Global investment performance standards: Meaning, Criticisms & Real-World Uses

What Are Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS)?

The Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) are a set of voluntary, ethical standards adopted by investment management firms worldwide for calculating and presenting investment performance results. As part of the broader field of investment performance reporting, GIPS aim to ensure that financial data is represented with fairness and full disclosure, enabling investors to compare the past performance of different asset managers on a consistent basis. Compliance with GIPS demonstrates a firm's commitment to transparency and ethical practices within the financial industry³⁴.

History and Origin

The evolution of the Global Investment Performance Standards began with the need for a standardized approach to investment performance reporting. Prior to GIPS, various country-specific guidelines existed, leading to inconsistencies that made it challenging for investors to compare firms across different regions. The predecessor to GIPS was the Association for Investment Management and Research–Performance Presentation Standards (AIMR-PPS), first published in 1993, which provided voluntary performance guidelines primarily for firms in the United States and Canada.
³³
Recognizing the increasing globalization of investment markets, the CFA Institute (then known as AIMR) sponsored and funded a committee in 1995 to develop truly global standards. This initiative culminated in the publication of the first edition of the GIPS Standards in April 1999. ³¹, ³²Further revisions followed, with a significant update in 2005 that led to the convergence of country-specific versions into a single global standard, effective January 1, 2006. The standards continue to evolve to keep pace with the changing investment landscape, with the most recent edition, GIPS 2020, taking effect on January 1, 2020, which expanded guidance to cover a wider range of investment strategies and asset classes.
²⁹, ³⁰

Key Takeaways

GIPS are voluntary ethical standards for investment management firms to ensure fair representation and full disclosure of investment performance.
Developed and maintained by the CFA Institute, GIPS aim to enhance comparability among different asset managers globally.
Compliance with GIPS requires firms to present at least five years of compliant performance history, building up to ten years where available, to prevent "cherry-picking" of favorable returns.
The standards cover various aspects of performance calculation and presentation, including composite construction and disclosure requirements.
Although voluntary, GIPS compliance is often viewed as a de facto requirement by institutional investors seeking to evaluate managers.
²⁸

Interpreting the GIPS

Interpreting performance reported under the Global Investment Performance Standards involves understanding that the figures presented adhere to a common framework, fostering greater reliability and comparability. When an investment firm claims GIPS compliance, it signifies that their reported rate of return has been calculated and presented according to a globally recognized set of ethical principles. This allows investors to more effectively assess an asset manager's historical performance relative to peers, rather than relying on potentially inconsistent or selectively presented data. It is crucial to examine the accompanying disclosures, which provide context on the firm's investment discretion and any specific methodologies used, offering a more complete picture of the reported results.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "Alpha Capital Management," an investment firm seeking to attract institutional clients. Before implementing GIPS, Alpha Capital presented performance figures for its "Global Equity Composite" using its own internal methodology. This methodology might have excluded certain terminated accounts or used different valuation dates, making direct comparisons with other firms difficult.

To become GIPS compliant, Alpha Capital must:

Define the Firm: Clearly define "Alpha Capital Management" as the entity for which GIPS compliance is claimed, ensuring all assets managed by the firm are considered.
Create Composites: Formulate "composites" of similar investment portfolios managed with a consistent strategy. For instance, the "Global Equity Composite" would include all discretionary fee-paying portfolios that follow its global equity strategy.
Calculate Performance: Apply specific GIPS-mandated methodologies for calculating performance, such as time-weighted returns, and include all eligible portfolios from inception or for a minimum of five years, building to ten.
²⁷4. Disclose: Provide comprehensive disclosures alongside the performance presentation, detailing calculation methodologies, significant market conditions, and any changes to the firm or composite.

By adhering to these steps, Alpha Capital's Global Equity Composite performance report becomes standardized, allowing a prospective client, "Institutional Pension Fund," to directly compare Alpha Capital's results with a GIPS-compliant report from another firm, "Beta Investments," providing a clear and transparent basis for due diligence.

Practical Applications

Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) are integral to the global financial reporting and marketing efforts of investment management firms. They provide a framework for consistently presenting historical investment results to prospective clients, fostering trust and transparency. Over 1,700 organizations from more than 50 markets worldwide claim GIPS compliance, including many of the top global asset managers.
²⁶
Firms use GIPS to:

Standardize Performance Presentations: Ensure uniform calculation and presentation of portfolio performance across different strategies and geographies.
Facilitate Due Diligence: Allow institutional investors, consultants, and individual clients to more easily compare the performance track records of different investment firms.
Demonstrate Ethical Commitment: Signal adherence to a high level of ethical standards and best practices in an industry where trust is paramount.
²⁵* Globalize Marketing Efforts: Enable firms to present their performance consistently across international borders without needing to adapt to multiple country-specific regulations.

