Skip to main content
← Back to G Definitions

Graveyard market

What Is a Graveyard Market?

A graveyard market refers to a prolonged period in financial markets where investment returns are stagnant or negative, often over many years or even decades, leading to frustration and disillusionment among investors. It is a concept within the broader field of market cycles and market analysis, highlighting phases where traditional buy-and-hold strategies yield little to no real growth. During a graveyard market, the underlying equity values may oscillate without a clear upward trend, effectively "burying" investor capital in terms of meaningful returns. This term aptly conveys the sense of investments lying dormant, failing to generate the expected appreciation.

History and Origin

The concept of a graveyard market, while not a formal academic term, gained colloquial traction to describe periods of extended market underperformance, particularly when adjusted for inflation. One of the most frequently cited historical examples in the United States is the "Lost Decade" of the 1970s, where the S&P 500 index delivered negligible real returns over a ten-year span due to high inflation and economic stagnation. This period challenged the prevailing belief in continuous stock market growth. Similarly, the early 2000s, following the dot-com bubble burst and preceding the 2008 financial crisis, also saw minimal or negative real returns for a decade. The "Lost Decade" of the 1970s, for instance, saw the S&P 500 fall by 46% from its peak and generate a mere 0.1% annualized return over more than a decade, adjusted for inflation.4

A striking international example of a protracted graveyard market is Japan's stock market, particularly the Nikkei 225. After peaking in 1989, the index struggled for over three decades to reclaim its all-time high. It wasn't until February 2024 that the Nikkei 225 finally eclipsed its 1989 record, marking a 34-year period of effective stagnation.3 This long period profoundly impacted investor psychology and challenged conventional investment strategies.

Key Takeaways

  • A graveyard market describes a prolonged period of stagnant or negative real returns in financial markets.
  • It can last for many years, significantly challenging long-term investor expectations.
  • Such periods erode the purchasing power of capital, especially in the presence of inflation.
  • Diversification and active asset allocation become critical in navigating these challenging market environments.

Interpreting the Graveyard Market

Interpreting a graveyard market involves recognizing that traditional growth assumptions, where a broadly diversified portfolio steadily appreciates over time, may not hold true for extended periods. Instead, investors must consider real returns, which account for the impact of inflation on purchasing power. In a graveyard market, while nominal returns might be positive or flat, high inflation can lead to negative real returns, meaning an investor's money buys less over time.

Recognizing such a market often occurs in hindsight, as it's difficult to predict the duration of stagnation. However, signs like persistent high inflation, low economic growth, or significant geopolitical instability can be indicators. During these times, patience and a focus on income-generating assets or strategies that aim to preserve capital become paramount.

Hypothetical Example

Consider an investor, Sarah, who begins investing a fixed amount monthly into a broad market index fund. Over the first five years, the market delivers consistent 8% annual returns, and her portfolio grows steadily. However, for the next ten years, the market enters a "graveyard market" phase. Despite Sarah continuing her monthly contributions, the index fund experiences an average annual nominal return of 1%, while inflation averages 3% per year.

After this ten-year period, Sarah's nominal portfolio value has grown slightly due to her consistent contributions and the meager nominal returns. However, when adjusted for inflation, the real value of her initial investments and early gains has significantly diminished. Her purchasing power, in real terms, has effectively declined, even though her account balance might show a small increase. This illustrates how a graveyard market can silently erode wealth, making it challenging for investors focused solely on nominal growth.

