Investment policies

What Are Investment Policies?

Investment policies refer to the set of guidelines, principles, and rules that govern the management of an investment portfolio for an individual or institution. These policies provide a structured framework within the broader field of portfolio management, ensuring that investment decisions align with specific objectives and constraints. An investment policy statement (IPS) formally documents these policies, outlining the investor's investment objectives, acceptable levels of risk tolerance, and the process for achieving financial goals. The clear articulation of investment policies helps to standardize decision-making, promote consistency, and manage expectations for all parties involved in the investment process.

History and Origin

The concept of formalizing investment policies gained prominence with the growth of institutional investing, particularly pension funds and endowments. As these entities grew in size and complexity, the need for a systematic approach to asset management became critical. A significant driver for the adoption of formal investment policies in the United States was the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA). While ERISA itself does not explicitly mandate an investment policy statement, the Department of Labor (DOL), which enforces ERISA, has consistently promoted its use as consistent with the fiduciary obligations outlined in the act¹⁴. Such policies demonstrate a prudent process for selecting and monitoring investments, a key aspect of fiduciary duty under ERISA¹³. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has also emphasized the importance of investment advisers adhering to fiduciary duties, which implicitly requires a well-defined approach to client investments, often documented within an IPS¹².

Key Takeaways

• Investment policies establish a formal framework for guiding all investment decisions.
• They define an investor's goals, risk tolerance, and acceptable investment types.
• A well-structured investment policy statement promotes consistency and discipline in portfolio management.
• These policies are crucial for demonstrating procedural prudence, especially for institutional fiduciaries.
• Regular review and revision of investment policies are essential to adapt to changing market conditions and investor circumstances.

Interpreting the Investment Policies

Interpreting investment policies involves understanding how the documented guidelines translate into practical investment decisions and ongoing portfolio oversight. For instance, a policy might specify a target asset allocation of 60% equities and 40% fixed income. This isn't merely a static target but dictates the process for initial portfolio construction and subsequent rebalancing as market fluctuations cause deviations. Similarly, explicit guidelines regarding acceptable asset classes, diversification requirements, or concentration limits serve as boundaries within which portfolio managers must operate. Adherence to these policies provides a measurable standard against which investment performance and decision-making can be evaluated, helping to ensure that actions remain consistent with the investor's long-term investment objectives.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "Horizon Growth Fund," a hypothetical institutional investor established to fund a university's scholarships. Its investment policies dictate a long-term growth objective, a moderate-to-high risk tolerance, and a primary focus on capital appreciation.

The investment policy statement specifies:

• Target Asset Allocation: 70% equities, 25% fixed income, 5% alternative investments.
• Equity Allocation Breakdown: Global diversification with 40% U.S. large-cap, 20% U.S. small/mid-cap, and 10% international developed markets.
• Fixed Income: High-quality government and corporate bonds, maintaining a weighted average duration of 5-7 years.
• Liquidity Requirements: Maintain at least 5% of total assets in highly liquid instruments to cover anticipated scholarship disbursements and operational expenses.
• Rebalancing Threshold: Portfolio to be rebalanced when any asset class deviates by more than 5% from its target allocation.

If, due to a strong equity market, the equity portion of the fund grew to 78%, the investment policy would trigger a rebalancing event. The investment committee would then direct the sale of some equity holdings and the purchase of fixed income or alternative assets to bring the portfolio back in line with the 70/25/5 target, maintaining the fund's defined risk profile and long-term strategy.

Practical Applications

Investment policies are fundamental documents with broad practical applications across various facets of the financial world. For institutional investors like defined contribution plan sponsors, pension funds, and charitable foundations, an IPS establishes a clear framework for fulfilling their fiduciary duty by guiding the selection, monitoring, and termination of investments¹¹. It provides a consistent decision-making process, even as members of an investment committee may change over time¹⁰.

In wealth management, financial advisors use investment policies to formalize the agreement with individual clients, ensuring that the portfolio aligns with the client's unique investment objectives, risk tolerance, and liquidity needs. These policies also dictate asset allocation targets and rebalancing procedures, acting as a roadmap for long-term financial planning. The presence of a clear investment policy can also be critical in regulatory oversight, where bodies like the SEC assess whether investment advisers are meeting their obligations to clients, including duties of care and loyalty⁹.

Limitations and Criticisms

While essential, investment policies are not without limitations. A common criticism is that overly rigid or complex policies can hinder effective portfolio management by limiting flexibility and adaptability to changing market conditions⁸. For instance, if an investment policy is too prescriptive about specific metrics for monitoring investments, it might compel fiduciaries to make decisions that, while compliant with the policy, may not be the most prudent given current circumstances⁷. The mere existence of an investment policy statement does not absolve fiduciaries of liability; the policy must be diligently followed and enforced⁶. Failure to adhere to the provisions of an investment policy, whether operational or substantive, may be viewed as a violation of fiduciary responsibilities.

Another challenge lies in the "set and forget" mentality, where policies are drafted but not regularly reviewed or updated. An effective investment policy must be a living document that evolves with the investor's changing circumstances and market dynamics⁵. Moreover, the quality of a policy depends heavily on its initial construction, as poorly drafted statements lacking clarity or failing to align with investor goals can lead to unfavorable outcomes⁴.

Investment Policies vs. Investment Strategy

While often used interchangeably, "investment policies" and "investment strategy" represent distinct but related concepts in finance. Investment policies are the foundational, overarching guidelines that define what an investor seeks to achieve and how they will generally operate within acceptable risk parameters. These policies articulate the investor's objectives, constraints, risk tolerance, and high-level asset allocation targets. They are the broad rules of engagement for managing capital.

In contrast, an investment strategy is the specific plan or methodology employed to execute the investment policies and achieve the stated objectives. It details the tactical approach—for example, specific security selection criteria, market timing decisions, or the use of particular investment vehicles like exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or mutual funds. An investment policy might state a desire for long-term growth with moderate risk, while the investment strategy would outline the specific blend of securities, industries, or geographic regions chosen to realize that growth, and how performance measurement will be conducted. The strategy operates within the boundaries set by the policies.

FAQs

What is the primary purpose of an investment policy statement (IPS)?

The primary purpose of an IPS is to formally document the investment goals, objectives, risk tolerance, and constraints of an investor or institution. It serves as a roadmap for all investment decisions, ensuring a disciplined and consistent approach to portfolio management.

Who creates an investment policy?

Investment policies are typically created by the investor in collaboration with their financial advisor or portfolio manager. For institutional investors, an investment committee or board of trustees is responsible for developing and overseeing the investment policies.
³

How often should investment policies be reviewed?

While there's no strict legal requirement for all plans, investment policies should generally be reviewed periodically, at least annually, and certainly whenever there are significant changes to the investor's financial situation, investment objectives, or major shifts in market conditions. ²This ensures the policy remains relevant and effective.

Are investment policies legally binding?

Once formally adopted and signed, especially for institutional plans subject to regulations like ERISA, an investment policy statement is considered a governing document. While not every provision may be legally enforceable in the same way, fiduciaries are generally expected to adhere to the policies outlined, and failure to do so can have legal implications.¹