Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to F Definitions

Fund structures

What Are Fund Structures?

Fund structures refer to the legal and operational frameworks under which pooled investment vehicles are organized and managed. These structures dictate how capital is raised, how investments are made, how assets are held, and how investors can buy and sell their interests. In the broader field of investment management, understanding various fund structures is critical for both investors and financial professionals, as each structure carries distinct implications for liquidity, regulation, transparency, and investor eligibility. Fund structures facilitate the collective investment of capital from multiple parties, allowing for professional management and diversification across various securities and asset classes.

History and Origin

The concept of pooled investments has roots stretching back centuries, with some historians tracing early forms to 18th-century Dutch merchants who created investment trusts to diversify risk. Early investment companies also emerged in Switzerland and Scotland in the 19th century. In the United States, the first modern mutual funds began to appear in the 1920s, with the MFS Massachusetts Investors’ Trust launching in 1924, pioneering innovations like a simplified capital structure and continuous share offerings.

The rapid growth and increasing complexity of these early pooled investment vehicles, particularly after the stock market crash of 1929, highlighted a need for robust regulation to protect investors and ensure transparency. This led to the enactment of the Investment Company Act of 1940. This landmark legislation, overseen by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), established a framework for regulating investment companies, including mutual funds, closed-end funds, and unit investment trusts. T7, 8he Investment Company Institute (ICI), a global association representing regulated funds, was established in the same year to assist in administering the act and promote ethical standards within the industry.

6## Key Takeaways

  • Fund structures define the legal and operational setup of pooled investment vehicles.
  • Common structures include mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), closed-end funds, hedge funds, and private equity funds.
  • Regulatory oversight, such as that provided by the SEC, significantly impacts the design and operation of different fund structures.
  • Key distinctions between fund structures often relate to liquidity, fee arrangements, investor eligibility, and transparency.
  • Understanding these structures is crucial for investors to align their investment goals with appropriate vehicle types.

Interpreting Fund Structures

Interpreting different fund structures involves understanding their core characteristics and how they impact an investor's experience. For instance, open-end fund structures, like mutual funds and exchange-traded funds, are designed for daily liquidity, allowing investors to buy or sell shares at their net asset value (NAV) at the end of each trading day (for mutual funds) or throughout the day on an exchange (for ETFs). This contrasts with closed-end fund structures, which typically trade on exchanges like stocks and whose market price can deviate from their NAV.

For less regulated fund structures, such as hedge funds and private equity funds, interpretation often hinges on the specific terms of their offering documents and the discretion granted to the investment adviser. These structures may offer limited liquidity, complex fee arrangements, and are typically accessible only to accredited investors due to their higher risk profiles and less stringent regulatory requirements. Investors must carefully review the prospectus or offering memorandum to understand the specific rules governing each fund structure.

Hypothetical Example

Consider two investors, Alice and Bob, each looking to invest $10,000.

Alice chooses a mutual fund: She invests in a diversified equity mutual fund. This fund structure is an "open-end" company, meaning new shares are created when she invests, and existing shares are redeemed when she sells. She places an order, and the transaction is executed at the fund's net asset value calculated at the end of the trading day. Her ownership is a percentage of the entire pooled portfolio. She receives regular updates and a simplified tax statement, and she can typically sell her shares on any business day.

Bob chooses a private equity fund: Bob, an accredited investor, invests his $10,000 in a private equity fund structured as a limited partnership. Unlike Alice's mutual fund, this private equity fund has a "closed-end" structure with a fixed investment period (e.g., 10 years). Bob's capital is committed over time as the fund identifies investment opportunities in private companies. He cannot redeem his investment daily; instead, his liquidity is tied to the fund's distributions as its underlying investments are sold. His ownership is a limited partner interest, and he receives detailed, less frequent reports. The private equity fund structure involves a different fee model and a longer-term commitment.

Practical Applications

Fund structures are fundamental to how financial markets operate and enable various investment strategies:

  • Retail Investing: Mutual funds and exchange-traded funds are widely used fund structures for individual investors seeking professional management and diversification. They offer daily liquidity and are subject to extensive regulation under the Investment Company Act of 1940, ensuring transparency through standardized disclosures.
  • Institutional Investing: Pension funds, endowments, and sovereign wealth funds often utilize more complex fund structures like hedge funds and private equity funds to access alternative asset classes and potentially higher returns. These structures typically involve longer lock-up periods and are designed for sophisticated investors.
  • Wealth Management: Wealth managers leverage various fund structures to build tailored portfolios for their clients, balancing risk, return, and liquidity needs. The choice of fund structure depends on the client's financial goals, risk tolerance, and regulatory eligibility.
  • Regulatory Compliance: The legal framework of a fund structure determines the compliance burden. For example, registered investment companies face rigorous reporting and disclosure requirements from the SEC. In contrast, private funds, while still regulated, have different compliance obligations, particularly following recent regulatory developments. In August 2023, the SEC adopted new SEC Private Fund Adviser Rules to increase transparency and accountability for private fund advisers, addressing areas like quarterly statements, annual audits, and preferential treatment for certain investors.
    *5 Fee Structures: Fund structures often dictate how fees are charged. Retail-oriented funds typically have expense ratios and potentially sales loads, while private funds commonly employ a "2 and 20" model (a management fee plus a percentage of profits). Investors should always examine the fee disclosure details from sources like FINRA to understand the total costs associated with a particular fund structure.

