Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to M Definitions

Mineral reserves

What Are Mineral Reserves?

Mineral reserves represent that part of a identified mineral deposit which can be economically and legally extracted or produced at the time of the reserve determination. Within the broader field of Extractive Industries Finance, mineral reserves are a crucial component for valuing mining companies and assessing the potential profitability of a given operation. They are distinguished from other mineral classifications by the rigorous demonstration of both technical feasibility and economic viability. Investors and financial analysts scrutinize mineral reserves as a primary indicator of a mining company's future production capacity and potential for generating cash flow. The accurate reporting of mineral reserves is essential for market transparency and for informing investment decisions in the mining sector.

History and Origin

The concept of mineral reserves has evolved significantly to provide greater clarity and reliability in public reporting, particularly for investment purposes. Early informal estimates of mineral deposits often lacked consistent methodologies, leading to potential misrepresentations and investor confusion. This led to a global push for standardized reporting. A major milestone in this standardization was the development of the Joint Ore Reserves Committee (JORC) Code. Established in Australia in 1971, JORC aimed to set minimum standards for public reporting of exploration results, mineral resources, and ore reserves. The first formal edition of the JORC Code was released in 1989, and it has since undergone several revisions to reflect evolving best practices in geological data collection and economic analysis. The JORC Code serves as a foundational framework for many international reporting standards, emphasizing transparency, materiality, and competence in reporting.5

In the United States, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted significant changes to its mining disclosure requirements in October 2018, effective for fiscal years beginning on or after January 1, 2021. These new rules, outlined in Subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K, aimed to align U.S. reporting standards more closely with global practices, including those of the JORC Code.4 The SEC's updated regulations mandate that disclosure of mineral reserves in SEC filings must be based on and accurately reflect information prepared by a "qualified person"—a mineral industry professional meeting specific experience criteria.

3## Key Takeaways

  • Economic Viability: Mineral reserves must be proven to be economically mineable under prevailing market conditions and regulatory frameworks.
  • Technical Feasibility: Extraction methods must be technically demonstrated as viable through pre-feasibility studies and feasibility studies.
  • Regulatory Compliance: Disclosure of mineral reserves is subject to strict regulatory oversight, such as the SEC's Subpart 1300 or the JORC Code, to ensure investor protection and market integrity.
  • Dynamic Nature: Mineral reserves are not static; they can change over time due to shifts in commodity prices, production costs, technological advancements, or revised geological understanding.
  • Valuation Basis: For mining companies, mineral reserves form a primary basis for asset valuation and future revenue projections.

Interpreting Mineral Reserves

Interpreting mineral reserves involves understanding the classifications and the underlying assumptions. Mineral reserves are typically categorized into "Proven Mineral Reserves" and "Probable Mineral Reserves," representing different levels of geological confidence and economic certainty. Proven reserves have the highest level of confidence, implying detailed geological and engineering studies have been completed. Probable reserves have a lower, but still high, level of confidence, based on less detailed but sufficient information.

When evaluating mineral reserves, it is crucial to consider the commodity prices used in the economic assessment, the assumed operating costs, and the regulatory environment. A high quantity of mineral reserves is beneficial, but only if they can be extracted profitably. Therefore, the grade (concentration of the valuable mineral), the metallurgical recovery rates, and the required capital expenditure for mining operations and processing are all critical factors in assessing the true value and extractability of the reserves. Understanding these nuances is vital for accurate market analysis and informed investment decisions.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "Gold Mountain Mining Co.," which owns a property believed to contain gold. After extensive exploration and drilling, they conduct a full feasibility study.

The study determines the following:

  • Estimated Gold Content: 5 million ounces of gold.
  • Gold Price Assumption: $1,800 per ounce (based on long-term forecasts).
  • Total Production Costs (including mining, processing, and administrative): $1,200 per ounce.
  • Capital Expenditure for Mine Development: $500 million.
  • Permitting and Regulatory Approvals: All necessary permits secured, demonstrating regulatory compliance.

Based on this, Gold Mountain Mining Co. can declare "Mineral Reserves." The 5 million ounces, after accounting for all technical and economic factors at the assumed gold price, qualify as mineral reserves. If the gold price were to fall significantly, say to $1,000 per ounce, then a portion or all of these reserves might no longer be economically viable to extract and would need to be reclassified, potentially as mineral resources or even discarded if economic viability cannot be reasonably established.

Practical Applications

Mineral reserves are fundamental to the mining industry and play a pivotal role in diverse financial and operational aspects. For mining companies, these reserves underpin strategic planning, influencing decisions on mine design, mining engineering, and the selection of appropriate processing techniques. They are a core metric used by investors to evaluate the long-term potential and intrinsic value of a company, directly impacting its market capitalization.

