Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to F Definitions

First mover advantage

What Is First Mover Advantage?

First mover advantage (FMA) refers to the competitive edge gained by a company that is the initial significant occupant of a market segment, or the first to introduce a new product or service to a market. This concept falls under the broader umbrella of strategic management and business strategy. Being a first mover can enable a company to establish strong brand recognition, capture significant market share, and foster deep customer loyalty before competitors emerge.84, 85, 86 However, the notion of a definitive first mover advantage is debated, as pioneers often face substantial risks and costs.82, 83

History and Origin

The concept of first mover advantage was popularized by Marvin Lieberman and David Montgomery in their seminal 1988 paper, "First Mover Advantages," which received an award from the Strategic Management Society in 1996.80, 81 Their work provided a theoretical framework for understanding how firms could benefit from early market entry.78, 79 While the term was coined in the late 20th century to explain the success of some pioneering companies, the underlying observations about the benefits of early market entry have existed for much longer.77

Lieberman and Montgomery further explored the nuances of this theory in a 1998 follow-up paper, "First-Mover (Dis)Advantages: Retrospective and Link with the Resource-Based View," acknowledging the complexities and potential drawbacks of being a first mover.76 Despite this, the intuitive appeal of FMA has led it to remain a frequently discussed concept in business strategy.74, 75

Key Takeaways

  • First mover advantage is the benefit gained by a company that is first to market with a new product or service.71, 72, 73
  • Key benefits include establishing brand recognition, capturing market share, setting industry standards, and creating barriers to entry for competitors.69, 70
  • First movers often face significant challenges such as high research and development costs, market education expenses, and the risk of technological obsolescence.66, 67, 68
  • Success as a first mover is not guaranteed and requires continuous innovation and adaptation.64, 65
  • The concept is often contrasted with the "fast follower" strategy, which involves learning from the pioneer's mistakes.62, 63

Formula and Calculation

First mover advantage is a qualitative concept in competitive advantage and does not have a specific mathematical formula for calculation. Its evaluation typically involves assessing various factors such as market share growth, brand equity, patent protection, and the ability to dictate industry standards. Financial metrics, such as early revenue generation and long-term profitability compared to later entrants, are often used to gauge the economic impact of being a first mover.

Interpreting the First Mover Advantage

Interpreting first mover advantage involves evaluating the tangible and intangible benefits a pioneering company secures by being first to market. When a company achieves FMA, it often enjoys several advantages. One key aspect is the ability to shape consumer preferences and become synonymous with the product category itself, much like Kleenex became a common term for disposable tissues.61 This strong association can lead to increased customer loyalty and makes it more challenging for later entrants to compete effectively.60

Furthermore, a successful first mover can preempt rivals in acquiring crucial resources, such as prime locations or supply chain partnerships.58, 59 This preemption can create significant barriers to entry, limiting the competitive landscape for subsequent firms.56, 57

Hypothetical Example

Consider a hypothetical startup, "HydroFleet," that develops the first commercially viable electric-powered freight trucks designed for long-haul transportation. By being the first to introduce this technology, HydroFleet immediately captures public and industry attention. They secure exclusive contracts with major logistics companies, establish a vast network of charging stations along key trucking routes, and obtain patents for their unique battery and propulsion systems. This early market presence allows HydroFleet to define the technical standards for the nascent electric freight industry.

Even when competitors eventually emerge, HydroFleet's strong brand recognition and established infrastructure make it difficult for new entrants to gain significant traction. The high initial investment in research and development and infrastructure development that HydroFleet undertook, while risky, ultimately yielded substantial market dominance and profitable operations.

