Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to G Definitions

Good faith estimate gfe

What Is a Good Faith Estimate (GFE)?

A Good Faith Estimate (GFE) was a standardized three-page disclosure form provided to prospective homebuyers by lenders at the beginning of the mortgage application process. It belonged to the broader category of Real Estate Finance disclosures, designed to give applicants an estimate of the total closing costs and loan terms they could expect. The GFE aimed to help consumers understand the costs associated with their mortgage loan and compare offers from different lenders. Before its replacement, the Good Faith Estimate played a crucial role in promoting transparency in residential real estate transactions, outlining key financial details such as the initial interest rate, loan amount, and estimated taxes and insurance.

History and Origin

The Good Faith Estimate originated from the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), enacted by the U.S. Congress in 1974. RESPA aimed to protect consumers by increasing transparency in the real estate settlement process and eliminating abusive practices such as kickbacks and unearned fees19. Initially enforced by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), RESPA's regulatory oversight was later transferred to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) when it was established in 201117, 18.

For decades, the Good Faith Estimate, along with the HUD-1 Settlement Statement and the Truth in Lending (TIL) disclosure, served as the primary documents informing borrowers about their loan costs. However, the complexity of having multiple forms with sometimes overlapping information led to confusion for consumers. To address this, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 mandated the creation of a single, integrated disclosure15, 16. This led to the development of the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure (TRID) Rule, also known as the "Know Before You Owe" mortgage disclosure rule. The TRID Rule, which went into effect on October 3, 2015, replaced the Good Faith Estimate and the initial Truth-in-Lending disclosure with a new form called the Loan Estimate13, 14.

Key Takeaways

  • The Good Faith Estimate (GFE) was a three-page form that provided borrowers with an estimate of their mortgage loan terms and closing costs.
  • It was mandated under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA) to enhance transparency for homebuyers.
  • The GFE was replaced by the Loan Estimate (LE) as part of the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure (TRID) Rule, effective October 3, 2015.
  • Its purpose was to allow consumers to compare loan offers and anticipate the financial obligations associated with their home purchase.
  • Lenders were required to provide the GFE within three business days of receiving a loan application.

Formula and Calculation

The Good Faith Estimate itself did not involve a specific formula or calculation in the traditional sense, as it was a disclosure document outlining estimated costs rather than deriving a value. However, the figures presented on the GFE (and now the Loan Estimate) were based on various cost components. These components included:

  • Origination Charges: Fees charged by the lender for processing the loan.
  • Third-Party Services You Can Shop For: Costs for services like appraisals, title insurance, and surveys, where the borrower could choose their provider.
  • Third-Party Services You Cannot Shop For: Costs for services like credit reports and flood determination, where the provider is typically chosen by the lender.
  • Taxes and Other Government Fees: Includes recording fees and transfer taxes.
  • Prepaid Items: Such as homeowner's insurance premiums and property taxes, often collected to establish an escrow account.
  • Initial Escrow Payment at Closing: Funds collected for future property taxes and insurance.

The total estimated closing costs were a sum of these various line items. For instance, if a borrower's total estimated third-party charges were $X, and prepaid expenses were $Y, the Good Faith Estimate would present these sums clearly.

Interpreting the Good Faith Estimate

Interpreting the Good Faith Estimate (GFE) involved comparing the estimated costs provided by a lender with offers from other financial institutions. The GFE was designed to promote a "good faith" standard, meaning the estimated charges should closely align with the actual costs at closing. It allowed prospective borrowers to see a breakdown of expenses, from the interest rate and loan amount to various settlement services and government fees.

Borrowers would examine the Good Faith Estimate to identify potential variances in fees. Certain charges, like the origination fee and the cost of services the borrower could not shop for, had zero tolerance for change between the GFE and the final closing. Other charges, such as recording fees, were allowed a 10% tolerance for increases, while some, like prepaid interest or homeowner's insurance, had no tolerance limits12. Understanding these tolerance levels was key to evaluating if the lender's estimates were truly in good faith and to anticipate potential financial adjustments before refinancing or purchasing a home.

Hypothetical Example

Imagine Sarah is applying for a $300,000 mortgage loan to purchase a new home. She receives a Good Faith Estimate from "Lender A." The GFE would list the estimated costs she could expect.

Here's a simplified breakdown from her hypothetical Good Faith Estimate:

  • Loan Origination Fee: $2,500
  • Appraisal Fee: $600
  • Title Insurance (Lender's Policy): $800
  • Recording Fees: $250
  • Prepaid Property Taxes (6 months): $1,800
  • Homeowner's Insurance Premium (1 year): $1,200
  • Credit Report Fee: $50

The Good Faith Estimate would then sum these items to show estimated total closing costs of $7,200. This estimate would allow Sarah to compare Lender A's offer against other lenders' GFEs, enabling her to make an informed decision based on the overall cost of the loan and associated services, rather than just the stated interest rate.

