Lost earning capacity

What Is Lost Earning Capacity?

Lost earning capacity refers to the reduction in an individual's potential to earn income in the future due to an injury, illness, or wrongful act. Unlike a direct loss of current wages, which accounts for income already missed, lost earning capacity is a forward-looking concept within the broader field of economic damages and financial planning. It assesses the hypothetical difference between what an individual could have earned had the incident not occurred and what they are now capable of earning given their impaired ability. This concept is central to personal injury lawsuits and other litigation where a claimant seeks damages for long-term financial detriment. The evaluation of lost earning capacity considers a person's skills, education, experience, and potential for career advancement.

History and Origin

The concept of compensating individuals for the impairment of their ability to work has roots in common law, evolving significantly with the development of modern tort law. Early legal systems recognized the need to compensate for direct, tangible losses from harm. However, as economies became more complex and the value of an individual's future productivity became more apparent, courts began to distinguish between immediate wage losses and the more abstract but equally real loss of future earning potential. Landmark legal cases throughout the 20th century further solidified the legal precedent for awarding damages based on lost earning capacity, emphasizing that the focus is on what the plaintiff could have earned, rather than what they would have earned. For instance, California courts have consistently upheld this distinction, viewing the impairment of the power to work as a form of general damage, separate from specific lost earnings¹⁵, ¹⁶.

Key Takeaways

• Lost earning capacity quantifies the potential future income an individual can no longer earn due to an injury or wrongful act.
• It is a forward-looking assessment, considering what a person could have earned over their working life.
• Calculations often involve experts in forensic economics and vocational rehabilitation.
• Factors considered include pre-injury earnings, education, skills, career trajectory, and work-life expectancy.
• Lost earning capacity differs from lost wages, which are actual past income losses.

Formula and Calculation

While there isn't a single universal formula for calculating lost earning capacity, the core principle involves comparing two hypothetical earnings streams: what the individual would have earned without the injury, and what they are now capable of earning with the impairment. This difference is then projected over their expected work-life and adjusted to its present value.

The general conceptual approach for calculating lost earning capacity is:

Where:

• (LEC) = Lost Earning Capacity
• (PE_t) = Projected Earnings in year (t) without the injury
• (AE_t) = Anticipated Earnings in year (t) with the injury
• (N) = Work-life expectancy (number of future working years)
• (DR) = Discount rate (to adjust future values to present value)
• (t) = Year in the projection period

This calculation is highly complex and typically performed by forensic economists. They consider various inputs, including the individual's pre-injury earnings, education, job skills, and potential for promotions and raises, often drawing on data from sources like the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics' Occupational Outlook Handbook for occupational wage and outlook information¹⁴. They also assess the impact of the injury on the individual's ability to perform their job or pursue alternative employment, and then apply a discount rate to account for the time value of money.

Interpreting the Lost Earning Capacity

Interpreting lost earning capacity involves understanding its role as a measure of long-term economic loss and potential. It represents the value of diminished human capital—the skills, knowledge, and abilities that contribute to an individual's earning potential. This assessment is not about what an individual did earn, but what they could have earned in the absence of the disabling event.

For instance, a highly educated individual who was temporarily unemployed at the time of an injury might still have a significant claim for lost earning capacity if the injury prevents them from pursuing their intended high-earning career path. Conversely, an individual with a stable, lower-paying job who suffers an injury that forces them into a significantly less demanding, but equally compensated, role might have a smaller claim for lost earning capacity, even if they experience short-term lost wages. The interpretation requires a holistic view of the individual's pre-injury potential and the demonstrable impact of the injury on that potential over their remaining work-life. It aims to restore, to the extent possible, the injured party's financial prospects.
¹³

Hypothetical Example

Consider Sarah, a 30-year-old aspiring software engineer. She recently completed her master's degree and was on the verge of accepting a position with a projected starting salary of $100,000 per year, with expected annual raises and career progression. Before she could start, a severe accident left her with a permanent hand injury, preventing her from performing the intricate tasks required for software development. Despite her extensive education, she is now limited to administrative roles, which pay approximately $40,000 per year.

