Economic futures contract

What Is an Economic Futures Contract?

An economic futures contract is a standardized legal agreement to buy or sell a specific commodity, financial instrument, or other underlying asset at a predetermined price on a specified future date. These contracts are a key component of the broader derivatives market, deriving their value from the performance of the underlying asset. They enable market participants to manage price risk, speculate on future price movements, and facilitate price discovery. An economic futures contract represents an obligation: the buyer (taking a long position) is obligated to purchase the asset, and the seller (taking a short position) is obligated to deliver it. While historically tied to physical commodities, modern economic futures contracts encompass a wide range of assets, including equity indices, interest rates, and currencies.

History and Origin

The concept of agreeing to buy or sell goods for future delivery dates back centuries, with early forms of forward agreements found in various agrarian societies. One of the earliest documented instances of organized futures trading occurred at the Dōjima Rice Exchange in Japan, established in 1730, where rice futures were traded to help stabilize prices and distribution for samurai who were often paid in rice.,¹⁸,

In the Western world, the formalization of these agreements into what are recognized as modern economic futures contracts began in the mid-19th century in the United States. The Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT), established in 1848, was pivotal in this evolution. It standardized "to arrive" contracts for agricultural commodities like corn and wheat, transforming them into the first exchange-traded futures contracts.,¹⁷,¹⁶ This standardization made contracts more fungible and tradable. The evolution from informal forward agreements to standardized futures contracts helped producers and consumers manage price risk more effectively in an increasingly complex economy.,^{15 14}By the 1970s, the futures industry expanded significantly beyond agriculture to include financial products, with the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) launching currency futures in 1972 and interest rate futures in 1976.,¹³ This marked a new era where economic futures contracts became crucial for hedging financial risks.

Key Takeaways

• An economic futures contract is a binding agreement to buy or sell an asset at a set price on a future date.
• They are standardized and traded on regulated exchanges, ensuring liquidity and transparency.
• Primary uses include hedging against adverse price movements and speculation on future price trends.
• Economic futures contribute to price discovery by reflecting collective market expectations of future supply and demand.
• Most futures contracts are settled financially rather than through physical delivery of the underlying asset.

Interpreting the Economic Futures Contract

Interpreting an economic futures contract involves understanding its key components and what they signal about market expectations. The quoted price of an economic futures contract is not necessarily a direct forecast of the spot price on the delivery date but rather reflects the market's collective expectation, considering factors like interest rates, storage costs (for physical commodities), and anticipated supply and demand dynamics.

Traders and analysts observe the relationship between different futures contract prices for the same underlying asset across various expiration months (known as the "futures curve"). A market where later-dated futures contracts trade at higher prices than nearer-dated ones is in "contango," often seen in commodity markets with storage costs. Conversely, "backwardation" occurs when later-dated contracts trade at lower prices, which might indicate immediate supply shortages or high demand. Understanding these relationships provides insights into market sentiment and expectations regarding future volatility and fundamental supply/demand balances. The convergence of futures prices to the spot price as the contract approaches expiration is a critical mechanism ensuring market efficiency.

Hypothetical Example

Consider an airline company, "AeroFleet," that anticipates needing 100,000 barrels of jet fuel in six months. AeroFleet is concerned that the price of crude oil, a primary input for jet fuel, might rise significantly over this period, increasing their operational costs. To mitigate this risk management challenge, AeroFleet decides to use an economic futures contract.

The current spot price for crude oil is $70 per barrel. AeroFleet's financial team observes that a crude oil futures contract, expiring in six months, is trading at $72 per barrel. AeroFleet decides to buy 100 crude oil futures contracts (each representing 1,000 barrels) at $72 per barrel.

Six months later, there are two possible scenarios:

• Scenario 1: Crude oil prices rise. The spot price for crude oil has risen to $80 per barrel. AeroFleet now pays $80 per barrel for its jet fuel on the physical market. However, the futures contracts AeroFleet bought at $72 are now worth $80, yielding a profit of $8 per barrel (or $800,000 for 100,000 barrels) from its futures position. This profit largely offsets the increased cost of buying jet fuel in the spot market, effectively "locking in" a price near $72 per barrel for their fuel.
• Scenario 2: Crude oil prices fall. The spot price for crude oil has fallen to $65 per barrel. AeroFleet buys jet fuel for $65 per barrel, which is cheaper than anticipated. However, the futures contracts they bought at $72 are now worth $65, resulting in a loss of $7 per barrel (or $700,000 for 100,000 barrels) on their futures position. Despite this loss, the airline still benefits from the lower price of physical jet fuel.

