Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to H Definitions

Hard to borrow list

What Is Hard-To-Borrow List?

A hard-to-borrow list is an inventory record maintained by a brokerage firm that indicates which equity securities are difficult to locate and borrow for the purpose of short selling. Within the broader category of securities lending and short selling, this list signals to prospective short sellers that shares of a particular stock are in limited supply and demand or are otherwise restricted. When a stock appears on a hard-to-borrow list, it often means that obtaining shares for a short sale will be more challenging, potentially incurring higher borrowing fees or even making the transaction impossible. The availability of shares for shorting is crucial because short sellers must borrow shares before selling them with the expectation of buying them back at a lower price.

History and Origin

The concept of a hard-to-borrow list is intrinsically linked to the history and regulation of short selling itself. While short selling has existed for centuries, with early instances recorded in the 17th century, formal regulation in the United States began to take shape following significant market events. Short selling was subject to scrutiny after the 1929 stock market crash, leading to the establishment of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 1934, which was authorized to regulate such practices. This ultimately led to rules like the uptick rule (Rule 10a-1) in 1938, designed to prevent short sales from driving down market prices excessively.

As markets evolved, so did the complexities of securities lending. The need for transparency and clear guidelines around borrowing shares became more pronounced. Regulations like Regulation SHO, enacted by the SEC in 2005, introduced specific requirements for brokers, including the "locate" rule, which mandates that a broker must have a reasonable belief that a security can be borrowed and delivered before a short sale can be executed. The practical implication of this rule is the creation and maintenance of hard-to-borrow lists by clearing firms and brokerages, as they need to systematically track and communicate the availability of shares to ensure compliance and manage risk. More recently, new rules like SEC Rule 10c-1a, adopted in October 2023, aim to further increase transparency in the securities lending market by requiring certain persons to report information about securities loans to a registered national securities association, which will then make some of this information publicly available.6

Key Takeaways

  • A hard-to-borrow list identifies stocks that are difficult or expensive to borrow for short selling due to limited availability.
  • Stocks may be on this list because of high short interest, low float, or other market conditions.
  • Attempting to short a stock on this list can result in higher borrowing fees or rejection of the trade.
  • Brokerages and their clearing firms maintain these lists to manage risk and comply with regulations like Regulation SHO.
  • The presence of a stock on a hard-to-borrow list can indicate strong demand from short sellers, often implying a widely held bearish sentiment.

Interpreting the Hard-To-Borrow List

Interpreting a hard-to-borrow list involves understanding the market dynamics at play. When a stock is listed as hard-to-borrow, it typically signifies that the supply of shares available for lending is constrained relative to the demand from investors looking to short the stock. This scarcity can drive up the cost of borrowing, known as the stock loan fee or rebate rate, which is the interest rate paid to the lender of the shares. A higher fee indicates greater difficulty in borrowing.

The underlying reasons for a stock appearing on this list can vary. It might be a small-capitalization company with a limited number of outstanding shares, making it naturally difficult to find lenders. Alternatively, it could be a company facing significant negative news or high market volatility, leading to an unusually high demand from short sellers who anticipate a substantial price decline. Such intense shorting interest often puts pressure on the available float, pushing the stock onto the hard-to-borrow list. Investors often monitor these lists as they can provide insights into prevailing bearish sentiment or potential liquidity issues in a particular security.

Hypothetical Example

Imagine an investor, Sarah, believes that shares of "TechInnovate Inc. (TI)" are significantly overvalued and will soon decline. She decides to initiate a short sale.

  1. Checking Availability: Sarah logs into her brokerage account to place a "sell short" order for TI shares. Before the order can be executed, her brokerage firm automatically checks its inventory and its network of lenders to see if TI shares are available for borrowing.
  2. Hard-to-Borrow Status: The brokerage's system shows that TI is on its internal hard-to-borrow list. This means there are very few, if any, shares readily available for lending.
  3. Broker's Action: Because TI is hard-to-borrow, the brokerage might:
    • Refuse the Order: If no shares can be located, Sarah's short sale order for TI might be immediately rejected.
    • Charge a Premium Fee: If some shares can be located but are scarce, the brokerage might offer them to Sarah at a very high borrowing fee—perhaps an annualized rate of 15% instead of the typical 0.5% for easily available stocks. This fee would be charged daily against the value of the borrowed shares.
    • Require a "Locate": The brokerage may require a manual "locate" process, where a representative actively searches for shares to borrow from other institutions or margin account holders. This process can take time, and there's no guarantee of success.
  4. Sarah's Decision: Faced with a high fee or the inability to borrow, Sarah might decide against shorting TI or look for other securities with more favorable borrowing conditions.

This example illustrates how the hard-to-borrow status directly impacts a short seller's ability and cost to execute their strategy.

Practical Applications

The hard-to-borrow list plays a critical role in several areas of financial markets and regulation.

