Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to D Definitions

Deferred discount rate

What Is Deferred Discount Rate?

A deferred discount rate refers to a discount rate that changes over different periods in the future, often becoming lower for periods further out in time. This concept falls under the broader field of behavioral economics, which studies the psychological, social, and emotional factors influencing economic decisions. While traditional finance often assumes a constant discount rate, the deferred discount rate acknowledges that individuals and organizations may value present rewards disproportionately more than near-future rewards, but then apply a less aggressive discount to rewards that are very far in the future.

This approach is particularly relevant when evaluating long-term projects or investments where the time horizon extends significantly. Understanding the nuances of a deferred discount rate is crucial for accurate financial modeling and decision-making, especially in scenarios involving long-term financial planning or intergenerational considerations.

History and Origin

The concept of a deferred discount rate, or more broadly, a declining discount rate, has roots in the observation of human behavior regarding intertemporal choices. Traditional economic theory often employs exponential discounting, which posits a constant discount rate over time. However, psychological studies began to reveal that individuals often exhibit "hyperbolic discounting," a cognitive bias where the perceived value of a future reward decreases more rapidly in the near term than in the distant future. For instance, a person might prefer $100 today over $110 tomorrow but choose $110 in 366 days over $100 in 365 days. This "time inconsistency" challenged the constant rate assumption.16

Academics and policymakers have increasingly recognized the implications of such non-constant discounting, especially for projects with very long time horizons, such as those related to climate change or infrastructure. Organizations like the OECD have explored how conventional procedures for establishing social discount rates become problematic in intergenerational contexts, suggesting the need for new approaches that might incorporate declining rates for benefits and costs far into the future.14, 15

Key Takeaways

  • A deferred discount rate acknowledges that the rate used to discount future values may not be constant, often declining as the time horizon extends.
  • This concept is rooted in behavioral economics, specifically the phenomenon of hyperbolic discounting, where immediate gratification is often preferred over slightly delayed rewards, but long-term delays are discounted less severely.
  • It is particularly relevant for evaluating projects or investments with very long time horizons, such as environmental initiatives or retirement planning.
  • Using a deferred discount rate can lead to different valuations of long-term benefits and costs compared to using a single, constant discount rate.
  • The application of a deferred discount rate helps to better align financial models with observed human preferences and the unique characteristics of long-term societal projects.

Formula and Calculation

The calculation of present value using a deferred discount rate involves applying different discount rates to different time periods. While there isn't a single universal formula for a "deferred discount rate" as it's a concept applied through varying rates, the general present value formula is used iteratively.

The present value (PV) of a future cash flow (FV) is calculated as:

PV=FV(1+r)nPV = \frac{FV}{(1+r)^n}

Where:

  • (PV) = Present Value
  • (FV) = Future Value
  • (r) = Discount Rate for a specific period
  • (n) = Number of periods until the future value is received

When using a deferred discount rate, you would segment the time horizon and apply a specific discount rate to each segment. For example, if you have a cash flow expected in 10 years, and a deferred discount rate specifies 5% for the first 5 years and 3% for years 6-10, the calculation would adjust accordingly. This contrasts with a single discount rate applied across all periods. The concept of present value is central to this calculation.

Interpreting the Deferred Discount Rate

Interpreting the deferred discount rate involves understanding that the value placed on future outcomes changes depending on how far into the future those outcomes lie. A higher discount rate applied to the near future reflects a stronger preference for immediate gratification or a greater perceived risk associated with short-term delays. As the time horizon extends, a lower deferred discount rate indicates that people are less impatient about those very distant outcomes, or that the uncertainty associated with the far future is being treated differently.

This interpretation is crucial for long-term investments, infrastructure projects, and policy decisions, especially in areas like climate economics where the benefits may accrue over centuries. It suggests that a project yielding significant benefits many decades from now might be considered more valuable than if a constant, high discount rate were applied across the entire period. This perspective helps in evaluating the time value of money in a way that more closely aligns with observed human behavior and societal priorities.

