Skip to main content
← Back to D Definitions

Double tax exempt

What Is Double Tax Exempt?

Double tax exempt refers to an investment, most commonly a type of municipal bond, whose interest income is free from taxation at two levels: the federal level and the state or local level. This specialized tax status falls under the broader category of investment taxation within public finance. For an investment to be considered double tax exempt, the bond is typically issued by a government entity within the investor's state of residence. This preferential tax treatment makes such bonds particularly attractive to high-net-worth investors seeking to maximize their after-tax return.

History and Origin

The concept of interest from municipal bonds being free from federal income tax dates back to the very origins of the federal income tax system in the United States. When Congress enacted the Revenue Act of 1913, which followed the ratification of the Sixteenth Amendment, it included an explicit exemption for interest earned on state and local government obligations. This was based on the then-prevailing legal doctrine of "reciprocal immunity," which suggested that federal and state governments should not tax each other's activities or instruments.9

Over the decades, this legal interpretation evolved. The U.S. Supreme Court, in South Carolina v. Baker (1988), ultimately clarified that bondholders do not possess a constitutional right to be exempt from federal taxes on municipal bond interest, shifting the justification from a constitutional mandate to a legislative policy choice.8 Despite this ruling, Congress has maintained the federal tax exemption for most municipal bonds. The double tax exempt status arises when the bond is also exempt from the state income tax and, in some cases, local income tax in the jurisdiction where the investor resides and where the bond was issued.

Key Takeaways

  • Double tax exempt investments, primarily municipal bonds, offer interest income free from both federal and state/local income taxes.
  • This tax advantage is generally available when an investor purchases a bond issued by a governmental entity within their own state and sometimes city.
  • The primary beneficiaries of double tax exempt bonds are investors in higher marginal tax brackets.
  • While offering tax benefits, the bond yield on double tax exempt bonds is typically lower than that of comparable taxable bonds.
  • These bonds play a crucial role in financing public infrastructure projects for state and local governments.

Formula and Calculation

While "double tax exempt" describes a tax status, its financial benefit is often quantified using the taxable equivalent yield formula. This formula helps investors compare the return of a tax-exempt bond to that of a taxable bond by calculating what interest rate a taxable bond would need to offer to provide the same after-tax return as the tax-exempt bond.

The formula for taxable equivalent yield is:

Taxable Equivalent Yield=Tax-Exempt Yield1Marginal Tax Rate\text{Taxable Equivalent Yield} = \frac{\text{Tax-Exempt Yield}}{1 - \text{Marginal Tax Rate}}

Where:

  • Tax-Exempt Yield: The stated yield of the double tax exempt bond.
  • Marginal Tax Rate: The investor's combined federal and state (and local, if applicable) income tax rate.

This calculation is critical for sophisticated financial planning.

Interpreting the Double Tax Exempt Benefit

Interpreting the benefit of a double tax exempt investment involves comparing its effective return to that of fully taxable alternatives. Because the interest income from double tax exempt bonds bypasses two layers of taxation, their seemingly lower stated yields can often translate into a higher net return for investors, especially those in higher income tax brackets. The true value lies in the investor's individual tax situation. For instance, an investor in a high federal and state tax bracket will find the double tax exempt status significantly more valuable than an investor in a lower bracket or one residing in a state with no state income tax. Understanding this allows investors to make informed decisions about allocating capital within their investment portfolio.

Hypothetical Example

Consider an investor residing in New York who is evaluating two bond options, both with a face value of $1,000 and a 10-year maturity:

  1. New York State General Obligation Bond (Double Tax Exempt): This bond offers a stated yield of 3.00%. Because it's a New York bond purchased by a New York resident, its interest income is exempt from federal income tax, New York state income tax, and New York City local income tax.
  2. Corporate Bond (Fully Taxable): This bond offers a stated yield of 4.50%. Its interest income is subject to federal, state, and local income taxes.

Assume the investor's combined marginal tax rate (federal, state, and local) is 35%.

Calculation for the Double Tax Exempt Bond:
The after-tax yield is simply 3.00% because no taxes are applied.

