Inclusion ratio: Meaning, Criticisms & Real-World Uses

What Is Inclusion Ratio?

The inclusion ratio, in the context of financial markets, refers to the proportion of a company's total shares outstanding that are considered "free float" and thus available for trading by the general public. It is a critical component within index construction methodologies, particularly for market-capitalization-weighted stock market indexes. The primary goal of applying an inclusion ratio is to ensure that an index accurately reflects the actual investable universe of a market, providing a more realistic measure of market performance for institutional investors and portfolio managers.

This concept falls under the broader financial category of portfolio management and market microstructure. A higher inclusion ratio for a company generally indicates greater liquidity for its shares, as a larger percentage is freely traded in the open market.

History and Origin

Historically, many early stock market indices were based on a "full market capitalization" methodology, meaning they included all shares outstanding when calculating a company's weight in the index. However, this approach often misrepresented the true investable market, as significant portions of a company's shares might be held by founders, governments, strategic investors, or other locked-in entities that are not actively traded.

The shift towards free-float methodology, which incorporates the inclusion ratio, gained prominence in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Major index providers, such as MSCI and S&P Dow Jones Indices, began adopting this method to create more representative and investable benchmarks. For instance, MSCI transitioned its Standard Index methodology to the Global Investable Market Indexes methodology, which emphasizes investability through screens for size and liquidity, and uses free float-adjusted factors¹⁴. Similarly, the S&P 500 Index, a widely followed benchmark, is now a public float-weighted/capitalization-weighted index¹³. This evolution aimed to provide a clearer picture of market movements by excluding shares not readily available for trading, thereby improving market efficiency and accuracy for investment products like exchange-traded funds.

Key Takeaways

The inclusion ratio represents the percentage of a company's shares available for public trading, excluding restricted holdings.
It is a key factor in calculating a company's float-adjusted market capitalization for index weighting.
A higher inclusion ratio typically correlates with greater stock liquidity and lower volatility.
Major index providers use inclusion ratios to ensure their indices accurately reflect the investable market.
Understanding the inclusion ratio helps investors assess a stock's liquidity and its potential impact on index performance.

Formula and Calculation

The inclusion ratio is generally expressed as a percentage or a factor, often referred to as the Investable Weight Factor (IWF) by index providers. It is determined by analyzing a company's shareholder structure and identifying shares that are not considered free float.

The formula for calculating a company's free-float market capitalization, which uses the inclusion ratio (or IWF), is:

\text{Free-Float Market Capitalization} = \text{Share Price} \times (\text{Total Shares Outstanding} - \text{Locked-In Shares})

Alternatively, if an Investable Weight Factor (IWF) is directly provided by an index provider:

\text{Free-Float Market Capitalization} = \text{Total Market Capitalization} \times \text{IWF}

Where:

Share Price: The current market price of one share of the company's stock.
Total Shares Outstanding: The total number of a company's shares currently in existence.
Locked-In Shares: Shares held by insiders, governments, strategic investors, or other entities that are not readily available for public trading. These are excluded from the free float¹².
Total Market Capitalization: Share Price $\times$ Total Shares Outstanding.
IWF (Investable Weight Factor): A multiplier (often a percentage expressed as a decimal) representing the inclusion ratio—the proportion of shares deemed free float.

Index providers like S&P Dow Jones Indices and MSCI assign an IWF to each security to determine its float-adjusted market value, which then dictates its weight within their indices.
¹⁰, ¹¹

Interpreting the Inclusion Ratio

The interpretation of the inclusion ratio primarily revolves around its implications for a stock's liquidity and its representation within a market index. A high inclusion ratio signifies that a substantial portion of a company's shares outstanding is available for public trading. This generally leads to higher trading volume and tighter bid-ask spreads, making it easier for investors to buy and sell shares without significantly impacting the price. Consequently, stocks with higher inclusion ratios tend to exhibit lower volatility and better price discovery.
⁹
Conversely, a low inclusion ratio means fewer shares are freely traded. Such stocks can be more susceptible to price swings due to limited supply, as even relatively small trades can have a disproportionate impact on their market price. For index providers, accurately assessing the inclusion ratio ensures that their indices genuinely reflect the performance of the liquid, investable portion of the market, which is crucial for those who use these indices as benchmarks for their portfolios.

Hypothetical Example

Consider Company A and Company B, both with 100 million shares outstanding and a current share price of $50. Their total market capitalization is $5 billion.

Company A: 20 million shares are held by the founding family, who have a long-term strategic interest and rarely trade their holdings. The remaining 80 million shares are publicly traded.
- Locked-In Shares = 20 million
- Free Float Shares = 100 million - 20 million = 80 million
- Inclusion Ratio = ( \frac{80 \text{ million}}{100 \text{ million}} = 0.80 ), or 80%.
- Free-Float Market Capitalization = $50 (\times) 80 million = $4 billion.
Company B: 50 million shares are held by a government entity with long-term strategic control, and 10 million shares are held by a private equity fund with a lock-up period. The remaining 40 million shares are publicly traded.
- Locked-In Shares = 50 million + 10 million = 60 million
- Free Float Shares = 100 million - 60 million = 40 million
- Inclusion Ratio = ( \frac{40 \text{ million}}{100 \text{ million}} = 0.40 ), or 40%.
- Free-Float Market Capitalization = $50 (\times) 40 million = $2 billion.

In this example, even though both companies have the same total market capitalization, their inclusion ratios and, consequently, their free-float market capitalizations differ significantly. In a free-float-weighted index, Company A would have a higher weighting than Company B, reflecting its greater investability and liquidity.

