Skip to main content
← Back to D Definitions

Dumping

What Is Dumping?

Dumping, in the context of international trade, is the practice where a company exports a product at a price lower than its normal value, typically the price it charges in its own domestic market. This falls under the broader category of international trade and is often considered an unfair trade practice, as it can significantly harm domestic industries in the importing country. Governments may impose anti-dumping duties to counteract the negative effects of dumping and protect local businesses from being undercut by artificially low-priced imports.44

History and Origin

Concerns about dumping are not new, with initial responses appearing in the early 20th century. Canada enacted the first national anti-dumping law in 1904 to address the dumping of U.S. steel. The United States followed with its own Anti-Dumping Act in 1916, which targeted predatory pricing. The concept of anti-dumping was later integrated into international trade agreements. Article VI of the 1947 General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) adopted international anti-dumping law, with further elaboration and evolution in subsequent GATT Anti-Dumping Codes.41, 42, 43 The current international framework governing dumping and anti-dumping measures is the Anti-Dumping Agreement of the World Trade Organization (WTO), which came into effect with the establishment of the WTO in 1995 following the Uruguay Round negotiations.38, 39, 40

Key Takeaways

  • Dumping is an international trade practice where a product is exported at a price below its normal value.37
  • It is considered an unfair trade practice due to its potential to harm domestic industries.36
  • Governments often impose anti-dumping duties to offset the effects of dumping.35
  • The World Trade Organization's Anti-Dumping Agreement sets the international rules for addressing dumping.34
  • Investigations involve determining if dumping and material injury to a domestic industry exist.33

Formula and Calculation

The determination of dumping typically involves comparing the export price of a product to its "normal value." The normal value is generally the price of the like product when sold in the ordinary course of trade in the exporting country's domestic market. If domestic sales do not exist or are not usable, the normal value can be based on sales to a third country or a "constructed value" (cost of production plus a reasonable amount for administrative, selling, and general costs, and profits).32

The dumping margin is calculated as:

Dumping Margin=Normal ValueExport Price\text{Dumping Margin} = \text{Normal Value} - \text{Export Price}

A positive dumping margin indicates that dumping is occurring. Anti-dumping duties are then applied up to the amount of this margin, though they can be lower if adequate to remove injury to the domestic industry.30, 31

Interpreting Dumping

When interpreting dumping, the focus is not solely on the price difference itself but on its impact. A product is considered "dumped" if its export price is less than its normal value, and crucially, if this dumping causes or threatens to cause "material injury" to an established domestic industry in the importing country.29 Without a finding of material injury, or the threat of it, anti-dumping measures generally cannot be imposed.28 The assessment of injury considers various economic indicators, such as the volume of dumped imports and their effect on domestic prices.26, 27

Hypothetical Example

Consider a scenario where "GloCo," a manufacturing company in Country A, produces specialized widgets. GloCo sells these widgets in its domestic market for $10 per unit. It then begins exporting the same widgets to Country B for $7 per unit. In Country B, a local company, "LocalWidgets Inc.," also produces similar widgets and sells them for $9 per unit.

LocalWidgets Inc. believes that GloCo is engaging in dumping, which is causing it significant financial harm. They file a petition with the relevant trade authorities in Country B. An investigation is initiated to determine if dumping is occurring and if it is causing material injury to LocalWidgets Inc. and the broader domestic widget industry. If the investigation confirms both dumping and injury, Country B's government may impose an anti-dumping duty on widgets imported from GloCo, effectively increasing their price in Country B to counteract the unfair competition. The duty might be set at $3 per unit, bringing GloCo's price to $10, or potentially lower, such as $2 per unit, if that is deemed sufficient to remove the injury. This measure aims to restore fair market competition.

