Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to M Definitions

Mineral reserve classification

What Is Mineral Reserve Classification?

Mineral reserve classification is a standardized system used in the mining industry to categorize known mineral deposits based on their geological confidence and economic viability. This critical aspect of Resource Valuation helps companies, investors, and regulators understand the quantity and quality of a mineral deposit, influencing key financial metrics and investment decisions. The process moves from less certain "resources" to more confidently defined "reserves," reflecting the progress of Geological exploration and subsequent technical and economic assessments. Mineral reserve classification provides a transparent framework for reporting extractable minerals.

History and Origin

The need for standardized mineral reserve classification systems arose from the complexities of valuing mineral assets and the varying levels of confidence associated with their estimation. Historically, different jurisdictions and companies used disparate methods, leading to inconsistencies and a lack of comparability in Public disclosure. To address this, international efforts began to harmonize reporting standards. A significant milestone was the establishment of the Committee for Mineral Reserves International Reporting Standards (CRIRSCO) in 1994. CRIRSCO, a non-governmental organization, was formed under the auspices of the Council of Mining and Metallurgical Institutes (CMMI) to promote consistency and transparency in reporting mineral deposit estimates.7,6

CRIRSCO developed an International Reporting Template (IRT), which draws on best practices from various national reporting codes, such as the JORC Code (Australasia), SAMREC Code (South Africa), CIM Guidelines (Canada), and SME Guide (USA).5 These harmonized standards aim to provide investors with a more comprehensive understanding of a registrant's mining properties. For instance, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States adopted amendments in 2018 to modernize property disclosure requirements for mining registrants, including rules for classifying mineral resources and reserves, becoming effective for fiscal years beginning on or after January 1, 2021.4,3

Key Takeaways

  • Mineral reserve classification categorizes mineral deposits based on geological confidence and economic viability.
  • It distinguishes between Mineral Resources (less certain) and Mineral Reserves (more certain, economically viable).
  • International standards, such as those promoted by CRIRSCO, ensure consistency and transparency in reporting.
  • This classification is vital for Investment decision making, Capital expenditure planning, and regulatory compliance in the Mining finance sector.
  • A "Qualified Person" is required to prepare and oversee the disclosure of mineral reserve classifications, ensuring professional expertise.

Interpreting the Mineral Reserve Classification

Interpreting mineral reserve classification involves understanding the levels of geological confidence and the economic factors that underpin each category. Mineral reserves are typically divided into "Proved" and "Probable" categories.

  • Proved Mineral Reserves: These are the highest confidence estimates. They represent economically mineable material for which the quantity, grade or quality, densities, shape, and physical characteristics are so well established that they can be estimated with a high level of accuracy. This confidence typically arises from detailed drilling, sampling, and testing, coupled with robust Feasibility study results.
  • Probable Mineral Reserves: These reserves have a lower level of geological confidence than Proved reserves but are still considered economically mineable. Estimates are based on adequate geological sampling, but the data density or certainty may be less than for Proved reserves. A positive Economic viability assessment, often through a pre-feasibility or full feasibility study, is still required.

The distinction between these categories is crucial for assessing Risk management associated with mining projects. A higher proportion of Proved reserves generally indicates a lower technical and economic risk for a mining operation.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "Golden Peak Mining Co." which owns a gold deposit. After extensive Geological survey and drilling, they identified a significant gold mineralization.

  1. Initial Assessment: Early drilling suggests a large volume of gold, categorized as an "Inferred Mineral Resource" due to limited data. This indicates the presence of gold but with low geological confidence.
  2. Pre-Feasibility Study: Golden Peak then conducts more infill drilling and initial engineering studies. Based on this, a portion of the Inferred Resource is upgraded to "Indicated Mineral Resource." This means there's enough data to estimate quantity and grade with reasonable confidence, and initial economic assessments show potential.
  3. Feasibility Study: A comprehensive Feasibility study is undertaken, involving detailed mining plans, metallurgical testing, environmental assessments, and precise cost estimations. This study confirms that a specific portion of the Indicated Mineral Resource can be economically extracted using current technology and market conditions. This portion is then classified as "Probable Mineral Reserve."
  4. Production Readiness: Further detailed drilling and refinement of mining plans in a specific area lead to a very high level of geological confidence and economic certainty. This highest confidence portion is then classified as "Proved Mineral Reserve."

This progression illustrates how confidence increases through successive stages of study and data collection, leading to the ultimate mineral reserve classification.

