Skip to main content
← Back to L Definitions

Lipstick_index

What Is the Lipstick Index?

The Lipstick Index is an unconventional, informal economic indicator that suggests consumers tend to increase their purchases of small, affordable luxury goods, such as lipstick, during times of economic hardship or uncertainty. It falls under the broader category of behavioral finance and aims to offer insight into consumer psychology and discretionary spending during an economic downturn. The theory behind the Lipstick Index posits that when larger, more expensive luxury items become unaffordable due to a struggling economy, consumers seek emotional gratification and comfort through smaller, more accessible indulgences.18

History and Origin

The concept of the Lipstick Index was popularized by Leonard Lauder, then chairman of Estée Lauder Companies, in 2001. Following the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks and the ensuing recession, Lauder observed an unusual increase in lipstick sales at a time when overall consumer spending was declining. 16, 17He posited that women, unable or unwilling to splurge on high-priced items like designer handbags or vacations, would instead opt for a less expensive "pick-me-up" like a tube of lipstick. This observation captured significant media attention and has since been discussed as an informal gauge of market sentiment and consumer resilience during challenging economic periods.
15

Key Takeaways

  • The Lipstick Index is an informal economic indicator suggesting that sales of small, affordable luxury items, like lipstick, may rise during periods of economic distress.
  • The theory posits that consumers seek minor indulgences when larger luxury purchases are out of reach due to financial constraints.
  • First observed in 2001, its predictive value and consistency as a reliable economic indicator are debated among economists.
  • Factors such as changing consumer behavioral economics and societal shifts can influence the applicability of the Lipstick Index.
  • While anecdotal, it provides a unique perspective on consumer confidence during economic slowdowns.

Interpreting the Lipstick Index

Interpreting the Lipstick Index involves observing trends in the sales of affordable luxury goods, particularly cosmetics, to infer broader economic conditions. A rise in lipstick sales, especially when coupled with a decline in larger luxury purchases, is theorized to signal a weakening economy or an impending recession. The underlying rationale is that individuals, facing tightened budgets, still desire a sense of normalcy and self-indulgence. A relatively inexpensive item like lipstick offers a psychological boost without significantly impacting their overall finances. However, the Lipstick Index is not a precise metric and should be viewed as a qualitative observation rather than a strict quantitative measure of economic health. It often provides narrative context and can signal warning signs ahead of traditional economic data.
13, 14

Hypothetical Example

Consider a hypothetical scenario where the national economy is experiencing rising unemployment rate and concerns about inflation are growing. A large retailer that tracks its sales data notices a significant shift in consumer behavior. Sales of high-end automobiles, luxury travel packages, and designer apparel have sharply declined over two consecutive quarters. However, within the same period, the sales figures for premium lipsticks, quality nail polishes, and specialized skincare products have shown a steady increase. This observation, where consumers are cutting back on "big-ticket" items but still indulging in smaller, more accessible luxuries, would align with the Lipstick Index theory, suggesting a prevalent sense of economic anxiety among the populace.

Practical Applications

The Lipstick Index, while not a formal econometric tool, can be applied informally in various contexts. In retail and marketing, businesses might use the concept to anticipate shifts in retail sales and adjust their product offerings and inventory during economic shifts. For instance, cosmetic companies might prioritize the production and marketing of affordable beauty items when signs of an economic downturn emerge. Financial analysts and economists occasionally reference such unconventional indicators to gain additional, albeit anecdotal, insights into consumer sentiment and the broader economy, alongside traditional metrics like gross domestic product (GDP). For example, data from NPD Group in June 2022 showed that sales of lipstick and other lip makeup grew 48% year-over-year in the first quarter, more than twice as fast as other beauty categories, amidst recession threats.
12

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its intriguing premise, the Lipstick Index has significant limitations and faces considerable criticism as a reliable economic predictor. Its correlation with economic downturns is largely anecdotal and has not been consistently validated across all recessions. For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, lipstick sales notably declined, largely attributed to widespread mask-wearing and reduced social activity, which countered the traditional Lipstick Index theory. 10, 11Estée Lauder's CEO even noted that moisturizers had supplanted lipsticks as an indicator during this period. C9ritics argue that the theory oversimplifies complex consumer behavior and can be influenced by various external factors, such as fashion trends, product innovation, or social changes. Furthermore, the "illusory truth effect," where repeated claims become more believable regardless of evidence, may contribute to its persistent popular appeal despite a lack of empirical support.

8## Lipstick Index vs. Men's Underwear Index

The Lipstick Index is often compared to other quirky economic indicators, such as the Men's Underwear Index. Both are informal gauges that attempt to reflect consumer sentiment and economic health through sales of seemingly unrelated, often personal, consumer goods.

FeatureLipstick IndexMen's Underwear Index
Core ConceptSales of affordable luxury items (e.g., lipstick) increase during economic downturns as consumers seek small indulgences when larger luxuries are out of reach.Sales of men's underwear, particularly higher-end brands, tend to decline during economic slowdowns, as men might delay replacing an unseen wardrobe item.
Primary DriverPsychological need for "pick-me-ups" and self-gratification when faced with financial stress.Tendency to cut spending on private, non-visible items first when disposable income is constrained.
OriginatorPopularized by Leonard Lauder, Chairman of Estée Lauder.Often attributed to former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, though evidence for this direct attribution is elusive.
ReliabilityDebated; anecdotal evidence for some downturns (e.g., 2001), but inconsistent for others (e.g., 2020).Also debated; considered a soft signal rather than a robust economic predictor, as consumer habits and fashion trends can complicate its interpretation.
Category of GoodsVisible, appearance-enhancing, small luxury.Non-visible, essential but often delayed purchase, basic apparel.

While both indices offer a glimpse into consumer spending patterns, they operate on different psychological premises regarding what consumers prioritize when tightening their belts.

FAQs

Is the Lipstick Index a proven economic indicator?

No, the Lipstick Index is not a scientifically proven economic indicator. It is an anecdotal observation and an informal theory within behavioral economics that has shown inconsistent reliability over time.

#6, 7## What other "unconventional" economic indicators exist?
Besides the Lipstick Index, other unconventional indicators include the Men's Underwear Index, the Skyscraper Index (suggesting recessions follow the construction of the world's tallest buildings), and the Hemline Index (proposing that skirt hemlines rise in good economic times and fall during downturns). Th4, 5ese are often seen as interesting observations rather than definitive predictive tools.

Why would people buy more lipstick during a recession?

The theory suggests that during an economic downturn, consumers cut back on expensive luxury items but still desire small indulgences that provide a psychological uplift or a sense of normalcy. Lipstick, being a relatively affordable cosmetic, fits this need for a small, accessible treat.

#3## Did the Lipstick Index hold true during the COVID-19 pandemic?
No, the Lipstick Index generally did not hold true during the COVID-19 pandemic. Due to mask-wearing and reduced social gatherings, lipstick sales actually declined in many regions, demonstrating that external factors can significantly impact consumer spending patterns, even for small luxuries.1, 2