Intestate

What Is Intestate?

Intestate refers to the condition of a person who dies without a valid will in place. In such cases, the distribution of their assets and property falls under state laws of intestate succession rather than their expressed wishes.¹⁵ Dying intestate means the decedent's estate will undergo a process determined by a probate court, which applies predefined legal formulas to distribute the estate among surviving family members. This concept is a fundamental aspect of estate planning and law.

History and Origin

The concept of intestacy and the legal frameworks governing it have deep historical roots, evolving alongside societal structures and inheritance norms. In ancient legal systems, such as Roman law, the idea of dying without a will was often seen as an exceptional situation, with strong societal and even religious emphasis on making a testament.¹⁴ However, even early Roman law recognized the need for rules of succession when a will was absent or incomplete.¹³

In Anglo-American common law, the rules of intestate succession also developed over centuries, prioritizing close relatives. Historically, concepts like "ancestral estate" dictated that property revert to the line from which it originated if an intestate person died without descendants.¹² Modern intestacy laws aim to reflect what a "reasonable testator" would have wanted, balancing traditional kinship structures with contemporary social policies. These laws vary significantly by jurisdiction, establishing a hierarchy for inheritance that typically prioritizes spouses, children, and then other extended family members.

Key Takeaways

• Absence of a Will: Dying intestate means a person passed away without a legally valid will.¹¹
• State Law Governs: When there is no will, state laws of intestate succession dictate how the decedent's property is distributed.¹⁰
• Probate Court Involvement: The estate of an intestate person must go through a probate court, which oversees the distribution process.⁹
• Hierarchical Distribution: Intestacy laws generally establish a hierarchy of heirs, typically prioritizing a surviving spouse and children, followed by other close relatives like parents and siblings.⁸
• Potential for Unintended Outcomes: The rigid nature of intestacy laws can lead to the distribution of assets in a manner that might not align with the deceased's unstated wishes.

Formula and Calculation

Intestacy does not involve a mathematical formula in the traditional sense, as it is a legal status rather than a quantitative measure. However, the distribution of an intestate estate follows specific statutory formulas defined by state law. These formulas dictate the percentages or portions of an estate that various classes of heir receive.

For example, a common distribution scheme in many states, often influenced by the Uniform Probate Code (UPC), might follow a pattern like this for the net estate (after debts and expenses are paid):

• If the decedent is survived by a spouse and no children from outside the marriage, the spouse often inherits the entire estate.
• If the decedent is survived by a spouse and children, and all children are also the children of the surviving spouse, the spouse typically receives a significant portion (e.g., the first $X amount plus a share of the remainder), and the children divide the rest.
• If the decedent is survived by children but no spouse, the children inherit the entire estate in equal shares (or by representation if a child has predeceased).
• If there is no surviving spouse or children, the estate typically passes to the decedent's parents, then siblings, and so on, following a defined lineage.

The specific "calculation" is a matter of applying the percentages or fixed amounts set forth in the relevant state's statutes for distribution among the designated beneficiary classes.

Interpreting the Intestate

Interpreting "intestate" simply means recognizing that a person has died without a valid testamentary document to guide the transfer of their wealth. The implication is that the process of asset transfer will be governed by statutory law, not personal preference. This legal state necessitates the appointment of an administrator (rather than an executor) by the probate court to manage the decedent's affairs, pay off any outstanding liabilities, and distribute the remaining estate. The interpretation hinges on understanding that the state's rigid rules will apply, potentially leading to outcomes the deceased might not have desired.

Hypothetical Example

Consider Jane, a single mother of two adult children, Alex and Ben. Jane tragically passes away unexpectedly without having created a will or any other trust documents. She owned a house, a bank account, and some investments.

Because Jane died intestate, her estate must go through probate. The probate court in her state will appoint an administrator to manage her estate. According to her state's intestate succession laws, which prioritize direct descendants when there is no surviving spouse, her assets would be divided equally between her two children, Alex and Ben. Had Jane wished for unequal distribution, or perhaps wanted to leave a portion to a charity or a friend, these wishes would not be honored under intestacy laws.

Practical Applications

The concept of intestacy is critical in various areas of financial and legal planning:

• Estate Administration: When an individual dies intestate, state law dictates the process for identifying heirs, settling debts, and distributing assets. This often involves a court-supervised process. The Uniform Probate Code (UPC), adopted in various forms by many states, provides a standardized framework for handling such situations, aiming to simplify the probate process.⁷,⁶,⁵
• Financial Planning: Understanding intestacy motivates individuals to engage in proactive estate planning. Creating a will or establishing a trust ensures that assets are distributed according to one's wishes, rather than generic state laws.
• Guardianship: In cases where a parent dies intestate and has minor children, the court will appoint a guardianship for those children, often based on statutory preferences, which may not align with the deceased parent's unstated desires.
• Taxation: While dying intestate doesn't directly impose specific taxes, the resulting estate administration and distribution can still be subject to federal estate taxes and state-level inheritance tax if the estate's value exceeds certain thresholds. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) outlines the requirements for federal estate tax, which applies to estates above a specified exemption amount.⁴,³ As of 2025, the federal estate tax threshold is $13.99 million for individuals.²

Limitations and Criticisms

The primary limitation of dying intestate is the loss of control over one's legacy. The rigid framework of state intestate laws may not reflect the decedent's true intentions or unique family circumstances.

• Unintended Heirs: Assets might be distributed to relatives the deceased was not close to, or did not intend to benefit, potentially excluding partners, friends, or charitable organizations.¹
• Complexities for Blended Families: Intestacy laws can be particularly problematic for blended families, where stepchildren may not have the same inheritance rights as biological or adopted children.
• Probate Costs and Delays: While wills also go through probate, dying intestate can sometimes complicate the process, potentially leading to increased legal fees and longer delays in asset distribution as the court must strictly adhere to statutory rules to identify heirs and manage the estate.
• Lack of Guardianship Designation: Without a will, a court must decide on the guardianship of minor children, which might not be the choice the deceased parent would have made.
• Esate Tax Implications: Although not a direct tax on intestacy, the absence of comprehensive estate planning can lead to higher federal or state estate tax burdens, as strategic tax planning mechanisms (like certain trusts) cannot be implemented post-mortem. The federal estate tax is levied on the transfer of a deceased person's estate and applies to property transferred by will or, in the absence of a will, according to state intestacy laws.,

Intestate vs. Probate

While closely related, "intestate" and "probate" refer to distinct legal concepts.

| Feature | Intestate | Probate