Practical Applications

Mineral reserve classification is fundamental across various facets of the financial and mining industries. For companies engaged in Resource extraction, it forms the basis for strategic planning, determining mine life, production schedules, and future Capital expenditure. Investors rely on accurate mineral reserve reports to conduct Due diligence and evaluate the intrinsic value of a mining company. These classifications are key factors considered by analysts when assessing a company's potential Return on investment and comparing it against others in Commodity markets.

Furthermore, mineral reserve classifications are crucial for Regulatory compliance. Publicly listed mining companies are often mandated by Stock exchange rules and securities commissions to disclose their mineral reserves according to specific standards to ensure transparency for shareholders. For example, mining companies operating globally must adhere to various national and international reporting codes based on the CRIRSCO framework. However, even with rigorous classification, unforeseen challenges can impact production. For instance, Gold Fields' Salares Norte gold mine in Chile faced delays and lower output forecasts due to commissioning problems and harsh winter weather conditions, highlighting that even well-classified reserves are subject to operational risks.2,1

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite the robust methodologies and international standards, mineral reserve classification is not without its limitations and criticisms. One primary concern is that even the highest confidence categories, Proved and Probable reserves, are still estimates and are inherently subject to geological and economic uncertainties. Geological models, while sophisticated, are interpretations based on limited data points. Economic factors, such as fluctuating commodity prices, exchange rates, operating costs, and technological advancements, can rapidly change the Economic viability of a deposit, potentially reclassifying reserves or even rendering them uneconomic.

Another critique revolves around the "Qualified Person" requirement. While intended to ensure professional rigor, the reliance on a single expert or team means that the quality of the estimate can still be influenced by human judgment, data interpretation, and potential biases. Additionally, external factors like political instability, changes in environmental regulations, or community opposition can impact a mine's ability to extract declared reserves, as seen with some projects that face significant delays or even cancellation despite confirmed reserves. This underscores that while mineral reserve classification provides a critical snapshot, it is a dynamic assessment influenced by a complex interplay of technical, economic, and external variables.

Mineral Reserve Classification vs. Mineral Resource Classification

Mineral reserve classification and Mineral resource classification are often confused but represent distinct stages in the evaluation of a mineral deposit. The fundamental difference lies in the level of geological confidence and, critically, the consideration of economic extractability.

Mineral Resources are concentrations of minerals with reasonable prospects for economic extraction. They are divided into:

  • Inferred Mineral Resources: The lowest confidence category, based on limited geological evidence and sampling.
  • Indicated Mineral Resources: Higher confidence than Inferred, with sufficient geological evidence to allow for reasonable estimation of quantity and quality.
  • Measured Mineral Resources: The highest confidence category for resources, where geological evidence is sufficient for a confident estimate of quantity and quality.

Mineral Reserves, on the other hand, are the economically mineable part of a Measured or Indicated Mineral Resource. This means that a comprehensive Feasibility study has been completed, demonstrating that extraction is technically feasible and economically viable under current market conditions. Mineral reserves are classified as "Proved" or "Probable," directly stemming from Measured and Indicated Resources, respectively. The transition from a resource to a reserve requires the application of "Modifying Factors," which include mining, processing, metallurgical, infrastructure, economic, marketing, legal, environmental, social, and governmental considerations.

FAQs

What are the main categories of mineral reserves?

The main categories of mineral reserves are Proved Mineral Reserves and Probable Mineral Reserves. Proved reserves have the highest level of geological confidence and economic certainty, while Probable reserves have a slightly lower but still robust level of confidence and economic viability.

Who is responsible for classifying mineral reserves?

Mineral reserve classification is typically undertaken by a "Qualified Person" (QP) or competent person. This individual is a highly experienced and credentialed mining professional, such as a geologist or mining engineer, who is independent of the company and responsible for ensuring the accuracy and integrity of the reserve estimate according to established industry standards.

Why is mineral reserve classification important for investors?

For investors, mineral reserve classification is crucial because it provides a clear, standardized indication of a mining company's future production potential and asset base. It helps investors assess the quantity and quality of minerals a company can realistically extract and sell, directly impacting its projected revenue and profitability. This information is vital for valuing the company's shares and making informed Investment decisions.

Can mineral reserves change over time?

Yes, mineral reserves can and often do change over time. These changes can be due to new Geological exploration data, improvements in mining technology, fluctuations in Commodity markets that affect economic viability, changes in operating costs, or shifts in Regulatory compliance and environmental policies. Companies regularly update their reserve estimates to reflect these dynamic factors.