Calculation for the Corporate Bond:
After-tax yield = Stated Yield × (1 - Marginal Tax Rate)
After-tax yield = 4.50% × (1 - 0.35)
After-tax yield = 4.50% × 0.65
After-tax yield = 2.925%

In this scenario, even though the double tax exempt bond has a lower nominal yield (3.00% vs. 4.50%), its after-tax return of 3.00% is higher than the corporate bond's 2.925%. This demonstrates the significant advantage of double tax exempt investments for eligible investors.

Practical Applications

Double tax exempt bonds are primarily used by state and local governments to finance public projects such as schools, hospitals, bridges, roads, and utility systems. For investors, they serve as a core component for capital preservation and generating tax-efficient income. The interest from most municipal bonds is exempt from federal income tax. Wh7en these bonds are issued by a state or local government within the investor's own state, the interest is also typically exempt from state and local income taxes, thus achieving double tax exempt status.

T6he Internal Revenue Service (IRS) provides extensive resources and guidance regarding tax-exempt bonds, highlighting the importance of compliance for both issuers and bondholders. Th5e Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board (MSRB) also offers information to help investors understand the municipal securities market, including the characteristics and risks of these investments. Du4e to their tax advantages, double tax exempt bonds are often favored by individuals in high-income tax brackets who seek to reduce their overall tax liability while investing in relatively low-risk fixed-income securities.

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their tax advantages, double tax exempt bonds come with certain limitations and criticisms. One significant drawback is their generally lower stated bond yield compared to comparable taxable bonds. While the tax benefits can make up for this, investors must carefully calculate the taxable equivalent yield to ensure the double tax exempt option truly provides a superior risk-adjusted return.

Furthermore, the tax-exempt status of municipal bonds, including those that are double tax exempt, periodically faces scrutiny from policymakers looking for ways to increase federal revenue. Discussions about limiting or eliminating the exemption for certain types of bonds, such as private activity bonds, emerge during tax reform debates. Wh3ile a complete elimination is often considered unlikely due to the critical role municipal bonds play in funding infrastructure, any curtailment could impact market dynamics., S2u1ch changes could lead to higher borrowing costs for state and local governments and potentially reduce the attractiveness of these bonds to investors. Moreover, while typically low-risk, municipal bonds are not entirely without risk, including interest rate risk and, in rare cases, default risk.

Double Tax Exempt vs. Single Tax Exempt

The distinction between double tax exempt and single tax exempt investments lies in the number of government levels from which the investment's income is shielded from taxation.

FeatureDouble Tax ExemptSingle Tax Exempt
Taxation LevelsExempt from federal, state, and often local income taxes.Exempt from federal income tax, but subject to state/local taxes.
Issuance SourceTypically municipal bonds issued within the investor's state of residence.Municipal bonds issued outside the investor's state of residence, or U.S. Treasury bonds.
Primary BenefitMaximizes after-tax income for investors in states with high income taxes.Provides federal tax relief, but state/local tax implications still exist.

A bond that is double tax exempt offers the most comprehensive tax relief for the investor, assuming they reside in the state of issuance. In contrast, a bond that is single tax exempt (e.g., a municipal bond issued by a different state or a U.S. Treasury bond, which is federal-taxable but state/local tax-exempt) provides a more limited tax advantage. The choice between them often depends on an investor's specific state income tax and local income tax obligations.

FAQs

Q1: What types of investments are typically double tax exempt?

The most common double tax exempt investments are municipal bonds issued by a state or local government within the investor's state of residence. For example, a California resident buying a bond issued by the state of California would typically find its interest income exempt from federal and California state income taxes.

Q2: Do all municipal bonds offer double tax exempt status?

No. While most municipal bonds are exempt from federal income tax, their exemption from state and local income taxes depends on where the bond was issued and where the investor resides. To be double tax exempt, the bond usually must be issued by a government entity within the investor's state of residence. If you buy a municipal bond from a different state, it will typically be exempt from federal tax but subject to that different state's income tax.

Q3: How do I determine if a double tax exempt bond is a good investment for me?

To determine if a double tax exempt bond is suitable, compare its taxable equivalent yield to the yields of taxable alternatives, considering your specific marginal tax bracket (federal, state, and local). This calculation helps you understand the true after-tax return and allows for an "apples-to-apples" comparison. Consulting a financial advisor can help assess your individual tax situation and investment goals.