Practical Applications

Dumping provisions are primarily applied in the realm of international trade law and trade policy. When a domestic industry believes it is being harmed by dumped imports, it can petition its government to initiate an anti-dumping investigation. In the United States, such petitions are filed concurrently with the U.S. Department of Commerce (Commerce) and the U.S. International Trade Commission (USITC).25 Commerce determines if dumping exists and calculates the dumping margin, while the USITC assesses whether the domestic industry has suffered material injury or faces a threat of it due to the dumped imports.23, 24 If both agencies make affirmative determinations, Commerce issues an anti-dumping order, directing U.S. Customs and Border Protection to collect anti-dumping duties on the imported merchandise.21, 22

For example, in May 2024, the U.S. Department of Commerce initiated anti-dumping investigations into crystalline silicon photovoltaic cells from several countries, including Cambodia, Malaysia, Thailand, and Vietnam, following petitions from domestic producers.20 These investigations highlight the ongoing application of anti-dumping measures to address concerns about unfair trade practices and protect domestic production.

Limitations and Criticisms

While anti-dumping measures are intended to ensure fair competition and protect domestic industries, they face several limitations and criticisms. One common critique is that these measures can be overly protectionist, leading to increased costs for consumers in the importing country and potentially triggering retaliatory trade measures from other nations.19 Economists often argue that the imposition of duties can lead to a loss in overall economic welfare, as the reduction in consumer surplus may outweigh the gains for domestic producers.18

Furthermore, the calculation of dumping margins can be highly artificial and may not accurately reflect an exporter's true pricing strategies.17 Critics also suggest that anti-dumping laws are sometimes used as a non-tariff barrier to trade, serving as a form of "regulatory protectionism" rather than a genuine response to unfair practices.15, 16 The complexity of demonstrating a causal link between dumped imports and injury to a domestic industry is also a significant challenge, with some arguing that the World Trade Organization's Anti-Dumping Agreement does not provide sufficiently clear guidelines for these determinations.13, 14

Dumping vs. Subsidies

Dumping and subsidies are both practices that can distort international trade, but they differ in their origin and the nature of the alleged unfairness.12

Dumping occurs when a company sells its products in a foreign market at a price lower than its normal value, often the price in its home market. This is primarily a pricing strategy by a private company.11 The aim of anti-dumping duties is to counteract this price discrimination by the exporting firm.10

Subsidies, on the other hand, involve financial assistance or benefits provided by a government or public body to specific industries or companies. These can take various forms, such as direct payments, tax breaks, or preferential loans, and effectively lower the cost of production or export for the recipient.9 The response to harmful subsidies in international trade is the imposition of countervailing duties, which aim to offset the competitive advantage gained from the subsidy.8 While dumping is about a company's pricing behavior, subsidies are about government intervention that distorts market prices and competition.

FAQs

What is the primary purpose of anti-dumping laws?

The primary purpose of anti-dumping laws is to protect domestic industries from material injury caused by imports that are sold at less than fair value.7 They aim to ensure fair trade practices and prevent foreign companies from unfairly undercutting local businesses.

How is dumping determined?

Dumping is determined by comparing the export price of a product to its "normal value," which is typically the price of a similar product in the exporter's domestic market. If the export price is lower, dumping may be found to exist.6 This involves detailed trade investigations by governmental authorities.

What are the consequences of a finding of dumping?

If dumping is found to exist and it causes or threatens material injury to a domestic industry, the importing country can impose anti-dumping duties on the dumped products.5 These duties are typically in the form of tariffs, increasing the cost of the imported goods to offset the unfair price advantage.

Are all instances of selling below cost considered dumping?

Not necessarily. While selling below cost can be a factor in determining dumping, it is specifically when the export price is below the "normal value" (often the home market price or a constructed value) and causes injury that it is considered dumping under international trade rules.3, 4 The intent to cause harm or destroy an industry, known as predatory pricing, is a particularly harmful form of dumping.

Who investigates dumping allegations?

In many countries, government agencies are responsible for investigating dumping allegations. For example, in the United States, the Department of Commerce investigates whether dumping has occurred and calculates the margin, while the International Trade Commission assesses the injury to the domestic industry.1, 2 These agencies follow specific regulatory frameworks established under national law and international agreements like those of the WTO.