Insurance claim: Meaning, Criticisms & Real-World Uses

What Is an Insurance Claim?

An insurance claim is a formal request by a policyholder to an insurance company for coverage or compensation for a covered loss or policy event. This process is a fundamental aspect of Risk Management, allowing individuals and entities to transfer the financial burden of potential future risks to an insurer in exchange for regular premium payments. When an insured event occurs, such as property damage, an accident, or an illness, the policyholder initiates an insurance claim to seek financial recovery as outlined in their insurance contract. The insurance claim process involves submitting documentation, an investigation by the insurer, and ultimately a decision on whether to pay, deny, or partially pay the claim.

History and Origin

The concept of insurance and the subsequent act of making a claim for a loss has ancient roots, with early forms traced back to Babylonian merchants around 4000–3000 BCE, who used "bottomry contracts" where loans for shipments would not need repayment if the cargo was lost at sea. The interest rate on these loans effectively covered the risk, a primitive form of a premium. ²⁵Guilds in the Middle Ages also practiced similar forms of mutual aid, where members contributed to a fund to cover losses.

Modern insurance, and by extension the modern insurance claim, gained significant impetus following the Great Fire of London in 1666, which destroyed over 30,000 homes. This event spurred the development of formal fire insurance companies. ²⁴Edward Lloyd's coffeehouse in 17th-century London became a hub for merchants, bankers, and underwriters to conduct maritime insurance business, laying the groundwork for Lloyd's of London, which would later become a global insurance market,.²³ ²²The development of standardized contracts and the formalization of underwriting practices paved the way for a more structured process for handling an insurance claim, ensuring that a system of indemnity was in place to restore the insured to their pre-loss financial state. Lloyd's is noted for its ethical handling of major claims, such as those from the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, which helped solidify its reputation.
²¹

Key Takeaways

An insurance claim is a formal request for compensation from an insurer for a covered loss.
The process generally involves notifying the insurer, submitting documentation, and an investigation by an adjuster.
Claim outcomes depend on the policy's terms, the nature of the loss, and the insurer's assessment.
Insurance companies are legally obligated to handle an insurance claim with "good faith" and fairness.
A policyholder's claims history can impact future premium rates and insurability.

Formula and Calculation

While there isn't a single universal formula for an entire insurance claim, the calculation of the payout for a covered loss often involves several components:

\text{Payout} = \text{Covered Loss Amount} - \text{Deductible} - \text{Depreciation (if applicable)}

Where:

Covered Loss Amount: The total financial impact of the event as determined by the insurer, up to the policy's coverage limits.
Deductible: The amount the policyholder must pay out of pocket before the insurance coverage begins to pay. This is a common feature in many insurance policies.
²⁰* Depreciation: For some types of property claims, especially older items, the payout may be reduced based on the item's depreciated value rather than its replacement cost.

Actuary professionals play a crucial role in the broader insurance industry by calculating probabilities and financial risks, which indirectly influences the pricing of policies and the reserves set aside to pay an insurance claim.

Interpreting the Insurance Claim

Interpreting an insurance claim primarily involves understanding the policy's terms and conditions, the nature of the loss, and the insurer's assessment. When an insurance claim is filed, the insurer investigates to determine if the event is covered by the existing policy. This includes verifying the cause of the loss, the extent of the damage or injury, and whether the policyholder has met their obligations, such as paying premiums and reporting the loss promptly.

The outcome of an insurance claim dictates the financial compensation or services provided. A full settlement means the insurer agrees to pay the full amount requested, up to policy limits, after any deductible is applied. A partial payment may occur if only a portion of the loss is covered, or if there are disputes over the value of the loss, such as in a Loss Assessment. A denial means the insurer believes the event is not covered, often due to policy exclusions, misrepresentation, or a lack of proof of loss. Understanding these interpretations is crucial for policyholders to navigate the claims process effectively.

Hypothetical Example

Consider Sarah, who has a homeowner's insurance policy with a $1,000 deductible. One evening, a severe hailstorm damages her roof. Sarah immediately contacts her insurance broker and then her insurance company to file an insurance claim.

An adjuster from the insurance company inspects the damage, estimating the repair cost for the roof to be $12,000. After verifying that hailstorm damage is covered under Sarah's policy, the insurance company processes her claim. The total covered loss is determined to be $12,000. Since Sarah has a $1,000 deductible, the insurance company will pay out $11,000 ($12,000 - $1,000). Sarah is responsible for the initial $1,000, and the insurer covers the remainder, allowing her to proceed with the necessary repairs.

