What Is Incremental Economic Profit?
Incremental economic profit refers to the change in a firm's economic profit resulting from a specific business decision, project, or investment. It is a critical concept within corporate finance that extends beyond traditional accounting measures by factoring in the opportunity cost of capital. While standard accounting profit only considers explicit expenses, incremental economic profit accounts for both explicit costs (e.g., wages, rent) and implicit costs (e.g., the return that could have been earned on the best alternative use of the capital). By focusing on the incremental change, businesses can assess the true economic impact and value added by a particular strategic move, rather than just the overall profitability of the entire enterprise. Understanding incremental economic profit helps companies make more informed investment decisions and optimally allocate resources.
History and Origin
The concept of economic profit has roots in classical economics, distinguishing between accounting returns and true economic returns that incorporate the cost of all inputs, including capital. However, its modern application and popularization in corporate financial management largely trace back to the early 1990s with the rise of Economic Value Added (EVA), a trademarked variant of economic profit. The U.S.-based consulting firm Stern Stewart & Co., co-founded by Joel Stern and Bennett Stewart, championed EVA as a superior measure of corporate performance and shareholder value creation.20,19,18
Stern Stewart promoted EVA as a tool to align management incentives with shareholder wealth creation, arguing that traditional accounting metrics often failed to capture the true economic performance of a company.17 Their methodology involved making adjustments to standard accounting figures to arrive at a more economically realistic measure of profit. The widespread adoption of EVA, and by extension, the broader concept of economic profit, influenced how companies evaluate projects, compensate executives, and approach overall strategic planning.16
Key Takeaways
- Incremental economic profit measures the additional value created by a specific decision or project beyond the cost of all capital employed, including equity.
- Unlike accounting profit, it incorporates the opportunity cost of capital, providing a more comprehensive view of true economic performance.
- A positive incremental economic profit indicates that a project is generating returns above what could have been earned on an alternative investment of similar risk.
- It serves as a powerful tool for optimal capital allocation and value creation within a firm.
- The concept is closely related to Economic Value Added (EVA), which was popularized as a performance metric in the 1990s.
Formula and Calculation
The fundamental concept of economic profit can be expressed as:
Where:
- NOPAT (Net Operating Profit After Tax): The company's profit from its core operations after deducting taxes, but before financing costs.
- Invested Capital: The total amount of capital (debt and equity) employed in the business or project.
- WACC (Weighted Average Cost of Capital): The average rate of return a company expects to pay to its investors (both debt and equity holders). This represents the cost of capital.
Alternatively, economic profit can be calculated using Return on Invested Capital (ROIC):
Incremental economic profit is then the difference in economic profit between two scenarios, typically comparing the economic profit with a new project or decision versus without it. It isolates the specific impact of that additional investment or strategic change.
Interpreting the Incremental Economic Profit
Interpreting incremental economic profit is crucial for strategic decision-making. A positive incremental economic profit signifies that a new project or initiative is expected to generate returns that not only cover its explicit costs but also exceed the return that could have been earned by investing the same capital elsewhere, considering its risk. This means the project is truly adding economic value creation for the company's shareholders.
Conversely, a negative incremental economic profit suggests that the proposed project, while it might show an accounting profit, is not generating a return sufficient to compensate for its cost of capital and the opportunity cost of foregoing alternative investments. In such cases, the capital could be better utilized elsewhere to generate greater economic returns. This metric guides executives in rigorous capital allocation and enhances the quality of investment decisions, ensuring resources are deployed to their highest and best use.
Hypothetical Example
Consider "Tech Innovations Inc." which is evaluating two potential new product lines: Product A and Product B. The company wants to determine which product line offers a higher incremental economic profit. Tech Innovations Inc. has a Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) of 10%.
Scenario 1: Investing in Product A
- Initial Investment (Invested Capital): $1,000,000
- Expected Annual NOPAT: $150,000
Economic Profit for Product A:
$150,000 - ($1,000,000 \times 0.10) = $150,000 - $100,000 = $50,000
Scenario 2: Investing in Product B
- Initial Investment (Invested Capital): $1,200,000
- Expected Annual NOPAT: $160,000
Economic Profit for Product B:
$160,000 - ($1,200,000 \times 0.10) = $160,000 - $120,000 = $40,000
In this simplified example, if the company chooses to pursue Product A, the incremental economic profit generated by Product A, relative to not undertaking either project (assuming zero economic profit for the status quo), would be $50,000. If Product B is chosen, it would generate $40,000. This analysis, based on a project's expected cash flow generation and capital charge, helps Tech Innovations Inc. identify which investment truly maximizes value creation for its shareholders. Even though Product B requires a larger investment, Product A yields a higher economic profit per dollar invested.
