.
  ⁴⁶* The debt limit was established in 1917 to provide the U.S. Treasury with greater flexibility in managing the national debt.
  ⁴⁵* When the government approaches this limit, the Treasury may employ "extraordinary measures" to temporarily avoid a default.
  ⁴⁴* Failure to raise or suspend the debt limit when necessary could lead to severe economic consequences, including a potential default on government obligations and a negative impact on financial markets.
  ⁴², ⁴³

Formula and Calculation

Debt outstanding subject to limitation is not calculated by a specific formula but is rather a cumulative figure determined by legislative action. It represents the sum of:

Where:

• Debt Held by the Public: This includes all federal debt securities, such as Treasury bonds, Treasury notes, and Treasury bills, held by individuals, institutions, foreign governments, and the Federal Reserve System. ⁴¹It's the portion of the national debt financed by external borrowing in the capital markets.
• Intragovernmental Holdings: This refers to debt issued by the Treasury to various federal government accounts, primarily federal trust funds like Social Security and Medicare. ³⁹, ⁴⁰These are internal transactions where one part of the government "borrows" from another.
• Adjustments: The U.S. Treasury explains that the "Total Public Debt Subject to Limit" is the "Total Public Debt Outstanding less the Unamortized Discount on Treasury Bills and Zero-Coupon Treasury Bonds, old debt issued before 1917, and old currency called United States Notes, as well as Debt held by the Federal Financing Bank and Guaranteed Debt".
  ³⁸
  The overall debt subject to limitation increases when the federal government runs a budget deficit, meaning its expenditures exceed its revenues, necessitating additional borrowing.
  ³⁷

Interpreting the Debt Outstanding Subject to Limitation

Interpreting the debt outstanding subject to limitation primarily involves understanding its proximity to the statutory debt limit. When the total federal debt approaches this limit, it signals that Congress must act to either raise or suspend the ceiling to avoid a potential default on the nation's financial obligations. A binding debt limit means the Treasury can no longer issue new debt to finance government operations, even for spending already authorized by law.
³⁶
Economists and policymakers closely monitor this figure as it highlights the ongoing need for the government to manage its fiscal policy. While the debt limit does not directly control future spending, it can become a point of political contention, leading to debates over government spending and the overall national debt. ³⁵The inability to raise the debt limit would force the Treasury to rely solely on incoming revenues to pay bills, potentially leading to delayed payments for various government services and obligations.
³⁴

Hypothetical Example

Imagine the U.S. government's debt outstanding subject to limitation is currently $34.5 trillion, and the statutory debt limit is $35 trillion. The government continues to spend money as authorized by Congress for various programs, including defense, healthcare, and social welfare, while also collecting tax revenues. Due to ongoing expenditures exceeding revenues, the debt outstanding subject to limitation continues to grow.

As the debt approaches $35 trillion, the Treasury Secretary would announce that the government is nearing its borrowing limit. At this point, the Treasury might begin to employ "extraordinary measures," such as suspending investments in certain government trust funds, to create temporary borrowing capacity without exceeding the statutory limit. ³³If these measures are exhausted and Congress does not act to raise or suspend the debt limit, the government would face the inability to pay all its bills, potentially leading to a technical default on its obligations. This scenario underscores the importance of the legislative process in managing the nation's finances and preventing a sovereign default.

Practical Applications

The concept of debt outstanding subject to limitation is crucial in several areas of finance and government.

• Government Operations: It dictates the federal government's ability to fund its day-to-day operations, including essential services and payments to citizens. ³²Without an increase in the debt limit, the government's capacity to fulfill its legal obligations is constrained.
• Financial Markets: The approaching or reaching of the debt limit can introduce significant uncertainty into financial markets. Concerns about a potential default on U.S. Treasury securities can lead to increased interest rates and market volatility, impacting the cost of borrowing for both the government and private entities.
  ³¹* Credit Ratings: Prolonged impasses over the debt ceiling have, in the past, led to downgrades in the U.S. credit rating, signaling increased risk to investors. For example, the 2011 debt ceiling crisis resulted in the nation's first-ever credit downgrade. ³⁰Such downgrades can affect investor confidence and the global standing of U.S. government debt, which is typically considered a safe haven asset.
• Budgetary Debates: The debt limit serves as a recurring trigger for congressional debates on federal spending and budgetary policy. While it doesn't control spending, it forces lawmakers to confront the cumulative effect of past spending decisions.
  ²⁹
  The Congressional Budget Office (CBO), a non-partisan agency, provides independent analyses and projections regarding the federal budget and debt, offering valuable insights into the implications of the debt limit for long-term fiscal health. CBO estimates for the impact of debt ceiling agreements are publicly available.