Hypothetical Example

Consider a renewable energy project that is expected to generate significant environmental benefits over 100 years. A traditional financial analysis might use a constant discount rate, say 5%, to calculate the present value of these benefits.

However, using a deferred discount rate approach, the analysis might apply:

  • A 7% discount rate for the first 10 years (reflecting a higher immediate discount).
  • A 4% discount rate for years 11 to 50.
  • A 2% discount rate for years 51 to 100 (reflecting a lower discount for very long-term benefits).

Let's assume a simplified scenario where the project yields a benefit of $1,000,000 in Year 5, $2,000,000 in Year 30, and $5,000,000 in Year 80.

Traditional Discounting (Constant 5%):

  • PV (Year 5 benefit) = $1,000,000 / (1 + 0.05)^5 = $783,526
  • PV (Year 30 benefit) = $2,000,000 / (1 + 0.05)^30 = $462,755
  • PV (Year 80 benefit) = $5,000,000 / (1 + 0.05)^80 = $88,092

Deferred Discounting:

  • Year 5 Benefit ($1,000,000): Falls within the first 10 years, so a 7% rate applies.
    PV = $1,000,000 / (1 + 0.07)^5 = $712,986
  • Year 30 Benefit ($2,000,000): Falls within years 11-50, so a 4% rate applies.
    PV = $2,000,000 / (1 + 0.04)^30 = $616,668
  • Year 80 Benefit ($5,000,000): Falls within years 51-100, so a 2% rate applies.
    PV = $5,000,000 / (1 + 0.02)^80 = $1,023,017

As this example illustrates, the choice of a discount rate—and particularly whether it is deferred—can significantly alter the present value of future cash flows, especially for long-duration projects. This can influence an investment decision by making long-term benefits appear more or less attractive.

Practical Applications

The deferred discount rate finds practical applications in various financial and policy domains, particularly in areas requiring long-term valuation and decision-making:

  • Environmental and Climate Policy: When evaluating the costs and benefits of environmental regulations or climate change mitigation strategies, which often have effects spanning many decades or centuries, a deferred discount rate can be used. This approach reflects the ethical considerations of valuing future generations' well-being and is discussed in research by organizations such as the OECD.
  • 13 Infrastructure Planning: Large-scale infrastructure projects, such as new transportation networks or energy grids, have very long operational lives. Using a deferred discount rate can help assess their long-term societal and economic impacts more accurately, influencing public policy and capital budgeting.
  • Retirement Planning and Social Security: In projecting the long-term solvency of retirement systems or the adequacy of individual retirement savings, a deferred discount rate can provide a more nuanced view of future liabilities and asset accumulation. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) often provides guidance on considering the long-term implications of investment costs and benefits, even in deferred compensation plans.
  • 9, 10, 11, 12 Long-Term Investment Valuation: For investors and portfolio managers assessing illiquid assets or strategies with extremely long investment horizons, a deferred discount rate can be a sophisticated tool for valuation. Research Affiliates, for instance, discusses long-term return expectations across asset classes, implicitly touching upon how valuations change over extended periods. Thi4, 5, 6, 7, 8s can influence asset allocation decisions.

These applications highlight how a deferred discount rate provides a more refined approach to valuing future outcomes, moving beyond the limitations of a single, constant rate.

Limitations and Criticisms

While the deferred discount rate offers a more nuanced approach to valuing future cash flows, it is not without limitations and criticisms. One primary challenge lies in determining the specific rates for each deferral period. There is no universally agreed-upon method for establishing these changing rates, which can introduce subjectivity and potential for manipulation in financial modeling. Differing assumptions about future economic conditions or societal preferences can lead to widely divergent valuations.