For instance, an Outsourced Chief Investment Officer (OCIO) firm navigating the complex landscape of client mandates and regulatory requirements might seek to comply with GIPS to enhance their credibility and streamline their performance reporting processes for diverse client portfolios. ²⁴The CFA Institute provides extensive guidance, including specific standards for firms, asset owners, and even verifiers, further solidifying GIPS's role as a global benchmark for performance presentation.
²³

Limitations and Criticisms

While Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) promote transparency and comparability, their implementation comes with certain limitations and criticisms. One significant challenge is the resource intensiveness of achieving and maintaining compliance. ²²Smaller firms, in particular, may face considerable financial and operational burdens in gathering the necessary data, developing robust processes, and undertaking independent verification. The complexity of some investment products, such as certain alternative investments like private equity, can also make strict GIPS adherence challenging due to unique valuation methodologies and infrequent cash flows.
²¹
Another area of discussion revolves around the voluntary nature of GIPS. While many prominent firms adopt them, compliance is not mandatory, meaning some firms may choose not to adhere, thereby limiting the universal comparability the standards aim to achieve. Furthermore, while GIPS provide a framework, the standards still require firms to make certain judgments and interpretations, which can introduce slight variations in presentation. Firms must ensure their interpretations align with the spirit of fair representation and full disclosure, and rigorous risk management procedures are critical to avoid misrepresentation, even unintentional.

Global Investment Performance Standards vs. SEC Marketing Rule

The Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) Marketing Rule both aim to ensure fair and transparent presentation of investment performance, but they differ significantly in scope, authority, and application.

Feature	Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS)	SEC Marketing Rule
Authority	Voluntary, ethical standards developed by the CFA Institute.	Mandatory regulation issued by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. ²⁰Registered investment advisers must comply. ¹⁹
Scope	Global in reach, applies to investment management firms and asset owners worldwide who choose to claim compliance. ¹⁷, ¹⁸	Applies to any investment adviser registered or required to be registered with the SEC, including private fund advisers. ¹⁶Primarily focused on advertising in the U.S.
Focus	Comprehensive framework for calculating and presenting historical performance, emphasizing fair representation and full disclosure.	Broadly defines "advertisement" and sets conditions for various types of content, including performance, testimonials, endorsements, and hypothetical performance. ¹⁵
Performance Periods	Requires a minimum of five years of GIPS-compliant performance, building to ten years.	Generally requires performance results for 1-, 5-, and 10-year periods with equal prominence, if the portfolio existed for those periods. ¹⁴
Gross vs. Net	Dictates detailed calculations for both time-weighted return and money-weighted return, often leading to both gross and net presentations. ¹³	Prohibits presenting gross performance without also presenting net performance with at least equal prominence and for the same time period. ¹²This applies to both individual investments and "extracted performance" from a larger portfolio. ¹¹
Hypothetical Performance	While GIPS focuses on actual performance, it provides guidance for advertising.	Highly scrutinized; requires policies and procedures to ensure relevance to the intended audience and generally prohibited on public websites without specific safeguards. ⁹, ¹⁰
Predecessor Performance	GIPS provides specific guidelines for presenting historical performance of predecessor firms or composites.	Permitted only if specific requirements are met, such as the same individuals being primarily responsible for the prior performance at the advertising firm. ⁸

While GIPS offers a global benchmark for performance reporting, the SEC Marketing Rule imposes legally binding requirements for firms operating in or serving clients in the U.S. Firms that are GIPS-compliant often find that many of their practices align with the SEC's objectives, though additional considerations and adjustments are typically needed to ensure full compliance with the SEC Marketing Rule.
⁷

FAQs

1. What is the main purpose of GIPS?

The main purpose of the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) is to provide a standardized, ethical framework for investment management firms to calculate and present their historical investment performance. This allows investors to make meaningful comparisons between different firms and strategies.

2. Is GIPS compliance mandatory?

No, GIPS compliance is voluntary. However, it is widely recognized and often expected by institutional investors and consultants as a demonstration of a firm's commitment to transparency and best practices in the investment industry.
⁵, ⁶

3. Who developed the Global Investment Performance Standards?

The Global Investment Performance Standards were developed and are maintained by the CFA Institute, a global association for investment management professionals. They work in partnership with industry experts and GIPS standards sponsors from around the world.
⁴

4. What is a "composite" in GIPS?

In GIPS, a "composite" is an aggregation of individual, discretionary portfolios managed by a firm according to a similar investment objective or strategy. Firms report the performance of these composites rather than individual accounts to provide a representative view of their capabilities.
³

5. Does GIPS apply to all types of investments?

The GIPS standards are designed to be broadly applicable to various asset classes and investment strategies, including traditional equity and fixed income, as well as pooled funds and alternative investments. The GIPS 2020 update provided enhanced guidance for applying the standards to a wider range of investment vehicles and approaches.¹, ²