In both scenarios, the use of the economic futures contract helped AeroFleet achieve a more predictable fuel cost, reducing the uncertainty associated with fluctuating oil prices.

Practical Applications

Economic futures contracts are widely utilized across various sectors for diverse financial purposes. Their most fundamental role is to provide a mechanism for hedging against future price movements, allowing businesses and investors to mitigate uncertainty. For example, a farmer might sell grain futures to lock in a price for their upcoming harvest, protecting against a potential price drop. Conversely, a food processing company might buy grain futures to secure a future input cost, safeguarding against price increases.,^12
11
Beyond agricultural commodities, economic futures are crucial in energy markets, where producers and consumers of oil and natural gas use them to manage revenue and expense volatility. In financial markets, interest rate futures are employed by banks and institutional investors to hedge against changes in interest rates that could impact bond portfolios or lending activities. ¹⁰Similarly, currency futures allow international businesses to manage foreign exchange rate risk, ensuring predictable costs for imports or revenues from exports. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), an independent U.S. government agency, regulates these markets to ensure integrity and protect the public from fraud and manipulation.,⁹ Furthermore, portfolio managers may use equity index futures for diversification or to gain broad market exposure without directly trading individual stocks, which can be useful for tactical asset allocation.

Limitations and Criticisms

While economic futures contracts offer significant benefits for risk management and price discovery, they also come with limitations and criticisms. One primary concern is the potential for substantial losses due to leverage. Futures contracts typically require only a small percentage of the contract's total value as initial margin, meaning a small price movement against a position can lead to significant percentage losses, potentially exceeding the initial investment. This inherent leverage makes futures trading high-risk.

Another criticism revolves around the debate regarding the efficiency of futures markets. While proponents argue that futures prices are efficient forecasts of future spot prices, empirical research has shown mixed results, with some studies suggesting that expected excess returns to speculation may sometimes be non-zero.,⁸,^{7 6}This suggests that while futures markets serve an insurance role by allowing the diversification of commodity price risk, their forecasting ability might not always be perfect.

Historically, periods of financial deregulation have sometimes been associated with increased risks in derivatives markets. For instance, the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000 (CFMA) removed regulatory oversight from certain over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives, which some argue contributed to the conditions leading to the 2008 financial crisis. ⁵In response, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 granted the CFTC enhanced authority to regulate the swaps market, aiming to bring greater transparency and reduce systemic risk by requiring standardized derivatives to be traded on regulated exchanges and moved into central clearing houses. ⁴Despite these regulatory efforts, the complexity of modern financial instruments and the global interconnectedness of markets continue to present challenges in preventing market manipulation or unintended consequences.

Economic Futures Contract vs. Forward Contract

An economic futures contract is often confused with a forward contract, as both involve an agreement to buy or sell an asset at a predetermined price on a future date. However, key differences exist between the two:

The standardization and exchange trading of economic futures contracts contribute to their transparency and ease of trading, making them a preferred instrument for risk management and speculation for a broad range of market participants. Forward contracts, while offering customization, are more susceptible to counterparty risk and are typically used by businesses with specific, tailored hedging needs.

FAQs

What is the primary purpose of an economic futures contract?

The primary purpose of an economic futures contract is to allow parties to hedge against price risk or to speculate on future price movements of an underlying asset. They help market participants lock in prices for future transactions, providing certainty in an environment of fluctuating market conditions.

Are economic futures contracts always settled by physical delivery?

No, most economic futures contracts are not settled by physical delivery of the underlying asset. Instead, they are typically cash-settsettled or closed out (offset) before their expiration date. This means that buyers and sellers unwind their positions by taking an opposite trade, with only the profit or loss from price changes being exchanged.,³

Who regulates economic futures markets in the U.S.?

In the United States, economic futures markets are primarily regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). The CFTC's role is to protect market participants and the public from fraud, manipulation, and abusive practices, ensuring the integrity and transparency of the futures and options markets.,^2
1

Can individual investors trade economic futures contracts?

Yes, individual investors can trade economic futures contracts, typically through brokerage firms that offer access to futures markets. However, due to the inherent leverage and volatility associated with futures, they are generally considered high-risk instruments and may not be suitable for all investors. It's crucial for individuals to understand the risks involved before engaging in futures trading.