To calculate Sarah's lost earning capacity, an expert would first project her earnings as a software engineer had the accident not occurred, taking into account potential promotions and salary growth over her expected working life, perhaps until age 67. Simultaneously, they would project her earnings in an administrative role over the same period. The difference between these two projected income streams each year, discounted to its present value, would represent her lost earning capacity. For instance, if the difference in potential earnings for just one year was $60,000, that amount would be included in the multi-year calculation.

Practical Applications

Lost earning capacity claims are primarily seen in legal and insurance claims settings where individuals seek compensation for injuries or wrongful acts that impact their future income potential.

• Personal Injury Lawsuits: In cases involving car accidents, medical malpractice, or workplace injuries, plaintiffs often seek to recover damages for their diminished ability to earn. This is particularly relevant for severe injuries that result in long-term disability or require a career change.
  ¹²* Wrongful Death Claims: When a person's death is caused by another's negligence, the surviving family may claim lost earning capacity on behalf of the deceased, representing the income the deceased would have contributed to the household over their lifetime. ¹¹Even for minors with no earnings history, courts may allow recovery based on factors like age, education, and family career achievements.
  ¹⁰* Disability Benefits Assessment: While not directly a claim for "lost earning capacity" in a legal settlement, the principles of assessing long-term impact on work ability are similar when determining eligibility for and amount of long-term disability benefits.
• Economic Analysis in Settlement Negotiations: Forensic economists are often employed by legal teams to provide expert testimony and calculations. They use methodologies that account for individual work history, education, and labor market trends, often referencing publications like the Bureau of Labor Statistics' Occupational Outlook Handbook, which provides detailed information on various occupations, including typical earnings, job outlook, and educational requirements.
  ⁹

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its importance in compensating individuals for future financial harm, assessing lost earning capacity presents several limitations and has faced criticism, primarily due to its inherently speculative nature.

One significant challenge is the need to predict an uncertain future. Factors such as an individual's career trajectory, potential promotions, economic recessions, industry shifts, and individual choices (e.g., career changes, early retirement) are difficult to forecast with absolute certainty. ⁸While experts use statistical models, historical data, and actuarial science (such as IRS life expectancy tables),⁷ these are projections, not guarantees.

Critics also point to the difficulty in quantifying non-monetary aspects of work, such as job satisfaction or the value of unpaid work, which are not captured in a pure earning capacity calculation. Furthermore, the selection of the appropriate discount rate can significantly impact the final calculation, leading to potential disputes between opposing parties. Different methodologies, such as statistical work-life tables versus more complex probabilistic models, can yield varying results, making the assessment process complex and often contentious. ⁶The distinction between "lost earnings" and "lost earning capacity" can also be misunderstood, as one focuses on actual past income loss, while the other addresses future potential.
⁵

Lost Earning Capacity vs. Lost Wages

While both "lost earning capacity" and "lost wages" relate to income loss, they represent distinct types of economic loss in financial and legal contexts.

Lost earning capacity assesses the impairment of an individual's fundamental ability to generate income in the future, regardless of their immediate employment status or specific income at the time of injury. ³, ⁴Lost wages, conversely, are a more direct measure of income actually forfeited from employment for a specific period due to an inability to work. ²A person could have a substantial claim for lost earning capacity even if their lost wages are minimal, especially if they were unemployed or in the early stages of a high-potential career at the time of the incident.

FAQs

What is the primary difference between lost earning capacity and lost wages?

Lost earning capacity assesses the reduction in an individual's potential to earn future income, while lost wages refer to actual income already missed from past work due to an injury or incident. Lost earning capacity is about future potential, whereas lost wages are about historical earnings.

Who typically calculates lost earning capacity?

Due to the complex and speculative nature of the calculation, experts such as forensic economists and vocational rehabilitation specialists are typically involved. They analyze various factors to project future income streams.

Can someone claim lost earning capacity if they were unemployed at the time of injury?

Yes, it is possible. Lost earning capacity is based on what an individual could have earned, not what they were actively earning at the moment of injury. Factors like education, skills, prior work history, and career aspirations are considered to establish their pre-injury earning potential.
¹

What factors influence the calculation of lost earning capacity?

Key factors include the individual's age, education level, pre-injury occupation and earning history, skill set, the severity and permanency of the injury, expected career path, and prevailing economic conditions. Risk assessment and the application of a discount rate are also crucial for determining the present value of future losses.