Practical Applications

Insurance claims are integral across various sectors, providing financial protection and facilitating recovery from unforeseen events. In Financial Planning, understanding how to file and manage an insurance claim is crucial for safeguarding assets and income. For instance, homeowners rely on property insurance claims for damage from natural disasters. California wildfires, for example, have resulted in significant payouts, with insured losses from the Eaton and Palisades fires alone estimated to range from $20 billion to $45 billion, potentially impacting state funds designed to protect consumers when utility equipment causes a blaze. ¹⁹As of early 2025, insurers have already paid nearly $7 billion in claims related to these fires.
¹⁸
Businesses frequently file liability insurance claims for incidents like product defects or workplace accidents. The process of an insurance claim is also fundamental in the healthcare system, where medical claims are submitted for treatment costs. In the financial markets, the insurance industry itself relies on the efficient handling of an insurance claim, often transferring risk through reinsurance agreements, where one insurer passes on some of its risks to another insurer.

The regulation of insurance companies, including their claims handling practices, is primarily managed at the state level in the U.S., although federal laws also apply to certain aspects of the industry, as outlined in Title 15, Chapter 20 of the U.S. Code.
¹⁷

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their vital role, insurance claims processes can face limitations and criticisms. A significant concern is "bad faith" insurance practices, where insurers unreasonably deny, delay, or underpay a legitimate insurance claim. Insurance companies have a legal obligation to act in "good faith," which includes conducting thorough investigations, communicating clearly, and assessing claims fairly,.¹⁶ ¹⁵However, instances of alleged bad faith can lead to disputes and legal action, causing significant financial and emotional distress for policyholders,.¹⁴ ¹³Such practices can include failing to respond promptly, inadequately investigating, or misrepresenting policy provisions.
¹²
Another limitation stems from the complexity of policies and the potential for misunderstandings regarding coverage and exclusions. This can lead to an insurance claim being denied because the specific event or type of damage falls outside the policy's scope. The extensive information gathering involved in an insurance claim, including the generation of a Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange (C.L.U.E.) report—which tracks claims on a property for up to seven years—can also affect future insurability or premium rates, even for new owners of a property with a history of claims,.

##¹¹ ¹⁰Insurance Claim vs. Loss History

While closely related, an insurance claim and a loss history represent distinct concepts. An insurance claim is the active request made by a policyholder to their insurer for compensation following a covered event. It is the action taken to initiate the process of receiving benefits from an insurance policy.

In contrast, loss history is a record of all past insurance claims made by a policyholder or against a specific property. This⁹ history includes details such as the date of the claim, the type of loss, the amount paid, and the outcome (e.g., paid, denied, abandoned). Insurance companies use loss history to evaluate the risk associated with an individual or property when determining eligibility for coverage and setting premium rates. A frequent or significant loss history can indicate higher future risk, potentially leading to higher premiums or even denial of coverage. Esse⁸ntially, an insurance claim is an event, while loss history is the cumulative record of those events.

FAQs

How long does an insurance claim take to process?

The time it takes to process an insurance claim varies greatly depending on the type and complexity of the claim. Simple claims, like a minor car accident, might be resolved within weeks. More complex claims, such as those involving significant property damage or personal injury, could take months or even longer, especially if disputes arise. Insurers generally have a duty to act promptly.

###⁷ What happens if my insurance claim is denied?
If an insurance claim is denied, the insurer must provide a reason for the denial, often citing specific policy exclusions or unmet conditions. Policyholders have the right to appeal the decision, provide additional documentation, or, in some cases, seek legal counsel to dispute the denial, especially if they believe the denial was made in "bad faith". Cons⁶umers can also file complaints with their state's insurance department or the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC),.

##⁵#⁴ Does filing an insurance claim increase my premiums?
Filing an insurance claim can, in many cases, lead to an increase in your premiums, especially for property and auto insurance. Insurers use your claims history to assess your future risk. Multiple claims or certain types of claims may indicate a higher risk profile, which can result in higher rates when your policy renews. Howe³ver, minor incidents or claims that don't involve fault may have less impact.

What is a "first-party" vs. "third-party" insurance claim?

A "first-party" insurance claim is filed by the policyholder directly with their own insurance company to cover their own losses, such as a claim for damage to your car under your collision coverage. A "t²hird-party" insurance claim is filed by someone who suffered a loss due to the actions of another party, against that other party's liability insurance policy, such as when a person injured in a car accident files a claim against the at-fault driver's insurance.¹