What Is Margin Call?
A margin call is a demand from a broker-dealer to an investor to deposit additional funds or securities into a margin account to bring the account's equity back up to a required minimum level. This typically occurs when the value of the securities held in the margin account falls below a certain threshold, indicating that the investor's borrowed funds (or leverage) are no longer adequately supported by the collateral in the account. Margin calls are a critical component of risk management within the broader category of portfolio theory and leveraged trading, designed to protect both the investor and the brokerage firm from excessive losses.
History and Origin
The concept of borrowing money to purchase securities, known as margin trading, has a long history, but its regulation significantly evolved after major market events. In the 1920s, margin requirements were often very low, allowing investors to borrow a substantial percentage of the purchase price of securities. This high leverage contributed to excessive speculation and amplified market volatility, culminating in the stock market crash of 1929. The widespread use of margin, combined with the lack of stringent regulations, led to a cascade of margin calls during the downturn, forcing investors to sell their holdings and further exacerbating the market's decline.10
In response to the financial instability observed during the Great Depression, the U.S. government enacted the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. This landmark legislation granted the Federal Reserve Board (FRB) the authority to regulate the extension of credit by brokers and dealers for the purchase of securities. Under this authority, the FRB established Regulation T (Reg T), which sets forth initial margin requirements for securities transactions.9 Since its inception, Regulation T has aimed to control the amount of credit available for stock purchases, thereby influencing speculative activity and limiting systemic risk in the financial system.
Key Takeaways
- A margin call is a demand from a broker to an investor to add funds or collateral to a margin account.
- It is triggered when the equity in a margin account falls below the maintenance margin requirement.
- Failure to meet a margin call can lead to the forced liquidation of securities in the account by the broker.
- Margin calls are a key mechanism in risk management for leveraged trading.
- They serve to protect both investors from excessive debt and brokerage firms from counterparty default.
Formula and Calculation
A margin call is not calculated using a specific formula, but rather it is triggered when the equity in a margin account falls below a certain percentage of the securities' current market value. This threshold is known as the maintenance margin requirement.
The equity in a margin account is calculated as:
A margin call is issued when:
The maintenance margin requirement is typically expressed as a percentage of the market value of the securities. For example, if the maintenance margin is 25%, a margin call occurs when:
To meet a margin call, an investor must deposit additional funds or securities to increase the account's equity so that it once again meets or exceeds the maintenance margin percentage.
Interpreting the Margin Call
Receiving a margin call indicates that an investor's leveraged positions have experienced a significant loss, eroding the cushioning equity that serves as collateral for the borrowed funds. It is a direct signal that the risk in the portfolio has increased and that the investor's current holdings no longer sufficiently secure the outstanding loan from the broker-dealer.
From the broker's perspective, a margin call is a necessary step to mitigate their own risk of loss. If an investor's account value continues to decline without additional collateral, the broker faces the potential of an unrecoverable debit balance (the amount owed by the investor). For the investor, a margin call presents a critical decision point: either inject more capital to maintain the positions or face the potential of forced liquidation of their holdings by the broker. Understanding the implications of a margin call is crucial for anyone engaging in leveraged trading, as it highlights the magnified risks associated with borrowing to invest.
Hypothetical Example
Consider an investor who purchases 1,000 shares of XYZ Corp. at $50 per share, totaling $50,000. Under Regulation T, the investor is required to put up an initial margin of 50%, meaning they pay $25,000 in cash and borrow $25,000 from their broker-dealer.
The initial state of the margin account is:
- Market Value of Securities: $50,000
- Debit Balance (Loan): $25,000
- Equity: $50,000 - $25,000 = $25,000
Assume the brokerage firm has a maintenance margin requirement of 30%. This means the investor must maintain at least 30% equity in relation to the current market value of the securities.
If the price of XYZ Corp. stock falls to $35 per share, the new market value of the securities is $35,000 (1,000 shares * $35).
The updated account status:
- Market Value of Securities: $35,000
- Debit Balance (Loan): $25,000 (the loan amount doesn't change unless paid down)
- Equity: $35,000 - $25,000 = $10,000
Now, let's check if a margin call is triggered:
Required Maintenance Margin = 30% of $35,000 = $10,500
Since the current equity ($10,000) is less than the required maintenance margin ($10,500), a margin call of $500 ($10,500 - $10,000) would be issued. The investor would need to deposit an additional $500 in cash or eligible securities to bring their equity back to the required level.