Practical Applications
Incremental economic profit is a versatile metric used across various facets of finance and business strategy. In capital allocation, companies use it to evaluate potential projects, comparing the expected economic value generated by each to prioritize investments that promise the greatest additional shareholder value.15 It guides decisions on mergers and acquisitions, new product development, and geographic expansion, ensuring that resources are directed towards ventures that truly enhance the firm's economic well-being.
Furthermore, incremental economic profit is integral to performance measurement and management incentive systems. By linking executive compensation to the growth of economic profit, companies aim to encourage managers to make decisions that optimize the use of capital and generate returns above the cost of capital. This focus helps companies achieve superior financial performance and maintain competitive growth.14 It also informs post-audit reviews of projects, allowing firms to assess whether actual economic returns align with initial projections, thereby refining future investment decisions.
Limitations and Criticisms
Despite its theoretical appeal and practical utility, incremental economic profit, much like its broader counterpart Economic Value Added (EVA), faces several limitations and criticisms. One significant challenge lies in the subjectivity and complexity involved in its calculation. Accurately determining implicit costs and the precise Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) can be difficult, as these estimates often rely on assumptions about risk, market conditions, and the opportunity cost of foregone alternatives.13,12 Small errors in these assumptions can lead to materially different economic profit figures.
Another criticism points to the reliance on adjusted accounting data. While adjustments are made to move closer to an "economic" reality, these adjustments themselves can be subjective and vary significantly between companies, making direct comparability challenging.11 Furthermore, focusing heavily on short-term incremental economic profit could inadvertently discourage long-term strategic investments, such as research and development, which might not generate immediate economic returns but are crucial for sustained future growth.10 Implementing and integrating economic profit metrics across an organization can also be resource-intensive, requiring extensive training and a cultural shift to move away from traditional accounting profit mentalities.9
Incremental Economic Profit vs. Accounting Profit
The primary distinction between incremental economic profit and accounting profit lies in the costs considered. Accounting profit, which is what most people typically refer to as "profit" in a business context, is calculated by subtracting only explicit costs (tangible expenses like wages, rent, raw materials, depreciation) from total revenue. It is the net income reported on a company's income statement and is governed by generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP).8,
Incremental economic profit, on the other hand, takes a broader view by deducting both explicit and implicit costs from revenue.7 The key implicit cost is the opportunity cost of capital—the return that could have been earned if the invested capital had been put to its next best alternative use. This means that a business can have a positive accounting profit but a zero or negative incremental economic profit if its returns do not exceed the minimum acceptable rate of return for the capital employed. W6hile accounting profit indicates financial viability in a statutory sense, incremental economic profit provides a more accurate measure of true value creation and resource efficiency from an economic standpoint, guiding optimal investment decisions.
5## FAQs
What is the core difference between economic profit and accounting profit?
The core difference lies in the inclusion of implicit costs. Accounting profit considers only explicit, out-of-pocket costs, while economic profit subtracts both explicit and implicit costs, notably the opportunity cost of capital.
4### Why is opportunity cost important in calculating incremental economic profit?
Opportunity cost is crucial because it represents the value of the next best alternative use of resources. By including it, incremental economic profit provides a true measure of whether a specific project or decision is truly adding value above what could have been earned elsewhere, ensuring efficient capital allocation.
3### Can a company have an accounting profit but a negative incremental economic profit?
Yes, absolutely. A company can show a positive accounting profit if its revenues exceed its explicit costs. However, if the return generated is less than the cost of capital (i.e., less than what the capital could have earned in an alternative investment of similar risk), then the incremental economic profit would be negative, indicating that the resources are not being used as efficiently as possible from an economic perspective.,
2
1### How does incremental economic profit help in strategic decision-making?
Incremental economic profit helps in strategic investment decisions by focusing on the additional value creation of a specific project. It allows management to compare different investment opportunities on an economically sound basis, prioritizing those that yield returns significantly above their cost of capital and contribute most effectively to shareholder value.