Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to F Definitions

Floating charge

What Is a Floating Charge?

A floating charge is a type of security interest granted by a company to a creditor, typically a lender, over a fluctuating pool of its assets. Unlike a fixed charge, which attaches to specific, identifiable assets (like land or machinery), a floating charge "hovers" over a general class of assets that change in the ordinary course of business, such as inventory, receivables, or cash. This allows the company to continue trading and dealing with these assets without needing the lender's consent for each transaction. The concept is a crucial element within secured lending, a broader category of corporate finance. A floating charge provides a lien over these changing assets, becoming fixed only upon the occurrence of a specified event, known as "crystallization," which typically happens when the company enters insolvency or defaults on its loan.

History and Origin

The concept of the floating charge is largely a creation of English common law, developed by judges in the 19th century to address the practical difficulties businesses faced when trying to secure loans against circulating assets like stock. Before its emergence, traditional fixed charges were impractical for such assets, as they would restrict a company's ability to trade. The first specific judicial recognition of the floating charge is often attributed to Lord Jessel in 1879, although the concept had been discussed and applied in various forms in earlier cases, such as Re Panama, New Zealand, and Australian Royal Mail Co (1870). This judicial activism was driven by the need for a flexible form of collateral that allowed companies to continue their day-to-day operations while providing lenders with security12.

The legal framework for floating charges has since been codified and refined by legislation, such as the Companies Act 2006 in the UK, which addresses their registration and certain aspects of their operation11. Despite its common law origins, the floating charge has become a cornerstone of modern corporate debt financing, allowing businesses to leverage their dynamic assets for capital.

Key Takeaways

  • A floating charge is a security interest over a class of fluctuating assets, such as inventory and receivables.
  • It allows a company to deal with these assets in the ordinary course of business without prior consent from the lender.
  • The charge "crystallizes" and becomes a fixed charge on specific assets upon an event like company insolvency or default.
  • Floating charges are common in jurisdictions that recognize English common law principles.
  • They provide a significant advantage to lenders compared to being an unsecured creditor, though they rank lower than fixed charges and certain preferential creditors in insolvency.

Interpreting the Floating Charge

A floating charge is interpreted as a dynamic security that adapts to the changing nature of a company's business. Its primary purpose is to provide lenders with a robust security interest over assets that are continuously being bought, sold, and replaced, such as stock or book debts. The "floating" nature means that it does not attach to individual assets until a specific event triggers its "crystallization." Until then, the company has the freedom to manage its assets, which is crucial for operational flexibility.

The existence of a floating charge signals that a company has used a significant portion of its movable assets as collateral for financing. When considering a company's financial health, it is important to understand which assets are encumbered by such charges, as this impacts the pool of assets available to other creditors in the event of financial distress or liquidation.

Hypothetical Example

Imagine "GreenTech Innovations Ltd.," a company that manufactures and sells renewable energy components. To expand its production, GreenTech needs a substantial loan. A bank agrees to provide the loan but requires security. Given that GreenTech's most valuable assets are its constantly changing inventory of raw materials, work-in-progress, and finished goods, along with its trade receivables, a floating charge is an ideal solution.

The bank registers a floating charge over GreenTech's entire undertaking and current assets. This allows GreenTech to continue buying new raw materials, converting them into components, selling finished products, and collecting payments from customers. The floating charge "floats" over this pool of assets, adapting as inventory levels and customer debts fluctuate. If GreenTech successfully repays the loan, the floating charge is discharged. However, if GreenTech faces severe financial difficulties and enters administration, the floating charge would "crystallize," attaching to all the specific assets in the defined class at that moment, giving the bank priority over unsecured creditors regarding those assets.

Practical Applications

Floating charges are widely used in commercial lending, particularly for businesses with significant circulating assets. They are a common feature of debenture agreements, which are often used by companies to raise capital.

Key practical applications include:

  • Asset-Backed Lending: A floating charge is central to asset-backed lending, where the loan is secured by a company's movable assets like inventory or accounts receivable. This enables businesses that lack significant fixed assets to secure financing.
  • Working Capital Financing: Companies often use floating charges to secure lines of credit or other facilities that provide working capital. The flexibility of the charge aligns with the dynamic nature of short-term operational funding.
  • Corporate Restructuring: In situations of corporate restructuring or turnaround, existing floating charges play a critical role in determining the hierarchy of creditors and the distribution of assets.
  • Registration Requirements: In jurisdictions like the UK, floating charges must be registered with the Companies House within a specific timeframe (e.g., 21 days from creation) to be valid against a liquidator, administrator, and other creditors10. This public registration provides transparency, allowing potential trade creditors to assess a company's existing encumbrances before engaging in business9.