Practical Applications

While the Good Faith Estimate (GFE) is no longer in use for most residential mortgage transactions, its underlying principle of providing transparent cost estimates remains crucial through its successor, the Loan Estimate. In the past, the Good Faith Estimate was a vital tool in Real Estate Finance for:

  • Cost Comparison: It allowed consumers to compare estimated closing costs and loan terms across different lenders, fostering competition.
  • Budgeting: Borrowers could use the Good Faith Estimate to anticipate the funds needed at closing, helping with personal financial planning.
  • Consumer Protection: By itemizing fees, the Good Faith Estimate helped consumers identify potentially excessive or unexpected charges, aligning with the goals of consumer protection agencies.

The spirit of the GFE is now embodied in the Loan Estimate, which continues to inform consumers about the full cost of obtaining a mortgage loan. This transparency is a cornerstone of responsible lending practices and is overseen by regulatory bodies like the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Financial literacy resources often emphasize the importance of understanding all disclosed fees to avoid surprises at closing. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) provides consumer alerts and resources to help individuals navigate the mortgage process and identify deceptive practices11.

Limitations and Criticisms

The Good Faith Estimate, despite its intentions, faced several limitations and criticisms that ultimately led to its replacement. One significant issue was the lack of consistency in how different lenders interpreted and disclosed certain fees, making true comparisons difficult for homebuyers. This inconsistency could lead to "bait-and-switch" tactics, where initial estimates on the GFE were significantly lower than the actual costs incurred at closing10.

Another common criticism was the permissible variance in estimated versus actual charges. While some fees had a zero-tolerance policy for changes, others allowed for up to a 10% increase, and some had no tolerance limits at all9. This flexibility could still result in unexpected increases in closing costs for the borrower. Furthermore, the GFE was often accompanied by other disclosures, such as the initial Truth in Lending Act statement and the HUD-1 settlement statement, creating a complex and confusing array of paperwork for consumers to decipher8. This fragmentation of information made it challenging for borrowers to gain a comprehensive understanding of their loan terms and total costs. The Federal Reserve, among other regulators, noted instances of inaccurate information and tolerance violations even after the introduction of TRID, indicating the persistent challenge of ensuring full transparency in loan disclosures6, 7.

Good Faith Estimate (GFE) vs. Loan Estimate (LE)

The Good Faith Estimate (GFE) and the Loan Estimate (LE) both serve the fundamental purpose of providing prospective homebuyers with estimated costs and terms for a mortgage loan. However, the Loan Estimate effectively replaced the GFE for most residential mortgage applications as part of the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure (TRID) Rule, effective October 3, 20154, 5.

The primary difference lies in their structure and integration. The GFE was one of three separate forms, alongside the initial Truth-in-Lending disclosure and the HUD-1 Settlement Statement. This often led to consumer confusion due to fragmented and sometimes redundant information. The Loan Estimate, on the other hand, is a consolidated, three-page form that integrates the information previously found in the GFE and the initial Truth-in-Lending disclosure. It is designed to be clearer, more comprehensive, and easier to understand, allowing for more straightforward comparisons of different loan offers. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau developed the LE to enhance transparency and provide a more streamlined disclosure process, emphasizing key figures like the estimated total closing costs and cash to close.

FAQs

Who was required to provide the Good Faith Estimate?

The Good Faith Estimate (GFE) was required to be provided by the lenders or mortgage brokers to homebuyers seeking a mortgage loan.

When was the Good Faith Estimate provided to a borrower?

Lenders were required to provide the Good Faith Estimate within three business days of receiving a borrower's loan application.

What replaced the Good Faith Estimate?

The Good Faith Estimate was replaced by the Loan Estimate (LE) under the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure (TRID) Rule, effective October 3, 20152, 3.

Did the Good Faith Estimate include all costs?

The Good Faith Estimate aimed to include most of the estimated closing costs associated with a mortgage loan, but some minor variations or additional fees could arise before closing. It did not typically include costs such as private mortgage insurance (PMI) unless specifically required for the loan.

Why was the Good Faith Estimate replaced?

The Good Faith Estimate was replaced to simplify and integrate the previously disparate mortgage disclosure forms. The goal was to make the information about loan terms and closing costs clearer and easier for consumers to understand and compare, thereby reducing confusion and improving consumer protection in Real Estate Finance1.