Skip to main content
← Back to N Definitions

Non qualifying asset

A non-qualifying asset, in the realm of retirement planning and taxation, refers to a financial arrangement or form of compensation that does not meet the specific requirements set forth by the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) or the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) for preferential tax treatment. Unlike "qualified" plans, which offer immediate tax deductions or tax-free growth, a non-qualifying asset typically results in deferred taxation for the employee and deferred deductibility for the employer. The most common embodiment of a non-qualifying asset is a non-qualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plan. These plans are contractual agreements, often utilized by employers to provide additional benefits to highly compensated employees (HCEs) beyond the limits allowed in qualified plans like a 401(k)).

History and Origin

The concept of a non-qualifying asset, particularly in the context of deferred compensation, evolved largely in response to the regulatory framework established for employee benefit plans in the United States. Historically, employers and employees sought ways to defer income tax on compensation, especially for higher earners. The passage of ERISA in 1974 brought stringent regulations to "qualified" plans, ensuring broad employee coverage and preventing discrimination in favor of highly compensated individuals. This created a need for separate arrangements that could offer additional deferred compensation opportunities to executives without needing to comply with all ERISA's non-discrimination rules.13

A significant regulatory development impacting non-qualifying assets was the enactment of Internal Revenue Code Section 409A in 2004. This section established specific requirements for NQDC plans to maintain their tax deferral status, largely in response to perceived abuses and the need for clearer guidelines on when deferred income should be taxed. Compliance with Section 409A is critical; failure to meet its stipulations can result in immediate taxation of all deferred amounts, along with penalties and interest.12

Key Takeaways

  • A non-qualifying asset typically refers to compensation or benefits that do not meet IRS or ERISA requirements for favorable tax treatment.
  • Non-qualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plans are the most common example, allowing executives to defer more income than qualified plans.
  • Unlike qualified plans, NQDC plans are often "unfunded" for tax purposes, meaning the deferred amounts remain subject to the employer's general creditors.
  • Taxation on a non-qualifying asset in an NQDC plan is generally deferred until the compensation is actually received by the employee.
  • Compliance with IRS Section 409A is mandatory for NQDC plans to maintain their tax-deferred status.

Interpreting the Non-Qualifying Asset

When evaluating a non-qualifying asset, especially in the form of an NQDC plan, its interpretation centers on the tax implications and the security of the deferred funds. For the employee, the primary benefit is the ability to defer income tax on a portion of current earnings and any growth on those deferred amounts until a later date, typically retirement or separation from service. This can be advantageous if an individual expects to be in a lower tax bracket in the future.

However, the "non-qualified" nature means these plans often lack the same protections as qualified plans. For tax purposes, many NQDC plans are considered "unfunded," meaning the deferred amounts are not held in a separate trust account for the employee's sole benefit and remain part of the company's general assets. This introduces a risk: if the employer faces financial difficulties or bankruptcy, the employee's deferred compensation could be at risk, as they are essentially a general creditor of the company.11 Therefore, understanding the financial health of the employer is a crucial part of interpreting the true value and security of a non-qualifying asset. Effective financial planning is essential when incorporating these arrangements into one's overall financial strategy.

Hypothetical Example

Consider Sarah, a highly compensated executive at TechCorp. She earns a significant annual bonus, and after maximizing her contributions to her 401(k)) and other qualified retirement plan options, she still wants to save more for retirement while deferring current taxes. TechCorp offers a non-qualified deferred compensation plan.

Sarah elects to defer $50,000 of her annual bonus into the NQDC plan. This $50,000, along with any earnings it accrues, is not immediately subject to federal income tax for Sarah. Instead, she will pay taxes on these funds when they are distributed to her in the future, as per the terms of the plan (e.g., upon retirement). For TechCorp, the company does not get a tax deduction for the deferred amount until it pays out the compensation to Sarah. The funds held by TechCorp to informally "fund" this deferred compensation are generally subject to the claims of the company's creditors. When Sarah eventually retires and receives the deferred $50,000 plus its accumulated earnings, the entire amount will be taxed as ordinary income in that year.

Practical Applications

Non-qualifying assets, primarily in the form of NQDC plans, have several practical applications, predominantly for businesses and their top-tier employees.

