Global investment performance standards gips

What Are Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS)?

The Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) are a set of voluntary ethical standards for investment management firms around the world. These standards fall under the broader category of Investment Performance Reporting and aim to ensure the full disclosure and fair representation of investment performance to prospective and existing clients. The primary objective of GIPS is to enable investors to compare the historical performance of various asset managers on a consistent and transparent basis, fostering greater confidence in reported results.

History and Origin

The Global Investment Performance Standards have their roots in the Association for Investment Management and Research–Performance Presentation Standards (AIMR-PPS), which were developed in 1987 for investment management firms in the United States and Canada. Recognizing the growing need for a universally accepted framework, the CFA Institute (formerly AIMR) established a committee in 1995 to develop global standards. The first edition of the GIPS standards was published in April 1999.,
^33
32This initiative was driven by a desire to prevent misleading practices in performance reporting, such as firms selectively presenting only their best-performing accounts (often referred to as "cherry-picking") or excluding poor-performing ones. T³¹he standards have since been updated periodically to adapt to evolving market practices and complexities, with a significant revision, GIPS 2020, becoming effective on January 1, 2020., T³⁰he CFA Institute continues to develop and promote the GIPS standards, collaborating with organizations in numerous countries.

²⁹## Key Takeaways

• GIPS are voluntary ethical standards for investment performance reporting.
• They aim to ensure fair representation and full disclosure of historical investment results.
• Compliance with GIPS promotes transparency and comparability among investment management firms globally.
• The standards cover areas such as data input, calculation methodology, composite construction, disclosure, and presentation.
• While voluntary, GIPS compliance is often a de facto requirement for firms seeking institutional capital.

Interpreting the GIPS

GIPS compliance signifies that an investment management firm adheres to a globally recognized set of principles for calculating and presenting its historical investment results. For investors, this means they can have a higher degree of confidence that the performance data presented by a GIPS-compliant firm is consistently calculated and fairly represented. It provides a standardized basis for evaluating different investment strategies and comparing managers, as it mitigates the risk of misleading practices like showing only successful portfolios or specific time periods.,
^28
27For example, the standards generally require firms to present a minimum of five years of GIPS-compliant performance history, building up to 10 years, or since inception if shorter., T²⁶his helps prevent firms from presenting only favorable short-term results and offers a more comprehensive view of long-term performance trends. Furthermore, GIPS compliance often leads to stronger internal controls over performance measurement processes.

²⁵## Hypothetical Example

Consider two hypothetical investment advisory firms, Alpha Advisors and Beta Investments, both managing diversified equity portfolios.

Alpha Advisors claims GIPS compliance. When presenting their "Large Cap Growth" composite, they provide a GIPS-compliant presentation that includes:

1. Annual time-weighted return for the past 10 years.
2. The aggregate assets under management for the composite.
3. Disclosure of all significant policies used in the calculation and presentation, such as the treatment of cash and fees.
4. The benchmark used for comparison and a clear explanation of its relevance.

Beta Investments, on the other hand, does not claim GIPS compliance. When presenting their "Large Cap Growth" strategy, they might only show the returns of a single, highly successful client account for the last three years, without detailing the calculation methodology or disclosing the universe of similar accounts.

An investor comparing these two firms would find Alpha Advisors' GIPS-compliant presentation much more robust and trustworthy, allowing for a more accurate comparison of their "Large Cap Growth" offering against other managers and against relevant benchmarks.

Practical Applications

GIPS are widely applied in the global financial markets by investment management firms that seek to attract institutional clients, such as pension funds, endowments, and foundations. Many institutional investors mandate GIPS compliance as a prerequisite for considering an asset manager.,
^24
23The standards provide a framework for consistent reporting across various asset classes, including traditional equity and fixed income, as well as alternative investments like private equity and real estate investments. F²²irms use GIPS to build and maintain composites, which are aggregations of discretionary portfolios managed with a similar investment mandate or strategy. T²¹his ensures that all relevant discretionary accounts are included in a composite, preventing firms from presenting only their best results.,

²⁰Moreover, GIPS plays a role in promoting industry self-regulation and fair competition globally. B¹⁹y adopting GIPS, firms demonstrate a commitment to best practices in performance reporting, enhancing their credibility in the eyes of investors worldwide.

¹⁸## Limitations and Criticisms

While GIPS are widely respected, their implementation can present challenges. For smaller asset managers, the cost and technical expertise required to achieve and maintain compliance can be significant. This includes investing in appropriate portfolio accounting systems, establishing robust policies and procedures, and potentially undergoing an independent verification process.

¹⁷Another point of consideration is that while GIPS compliance is voluntary, its adoption is often a business necessity for firms targeting institutional investors. This creates a de facto requirement that can be burdensome. F¹⁶urthermore, while the GIPS standards aim for global consistency, minor conflicts with local regulations can sometimes arise, requiring firms to prioritize the stricter of the two, though direct conflicts are rare.

¹⁵The standards primarily focus on the calculation and presentation of historical performance data. While critical, they do not prescribe specific investment methodologies or guarantee future results. Investors must still perform their own due diligence beyond GIPS compliance to evaluate a firm's investment process, risk management, and suitability for their specific needs.

GIPS vs. SEC Marketing Rule

The Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) and the SEC Marketing Rule both govern how investment performance is presented, but they differ in scope, authority, and primary focus. GIPS are a set of voluntary ethical standards developed by the CFA Institute, aiming for global consistency in performance reporting. Firms choose to adopt GIPS to demonstrate their commitment to transparency and to facilitate comparability across different markets.

In contrast, the SEC Marketing Rule (Rule 206(4)-1 under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940) is a mandatory regulation issued by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for registered investment advisers. Effective from November 4, 2022, this rule aims to modernize advertising regulations and prevent fraudulent or misleading claims in advertisements.,
^14
13Key differences include:

While GIPS provides a comprehensive framework for calculating and presenting performance, the SEC Marketing Rule sets specific legal requirements for how that performance can be advertised to the public, including requirements for presenting gross vs. net performance and standardized time periods., ⁹F⁸irms that are GIPS-compliant may still need to adjust their marketing materials to fully comply with the SEC Marketing Rule.

⁷## FAQs

Who developed the GIPS standards?

The Global Investment Performance Standards were developed by the CFA Institute, a global association for investment professionals. The CFA Institute continues to maintain and promote these standards to foster transparency and comparability in investment performance reporting.,

⁶### Is GIPS compliance mandatory?
No, GIPS compliance is voluntary. However, it is widely considered an industry best practice and is often a practical necessity for investment management firms seeking to attract and retain institutional clients who frequently require GIPS-compliant performance presentations.,

⁵### What are composites in GIPS?
In the context of GIPS, a composite is an aggregation of all discretionary portfolios managed according to a particular investment strategy or objective. Firms create composites to present a holistic view of the performance of a specific strategy, rather than cherry-picking individual accounts. All actual, fee-paying, discretionary accounts must be included in at least one composite.

⁴### How often do GIPS standards get updated?
The GIPS standards are periodically reviewed and updated to remain relevant with evolving market practices, new financial products, and changes in the global investment landscape. For instance, the GIPS 2020 edition introduced changes to better accommodate asset owners and pooled funds.,
^3
2### What are the benefits of GIPS compliance for investors?
For investors, GIPS compliance offers several key benefits. It provides assurance that the investment performance data they receive is calculated and presented in a consistent and fair manner. This transparency allows investors to make more informed decisions by enabling them to easily compare the past results of different asset managers and their investment strategies on a level playing field.,¹