Practical Applications

Understanding graveyard markets has several practical applications for investors and financial professionals:

  • Portfolio Construction: It emphasizes the importance of building robust portfolios that can withstand prolonged periods of low or negative returns. This may involve incorporating various asset classes beyond traditional equities, such as fixed income, real estate, or commodities, which may perform differently during stagnation.
  • Risk Management: Graveyard markets highlight the need for comprehensive risk management strategies. Investors might consider reducing exposure to highly volatile assets or implementing strategies that aim to protect against significant drawdowns.
  • Financial Planning: For long-term financial planning, particularly for retirement, it's crucial not to solely rely on historical average stock market returns, which often assume continuous growth. Planners should stress the importance of adequate savings rates and realistic return expectations to account for potential periods of market stagnation.
  • Active Management: While "buy and hold" is a foundational principle for many, a graveyard market can make a case for more active management or tactical asset allocation, where adjustments are made based on evolving market conditions to seek opportunities or mitigate losses. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) provides guidance on investing, emphasizing the importance of understanding fees, managing risk, and diversifying investments, which are critical considerations in any market environment.2

Limitations and Criticisms

The primary limitation of the "graveyard market" concept is its retrospective nature; it's typically identified after a period of prolonged stagnation has already occurred, making it difficult to act proactively. Predicting the onset or duration of a graveyard market with certainty is nearly impossible.

Another criticism is that while broad market indices may show stagnation, specific sectors or individual securities might still offer positive returns. Therefore, a "graveyard market" might not be uniformly bleak across all investment opportunities. However, for the average investor in broadly diversified index funds, such periods can be highly frustrating. During the "Lost Decade" of the 2000s, for instance, even with the S&P 500 delivering negative returns, investors who diversified into mid-cap or small-cap stocks might have generated positive returns.1 This underscores the complexity of market dynamics even during periods of overall stagnation.

Furthermore, the impact of a graveyard market is heavily influenced by inflation. In a deflationary environment, even flat nominal returns could translate to positive real returns. Conversely, high inflation exacerbates the negative impact on purchasing power, making the "graveyard" feel deeper for bond yields.

Graveyard Market vs. Lost Decade

The terms "graveyard market" and "Lost Decade" are closely related and often used interchangeably, but there's a subtle distinction.

A Graveyard Market is a more colloquial and descriptive term for any extended period of market stagnation or decline in real terms, encompassing periods longer or shorter than a decade. It conveys the general sense of investments lying dormant without significant growth.

A Lost Decade, on the other hand, is a more specific financial term referring to a ten-year period where a particular stock market index, after accounting for inflation and sometimes dividends, delivers flat or negative overall returns. It's a quantifiable historical occurrence, such as the U.S. market in the 1970s or 2000s.

Essentially, a "Lost Decade" is a specific instance of a "graveyard market." All "Lost Decades" are graveyard markets, but not all graveyard markets are precisely ten years long or confined to a specific index. The commonality is the investor's experience of prolonged lack of meaningful capital appreciation.

FAQs

How long does a graveyard market last?

The duration of a graveyard market can vary significantly. While the term "Lost Decade" specifically refers to a ten-year period, a graveyard market can extend for more than a decade, as seen with Japan's stock market, or for shorter, multi-year periods of stagnation.

How does inflation impact a graveyard market?

Inflation is a critical factor in a graveyard market. Even if nominal returns are flat or slightly positive, high inflation will erode the purchasing power of your investments, leading to negative real returns. This means your money can buy less over time. Understanding purchasing power is crucial in these environments.

Can active management help in a graveyard market?

While not guaranteed, active management strategies that focus on value investing, income generation, or tactical shifts between asset classes may potentially outperform passive index investing during a graveyard market. However, active management carries its own risks and higher fees.

Is a graveyard market the same as a bear market?

No, they are distinct. A bear market is typically defined as a decline of 20% or more from recent highs in a broad market index, usually lasting for months or a year or two. A graveyard market, however, is characterized by prolonged stagnation or very low returns, often extending for many years, rather than a sharp, deep decline. A bear market might be part of a larger graveyard market period.

How can investors protect themselves from a graveyard market?

Investors can consider strategies such as broad diversification across different asset classes, including those less correlated with equities; focusing on income-generating investments; maintaining a long-term perspective; and adjusting expectations for returns during such challenging periods. Emphasizing long-term investing and understanding economic data can also provide some guidance.