Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to F Definitions

Fear and greed index

What Is the Fear and Greed Index?

The Fear and Greed Index is a market sentiment indicator that measures the two primary emotions, fear and greed, that influence investor behavior in the stock market. It falls under the umbrella of behavioral finance, a field that studies the psychological influences and cognitive biases affecting financial decision-making. The index aims to quantify how much these powerful emotions are driving the market, typically ranging from 0 (Extreme Fear) to 100 (Extreme Greed). A higher score suggests widespread greed, indicating that investors may be overpaying for assets, while a lower score reflects pervasive fear, potentially signaling oversold conditions.

History and Origin

The Fear and Greed Index was originally developed by CNNMoney (now CNN Business) to provide a unique perspective on the underlying emotions swaying the stock market. Its creation stemmed from the understanding that while fundamental factors drive long-term value, short-term market movements are often influenced by the collective psychological state of investors. This tool brought together various disparate market indicators to create a composite measure, offering a snapshot of investor sentiment at any given time. The index compiles data from several key components, each reflecting a different aspect of market behavior, to provide a holistic view of the prevailing emotional climate. The official CNN Business website continues to host and update the index regularly.9

Key Takeaways

  • The Fear and Greed Index quantifies market emotions, ranging from 0 (Extreme Fear) to 100 (Extreme Greed).
  • It is a composite indicator derived from seven different market behaviors, each weighted equally.
  • The index is often used by market participants as a contrarian investing signal, suggesting potential buying opportunities during extreme fear and caution during extreme greed.
  • It operates on the premise that emotions can lead to irrational market behavior, deviating from the assumptions of the efficient market hypothesis.
  • While useful for gauging sentiment, the Fear and Greed Index should be used in conjunction with other forms of financial analysis rather than as a standalone predictor.

Formula and Calculation

The Fear and Greed Index is a composite index that aggregates data from seven equally weighted indicators. Each indicator is measured by how much it deviates from its average performance, normalized to a score between 0 and 100. A score of 0 represents maximum fear, and 100 represents maximum greed.

The seven components are:

  1. Market Momentum: Measures the S&P 500's performance relative to its 125-day moving average. A strong upward trend indicates greed, while a downward trend suggests fear.
  2. Stock Price Strength: Compares the number of stocks hitting 52-week highs versus 52-week lows on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). More highs signal greed, more lows signal fear.
  3. Stock Price Breadth: Analyzes the trading volume in advancing stocks versus declining stocks on the NYSE. Higher advancing volume suggests greed, while higher declining volume indicates fear.8
  4. Put and Call Options: Examines the put/call ratio, which compares the trading volume of put options (bets on falling prices) to call options (bets on rising prices). A higher volume of puts relative to calls implies fear, while the opposite suggests greed.
  5. Market Volatility: Uses the Cboe Volatility Index (VIX) to measure market fear. The VIX is often referred to as the "fear index." A higher VIX typically indicates greater fear.7,6
  6. Safe Haven Demand: Compares the performance of stocks versus safe haven assets like bonds. If bonds outperform stocks, it suggests investors are seeking safety (fear), whereas stock outperformance indicates risk-taking (greed).
  7. Junk Bond Demand: Measures the spread between yields on investment-grade bonds and junk bonds. A narrower spread suggests investors are more willing to take on risk (greed), while a wider spread indicates fear.5

Each of these components is scored, and their average forms the final Fear and Greed Index value.

Interpreting the Fear and Greed Index

Interpreting the Fear and Greed Index involves understanding its scale and what various readings imply about market psychology. The index typically operates on a scale from 0 to 100, categorized into distinct zones:

  • 0-24: Extreme Fear – At this level, widespread panic and pessimism dominate the market. Investors may be selling off assets irrationally. This often signals a potential buying opportunity for long-term investors, as assets may be undervalued due to emotional selling.
  • 25-49: Fear – Investors are cautious and apprehensive, leading to subdued market activity or moderate selling.
  • 50: Neutral – This level indicates a balanced market where fear and greed are in equilibrium, and prices may reflect underlying economic data more directly.
  • 51-74: Greed – Optimism is rising, and investors are becoming more confident. This can lead to increased buying pressure.
  • 75-100: Extreme Greed – Euphoria and excessive optimism characterize the market. Prices may be inflated as investors eagerly bid up assets, often disregarding underlying fundamental analysis. This level can signal a potential market top or a forthcoming correction.

Many investors use the Fear and Greed Index as a contrarian indicator. When the index shows "Extreme Fear," it might suggest that the market has oversold, creating a chance for investors to buy at lower prices. Conversely, when the index indicates "Extreme Greed," it could signal that the market is overbought and due for a correction, prompting investors to consider taking profits or exercising caution.

Hypothetical Example

Consider a scenario in late 202X where the Fear and Greed Index registers a value of 15, indicating "Extreme Fear." This low reading is driven by several factors: the S&P 500 has been consistently trading below its 125-day moving average (low market momentum), there's a significant imbalance of stocks hitting 52-week lows over highs (poor stock price strength), and the VIX has surged to unusually high levels, signaling elevated market volatility.