3, 4## Limitations and Criticisms

While fund structures offer numerous benefits, they also come with limitations and criticisms depending on their design:

  • Liquidity Constraints: Some fund structures, particularly private equity and hedge funds, impose significant liquidity restrictions, meaning investors cannot easily redeem their capital when desired. This illiquidity can be a major drawback for investors who might need access to their funds.
  • High Fees: Certain fund structures, especially those catering to sophisticated investors, can have high management fees and performance fees, which can significantly erode returns over time. Critics argue that these fees are not always justified by the fund's performance or the value provided.
  • Lack of Transparency: Compared to regulated investment companies like mutual funds, private fund structures generally offer less transparency regarding their holdings, valuation methodologies, and operations. This can make it difficult for investors to fully assess risk and performance. The recent SEC Private Fund Adviser Rules aim to mitigate some of these transparency issues for private funds by requiring more standardized disclosures and independent audits.
    *1, 2 Regulatory Arbitrage: Historically, the less stringent regulation of certain private fund structures compared to public funds has been a point of criticism, with some arguing it allows for "regulatory arbitrage" where funds operate in a less regulated environment. However, regulators continue to enhance oversight where deemed necessary to protect investors and maintain market integrity.
  • Complexity: The legal and operational complexity of some fund structures can be daunting for average investors, making it challenging to understand the intricacies of their investments, including the fiduciary duty owed by the fund's management.

Fund Structures vs. Investment Vehicles

While often used interchangeably, "fund structures" and "investment vehicles" have a subtle but important distinction in the realm of investment management. Fund structures refer to the legal and organizational blueprint of a collective investment scheme. This includes the legal entity type (e.g., corporation, trust, limited partnership), the regulatory framework it operates under (e.g., Investment Company Act of 1940), and its operational characteristics (e.g., open-end vs. closed-end, redemption frequency).

Investment vehicles, on the other hand, is a broader term encompassing any mechanism or instrument used to hold or facilitate an investment. All fund structures are investment vehicles, but not all investment vehicles are fund structures. For example, a single stock, a bond, or real estate directly owned by an individual are investment vehicles, but they are not "fund structures" because they do not involve the pooling of capital from multiple investors under a specific collective legal framework. Common investment vehicles that are fund structures include mutual funds, exchange-traded funds, closed-end funds, hedge funds, and private equity funds. The confusion arises because these structured funds are indeed vehicles for investment, but "fund structures" specifically emphasizes their underlying organizational design.

FAQs

What are the main types of fund structures?

The main types of fund structures are generally categorized by their liquidity, regulatory oversight, and investor base. These include open-end funds (like mutual funds and exchange-traded funds), which offer daily liquidity; closed-end funds, which trade like stocks on an exchange; and private funds (such as hedge funds and private equity funds), which are typically less regulated and accessible to accredited investors.

How do fund structures impact investors?

Fund structures directly impact investors by determining how easily they can buy and sell shares, the fees they pay, the level of transparency they receive regarding fund holdings and operations, and who is eligible to invest. A highly regulated structure like a mutual fund offers high transparency and daily liquidity for all investors, while a private equity fund structure requires a long-term commitment and is only available to certain qualified individuals or institutions.

Are all fund structures regulated by the SEC?

Not all fund structures are regulated by the SEC in the same way. Publicly offered fund structures like mutual funds and exchange-traded funds are highly regulated under the Investment Company Act of 1940. Private fund structures, such as hedge funds and private equity funds, have different, generally less extensive, direct regulation of their operations, although their investment advisers are often registered with the SEC and subject to certain rules.

Why do different fund structures have different fees?

Different fund structures have varying fee arrangements primarily due to their operational complexity, investment strategies, and target investor base. Retail-focused fund structures, like mutual funds, typically have annual expense ratios covering management and operating costs, plus potential sales charges. Private fund structures often have a "2 and 20" fee model, which includes a management fee (e.g., 2% of assets under management) and a performance fee (e.g., 20% of profits), reflecting the specialized nature of their investments and the incentive structure for the fund manager.