Practical Applications

The inclusion ratio has several practical applications across the financial industry, primarily in index construction, portfolio management, and investment analysis:

Index Calculation and Weighting: Major index providers like S&P Dow Jones Indices and MSCI utilize inclusion ratios to calculate the float-adjusted market capitalization of constituent companies. This ensures that the weight of a company in a stock market index accurately reflects the proportion of its shares readily available to public investors. ⁸For example, the S&P 500 is weighted by free-float market capitalization.
⁷* ETF and Mutual Fund Replication: Fund managers who manage exchange-traded funds or index mutual funds rely on these float-adjusted indices to replicate market performance. The inclusion ratio ensures that their portfolios primarily consist of liquid shares that can be easily bought and sold, minimizing tracking error.
Liquidity Assessment: Investors and analysts use the inclusion ratio as an indicator of a stock's liquidity. Companies with higher free float are generally more liquid, meaning they can be traded in large volumes without drastically affecting their share price. ⁶This is vital for large institutional investors who need to enter or exit positions efficiently.
Risk Management: From a risk management perspective, stocks with lower inclusion ratios may present higher volatility and potential for price manipulation due to limited supply, which fund managers must consider.
Market Analysis: Understanding the average inclusion ratio across a market or sector can provide insights into the overall accessibility and depth of that market, influencing strategic asset allocation decisions. Research indicates that stocks with higher levels of free float are associated with higher levels of liquidity across various global markets.
⁵

Limitations and Criticisms

While the inclusion ratio methodology is widely adopted for its accuracy in representing investable markets, it is not without its limitations and criticisms:

Subjectivity in Definition: The determination of what constitutes "locked-in" or "non-free float" shares can involve a degree of subjectivity. Different index providers may have slightly varying criteria for classifying certain shareholdings, such as those held by pension funds or long-term strategic partners, leading to minor discrepancies in inclusion ratios across different indices for the same company.
Calculation Complexity: Calculating the precise free float can be complex, requiring detailed knowledge of a company's shareholder structure and ongoing monitoring of corporate actions that might affect share availability.
⁴* Dynamic Nature: The inclusion ratio of a company is not static. It can change due to new share issuances, share buybacks, shifts in ownership structure (e.g., large block sales by insiders), or changes in foreign ownership limits. These changes necessitate regular rebalancing by index providers, which can lead to higher turnover rates within indices.
Impact on Low Free-Float Stocks: While generally improving overall index quality, the methodology can sometimes lead to certain companies with significant strategic holdings having a lower representation in indices, even if their total market capitalization is very large. Stocks with smaller free floats can be more susceptible to volatility and potential manipulation, as fewer shares are available for trading.
³* Information Asymmetry: Despite aiming for transparency, firms with less free float may still face issues related to information asymmetry, which can affect investor confidence and price discovery.
²

Inclusion Ratio vs. Free Float

While closely related, "inclusion ratio" and "free float" are often used interchangeably, but it's helpful to clarify their nuanced relationship.

Inclusion Ratio refers specifically to the proportion or factor (often a percentage or an Investable Weight Factor) that determines how much of a company's total shares outstanding is considered available for public trading and thus "includable" in a free-float weighted index. It's the numerical output of the free-float assessment.

Free Float refers to the actual number of shares or the concept of shares that are readily available for trading in the open market, excluding those held by insiders, governments, or other locked-in entities. ¹It is the pool of shares from which the inclusion ratio is derived.

In essence, the inclusion ratio is the mathematical representation or factor applied to the total shares to arrive at the free float for index calculation purposes. An index committee determines a company's free float shares, and then an inclusion ratio (or Investable Weight Factor) is assigned based on this determination. Therefore, while free float is the underlying concept of readily tradable shares, the inclusion ratio is the specific factor used by index providers to adjust a company's market capitalization for index weighting.

FAQs

Q1: Why do index providers use the inclusion ratio?

Index providers use the inclusion ratio to ensure that their indices accurately reflect the investable portion of the market. By excluding shares not freely traded, the index becomes a better benchmark for investable portfolios, enhancing its relevance for institutional investors and fund managers.

Q2: How does the inclusion ratio affect a stock's price?

The inclusion ratio itself doesn't directly affect a stock's price on a day-to-day basis. However, a low inclusion ratio implies a smaller supply of freely traded shares, which can lead to higher volatility as even small buy or sell orders can have a larger impact on the price due to reduced liquidity.

Q3: Can a company's inclusion ratio change?

Yes, a company's inclusion ratio can change. Factors such as new share issuances, share buybacks, significant block trades by large shareholders, or changes in regulatory foreign ownership limits can alter the number of shares considered free float. Index providers regularly review and adjust inclusion ratios for their constituents.

Q4: Is the inclusion ratio the same across all index providers?

Not necessarily. While the underlying concept of free float is consistent, different index providers (e.g., MSCI, S&P Dow Jones Indices) may have slightly different methodologies or thresholds for determining what constitutes "locked-in" shares or how they classify various shareholder types. This can lead to minor variations in the assigned inclusion ratios for the same company across different indices.

Q5: How does the inclusion ratio relate to factor investing?

While not a direct factor itself, the inclusion ratio impacts the "size" and "liquidity" factors often considered in factor investing. Companies with higher inclusion ratios tend to have higher float-adjusted market capitalizations and better liquidity, which can influence their attractiveness within factor-based strategies.