Firstly, for individual and institutional short selling, it dictates which securities can be shorted and at what cost. Traders actively seeking to profit from declining prices must contend with these lists, as a stock's presence on the hard-to-borrow list directly impacts the feasibility and profitability of a short position due to potentially high borrowing fees.

Secondly, for brokers and clearing firms, maintaining an accurate hard-to-borrow list is essential for risk management and regulatory compliance. Under the SEC's Regulation SHO, specifically Rule 204, brokers must close out "fails-to-deliver" positions within established timeframes by purchasing or borrowing the relevant security. I5f a stock is hard to borrow, it increases the risk of a "fail-to-deliver," which can lead to regulatory penalties. This necessitates proactive management of the available securities lending inventory. Rule 204 requires firms to close out failed deliveries, and if they don't, they may be prohibited from accepting new short sale orders in that security until the fail is resolved.

4Finally, from an academic and analytical perspective, the hard-to-borrow status of a stock can be an indicator of market sentiment and potential mispricing. When a stock is consistently hard to borrow, it often suggests a strong consensus among a segment of investors that the stock is overvalued. Research indicates that the introduction of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) can impact short-sale constraints in their constituent stocks, highlighting how the structure of investment vehicles can affect the supply of lendable shares. H3igh borrowing costs associated with hard-to-borrow stocks can also reflect the supply-demand dynamics within the collateralized securities lending market.

Limitations and Criticisms

While the hard-to-borrow list serves as a practical tool in securities lending, it has certain limitations and can draw criticism. One primary limitation is that it reflects the supply and demand for shares at a specific brokerage or its clearing firm, not necessarily across the entire market. A stock might be hard to borrow at one firm but more readily available at another with a different network of lenders. This fragmented view can sometimes lead to an incomplete picture of true borrowing availability.

Another point of contention arises from the impact on price discovery. If a stock is consistently hard to borrow and short sellers cannot easily take positions, it could theoretically impede the market's ability to fully incorporate negative information into the stock price. This is because short selling contributes to price discovery by allowing pessimistic views to be expressed through trading activity. When short selling is constrained by a lack of lendable shares, some argue that it could lead to inflated stock prices, as the downward pressure from short sellers is limited.
2
Furthermore, the fees associated with hard-to-borrow stocks can become prohibitively expensive, deterring even conviction-based short sellers. While these fees reflect market forces, they can also exacerbate situations where a stock is already volatile or experiencing intense speculative interest, potentially contributing to what some observers might perceive as a "short squeeze" if short positions become trapped due to lack of shares for covering.

Hard-To-Borrow List vs. Easy-To-Borrow List

The hard-to-borrow list and the easy-to-borrow list are two sides of the same coin in the world of short selling. Both are inventory records maintained by brokerage firms to classify the availability of securities for lending. The easy-to-borrow list contains securities that are readily available in sufficient quantities for short sale transactions, typically with low or no borrowing fees. These are usually highly liquid stocks with a large float and many institutional holders willing to lend them out. Conversely, the hard-to-borrow list comprises securities that are scarce, difficult to locate, and expensive to borrow, often due to high demand for shorting, low overall share availability, or other specific market conditions. While an easy-to-borrow stock allows for immediate execution of a short sale order, a hard-to-borrow stock may require a "locate" process, incur significant daily fees, or result in the rejection of the short sale attempt.

FAQs

What does it mean if a stock is on the hard-to-borrow list?

If a stock is on the hard-to-borrow list, it means there is a limited supply of its shares available for investors to borrow for the purpose of short selling. This scarcity can lead to higher borrowing fees or may prevent a short sale from being executed at all.

Why do stocks become hard to borrow?

Stocks can become hard to borrow for several reasons. Common factors include a high demand from short sellers, a small number of outstanding shares (low float), a large portion of shares held by long-term investors unwilling to lend, or specific regulatory restrictions. Market forces influencing the demand for shorting a stock can change daily.

1### How do borrowing fees work for hard-to-borrow stocks?
When a stock is hard to borrow, the brokerage firm charges a higher annualized fee on the value of the borrowed shares. This fee is typically accrued daily and deducted from the short seller's account. The rate can fluctuate significantly based on changes in supply and demand for the shares.

Can I still short a stock on the hard-to-borrow list?

It depends on the brokerage firm's policies and the specific availability. Some brokerages may allow it with significantly higher borrowing fees, while others might require a manual "locate" process or outright prohibit shorting that particular stock if no shares can be found.

Is a hard-to-borrow stock a good indicator for investing?

A stock being hard to borrow is not necessarily a "good" or "bad" indicator for a long-term investment. It primarily indicates strong bearish sentiment or limited share availability for shorting. While it shows high short interest, which some consider a contrarian indicator, it also suggests that many market participants believe the stock's price will fall.