Another criticism revolves around complexity. Implementing a deferred discount rate adds layers of complexity to financial analysis compared to using a single, constant rate. This can make models harder to understand, audit, and compare across different projects or organizations. Critics might argue that the increased complexity does not always yield a proportionally greater accuracy, especially when the underlying data for long-term forecasts is inherently uncertain.

Furthermore, the theoretical basis, particularly hyperbolic discounting, while supported by behavioral economics, describes how people do discount, rather than how they should discount from a purely rational economic perspective. This distinction raises questions about whether models should primarily reflect observed, sometimes irrational, human behavior or adhere to a more prescriptive, economically rational framework. The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, for example, explores various economic concepts, including those that touch upon behavioral aspects.

Fi1, 2, 3nally, the deferred discount rate can potentially mask certain risks or assumptions. By adjusting the rate over time, some argue it might obscure the true sensitivity of a project's net present value to changes in initial discount rate assumptions or early-stage cash flow projections. It also complicates sensitivity analysis, as multiple rates, rather than a single rate, must be varied to understand their impact.

Deferred Discount Rate vs. Exponential Discounting

The deferred discount rate and exponential discounting represent two distinct approaches to valuing future sums. The core difference lies in their treatment of the discount rate over time.

Exponential Discounting assumes a constant discount rate applied uniformly across all future periods. This means that the rate at which future values diminish is the same whether you're looking at the next year or a hundred years from now. It implies time consistency, meaning an individual's preferences between two future outcomes will remain the same regardless of when the evaluation is made. For example, if you prefer $100 in two years over $90 in one year today, you would also prefer $100 in ten years over $90 in nine years. This model is simpler to apply and has been a cornerstone of traditional finance.

In contrast, a deferred discount rate (often associated with hyperbolic discounting) posits that the discount rate is not constant but typically declines as the time horizon lengthens. This approach acknowledges that people often demonstrate a stronger preference for immediate gratification over slightly delayed rewards, but become less impatient when comparing rewards far in the future. For instance, the difference in perceived value between receiving $100 today versus $110 in a month might be significant, reflecting a high implicit discount rate. However, the difference between receiving $100 in 10 years versus $110 in 10 years and one month might be much smaller, implying a lower discount rate for the longer, deferred period. This model is considered time-inconsistent, as preferences can shift as the future becomes the present. The related term hyperbolic discounting explicitly captures this human tendency.

FAQs

Why is a deferred discount rate used?

A deferred discount rate is used to more accurately reflect how individuals and societies actually value outcomes that occur at different points in the future. It addresses the observation that people tend to discount immediate or near-term rewards more heavily than rewards that are far in the future. This approach is particularly relevant for long-term projects and policies, such as those related to environmental protection or infrastructure, where benefits and costs accrue over extended periods.

How does a deferred discount rate differ from a constant discount rate?

A constant discount rate applies the same rate of reduction to future values regardless of how far in the future they are. A deferred discount rate, however, uses different rates for different time segments, typically applying a higher discount rate for the near future and a lower rate for more distant future periods. This reflects a non-linear preference for time.

What is the primary benefit of using a deferred discount rate?

The primary benefit is that it can provide a more realistic valuation of long-term projects and benefits, especially when considering intergenerational equity or decisions with very distant consequences. It allows for a more nuanced understanding of the time value of money than a single, constant rate.

Is a deferred discount rate always applied?

No, a deferred discount rate is not always applied. Traditional financial analysis often uses a constant discount rate due to its simplicity and the theoretical assumption of time consistency in preferences. The use of a deferred discount rate is more common in specialized areas like behavioral finance, public policy analysis, and environmental economics, where long-term societal impacts are a key consideration.

Can a deferred discount rate lead to different investment decisions?

Yes, it can significantly alter investment decisions, particularly for projects with long time horizons. By applying lower discount rates to distant future benefits, a deferred discount rate can make long-term investments, such as those in renewable energy or education, appear more economically viable and attractive than they might under a constant, higher discount rate. This can influence capital allocation.