An investor adhering to a contrarian approach might view this "Extreme Fear" reading as a potential signal to explore buying opportunities. They would then conduct thorough research, perhaps using technical analysis to identify oversold securities or sectors. For instance, they might identify a company with strong underlying fundamentals whose stock price has been unfairly punished by the general market panic. While the Fear and Greed Index provides the initial emotional context, the subsequent investment decision would still rely on a detailed assessment of individual assets and a sound asset allocation strategy.

Practical Applications

The Fear and Greed Index serves several practical applications for investors and analysts:

  • Gauging Market Psychology: It provides a quick and easily digestible snapshot of the prevailing emotional state in the stock market. This can help investors understand whether rational decision-making or emotional impulses are currently dominating trading activity.
  • Contrarian Signal: As noted, it's often employed as a contrarian indicator. During periods of "Extreme Fear," experienced investors might view oversold conditions as a chance to buy, while "Extreme Greed" could suggest caution or profit-taking.
  • Risk Management: By understanding the emotional temperature of the market, investors can adjust their risk exposure. For example, during times of extreme greed, one might reduce exposure to highly speculative assets.
  • Complementary Tool: The Fear and Greed Index is not a standalone trading signal but rather a tool to be used in conjunction with other forms of analysis. It can inform a broader investment strategy by providing a behavioral context. For example, a Reuters report on general market sentiment, such as stocks surging after a trade agreement due to lifted sentiment, illustrates how collective mood can directly impact market performance, reinforcing the index's utility. Academic 4research has also increasingly confirmed the importance of sentiment in asset pricing and its potential to influence stock returns.,

Limi3t2ations and Criticisms

While the Fear and Greed Index offers valuable insights into market psychology, it has several limitations and faces criticisms:

  • Subjectivity of Components: Although quantitative, the selection and weighting of its seven components involve a degree of subjectivity. Different sentiment indicators might use alternative metrics or assign different weights, leading to varying results.
  • Lagging vs. Leading Indicator: Like many indicators, the Fear and Greed Index can sometimes be a lagging indicator, reflecting sentiment after price movements have already occurred rather than predicting them. This challenges its utility for precise timing of market entries or exits.
  • Correlation vs. Causation: While there's a recognized correlation between extreme sentiment and market reversals, it's not a direct causal relationship. Other macroeconomic factors, geopolitical events, or unexpected news can also trigger significant market shifts independent of emotional readings.
  • No Guarantee of Outcomes: The index does not guarantee future market performance. A period of extreme fear might deepen, or extreme greed might persist longer than anticipated, leading to losses if acted upon without other confirming signals. Market participants should avoid relying solely on the Fear and Greed Index for investment decisions.
  • Oversimplification of Emotions: Reducing complex market dynamics to just "fear" and "greed" can be an oversimplification of the myriad psychological biases (e.g., herding behavior, confirmation bias) that influence investors. Academic research highlights the complexity of investor irrationality and how sentiment can be heterogeneous among different types of investors.

Fear 1and Greed Index vs. Investor Sentiment

While often used interchangeably in casual conversation, the Fear and Greed Index is a specific measure of investor sentiment. Investor sentiment is a broader term referring to the overall attitude of investors toward a particular market or financial asset. It reflects their collective psychological mood and expectations, encompassing optimism, pessimism, or neutrality. This broader concept can be influenced by news, economic reports, geopolitical events, and even social media.

The Fear and Greed Index, by contrast, is a proprietary, quantitative tool that attempts to quantify this abstract concept of investor sentiment. It does so by combining several distinct market indicators, each representing a facet of fear or greed. So, while the Fear and Greed Index provides a numerical representation and categorized range (Extreme Fear, Fear, Neutral, Greed, Extreme Greed) for sentiment, investor sentiment itself is the underlying, pervasive feeling that the index seeks to measure. Many other methods and indicators also attempt to measure investor sentiment, such as surveys (e.g., the American Association of Individual Investors survey), options activity, or news analysis.

FAQs

What does a high reading on the Fear and Greed Index mean?

A high reading (e.g., above 75, indicating "Extreme Greed") suggests that investors are overly optimistic and confident, potentially leading to inflated asset prices. This could be a signal for increased caution or a potential market correction.

What does a low reading on the Fear and Greed Index mean?

A low reading (e.g., below 25, indicating "Extreme Fear") signifies widespread panic and pessimism. This often occurs during market downturns and may suggest that assets are oversold, potentially creating attractive buying opportunities for long-term investors.

Can the Fear and Greed Index predict market movements?

The Fear and Greed Index is a sentiment indicator, not a definitive predictive tool. While extreme readings often precede market reversals, it cannot precisely predict the timing or magnitude of such movements. It should be used as one piece of information within a comprehensive investment strategy, alongside quantitative analysis and qualitative factors.

Is the Fear and Greed Index only for the stock market?

While the most well-known Fear and Greed Index is for the U.S. stock market (developed by CNN Business), similar sentiment indices have been created for other markets, including cryptocurrencies. These adapt the underlying methodology to relevant indicators within their respective asset classes.