Lenders rely on declared mineral reserves when assessing the viability of project financing for new mine developments or expansions, as the reserves represent the collateral and the future revenue stream. Government bodies often use reported mineral reserves to calculate royalties and taxes, and for broader resource management and national economic planning, as exemplified by the U.S. Geological Survey's annual Mineral Commodity Summaries, which provides detailed data on U.S. and world mineral production, reserves, and resources. F2urthermore, accurate disclosure of mineral reserves is a critical component of a company's financial reporting to ensure transparency with shareholders and regulators.

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their critical importance, mineral reserves are not without limitations and criticisms. They are inherently estimates and projections, subject to uncertainties in geological interpretation, metallurgical performance, and future economic conditions such as commodity prices and exchange rates. A significant change in any of these variables can materially impact the declared mineral reserves, potentially rendering previously economic deposits uneconomic.

Another criticism relates to the "qualified person" requirement in reporting. While designed to ensure competence, the definition and application can vary, potentially leading to inconsistencies. Additionally, the process of converting mineral resources to mineral reserves is costly and time-consuming, requiring extensive drilling, sampling, and detailed technical and economic studies. Companies might defer these expenditures, leading to a situation where potential reserves exist but are not officially declared.

Furthermore, political and regulatory environments can introduce significant risks. Changes in government policies, such as increased taxation or stricter environmental impact regulations, can reduce the economic viability of a project, thereby diminishing or eliminating mineral reserves, even if the geological quantity remains unchanged. For instance, new mining codes implemented in countries like Mali have altered the risk-reward calculation for investors, impacting perceived regulatory uncertainty and potentially influencing future exploration and investment in declared reserves. T1hese factors underscore the need for continuous risk assessment and careful due diligence when relying on mineral reserve figures.

Mineral Reserves vs. Mineral Resources

Mineral reserves and mineral resources are distinct but related classifications used in the mining industry to categorize the quantity and quality of mineral occurrences. The key difference lies in the level of geological confidence and, crucially, the demonstration of economic viability and technical feasibility.

  • Mineral Resources: These are concentrations of minerals that have reasonable prospects for economic extraction. They are estimated based on geological evidence and knowledge and are categorized into Inferred, Indicated, and Measured Mineral Resources, reflecting increasing levels of geological confidence. However, they do not yet have demonstrated technical feasibility and economic viability for extraction. A mineral resource might exist, but it may not be profitable to mine under current conditions or with current technology.
  • Mineral Reserves: These are the economically mineable part of a Measured or Indicated Mineral Resource. They have been demonstrated to be technically feasible and economically viable through detailed studies (like pre-feasibility and feasibility studies), considering all modifying factors such as mining, metallurgical, processing, infrastructure development, marketing, legal, environmental, social, and governmental factors. In essence, all the hurdles to profitable extraction have been cleared or are reasonably expected to be cleared.

Confusion often arises because a large mineral resource does not automatically translate into a large mineral reserve. The process of converting resources to reserves requires significant investment and successful navigation of technical and economic challenges. Only a portion of a mineral resource may ultimately qualify as a mineral reserve.

FAQs

1. Who determines mineral reserves?

Mineral reserves are determined by a "qualified person" or "competent person," which is typically a geologist, mining engineer, or other mineral industry professional with significant relevant experience in the type of deposit and activity being undertaken. These professionals are bound by ethical codes and industry standards to ensure objective and accurate reporting.

2. Why are mineral reserves important for investors?

Mineral reserves are critical for investors because they indicate the long-term production potential and economic viability of a mining company. They provide a tangible basis for valuing the company's assets and forecasting future revenues and profits, directly impacting shareholder value. Companies with substantial, well-defined mineral reserves are often considered more stable and attractive investments.

3. How do changes in commodity markets affect mineral reserves?

Fluctuations in commodity prices can directly impact mineral reserves. If the price of the commodity (e.g., gold, copper) falls below the cost of extraction, previously economic mineral reserves may become uneconomic and would need to be reclassified as mineral resources or even removed from the company's inventory, as they are no longer profitably extractable. Conversely, a significant price increase can convert mineral resources into mineral reserves by making their extraction economically viable. This highlights why sound corporate governance practices are necessary.

4. Are mineral reserves static, or do they change over time?

Mineral reserves are dynamic and change over time. They are depleted as minerals are extracted through mining operations. However, they can also increase through new discoveries, successful exploration efforts converting mineral resources into reserves, technological advancements that lower extraction costs, or favorable shifts in commodity prices. Regulatory changes or revised economic assumptions can also lead to reclassifications.