  • Executive Retention and Recruitment: Employers use NQDC plans to attract and retain key executives by offering additional savings opportunities beyond traditional qualified plans, which are subject to IRS contribution limits.10 This supplemental benefit can be a powerful tool in a competitive labor market.
  • Tax Management for High Earners: For highly compensated employees, NQDC plans allow for significant tax deferral on current income. This can be particularly appealing if they anticipate being in a lower income tax bracket in retirement, effectively shifting taxable income to a time when it may be taxed at a lower rate.9
  • Flexible Benefit Design: Unlike regulated qualified plans, NQDC plans offer greater flexibility in design, allowing employers to tailor specific payout triggers (e.g., retirement, termination, death, or a fixed date) and eligibility criteria for a select group of employees.8
  • Corporate Financial Strategy: From an employer's perspective, NQDC plans are often "unfunded" for tax purposes, meaning the company is not required to set aside assets in a separate trust for the employees. This can provide the company with greater liquidity and flexibility, as the deferred amounts remain part of the company's general assets until distributed.7

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their advantages, non-qualifying assets, particularly NQDC plans, come with significant limitations and criticisms.

A major drawback is the lack of asset protection for the employee. Because these plans are often unfunded for tax purposes, the deferred funds are subject to the employer's general creditors in the event of bankruptcy or financial distress. This means an employee could lose their entire deferred compensation if the company goes under, as the money is not held in a protected trust like a pension plan or 401(k)).6

Another limitation relates to inflexibility in distribution elections. IRS Section 409A mandates that the timing and form of distributions from an NQDC plan generally must be elected before the compensation is earned and cannot be changed easily. This lack of flexibility can be problematic if an employee's financial needs or tax situation changes unexpectedly.5

Furthermore, the tax benefits are a deferral, not an elimination, of taxes. While tax deferral can be advantageous, employees will eventually pay income tax on the full amount when it is distributed. If tax rates unexpectedly rise in retirement, the benefit of deferral could be diminished. Also, FICA (Social Security and Medicare) taxes are typically due when the compensation is deferred or vests, not when it is paid, which can create a current tax liability on future income.4

Non-Qualifying Asset vs. Qualified Plan

The core distinction between a non-qualifying asset (most notably an NQDC plan) and a qualified plan lies in their compliance with specific IRS and ERISA rules, which in turn dictates their tax treatment and participant protections.

FeatureNon-Qualifying Asset (e.g., NQDC Plan)Qualified Plan (e.g., 401(k), pension)
IRS & ERISA RulesDoes not meet all stringent requirements; subject to Section 409A.Must meet strict non-discrimination, funding, and participation requirements.
EligibilityTypically offered to a select group of highly compensated employees or management.Must be offered to a broad base of employees.
Tax DeductionEmployer deduction is generally deferred until payment to employee.Employer deduction usually taken when contributions are made.
Employee TaxIncome tax deferred until actual receipt.Contributions may be pre-tax (Traditional) or after-tax (Roth), with tax-deferred growth or tax-free withdrawals.
Asset ProtectionOften unfunded; subject to employer's general creditors. Risk of forfeiture.Assets held in a separate trust; protected from employer bankruptcy.
Contribution LimitsGenerally no specific IRS limits on deferred amounts.Subject to annual IRS contribution limits.

The confusion between the two often arises from both offering a form of deferred compensation for retirement. However, the regulatory environment and the security of the funds differ significantly. A Traditional IRA and a Roth IRA are examples of qualified individual retirement accounts, adhering to their own sets of rules for tax treatment and withdrawals.

FAQs

What is the main benefit of a non-qualifying asset like an NQDC plan?

The main benefit is the ability for highly compensated employees to defer a significant portion of their current income tax to a future date, potentially when they are in a lower tax bracket during retirement.3

Are non-qualifying assets protected from my employer's creditors?

Generally, no. For tax purposes, many non-qualified deferred compensation plans are considered "unfunded," meaning the money is not held in a separate trust for your benefit and remains part of the company's general assets. This exposes the deferred funds to the claims of the employer's creditors if the company faces financial difficulties or bankruptcy.2

Can I roll over a non-qualifying asset into an IRA?

No, non-qualified deferred compensation plans generally cannot be rolled over into an IRA or another qualified retirement plan. When the funds are distributed, they are typically paid directly to the employee and are subject to ordinary income tax at that time.

How does IRS Section 409A affect non-qualifying assets?

IRS Section 409A provides specific rules that non-qualified deferred compensation plans must follow to maintain their tax-deferred status. These rules dictate when deferral elections can be made, when distributions can occur, and other administrative requirements. Failure to comply can result in immediate taxation of all deferred amounts, plus penalties and interest.1