²⁸## Limitations and Criticisms

While intended as a mechanism for fiscal discipline, the debt outstanding subject to limitation, or debt ceiling, faces significant limitations and criticisms.

One primary critique is that it does not effectively control government spending. The debt limit is a cap on borrowing to pay for spending commitments already authorized by Congress, rather than a control on future appropriations. ²⁶, ²⁷Therefore, debates over the debt ceiling often become political confrontations rather than meaningful discussions about fiscal restraint. ²⁵Some argue that it is an inefficient way to manage public debt and can create unnecessary uncertainty.
²⁴
Another major limitation is the potential for severe economic disruption if the debt limit is not raised in a timely manner. A failure to increase the debt ceiling could lead to the U.S. government defaulting on its obligations, which would have catastrophic consequences for the domestic and global economies. ²³This includes risks of a recession, significant job losses, erosion of household wealth, and a decline in the U.S. economy. ²²Such an event could also shake confidence in the reliability of U.S. Treasury securities, which are foundational to global financial markets.
²¹
Critics also point to the "extraordinary measures" used by the Treasury to avoid breaching the limit as evidence of its ineffectiveness. While these measures buy time, they can come with costs, including increased rates and reduced liquidity in secondary markets for affected securities. ²⁰Some legal scholars and economists argue that the debt ceiling itself may be constitutionally problematic and that the president should prioritize paying authorized obligations even if it means exceeding the limit. ¹⁸, ¹⁹The recurring nature of these debates, particularly in periods of divided government, highlights the ongoing challenge of using the debt ceiling as a tool for fiscal management.
¹⁷

Debt Outstanding Subject to Limitation vs. Total Public Debt Outstanding

While often used interchangeably in public discourse, "debt outstanding subject to limitation" and "total public debt outstanding" are distinct financial terms related to U.S. government debt.

Debt Outstanding Subject to Limitation refers specifically to the portion of the national debt that is counted against the statutory debt ceiling established by Congress. As defined by the U.S. Treasury, this amount excludes certain minor components of the total public debt, such as unamortized discounts on Treasury bills and old debt issued before 1917. ¹⁶It is the operational figure that the Treasury must manage to remain below the legally mandated borrowing cap.

Total Public Debt Outstanding, on the other hand, represents the full par (principal) amount of all outstanding Treasury marketable securities (like bills, notes, and bonds) and Treasury non-marketable securities (such as savings bonds and special securities issued to federal trust funds). ¹⁵It is the comprehensive measure of all money borrowed by the U.S. government that has not yet been repaid. The debt outstanding subject to limitation is typically more than 99% of the total federal debt. ¹⁴The distinction is primarily technical, with the former being the direct legal constraint on federal borrowing.

FAQs

What happens if the U.S. government reaches the debt limit?

If the U.S. government reaches the debt limit, the Treasury Department typically employs "extraordinary measures" to temporarily avoid a default. These measures can include suspending investments in certain government trust funds or exchanging debt securities not subject to the limit. ¹³If these measures are exhausted without Congress raising or suspending the limit, the government would be unable to borrow further and would have to rely solely on incoming revenues to pay its bills, which could lead to delayed payments for various obligations like Social Security, Medicare, and military salaries.
¹¹, ¹²

Does raising the debt limit authorize new spending?

No, raising the debt limit does not authorize new spending. ¹⁰It simply allows the government to borrow money to pay for spending that has already been authorized and committed by Congress and the President through previously enacted laws and appropriations. It's a mechanism to ensure the government can meet its existing legal financial obligations.

Why does the U.S. have a debt limit?

The U.S. has a debt limit primarily for historical reasons, stemming from the Second Liberty Bond Act of 1917. ⁹It was initially designed to provide the Treasury with more flexibility in managing debt during World War I, replacing the need for Congress to approve each individual debt issuance. ⁸While its original purpose was administrative convenience, it has evolved into a mechanism that forces Congress to confront the cumulative effect of past spending decisions, though its effectiveness in controlling overall spending is widely debated.
⁶, ⁷

What are "extraordinary measures"?

"Extraordinary measures" are accounting tools and actions the Treasury Secretary can take when the federal government approaches the debt limit to temporarily create more borrowing room without exceeding the statutory cap. These measures can include suspending investments in specific government funds, such as the Civil Service Retirement and Disability Fund, or exchanging certain debt securities. ⁴, ⁵These actions buy time for Congress to act, but they are temporary and do not solve the underlying fiscal challenge.
³

Has the U.S. ever defaulted on its debt?

The U.S. has never technically defaulted on its debt obligations in the sense of missing principal or interest payments on Treasury securities. However, impasses over the debt ceiling have brought the country close to default on several occasions, leading to market uncertainty and, in one instance, a downgrade of the nation's credit rating. ¹, ²While a full default has been avoided, the debates themselves have carried economic costs.