Practical Applications

First mover advantage is observed across various industries, impacting how companies approach innovation and market entry. In the technology sector, companies like Google, by pioneering sophisticated search algorithms, gained an early lead that solidified their position as the dominant search engine.53, 54, 55 Similarly, Amazon's early foray into online retail allowed it to establish substantial market share and customer loyalty, even selling books below cost initially to build its base.50, 51, 52 Tesla leveraged its first mover status in high-performance electric vehicles, differentiating itself from traditional automakers.47, 48, 49

Beyond technology, FMA can be seen in consumer goods. Coca-Cola, while not the absolute first fizzy drink, became a first mover by rapidly gaining the largest market share and establishing its brand as a household name.45, 46 These examples highlight how establishing strong brand identity, securing key resources, and setting industry standards can create a lasting competitive advantage.43, 44

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its theoretical appeal, first mover advantage is not without limitations and criticisms. Pioneers often bear significant costs and risks associated with educating the market about a new product or service and developing entirely new production and distribution channels.40, 41, 42 This can be expensive and time-consuming, and there is no guarantee of market acceptance.37, 38, 39 For instance, Xerox, while pioneering the plain-paper photocopier, eventually lost its dominant position to later entrants who learned from Xerox's initial challenges and offered more affordable and reliable products.36

Another significant drawback is the potential for technological obsolescence. First movers might invest heavily in a technology that rapidly becomes outdated, allowing later entrants to "leapfrog" them with superior or more cost-effective solutions.34, 35 Critics also point to the "free-rider effect," where followers can benefit from the first mover's investments in research and development and market education without incurring the same initial expenses.32, 33

Furthermore, the "first-mover disadvantage" highlights instances where being first proves detrimental. Google Glass, an early wearable computer, faced issues with immature technology, privacy concerns, and unclear use cases, leading to its discontinuation.31 This illustrates that even well-resourced companies can struggle as first movers if they are too far ahead of market readiness or fail to adapt to changing consumer needs.30 The long-standing debate suggests that for every study proving first mover advantages, there is one that disputes it, indicating that there is no optimal timing for market entry in all situations.28, 29

First Mover Advantage vs. Second Mover Advantage

First mover advantage and second mover advantage represent contrasting market entry strategies, each with its own set of potential benefits and drawbacks. First mover advantage is the competitive edge gained by being the first to introduce a product, service, or business model to a market. This can lead to benefits such as establishing brand recognition, securing prime resources, and setting industry standards.27 Companies aiming for first mover status often invest heavily in research and development to innovate and capture early market share.25, 26

In contrast, a second mover advantage (also known as a fast follower strategy) refers to the benefits enjoyed by a company that enters a market after the pioneer. These firms can learn from the first mover's mistakes, observe market reception, and often enter with an improved, more refined, or more cost-effective product.22, 23, 24 For example, while MySpace was an early social networking site, Facebook, as a later entrant, leveraged lessons learned to create a more robust and scalable platform, ultimately dominating the market.20, 21 Second movers may also avoid the high costs of market education and technology development borne by the pioneer.18, 19 The choice between these strategies depends heavily on the specific industry, market risk, and the capabilities of the entering firm.

FAQs

What are the main benefits of being a first mover?

The primary benefits of being a first mover include the ability to establish strong brand recognition and customer loyalty, capture a significant market share before competitors, define industry standards, and potentially secure intellectual property like patents.16, 17 Additionally, first movers may achieve economies of scale due to early production volume.15

What are the risks of being a first mover?

Being a first mover carries significant risks, such as high research and development costs, the need to educate the market about a new product or service, and uncertainty about consumer acceptance.12, 13, 14 There's also the risk of technological obsolescence if the initial technology is quickly surpassed, and the "free-rider effect" where competitors benefit from the pioneer's efforts.10, 11

Can a second mover outperform a first mover?

Yes, a second mover can often outperform a first mover.9 This typically occurs when the second mover learns from the pioneer's mistakes, introduces an improved or more affordable product, or enters the market at a more opportune time when consumer demand is clearer.6, 7, 8 This is often referred to as a "fast follower" strategy.

Is first mover advantage always desirable?

No, first mover advantage is not always desirable. While it offers potential benefits, the substantial costs, high market risk, and the potential for a "first-mover disadvantage" mean that being first does not guarantee success.4, 5 The optimal market entry strategy depends on various factors, including the industry dynamics and the firm's specific resources and capabilities.1, 2, 3