Practical Applications
Margin calls are a practical reality for investors who engage in margin trading across various financial markets, including equities, commodities, and derivatives. They are a core component of the regulatory oversight framework designed to manage the risks inherent in leveraged positions.
Regulatory bodies like the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) enforce rules regarding margin requirements and the handling of margin accounts. For example, FINRA Rule 4210 sets minimum maintenance margin requirements, generally 25% for equity securities, though individual broker-dealer firms can impose higher "house" requirements.8,7 The SEC also provides guidelines to investors on understanding margin accounts and the potential for margin calls.6
In real-world scenarios, margin calls can have significant ripple effects, particularly during periods of high volatility or market downturns. The forced selling of assets to meet margin calls can accelerate price declines, contributing to a "domino effect" that spreads through the financial system.5 Notable examples include the selling pressure seen during the 2008 financial crisis, where widespread margin calls amplified the market's descent.4 More recently, the collapse of Archegos Capital Management in 2021 was attributed to the firm's inability to meet substantial margin calls, leading to massive forced liquidation of its positions and significant losses for its prime brokers.3
Limitations and Criticisms
While margin calls are intended as a risk management tool, their effectiveness and broader implications have been subject to criticism. One primary concern is their potential to exacerbate market downturns. When a large number of investors face margin calls simultaneously, the resulting forced liquidation of securities can create a self-reinforcing cycle of selling pressure, pushing asset prices down further. This can lead to a systemic risk where problems in one part of the market spread, impacting overall market stability.2
Some academic perspectives suggest that while margin requirements may influence market volatility, their overall impact as a policy tool might be limited. This is partly due to the existence of substitute forms of leverage available to investors, which can circumvent the intended effects of stricter margin rules.1 Critics also point out that investors who are prone to taking excessive risks may find alternative ways to do so, regardless of margin policies. While margin calls aim to protect investors from outsized losses, they can also lead to significant and rapid erosion of capital, especially for those who are unable to meet the demand for additional funds. The sudden nature of a margin call can catch unprepared investors off guard, forcing them to sell assets at unfavorable prices.
Margin Call vs. Margin Requirement
The terms "margin call" and "margin requirement" are closely related but refer to distinct concepts in leveraged investing. Understanding the difference is crucial for any investor using a margin account.
-
Margin Requirement: This refers to the standing rules or percentages of equity that an investor must maintain in their margin account. There are two primary types of margin requirements:
- Initial margin: The percentage of the purchase price an investor must pay in cash when buying securities on margin. For instance, Regulation T typically sets this at 50% for equity securities.
- Maintenance margin: The minimum percentage of equity that an investor must maintain in their margin account after the initial purchase. If the equity falls below this level due to market fluctuations, it triggers a margin call. FINRA generally sets this at 25% for most securities, though individual brokers often have higher "house" requirements.
-
Margin Call: This is an event or a notification from the broker-dealer to the investor. It occurs when the equity in the investor's margin account drops below the specified maintenance margin requirement. The margin call demands that the investor deposit additional cash or securities to bring the account's equity back up to the required maintenance level. Essentially, the margin requirement is the rule, and a margin call is the consequence of failing to meet that rule in real-time.
FAQs
What happens if I don't meet a margin call?
If you fail to meet a margin call within the specified timeframe (typically a few business days), your broker-dealer has the right to sell some or all of the securities in your margin account without prior notification. This is known as forced liquidation, and it is done to cover the outstanding loan and bring your account back to the required maintenance margin level. This can result in significant losses, as the broker will sell at current market prices, regardless of how low they may be.
How can I avoid a margin call?
To avoid a margin call, it's crucial to manage your leverage carefully. You can do this by keeping a substantial amount of equity in your margin account beyond the minimum maintenance margin requirement, closely monitoring your positions and overall portfolio value, and being prepared to deposit additional funds if market conditions turn unfavorable. A conservative trading strategy that uses less borrowed money can also reduce the risk of receiving a margin call.
Can interest rates affect margin calls?
While interest rates directly affect the cost of borrowing on margin, they do not directly trigger a margin call. A margin call is prompted by a decline in the value of the securities held in your margin account, which reduces your equity below the required threshold. However, higher interest rates increase the overall cost of carrying a leveraged position, which can indirectly put pressure on an account's profitability and potentially contribute to conditions where a margin call is more likely if the underlying investments are not performing well.