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their utility, floating charges have several limitations and have been subject to criticism, primarily concerning their impact on other creditors during insolvency.

  • Priority Ranking: A significant disadvantage for the holder of a floating charge is its lower priority in insolvency compared to a fixed charge. In the event of insolvency, assets secured by fixed charges are satisfied first. Additionally, certain "preferential creditors," such as employees (for unpaid wages) and, in some jurisdictions, government bodies (for taxes), rank ahead of floating charge holders8. Furthermore, a "prescribed part" of the company's net property subject to a floating charge must be set aside for distribution to unsecured creditors before the floating charge holder can recover their debt7.
  • Vulnerability to Dissipation: Before crystallization, the company retains the right to deal with the assets. While this flexibility is beneficial, it also presents a risk that the value of the charged assets could be dissipated or reduced, potentially leaving less for the floating charge holder to recover upon insolvency6.
  • Automatic Crystallization Challenges: While security documents often include "automatic crystallization" clauses, their effectiveness has been subject to judicial scrutiny and varies across jurisdictions.
  • Avoidance Provisions: Under insolvency law, such as Section 245 of the UK Insolvency Act 1986, a floating charge created within a specific period before the onset of insolvency may be wholly or partially void if no new value was provided to the company at the time or after its creation5. This provision aims to prevent companies from granting floating charges to existing unsecured creditors shortly before insolvency, thereby unfairly improving that creditor's position4.

Floating Charge vs. Fixed Charge

The distinction between a floating charge and a fixed charge is fundamental in company law and secured lending. A fixed charge attaches to a specific, identifiable asset that remains static or whose disposal is strictly controlled by the lender. Examples include a mortgage over a specific piece of land or a charge over a particular piece of machinery. The company generally cannot dispose of or deal with a fixed-charge asset without the lender's explicit permission. In contrast, a floating charge is placed over a class of assets that are constantly changing, such as inventory or accounts receivable, allowing the company to trade with these assets freely until a specific event (crystallization) occurs.

The key difference lies in the level of control and the specific assets covered. A fixed charge provides the lender with a higher degree of control and priority in insolvency because it attaches to definite property from the outset. A floating charge, while offering flexibility to the borrower, is inherently less secure in terms of its initial attachment to specific assets and its ranking in the event of insolvency3. While a fixed charge gives a lender strong rights over an asset, a floating charge allows the borrower to continue operating its business normally until default or insolvency, at which point it converts into a fixed charge over the assets then existing2.

FAQs

What assets can a floating charge be placed over?

A floating charge can be placed over a class of assets that change in the ordinary course of business, such as a company's inventory, raw materials, work-in-progress, finished goods, trade receivables, and cash. It typically covers assets that are regularly bought, sold, or converted.

What does it mean for a floating charge to "crystallize"?

Crystallization is the process by which a floating charge transforms into a fixed charge. This typically occurs when a company defaults on its loan, enters insolvency proceedings (like liquidation or administration), or triggers a specific event outlined in the security agreement. Once crystallized, the charge attaches to the specific assets existing within the defined class at that moment, and the company can no longer deal with them freely.

Is a floating charge more secure than an unsecured loan?

Yes, a floating charge provides a lender with significantly more security than an unsecured loan. In the event of a company's insolvency, a floating charge holder has a legal right to the proceeds of the charged assets, ranking above unsecured creditors, although it ranks below fixed charges and certain preferential claims.

Can individuals grant a floating charge?

Generally, floating charges can only be granted by companies or other legal entities, such as Limited Liability Partnerships. In most common law jurisdictions, individuals or partnerships are not permitted to grant floating charges; attempts to do so would typically be void as a general assignment in bankruptcy.

Are floating charges common in other countries?

Floating charges are primarily a feature of English common law and are common in countries that have adopted similar legal systems, such as Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and various Commonwealth nations. While other jurisdictions, like the United States, have mechanisms for securing present and future assets (e.g., under the Uniform Commercial Code, or UCC), the specific concept of a "floating charge" with its unique crystallization process is distinct to these common law systems1.